Question Locked

Licensing in Windows - Remote Desktop Vs Terminal Server

0 helpful
13 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

We have a setup of 5 member project team. They dont have MS office installed in their system. However they may need to use MS Office very rarely.

We are planning to setup a new system with MS office installed in it and allow 5 members (from 5 different workstations) to connect to this new system via Remote Desktop.

Now, the next question is about MS licensing. Do we need 5 MS office license in all 5 different workstations? OR Is it OK to have 1 license in Remote Desktop and allowing 5 others to connect one at a time?

I know for sure, if we use Terminal services, we should have 5 licenses. We are not sure if this applies to Remote Desktop too (where only one user connects at a time). We dont want to invest in 5 licenses for a very less usage.

Any help on this is highly appreciated. Thanks in Advance.

13 replies

by 1bn0

If so, only one person can connect to it at a time.

I don't beleive there is any issue with that.

I would consider it the same is if each user was walking over to the desktop and using the application. You have one license for one installation being used by one person at a time.

by rtp2006

Most MS products are offered as a device license or user license so if you license it to the device (PC) you are licensed correctly...

by cmiller5400

Best bet is to contact Microsoft for the final say but, from what I have read, you will need a copy for each device that connects to the Remote Desktop session.

An excerpt from the MS Office 2003 EULA

[i]1.2 Alternative Rights for Storage/Network Use. As an alternative to Section 1.1(a), you may install a copy of the Software on a network storage device, such as a server computer, and allow one access device, such as a personal computer, to access and use that licensed copy of the Software over a private network. You must obtain a license to the Software for each additional device that accesses and uses the Software installed on the network storage device, except as permitted by Section 1.4 of this EULA.
1.3 License Grant for Remote Desktop. You may use remote access technologies, such as the Remote Desktop features in Microsoft Windows or NetMeeting, to access and use your licensed copy of the Software, provided that only the primary user of the device hosting the remote desktop session accesses and uses the Software with a remote access device. These remote desktop rights do not permit you to use the Software on both the device hosting the remote desktop session and the access device at the same time.
1.4 License Grant for Remote Assistance. You may permit any device to access and use your licensed copy of the Software for the sole purpose of providing you with technical support and maintenance services.[/i]

by 1bn0

1.3 states "These remote desktop rights do not permit you to use the Software on both the device hosting the remote desktop session and the access device at the same time."

Since he is not attempting to use the software both locally and remotely at the same time , he is not violating the limit of the license. One user at a time.

If each user has an account on the local workstation and office is installed on that workstation, each user can use the software, just not at the sane time.

Remote desktop is only providing the ability for one user at a time to access the local machine without actually sitting at the computer.

There is no concurrent use.

by cmiller5400

In 1.3 there is a snippet.. [i]"...provided that only the [b]primary user[/b] of the device hosting the remote desktop session accesses and uses the Software with a remote access device"[/i]

Doesn't that mean that you can't share?

by ---tk---

though about Open Office? If they are worried about money I would have them try it, or at least offer it up... The worst they can say is no.

There is also Star Office, which you need to pay for, but its much cheaper than MS Office. At my job most of us switched over to that.

by dvijay

Thanks for your suggestion.

We thought about Open Office & Star Office, however we finally decided to go with MS Office. The reason being, most (or all) of our customers uses MS Office and we found it hard to work with customer's document.

by 1bn0

What do you mean by hard?

We use MSOffice 2003 at work. I regularly recover corrupted Word documents by opening them and resaving them with Open Office writer.

OpenOffice can be configured to use the Microsoft formats as default. So if you create a document and save it, it saves as a Word .doc , Excel .xls or Powerpoint .ppt.

Unless the customers documents are very complex, there should not be too many issues.

The word documents I work with are heavy with tables, headers, footers and formatted sections. Latest version of OpenOffice rarely has any problem, none tha tI can recall recently.

by dvijay

Almost all the admins I enquired confirmed that we need license in each workstation. None of them have provided me the sections which supports their thoughts.

Actually I am looking for some clear sections and easy to read agreement. 1.3 is definitely helpful.

As you rightly suggested, we need to check with MS Vendor

by cmiller5400

If you check with the MS partner/vendor, you can always say that they were the ones that told you the licensing requirement. But always get it in writing/e-mail!

by dvijay

I have not heard 100% positive feedback about Open Office with in our organization as a replacement for MS Office. There were complaints - that's why we initially decided to go with MS office.

Now that I seen your confidence with Open Office, will definitely get deeper into it and see how I can promote the idea of Open Office as a potential replacement for MS Office

by dvijay

I know I am out of my mind - but couldnt stop in posting this.

How about connecting to other Windows Desktop through Windows VNC (not through Remote Desktop or terminal services client)? Would we still need to have 5 licenses?

How about a Linux box connecting to Windows Desktop remotely? (first of all, is this possible?) Let's say if this works, would we still need to have 5 licenses?

Somehow I would like to beat MS Licensing policy, however I know the chances are almost close to nil.

Again thanks for all your responses.

This discussion is closed to new replies.