Discussion Locked

Look for jobs in downsizing companies

0 helpful
17 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.
Tell us what you think about looking for jobs at companies that are downsizing, as featured in Monday's Career Advice e-newsletter. Would you consider a position with a company that had just gone through layoffs? What terms would you require before accepting the job?

17 replies

by discordian

if they layoff once, especially if it happened recently, then you know that they do not value their employees and the threat of being laid off yourself is greatly increased. i would only take a position with such a company with the full realization that it was a temporary position and that i had best keep looking for something stable.

in addition, the salary offers would be less because companies usually lay off senior personnel to reduce salary and benefit offerings and would be looking to new hires to take reduced pay. something i would not want to accept on and ethical and financial basis.

also, comming in after a round of layoffs you come into an environment filled with nervous and demoralized workers who will attempt to backstaband play politics more than usual, thus it is not a very freindly workplace to position yourself in.

overall, it's a losing proposition that i would be extermely hesitant to take unless there was no other option available.

by james r linn

I wouldn't necessarily say that company's who lay off don't value their employees. Sometimes a small layoff to reduce expenses is preferabble to continued financial losses and massive layoffs or worse bankruptcy.

But I wouldn't want to go into the environment where layoffs have taken place. If its been a small layoff, its always possible that it won't be enough, and more will be laid off. Even if you have guarentees or job security, its still not productive to keep losing teams members, transferring responsibilities and dealing with the loss of team members on projects.

Having survived many layoffs, I know that its often more stressful for those who survive, as their work load increases and the possiblity of further layoffs still hangs over their heads.

In short, I'd stay away, unless I was a high level exec who specialized in turn arounds.

James

by discordian

sure, there are probably companies out there who layoff out of shear necessity where if they did not there would be a more catastrophic downsize. yet, the problem is that you don't know whether the company laid of due to strategic placement with an eye to the future or if there was a cut with a mindset to short term gain where someone just wanted better bonus by cutting personnel just to make that year's profits look better.

this is the problem that i see in that there is just too much uncertainty in a business where there were layoffs and we both agree that in many ways the work environment after a round of cuts is much less than productive or worthwhile.

by http://stobie.home.sprynet.com/work/

1. Most Downsizing Companies only Microhire.

These means the focus almost exclusively on immediate needs as seen by one or two people and not what is best for the organization. They look for specific skills set and anything else hinders employment as more skills means higher pay, so often the less overall skilled with be hired.

2. Ask for full severence eligibility.

Ask for the same severence that someone with 20 years would get. That will influence their decision to retain you whenthe immediate need is reduced.

3. EXamine the organization for strategic activity.

Organizations that conduct strategic development are looking for the future and downsizing tends to be limited to where they are overstaffed for market reasons.

Most downsizing organizations cut most to all of strategic development, hurting their long term results and growth.

4. If you are strategic and you get a job, go for it.

If a company knows who are a strategic thinker and want to hire you during downsizing, it is stating that it cares for the future and wants to work for what is best for the organization.

by sysdev1

I see many companies doing this as the people who are being fired (layed off is is essentially the same thing with perhaps a few perks) are earning a higher salary than the people who are being hired are going to earn. Even with the high cost of recruiting, there is still some financial benefit to doing this. What is not often realized is that this improves only the SHORT TERM bottom line and not the long term bottom line. What is being lost is experience and many managers who have reached their position by violating the "Peter Principle" is that in the long run, this is more likely to hurt than help the company. Getting rid of "dead wood" is ok but along with those, many people who are or can be vital to the success of the company arestill lost.

by brian.kiser

Sure, I'd take this job if I had nothing else. However, if the choice is between working for a company that practices layoffs and another company that never has layoffs, I should think the correct choice is obvious.

The article's problem is thatcompanies hiring in "growth" areas and laying off in other areas--what if your "growing" area isn't growing anymore in 5 years?

A company that practices layoffs is not a place I want to work. Many companies, especially Japanese companies, practice a policy of "no layoffs". I used to work at one of these companies, and the economy has never gotten bad enough for that company to have even one layoff. Now that's where you want to work, if possible.

by admin

often is a precurser to major change, and usually for change to be successful it leads to 60% or more of the employees turning over in time. Essentially, at the end of downsizing, internal (or External) raiding is alive and well and gets the turnarounds shareholders desire in the end.

I would take a job in a downsizing company at the point in time that the major shift was occurring and I was one of the employees on the "new" team and that I clearly understood that there was a 48% or better ratio of "new" staff to old and that more was in the works. In this enviroment there is great opportunity for rapid advancement and future security. I would never take a position with a downsizing company otherwise unless they hired me as the raider and I was fully empowered to be able to carry out this difficult task of turning a companies profits about.

by discordian

you're telling us that you would only join a downsizing company if they let you wield the axe?

thanks mr chainsaw al.

by admin

Better me than someone else. A downsizing company is almost always doomed in the long run anyway unless they have significant change. I would work with the employees as much as I could but in choosing to move to a new company that is downsizing it'slike inheriting an orchard that no longer produces enough fruit and you have to prune deep to get fruit.

The trick in an existing management position is to not let this happen. Prune a little every year and you don't have to take out whole branches later. Keep up production. Follow markets. Keep your people in work. If this isn't done and a company is in trouble then over time chainsaws are needed instead of hand pruners.

by penguinsrule

I've seen the layoff/hiring happen in one of two ways:

1) that more experienced, more expensive people will be laid off, and cheaper help hired
2) This creates some interesting opportunities for particular people to enter management. I've seen one case where a person quit, then there was a layoff, and then that person came back as a high level manager. It was like this individual was a part of this process.

Actually whatever you sow, that you will also reap. All this does is create uncertainty and you don't build winning football teams by changing the roster constantly.. It doesn't work any better in business.

The bottom line is that companies are no longer committed to PEOPLE. PEOPLE are your business - your employees, your customers, your shareholders, everybody from the top down. Once you forget PEOPLE, then your business will suffer. Treat PEOPLE poorly, and it will come back to slap you in the face. Hasn't Enron shown anybody that yet?

by admin

and turned around before it got so bad. That's why lying to shareholders is such a big deal.

by bill_gatex

It is absurd to think companies are down sizing and fire employees based on their growth strategy alone while at the same time ignoring the international political climate that does effect the outcome of business hiring and firing.

Decisions on large that support political leader views without regards to properly informing the public with news events about real issues around the globe with a twisted tongue news media.We live in a age of information however its misuse by leaders and newspapers of any country business that leads to false and misguided perceptions conveyed to public in broad sense relates to effect downsizing in some form.
Whether it is export import of any business services by placing bans etc on other countries due to leaders while not depicting a true picture the general public in any country lead to improper disernment on large scale fostering many other problems. This obviously means less investment $$ income return any business institution or banking.There are no bends other then the ones people impose on them selves for a slow down in a larger perspective of downsizing etc.To look at simply for ones self gain for a job is a very narrow aptitiude that there is a pool of people to select whether from a business or individual point rather then seeing the large picture of why a company is not doing well and why there needs to be a downsizing based on a analysis and addressing issues.We need to ask alot more questions then be first in line to get a job because someelse lost theirs.

by dlreazor

Some companies do what Wall Street tells them. Employee expense to high, cure, early retirement and 'realignment' (staff reduction). Then the real trick is to hire people back via a contract company, which shows as an expense, but not employee expense. Worked for a while (espically for those with early retirement) and covered the gap between loss of staff to do the job and replacement with lower cost staff or reduction in service. A lot of companies are doing this to lower the average employee age. Illegal, you bet, but the odds of getting caught are low. It's also a way to cut 'dead' wood. Companies (the best places to work) care about their employees and try to shift them to meet the change in demands. Sometimes they still need to reducestaff in one area if they do not has results in transitioning staff (some folks just don't want to change). My personal observation is that this is rare and most companies use this process to get around the legal hassels of today of eliminating employees or cutting the work force age where the savings can be big in the benefit category.

by james r linn

Every mature organization has some deadwood. You can try and see if they will work out better in another position - but my experience has been that this usually doesn't suceed.

So you choice is ignore the problem, hope it goes away, and jepordizethe department/division/company. Or keep trimming away the deadwood as you go.

Sometimes its in the best interests of the employees too. I was once laid off from a job that had become kind of dead end, and it was the best thing that could happen to me. I had a similar thing happen when I had to do my first layoff. The person found another position in the organization and is now thriving instead of being stuck in a low value job.

I don't know anyone who likes to lay people off, or truthbe told, even fire people who deserve it. Its a hard thing to do. But sometimes it has to be done.

James

by http://stobie.home.sprynet.com/work/

It makes a difference if it is industry-wide (such as Telecom 2001-2002) downsizing.

In these cases, care is still needed, but look at the workload and the future of the position being hired to. The industries will go on and those companies inside that adapt well will outperform the others.

by neomatsu

I was working for a temp agency and got placed at PwC and worked for 4 months as a contractor and then due to my performance was hired on permanent in March of 2001 and I accepted. In June of 2001, PwC started telling employees that there were going to be layoffs, however, we were told that our unit was bring in a positive cash flow and so we were safe. Then in October of 2001, with no warning, 4 of us were laid off. This was after some of us had become eligible to invest in a 401(k) and we did with a lot of money since they were giving us a incentive amount that they would invest in our account and this was 3 weeks before the layoff. If I had known that I was going to be laid off I never would have invested. Kinda hard to believe that this layoff was that quickly determined. When we were called in we were told that business was not as good as they hoped and they had not gotten some accounts and so we were being laid off and it definitely was not due to performance. Now this company has 180 offices in 150 countries and they did not offer any of us relocation. It really left a sour taste in my mouth for International business's and I will take a real serious look at hiring on with another. What's even more irritating is that companies want employees to be loyal, honest, hard-working and dedicated, but at the same time we cannot expect the same from the company. Somewhere along the line we have allowed the big business to go unfettered and now they believe that we and the consumers are there for them. We are one of the greatest nations in the world, yet we allow big business to dictate politics, life and liberty...we really need to go back to some old fundamental ideas of employees and companies working on a 2 way street...

by max98037

You are right, Neomatsu!! Every company I have worked for has treated me like company equipment and expected me to run 500 miles for them. Not fair!!

This discussion is closed to new replies.