Discussion Locked

M$ Audit....just marketing

0 helpful
27 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Like many of you, serveral months ago we went thru a Microsoft Audit. Where they send you a neat letter from their lawyers saying that you need to fill out this audit affidavit stating what OS's/M$ products you are running and if you are short on anything.

So we like others, dillegintly sat down and inventoried everything and made sure our liscenses were current.

Well, it turns out it was a marketing ploy. I just received in the mail, a "Estimated Liscensing Options and Reccomendations"form saying what liscenses I "Should" buy to keep current with M$ OS's (ie xp).

And guess what was on there? All of the numbers that I supplied to them. They claim it was from volume liscensing data, but that is BS. These numbers reflect the exact count that I sent into them.

I have no gumption to upgrade (if you can call it that) my systems to XP. It was however, awfully nice of them to tell me how much money I will waste if I wait to upgrade my current liscenes to XP.

Nice to know that they are looking out for our (you mean their) best interest.

27 replies

by radiic

That all of your hard work paid off...(for them) I guess thats one way to estimate how many systems they think will get XP...Too bad they dont realize that all of us Admins are not going to upgrade to XP.

by lordinfidel

I've been in the middle of a major network change this past couple of months.

I've been building out a whole new production network on shiny new servers (in parallel to my current network) and deployed it into a Co-location facilty.

It basically ate up 90% of my availble 24 hour day time block. I figured it out that we were putting in 80-90 hour work weeks for 3 months solid. It was kind of insane.

by tomsal

Last fall I had gotten one of those "Audit Affidavit" letters from Microsoft. So, like you said, I went through the processed and fill out the paperwork reflecting our must up to date state of licensing as it pertains to Microsoft products.

A fewmonths went buy, bringing us to about January. A MS regional rep called me and did the whole "Did you know Microsoft Licensing is changing this summer" speal. He tried to talk me to upgrading our systems to XP for the OS and Office XP for our desktop apps. I told him no dice of course.

Wouldn't you know that over the course of the last few months, I've gotten TWO ads inviting me to Microsoft licensing seminars, 2 letters from MS trying to sell me on the "finer points" of buying into their "upgrade advantage" program. And last but not least, just last week I got that same package you described that used my numbers - they were nice enough to prepare a full color fancy looking chart telling me what purchases I should make for my company.
We are a small company, so you could imagine how much I laughed when I saw they were basically asking me to spend about $100,000 in one lump sum on software upgrades.

NOT!

by tomsal

Sorry for the hideously poor grammar and spelling in my last reply, I was typing that and on the phone at the same time...

So much for multitasking.

by tomsal

Sorry for the hideously poor grammar and spelling in my last reply, I was typing that and on the phone at the same time...

So much for multitasking.

by lordinfidel

Its as if we did their marketing research for them.

But, on the other hand, my counterpart here brought up a good point.

That those who did'nt turn it in probably got a knock on the door from the federal marshalls.

So it was kind of like a double edged sword.

by generalist

Would the knock on the door be from the Feds or the BSA?

I sometimes wonder what would happen if either group did a software audit of a small organization and discovered that said organization has legitimate copies of all the necessary software but had failed to register them. IS there a requirement that you register software?

For that matter, if what would happen to an organization that has legitimately paid for the software that, unknown to them, was previously sold and returned? Doespossession of the original CD-ROMs and paper registration forms protect them?

by madroxxx

I got one, checked to make sure I had my licenses straight, then threw it in the garbage. They began calling me over and over. I let them rot in voicemail hell. Finally I got the same packet here that you all got only mine didn't very accurately describe my setup(guess they took a wild guess).

by tomsal

you lose the "privilege and honor" of giving Microsoft your money for "upgraded" software that you really don't need because your network is working fine as it is already and despite the fact that research study's have been done that prove that mostusers don't use more than 10-20% of the features bundled in CURRENT office suites, but (of course) MS thinks you're company will be behind in the dust if you don't upgrade your OS and office suites every 12-18 months. ;)

Oh yeah, you wouldn't want to lose the right to that excellent Microsoft tech support either would you? ;)

LOL

by generalist

*** BEGIN SARCASM MARKS ***

Gasp! You mean there is actual research that supports my long felt feeling that people can actually survive without the latest and greatest features from MS and others?

Wow! Maybe I can use such research to convince key people that upgrade driven 'featuritus' is a disease that has a cure. That cure is to 'Just Say No' to upgrades.

(Of course, if too many people did that, the PC hardware and software industry would collapse...)

*** END SARCASM MARKS ***

by lordinfidel

This corresponds basically to the bsa.

The BSA will leave you alone unless you contact them and use your truce. (unless of course a disgruntled employee contacts them)

M$ is probably the opposite. They will probably contact you if you "Don't"send it in.

My point was, I did'nt mind taking the time out and making sure my liscenses were in compliance and letting them know our numbers.

What peeves me is that they turned away and used those numbers as a marketing tactic. Now they now the numbers I have on my network and can target me for those upgrades.

If I wanted to upgrade I would. I did'nt need them sending a pretty package to my CEO.

by jimhm

Big Bill is watching - You can't order a system without it coming with XP on it. Dell's don't support 2000 - because they are in bed with Bill.

So what's the little home owner to do.. I guess just bend over - and take it up the - and smile as Bill says he wants more.

by madroxxx

You know that in your EULA it states that you may downgrade legally any microsoft software. So I get my Dells wipe them of XP and install 2000.

by generalist

Ah, so the rumor that you can downgrade IS accurate. (I'm not one for memorizing the EULAs of the world...)

That will make it possible for me to 'purchase' Win95 for my low end machines.

I just hope that they don't change the EULA.

by curtisinterruptus

You just aren't screaming at Dell loud enough! I think I am going to contract my purchasing lady here to other IT departments just to buy laptops withOUT XP on it! She is great!

Curt

by curtisinterruptus

Yeah, Dell tried pulling that old "we only ship XP on our systems" on me the other day. Luckily my purchaser screamed bloody murder at everyone who would finally pickup the phone there until they finally admitted that they COULD ship with 2000 Pro.... Geezus.... I don't want to have to be a prototype tester for Uncle Bill and M$.

Curt

by admin

So does anyone know if FUD was officially a marketing program name at MS?

It is really hard to tell what MS considers protection. I have talked to different people there over the years on registration compared to legal ownership, used licenses, what have you and it seems that when pressed they clam up and pretty much maintain a line that approximately sounds like "If you buy from an approved MS reseller they will take care of this for you"
Based on some court cases, it appears to me that proof of legitimately purchased software new or used requires bills of sales at "reasonable prices" for new software, and bills of sale from reputable companies for used software. Of course, used OEM's don't cut it nor does any product that is being used as an upgrade. Ask questions first and get the sticky bits in writing. Don't buy at ridiculous low prices or on eBay or from individuals and you steer clear of complications if you do go to court.

We get computers donated, usually without original bills of sale even though we sometimes get the cd's with them. As far as I can tell, this software is useless in court. It looks to me like you either need to be in a MS retailer database or you need legit, reasonable bills of sale if you go to court.

I definately could be wrong though, MS has given me so many different stories at different times. :)

At any rate, our desktops are still 98se and o97 mostly. Our servers are NT and Linux. Our next upgade could very well be Linux desktops at the current pricing. I am getting more warmth on this idea from top management now. I keep hearing "Linux is more in keeping with our company culture" "Linux is more in keeping with our mission, etc." from our director these days when we talk about future platforms...

by generalist

I recently picked up a number of surplused PCs that I'm using for a low end home network and for PC maintenance practice. I open up the boxes, shuffle things around and end up with a PC that functions from a hardware point of view. Call it a low end hardware option.

The biggest problem I'm having thus far is staying legal when dealing with the operating system.

I would like to have a couple of machines running DOS, Win95 and Win98 so that some of my older software will function properly. Being a packrat of sorts, I still have the original diskettes and CD-ROMs for most of the application software. Better still, much of it is outside the upgrade paths, so I can legally install it.

I think I can use DR-DOS for the DOS side. Theprice for a five pack is less than that of one copy of Win98.

Win98, for the moment, can be picked up at CDW. It is kind of expensive though. One copy almost doubles my budget.

Win95 looks almost hopeless at this time. There aren't any sources I can trust.

Linux, as a low end operating system option for a low end hardware solution, is looking better every day.

by admin

I absolutely loved DRDOS :) I remember it as quicker and more feature rich than MSDOS or PCDOS.

Makes me kinda want to dust off the XT :>

by lordinfidel

Generally if you purchase a system from lets say, office depot/dell/compaq. The os is considered OEM and stays with the machine no matter where it goes. That machine is always liscensed for that OS.

Now if you buy a machine with 98 and you wipeit and install 2K w/o buying the upgrade liscense. Then you are in violation of the OEM agreement.

If the "liscense police" come in and ask for your liscenses and you have 20 systems purchased from office depot. Simply show them the receipts and you are good to go.

But if you have 20 systems that you built your self, then you better have 20 liscense registered in open liscense or hard copies.

Luckily most of the time they are just asking for numbers and not os to machine mappings. So there is room for transferral, which happens alot on cororate networks. Although it's not the most legal way, unless they do a phyisical audit then your covered.

On a side note... If they do do a physical audit, then there is usually a very good reason why they are doing it and you are probably way out of compliance anyways.

by mc_user

I seem to remember a Microsoft NT instructor of mine saying that there is a full copy of 95 included with NT server. I think it was there so that NT server could have a client to test with after installation. I hope I am not off base with this.

by tomsal

The BSA is the one's who come knocking. Though it usually starts out as legal papers mailed to the attention of the CIO (or equivalent position) of a company. Usually the next part is that the lawyers (both those representing the BSA and your own company's lawyers) keep in constant touch with one another.

The BSA will send inventory affidavits along with any terms they want met (ie. $15,000 plus licensing all illegal software copies, plus agreeing to open audits for 3 years, etc.) or else they can threaten to try the case in court. That's a bad thing because in court the penalty can be a max of $150,000 FOR EACH INSTANCE OF VIOLATION* and prison time.

*This is not me guessing by the way, this information comes DIRECT from the mouth of Microsoft's Regional Headquarters for my area.

So theoretically if you violated copyrights/licensing agreements in 10 instances you could be charged with $1.5 MILLION in fines.

Of course realistically, this would be EXTREMELY rare because just think about it. If a software company hit all the small offenders with the max penalities, they'd lose so much market share out of fear and a "EVIL" reputation it wouldn't be funny (at least not for them). ;)

PS. I know some of this stuff because our company got charged a few years ago for licensing violations --- and no it wasn't my fault or my staff's fault (IT depart.), we warned the powers that be MANY times by they ignored our advice! Needless to say they listen to us now on licensing issues--- real good.

by generalist

This makes me glad that I make an effort to keep things clean as far as software licenses are concerned. While I'm currently NOT a business, I've been investigating setting up a small IT oriented business using existing hardware/software assets.Given the cost of things like the OS and simple applications, Linux and open source software is looking more and more tempting for 'generic' computing. I can see a network where the high end machines with MS compatible software handle specialty things like graphics and heavy duty database work while other machines handle word processing, spreadsheets and hardware handling.

I'll just have to make sure that EVERYTHING is well documented and I have the appropriate types of insurance and legalese behind the organization.

by generalist

Interesting.

I have a copy of NT that I picked up as part of an OS/NIC package. Unfortunately I don't think it is NT server.

I'll have to check.

This discussion is closed to new replies.