Question Locked

Lan Segmentation

0 helpful
6 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.
I have two LANs because my ISP is giving me 6 MBs with 3 MB on one ADSL router and 3 MB on another ADSL router. I want to combine these two LANS to share resources like printers and such. The gateways are 192.168.10.1 and 192.168.2.1. I have both routers connected to a 24 port switch. All PCs have XP. What do I do to combine these? Getting rid of one of the routers is not an option because of line limitations for speed. I need the two connections to get the full 6 MBs.

6 replies

by ashij

You said that the routers are connected to your switch (model?). Does this switch have 2 uplinks?

My suggestion is that you get a load balancing router (e.g. D Link DI-LB604) which has 2 Uplinks. What u need is load balancing not segmentation.

If you want to do it the really cheap way. you could get your own STP/UTP splitter cable, connect the single end to the uplink port on switch and the two split ends to each router.

what you say?

by dedlbug

Ashij's method of a load balancing switch is preferred and my favorite. But I interperted the question another way.... a more complicated and unecessary way. lol

If you want to seperate/segment the LAN so half has a 3MB connection and the other has a 3MB connection, then make the router/Gateways on the same IP range. (192.168.10.1 and 192.168.10.2) Disable DHCP. Then assign static IP's to the computers and point to the desired Gateways. Again, not really an option for a large network, but if you are flat broke and have a small LAN, this method may work.

by <itman>

If you set the subnet mask on all devices including inside interface of routers to be 255.255.0.0 then all hosts in both IP ranges should be able to see each other at Layer 2 as this would be one network.

If you want to combine two networks then the only way to really do this and have an environment that you can administer easily is to use a layer 3 swith. That way you can simply route between the networks and hosts connected to the switch will be able to share resources in both networks.

You will also need to correctly set the default gateways and subnet masks on the hosts and ensure that both your routers have a static route back to your local networks.

by wenos

Thanks for the ideas everyone. I may try to get the D-Link Dual Wan router. Just to clarify I don't want two 3MB connections it is just what is being given to me by the ISP so I have to deal with it. My thoughts are to do the 255.255.0.0 so that everyone can see everyone and have one workgroup. I tried that once before when I didn't have XP on all PCs and the network crapped out on me after, I think, 8 were working fine. The next one killed it. That way we can share resources and do backups to one server. The load balancing/failover of the D-Link piece would also be good to have. One other thought is I am trying to setup a WIFI router Linksys WRT54G as well. I disabled the DHCP on the WIFI since the two ADSL routers do this and we use static IPs but I still seem to be running into some problem. Linksys support told me to give the router an IP address 192.168.2.3 and then number all the PCs from there. I have done this but I still have problems. We share printers here via PC (we will be getting IP printers soon) and for some reason people cannot print if I turn the WIFI on. Somehow I haven't got something configured correctly and I have a conflict somewhere. I think in the end the D-Link router is probably the easiest solution. If I go that way I connect the routers to the WAN ports obviously and then just run a cable from a Lan port to a Lan port on my D-Link DES 1024D switch. So that means all my traffic (9 PCs) would route through one cable to the WANS, right? Someone asked before about the switch we used. I assume the DES 1024D is capable in this setup. I am thinking now that with the Dual Wan router the subnetting 255.255.0.0 would not be necessary. I think that is right, right? Sorry, I am a bit lost on this and am obviously not an expert. Thanks to all.

by ashij

Yes!
you are right, you won't need to do any special subnetting, since all the computers will be on the same subnet. The Load-Balancing router will take care of that. And the 24-port switch will let you connect the users. For WiFi you'll just have to run a cable to your Wireless Router and make it work like a switch (I use the same Linksys router as a switch at home). This will actually save you the headache of extra configuring and you'll have less nodes to troubleshoot in case of a problem.

Have a great day!!

This discussion is closed to new replies.