Discussion Locked

Man-Caused Global Warming - Who's right, and why?

0 helpful
131 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

.
America's Al Gore, author of "Earth in the Balance", has called the internal combustion engine, a primary contributor to greenhouse gasses that cause "global warming", a worse threat to the Earth than nuclear weapons.

Australia's Cooperative Research Center for Greenhouse Accounting has recently suggested that the Earth may be more resilient to global warming than first thought.

Sir David King, Britain's Chief Scientific Adviser and Head of the Office of Science and Technology, described the "global warming" threat worse as than terrorism.

Philip Stott, professor emeritus of biogeography at the University of London said, "The notion that human activity is the controlling factor (of climate change) is inherently bogus. To believe that, you would have to believe that the sun, the oceans, the clouds, volcanic activity, and countless other factors do not play a major role in the weather.

Connecticut Senator Joe Lieberman (D) said, "The question of how and when we deal with the threat of global warming is one of the great tests for our generation of elected officials. The question is do we have the courage to begin to bring about the changes to protect us, our children and grandchildren?"

Oklahoma Senator James Inhofe (R) said, "Global warming is the greatest hoax ever perpetrated on the American people."

Massachusetts Senator John Kerry (D) said, "Global warming is America's biggest threat since the Cold War."

The Bush White House has said there was not enough scientific evidence to blame industrial emissions for global warming.

Okay, what do the experts at MIT (Massachusetts Institute of Technology) think?

Professor Ronald Prinn, Head of MIT?s Department of Earth, Atmospheric and Planetary Sciences, and Co-Director of MIT?s Joint Program on the Policy and Science of Global Change, said that, "global warming is the most difficult and important environmental problem that we face this century, and that it is a problem that we are going to have to solve, and we need to start forming solutions now.?

However, Richard Lindzen, professor of meteorology at MIT (Massachusetts Institute of Technology) and a member of the National Academy of Sciences, said in a paper titled, Scientists' Report Doesn't Support The Kyoto Treaty, "There is no serious evidence that man-made global warming is taking place. The computer models used in U.N. studies say the first area to heat under the 'greenhouse gas effect' should be the lower atmosphere - known as the troposphere. Highly accurate, carefully checked satellite data have shown absolutely no such troposphere warming. There has been surface warming of about half a degree Celsius, but this is far below the customary natural swings in surface temperatures." (Published in The Wall Street Journal, June 11, 2001.) Professor Lindzen has also pointed out that, "Claims that scientific opinion is nearly unanimous on the subject of global warming are wrong. The Oregon Institute of Science and Medicine received signatures from over 17,100 basic and applied American scientists, two-thirds with advanced degrees, to a document saying, "There is no convincing scientific evidence that human release of carbon dioxide, methane, or other greenhouse gasses is causing or will, in the foreseeable future, cause catastrophic heating of the Earth's atmosphere and disruption of the Earth's climate."

For argument's sake, let's concede that the Earth's surface has warmed a bit (a very little bit) over the past century. But is that warming caused mainly by humans or by natural cycles?

Is all this man-caused "global warming" propaganda real or imagined? What do you believe, and why? Who do you believe, and why? And the $64,000 question, therefore what?

131 replies

by thechas

In my mind, there are many things that we humans can (and should) do to reduce our impact on the resources of planet earth.

Industry groups spend far too much time and effort to attempt to prove that environmental problems don't exist. Yet, we regularly hear of companies who invest in efficient environmentally friendly processes and find their costs reduced.
The main difference, is that these companies take a long term view and are willing to make investments that payoff beyond a 6 month time-frame.

But first, I should keep to the topic.

The motor vehicles main contribution to environmental problems is that it allows people to live further and further from where they work.

The infrastructure to support our suburban life-styles provide acres of solar heat absorbing concrete and asphalt.

The acres of concrete have replaced acres of agricultural land, forests, and plains that provided natural evaporative cooling.

On a clear sunny day, there can easily be a 10 degree (F) temperature difference between a parking lot and a field near each other.

The heat absorption impact of parking lots and roads extends into the winter. Preventing the complete snow cover that there used to be just a few decades ago.

Another major culprit in man related warming is air conditioning.

Air conditioning adds to the global heat load in at least 3 ways:

The heat generated producing the electricity to run the air conditioner.

The heat from the condenser coil. (up to twice the BTUs removed from the cooled air)

And building design "choices" that require excessive amounts of air conditioning.
Prior to the invention of air conditioning, a dark colored roof was a rare site.
Now, with mechanical cooling, a dark roof is considered "fashionable".

Without air conditioning, there would also be few if any glass walled buildings.

Yes, it is very easy to dismiss concerns about global warming as periodic changes. It is also probable that the earth can "compensate" for some of the added warmth.

My concern is that there is some threshold where once we cross it, the planet will not be able to recover on it's own.

My overall view on global warming is that it is selfish to believe that human activity does not impact the environment in a negative way.

One need only review the global impacts of the last few major volcanic events to see the potential.

If we all would make a few minor changes in how we abuse the earth's resources, it would be fairly easy to reduce our impact.

Together, we have the ability to make global warming become a non-issue.

Chas

by gbrownlee

I live in a rural area in West Central Alberta, thats in Canada, and I spend a great deal of time outside. In the past 5 years the changes that have ocurred to the long term weater patterns here are unprecedented. Even out here, on a calm morning, there is a brown tinge on the horizon.

Then what I have come to call the daily hurricane starts to blow, and all the airborne pollution is blown into Saskatchewan, also in Canada. This brown haze is homegrown. The oil and gas industry is mercilessly raping our countryside in the quest to sait the Americans insatiable thirst for oil and gas.

As a former gasprocessing plant operator, I can bear witness to willful dumping and atmospheric releases of hydrocarbons and other extemely toxic wastes.

So you see, the source of major carbon dioxide release starts right at the source and just gets worse from then on.

Do I believe in global warming? YES. Thirty years ago, scientists were already warning those who chose to listen, that if we kept on the present course of hydrocarbon consumption, what is happening to our weather right now, would come to pass.

But then as one of my neighbors says " I dunno bout dis global warmin thing ".

Who's right? Only time will tell. But for the sake of our planet, could we please err on the side of caution.

by wiremaster

I was born in Rome and lived there for 20 years, then i moved to the countryside; i studied some agricultural science at the university and a lot of environmental-climate-bio-chemical-stuff.
One thing that drives me insane is that we don't ever seem learn: in the 70's they said CFC are bad and we still use them somewhere; PCB are perhaps worst and you can find them everywhere; a lot of chemicals, medicines, pesticides supposed to help us are now known to be worst than the problems/diseases they were supposed to cure (think about the resistant bacteria coming out every now and then).
It is proven and written that a lot of things we do can make changes in the weather, both in local and global scale but everybody just seem to care about the 5700cm3 V8 engine inside the hood and cheap fuel to let it run...
I think that we humans are just planning a mass suicide; i am lucky 'cause i still can see some grass and trees but how long will it last?
That's for the posterity to answer, if there'll be one.
I beg your pardon if i sound pessimistic, but i wanted to express my thought; ciao, wiremaster.

by jimhm

I will not disagree with you about polution of the air, water and land - and companies need to be held financially and morally accountable to clean-up their mess. I flew in the 1970's and you wouldn't see brown air until maybe 10 or 30 miles from a major city (say LA) - now you can't find clear air anywhere.

But for global warming - no way - now NASA is saying that clouds made by jets are causing an increase in temperatures - right! NASA hasn't done anything right since landing on the moon.

But I will argee 100% with you on Polution - and cleaning it up - AIR / WATER / LAND - hold these companies accountable... Global Warming - Red/Green party BS.

As others have said - to many factors - man maybe a small part - but there are just to many factors involved to say "Man and Fossil Fuels are the killers" ...

Fossil fuels are making the air brown - earth has been around a long time before man - and will be around a long time after man...

by hal 9000

Actions upon the planet.

While the planet may be able to save itself from natural occurrences we may just be pushing it that little bit that causes the whole thing to break. If you take a close look at mans activities on the planet and only restrict this look to modern times like the last 100 years or so just how many species of animals have we wiped out? How much land have we cleared for no reason other than wood chipping? While we continually rape the planet it only stands to reason that the delicately balanced system must eventually break down and no longer be able to support itself.

However on the bright side it will eventually repair itself as well although man might no longer be around to witness this event.

Col

by rabbit_runner

In all of this discussion, I believe that there is somehing being forgotten. Nearly all of the comments I have read (and heard) deal with man's actions/inaction on the environment.
My thought is, "What about the Sun?" The sun goes through cycles of giving off more or less heat. This does affect the earth. I believe that there is an 11 year cycle for sun spots. And this will affect the amount of radiation being given off. Or perhaps the lack of it.
I will agree that on a limited local level, creating areas of cement will cause warming. Also larger metropolitan areas will have slightly differnt temperatures than the surrounding countryside. However this will not prove or disprove global warming.

For anyone to prove to me, or disprove to me, that Global warming is a fact, it will require taking the sun into the equation. Until then, the items that may point towards the theory of global warming are simply ideas being present. No positive proof is being given.

Just my two cents.

by dc_guy

I have no doubt that human activity since the discovery of fossil fuels CAN have a measurable effect on the climate. What I doubt is whether current scientific models can determine that the ACTUAL effect is serious. I can't help coming back to the flippant but irrefutable argument: These very same "scientists" can't predict tomorrow's weather with much greater accuracy than a look out the window and a coin toss; who in his right mind could possibly trust them to predict the weather fifty years from now?

Less flippantly, huge fluctuations in the Earth's climate have occurred with utterly no regularity for as far back as we can measure with soil core samples, tree rings, and even archeological evidence.

12,000 years ago the Earth was so cold, and so much of its water was locked into the polar caps and the glaciers that radiate out from them, that sea level had dropped hundreds of feet. The Western Hemisphere was first populated by humans simply walking across what is now the Bering Strait. During one of these ice ages, mammoths established colonies on what are now the islands off of Santa Barbara, and got trapped there when the sea level rose back up.

Yet 800 years ago, the Earth was so warm that the people of England grew their own grapes and made their own wine.

Fossil fuel and man-made greenhouse gases had nothing to do with these dramatic temperature shifts, many of which far exceed those predicted by the Red-repainted-Green party.

Here's one that simply can't be explained away. Recent advances in astronomy have allowed the polar ice caps on Mars to be studied in much more detail than ever before. Guess what? They are melting, just like ours! Since no one is burning fossil fuels on Mars, another reason had to be sought.

Well gee, what else could possibly affect a planet's weather? Hint: It's big and it's yellow and it's known by various endearing names such as "Giver of Life." By pivoting their instruments about 180 degrees, scientists have determined that the energy output of the sun is not stable.

The amount of solar radiation available to the Earth has varied by enough to fully account for climate fluctuations -- just during the short time we've been able to measure it. There's no telling how much it might increase or decrease in a millennium or ten millennia.

So there's nothing wrong with cleaning up our act and taking better care of the planet. But when it all comes down, it's really the Big Landlord in the Sky's call.

by hal 9000

Several hundred years ago we certainly didn't have fossil fuels {as we have today but we where still using different forms of fuels} but we had other sources of fuel that was used quite extensively like wood from trees that where cut down to provide heat and cooking, then there where the oil lamps that where being used all through the Old Testament so some form of oil was being used although granted in smaller quantities than it is today.

Then there was the fact that we had a far smaller population than today so we didn't need to clear as much land to produce the food that we need to survive so with the advent of "Modern Civilization" we are having a far more dramatic effect upon the planet first just by having far more people inhabiting the place and then requiring far more land cleared to feed these people not to mention all the extra energy that these people are using this has to come from somewhere and it produces pollution. While not something new Europe has been suffering from "Acid Rain" for several decades now and they are fighting hard to eradicate this problem although to date that have not proved totally successful.

What about the hole in the Ozone Layer that is necessary to protect us all from what you like to call "The Giver of Life" as it is effectively a fission reaction on a massive scale that is throwing out masses of energy and other compounds/elements. While it is necessary to life on this planet and undoubtedly goes through cycles we don't need to destroy our own protection from this source of energy either. While I don't know what will happen and if "Global Warming" is real I do know that we are destroying the planet far faster than it can regenerate so it only stands to reason that eventually something must give and we will all suffer.

The main problem here is that something can only be proved after it has happened and by then it is far too late to try to stop it so the best that can be hoped for is to minimize the problem.

After all you certainly do not want to be in the position of having LA under 85 feet of water and ask why wasn't something done sooner? Do you? There is one certainly that change will be slow to happen and will be slow to recover so none of us want to run the risk of being wiped out as a species only to say just before the last of us dies "Well I guess that those Wacko's where right when they spoke about Global Warming after all!"

Of perhaps you are starting to build your own floating cities like in "Water World" although it would not be a feasible alternative as they had no long tern capacity to provide the necessary food that they would require but it did make an interesting movie.

Col

by deadly ernest

The truth is that both sides are right and wrong. Over the millenia the earth has gone through a number of warming and cooling phases, the geological evidence is there, we have been warming up since the last ice age. Natural processes like the sun and volcanoes are the main cause of this, and it is a growth curve process.

Yet some of the actions of man have had an effect on this process, the most severe effect comes from the reduction in greenleaf through forest and pasture reductions. Even if mankind were to return everything to its original state global warming would still continue.

BTW why is man building a dam for his purposes is artificual and wrong, whilst when a beaver does it for beaver purposes it is natural and right?

Anyway, there is no reason why we should not do what we can to lessen the impact of humanity on the environment. Simple changes, a decade or so agao the various govts banned production of new cars using leaded fuel, why not ban production of any vehicle that use petroleum based fuel. Biodiesel works it only needs govt support to help establish a standard with a production and delivery infrastructure and every existing petrol vehicle could be easily switched over to a much more environmentally friendly fuel. Enforce requirements to plant more greenleaf. these two factors alone woulr so change the environmental impact, and the economy it is frightening.

by hal 9000

On Hydrogen?

If that was to happen the main by product of combustion would be H2O which is far more friendly then even "Bio Fuels" and a lot easier to convert most motor cars and aircraft to as well.

Col

by jimhm

Come on Al Gore knows something about Global Warming - like when he said him and Clinton invented the Internet.

Na - but all kidding aside, its just a cycle the earth is in - the small amount of time man has been on this planet isn't enough to figure or even guess what nature is doing. Not when man has inhabited the planet can be measured in hundreds of thousands of years.

Look when I was a kid (50 now) they said no other star in the universe had a planets - now they are finding them all over - space travel something that happened in the movies - bottom of the ocean was dead, no life to deep nothing could live at those pressures -

Right no the information may point to a warming trend - but is it from Human - or cow poop - or just a cycle the nature is in - whats going to happen as the moon moves away from the earth - no one knows -

Al's book is all hype no scientific evidence - only speculations and greeny scare hype.

by hal 9000

But what I do know is that when vested interest groups start legal action to stop the various Government Departments from publishing reports on possible affects there is something to worry about.

Just image what we would be doing now if there was no research into tobacco or for that matter Cocaine as that was very popular a couple of hundred years ago ands somewhat less as well. Then there was the good old Indian Hemp which is an all natural product that is no longer being grown legally in large quantities because of someone asking something like "Could this be doing harm?" Research followed which proved all of these substances where harmful to man and even though Hemp made the best ropes that where used on all the sailing ships of the time it has been outlawed.

I actually have a "Companion Planting Guide" here from around the 1890 era which advises you to plant Indian Hemp around all your above ground crops to stop any insects from damaging your produce. I personally don't think that, that argument would wash in any court action now days do you?

While I'm the first to admit that I really don't know what is happening (I have seen weather patterns change in my short lifetime and while they could be a natural thing they could also be helped by mans activities as well. We have a louse history at protecting this planet and all its life as we have managed to wipe out quite a few species in just the last 30 years let alone the last 300 years and as time goes by we are destroying faster than we can rebuild the natural environment.

Here in Australia we have a massive salinity problem that is being brought about by land clearing and our current farming practices as well as our water management practices so we are losing productive land at an alarming rate with at present no solution available and even better while it is admitted that there is a problem only small amounts of money have been set aside to begin to study this problem. Governments talk quite a lot about this but come up short when they are required to put their hands in their pockets to fund research to prevent the problem in the first place as they just hope it will go away but unfortunately it only gets worse.

I have a horrible feeling that Global Warming if it actually exists will fall into the same category and action will only be taken after it is no longer a possible theory but a proven fact. So as we all watch our Detroit gas guzzlers disappear under water we will have to come up with another alternative to our current lifestyle and provide food from a smaller land mass for at the very least many more people so maybe "Soylent Green" isn't so far off.

Now isn't that something interesting to look forward to?

Col

by maxwell edison

Colin, you suggested that, "vested interest groups start legal action to stop the various Government Departments from publishing reports on possible affects".

Will you be so kind as to be specific, and name some of these "vested interest groups" who have initiated such legal action?

And by the way, speaking of vested interest groups, I would be willing to make a wager that all, or almost all, of the "scientists" who are on the "global warming" scare bandwagon are either employees of a government agency or are with an organization receiving grants from the government to study the "problem". Who pays these guys? Follow the money.

How's that for a "vested interest group"? Create a scare, and get paid to study it some more.

by hal 9000

There was a story in New Scientist about a group sueing a US Department Governemnt for publishing scientific data about Global Warming as they are claiming that it just doesn't exist. You should be able to find the story in the back issues of New Scientist or if you like I'll have a look around and see what I can find as I tend to keep these mags for quite some time so it's probably somewhere around here along with all the other technical mags that I get and don't get enough time to actually read. But this particular story I did read as I had just bought the mag and was waiting at the doctors so I had a bit of spare time.

Col

by voldar

are not fair. See also the other face of the coin, please. Follow all the "traces" of the money.

by fluxit

We need to care for our environment as we care for our individual homes. I remember back in the early 70's when fires would spontaneously combust on the great lakes and in the Mississippi and Ohio Rivers due to pollution. At one point in the 60's over 95% of the shore line in the Great Lakes were contaminated with foreign bacteria. No one could swim and enjoy the natural wonder. The stynch was unbearable and the views were unsightly. Massive cleanups were undertaken and America reclaimed the shores and rivers. We now have the clean water and air acts to safe guard the environment preventing Times Beach or other superfund cleanup sites.

IRT the green house gases and global warming, I recall in the 70's when there was a panic because the Earth was cooling and we were faced with the prospect of another Ice Age. The US Government had a project to tow icebergs out into the open ocean to melt them down reducing the risk of the polar caps from expanding too far. I also remember a panic that human populations were growing too fast. The Global populations were faced with starvation if something was not done soon about food supplies. Today, nearly 30 years later, the global population has nearly tripled and we over produce food. In fact, the US over produces so much food that we alone could feed the world.

I think everyone should note that behind every panic today is a call for money and a political motive. Projects are spun up and politicians claim they created millions of new jobs that are not real jobs. Just a few years ago there were an incredible number of forest fires. Then Vice President Gore pulled an Alexander Haig style exhibition at a press conference. He grabbed the microphone exclaiming, "People, people the only way to stop these fires is to increase taxes!" There was no mention that the administration he was in forbid clearing of underbrush that was fueling the fires. A change in policy was in better order than increasing taxes. But then the motives for the tax increase is a political point of view and another discussion in itself.

From a rational view regarding global warming the volume of the atmosphere compared to the annual reported volume of green house gas pollution amounts to a drop of red food coloring in the Pacific Ocean. In short, I do not sense an eminent danger of the Pacific Ocean turning red nor Green House Gases destroying the atmosphere. However, my nose does get irritated with the smell of the big city, burning fuels, and other distillates.

So yes I would like to see more environmentally friendlier vehicles and energy sources not because of green house gases but simply a desire for more pleasant living conditions. Have you ever seen carbon dioxide burns on plants close to highways or damage to your cars finish from acid rain? Ever wonder why water spots evaporate leaving a oxidized ring on your car finish?

Let's seek other energy sources and better modes of transportation making our world a better place.

by hal 9000

I particularly liked the one about raising taxes as that is the main reason behind almost everything that any Government ever does and it certainly isn't limited to America but to most of the Governments in the world.

I think you second last paragraph says it all and is totally correct.

Col

by jardinier

I think that all the arguments presented here
from various points of view are valid to a
greater or lesser extent.

But I concur with "ruralgeezer"

"Who's right? Only time will tell. But for the
sake of our planet, could we please err on the
side of caution?"

by maxwell edison

Colin,

You make these ludicrous claims, but can't back them up with anything at all. So I tried to back it up for you.

I took your challenge and searched for cases of lawsuits against any government attempting to keep them from publishing information. I didn't find any.

What I did find, however, were dozens of instances where environmental groups were suing various governments. AND there's a new movement that will attempt to sue people to collect damages caused by climate change, an "alleged" effect of global warming.

NOW THESE WHACKOS WANT TO SUE!

----------

Green party suing the government of Spain

http://www.newscientist.com/news/news.jsp?id=ns99993134

----------

This next decade is going to see quite a lot of climate change cases around the world "
Environment lawyer Peter Roderick
Some environmental lawyers believe this was a hugely significant step in paving the way to compensation claims against those responsible for climate change.

http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/low/science/nature/2910017.stm

----------

In the first suit of its kind filed by state governments, attorneys general from Massachusetts, Maine, and Connecticut are suing the US Environmental Protection Agency. They argue the Bush administration is jeopardizing the health of citizens and violating clean-air laws by failing to regulate carbon dioxide emissions. From the Boston Globe, January 31, 2003.

----------

US groups sue government agency over global warming:
Three major US environmental groups are suing the Environmental Protection Agency for failing to curb global warming despite its growing impacts on human health and the environment. The move comes amid growing anger among environmentalists over the record and intentions of President George W Bush.

----------

The basic message of the ABC report is that companies and organizations who are identified as CO2 emitters could find themselves being sued in courts for `damages' by litigants with real or imagined claims of loss through climate change. The notion is legally absurd anyway, even though the ABC report was co-authored by a lawyer. In real damages cases, it is normal for the court to determine the proportion of damage which can be attributed to the defendant. Since greenhouse gases are the accumulation of over a hundred years of industrialization and global economic activity, the total number of defendants is over 6 billion - the whole population of the planet.

The idea of one plaintiff, or a class action of them, suing 6 billion people - plus the billions more already dead but who contributed to the total greenhouse gas quantity - is a legal absurdity, but is one which is being promoted by the Greens anyway as a political correctness bludgeon to silence criticism of their agenda.

But a sinister new twist has been promoted by the ABC, a way to be more selective about who to blame - and therefore who to sue - for `climate change'. According to Martijn Wilder, a lawyer for the law firm Baker and McKenzie who floated this idea in Australia,

"The reality is that those who are probably going to be most exposed are the companies who have publicly taken an anti-climate change line."

What is that but a direct threat against free speech itself? Express your opinion and you will be the target of legal action - and this from the public broadcaster of Australia! Using, or even threatening to use, the courts to suppress the free expression of opinion is a flagrant abuse of the legal process and an unprincipled attack on democracy itself.

Heckling an invited head of state in our parliament was but the tip of a very sinister iceberg.

----------

4. SUING OVER CLIMATE CHANGE? THE DEBATE OVER GLOBAL WARMING IS GAINING A NEW DIMENSION: LITIGATION

http://www.sepp.org/weekwas/2003/April12.htm

"Some of it might be down to things you'd have trouble suing - like the Sun - so you obviously need to work how particularly human influence has contributed to the overall change in risk," the scientist, who has worked with the UN's Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC), said.

"But once you've done that, then we as scientists can essentially hand the problem over to the lawyers, for them to assess whether the change in risk is enough for the courts to decide that a settlement could be made."

----------

I could go on, but this is getting to be too much.

Suing people over global warming. Geesh - what's next?

by hal 9000

But it was about some special interest groups planing to sue the Environmental Protection Agency {I think} for publishing some study papers that claimed that the Green House Effect was going to have some adverse impacts upon the planet.

The basis of their claim was the fact that there was no proven facts behind these studies so they "The Government Agency" involved should not be allowing these papers to be published in the first place. They also went on to say that by allowing these papers to be published it was adversely impacting upon their profitability so they where seeking punitive damages as well.

Now as I originally said I don't know! but when I see things like this happening where research is stopped for short term gain by special interest groups I get a bad feeling in my gut.

While I'm unsure about any potential threat that may be posed by Global Warming that isn't a natural occurrence I do begin to feel uneasy when I see this type of thing happening as to me it tends to make the whole argument more supportive when you see special interest groups trying to prevent any study and publication of Scientific findings.

But just to make you happy I'll dig out the copy of New Scientist and list the story and Issue that it came from will that make you happy?

Col

by hal 9000

ludicrous claims If you would like to look up the 11 October 2003 Edition of New Scientist Number 2416 Australian copy on page 12 you will find an article headed "US court case challenges climate change warning" it is a half page article written by Fred Pearce and goes on to talk about how the "Competitive Enterprise Institute" is suing the White House Office of Science and Technology Policy for failing to block the report which is titled "Climate Action Report 2002."

Anyway this group is claiming that the EPA has published "knowingly fictional" science and is using the courts to block any form of action on this report. There is also a quote that "Several State Governments that support moves to tackle global warming claim that the Bush Administration is sympathetic towards the legal action which they say is a "Sweetheart Suit" that undermines scientific claims about Global Warming."

Also as I was looking for that article I found the following that may be of interest it is in the 27 July 2002 edition of New Scientist on page 7 and is titled "Insurers count cost of Global Warming." This particular article is about 2/3 of a page long and is written by Fred Pearce {again} but it starts off with the following "Insurance Premiums against floods and other disasters are set to rocket because the world's biggest insurance companies are getting nervous about climate change. Swiss Re, a company that provides insurance to other insurers, warned in a report this week that premium hikes are inevitable."

Now I don't know personally if any of this is real but what I do know is that New Scientist is a respected source of information and not thought of as "Trendy Left Wing Propaganda."

If you like I can scan these articles in and e-mail them to you when my ISP gets their e-mail server working again hopefully tomorrow but there is one thing plainly clear here that I didn't make up the story that I refereed to in my original post it does exist so it is hardly as you so kindly put it a "ludicrous claim" just because you couldn't find doesn't mean that it doesn't exist but only that you didn't look hard enough particularly since the article in question is less than 12 months old you should have found it easily as you had the name of the publication so it wasn't as if you had to search the world to find something that you didn't know where to start looking. I might add that I tend to work from memory and this is most times fairly right as I have actually seen and read what I talk about and as such I don't need to resort to posting multiple URL's to try to prove a point particularly when I said in the very beginning that "I DIDN'T KNOW" but that I do get concerned when vested interest groups started taking action to stop publication of things like this. In all honesty if the subject had not been mentioned I wound never have read it and I certainly didn't think that it warranted any kind or investigative response but if it makes you happy so be it.

However I'm in complete agreement with you about the stupidity of suing on things like this as it can only be proved one way or the other after the event and by then it is far too late to do any thing preventive to stop this from happening. I personally think that the only people who gain from this type of action are the "Legal Whores" who are only too willing to take on court action just to line their pockets at everyone else's expense.

Col

by maxwell edison

.
...for finding that article. It was an interesting post indeed. It led me to look into it further, and my findings were just as interesting. You're right. There was a lawsuit filed just as you said.

Who/what is the Competitive Enterprise Institute, one might ask? Well, the Competitive Enterprise Institute, called "the best environmental think tank in the country" by The Wall Street Journal, the Competitive Enterprise Institute focuses on the development and promotion of free market approaches to environmental policy. They believe that where individual property rights exist in environmental resources, the environment is most likely to be protected, and that market institutions more effectively allow for the realization of environmental values than political agencies and bureaucracies. As one of the leading proponents of free market environmentalism, CEI's program includes both an overall effort to reframe the environmental debate and a series of targeted projects to reform specific policies, ranging from federal land management and species protection to risk regulation and global warming.

In my estimation, they are also proponents of finding solutions to "global warming", but seek free-market approaches instead of, what they call, Eco-Socialism, a threat to Liberty around the World.

In the lawsuit you mentioned, you may be happy to hear that they withdrew that suit. Here's how it was explained:

Washington, D.C., November 6, 2003:

The White House Office of Science and Technology Policy (OSTP) has publicly acknowledged that the National Assessment on Climate Change was not ?subjected to OSTP?s Information Quality Act guidelines.? This acknowledgement now appears prominently on the document posted on the U. S. Global Change Research Program?s web site (http://www.usgcrp.gov/usgcrp/nacc/). With this admission, the Competitive Enterprise Institute has withdrawn its complaint in federal court that the National Assessment did not meet the minimal scientific standards required by the Federal Data Quality Act.

A subsequent product disseminated by the Environmental Protection Agency, Climate Action Report 2002, repeats many of the scientifically unsupportable assertions contained in the National Assessment and should now be subjected to FDQA guidelines, as should the next National Assessment due in October 2004.

?The record shows that the Clinton White House pressured bureaucrats to rush out an incomplete and inaccurate report despite protests from government scientists,? said Christopher C. Horner, Senior Fellow at CEI. ?The government also subsequently confirmed that the two climate models selected for the National Assessment are ?outliers? chosen to guarantee extreme results and are incapable of replicating even past climate trends.?

CEI argued in its complaint that the National Assessment violates legal requirements of objectivity and utility by employing computer models proven unreliable and by incorrectly revising climate history to portray the climate of the 20th century as unusual.

?We are pleased to see that the federal government has now put the public on notice that the National Assessment is propaganda, not science,? said Myron Ebell, Director of Global Warming Policy at CEI. ?The next report must meet the minimal scientific standards required by the Federal Data Quality Act.?

by maxwell edison

The Competitive Enterprise Institute is a non-profit public policy organization dedicated to the principles of free enterprise and limited government. We believe that consumers are best helped not by government regulation but by being allowed to make their own choices in a free marketplace. Since its founding in 1984, CEI has grown into a $3,000,000 institution with a team of nearly 40 policy experts and other staff.

We are nationally recognized as a leading voice on a broad range of regulatory issues ranging from environmental laws to antitrust policy to regulatory risk. CEI is not a traditional "think tank." We frequently produce groundbreaking research on regulatory issues, but our work does not stop there. It is not enough to simply identify and articulate solutions to public policy problems; it is also necessary to defend and promote those solutions. For that reason, we are actively engaged in many phases of the public policy debate.

We reach out to the public and the media to ensure that our ideas are heard, work with policymakers to ensure that they are implemented and, when necessary, take our arguments to court to ensure the law is upheld. This "full service approach" to public policy helps make

http://www.cei.org/

by maxwell edison

.
The "global warming" theory and the quest to live in a clean environment are not one in the same.

There's probably no one who wants a cleaner environment more than I do, but that doesn't automatically mean that I must subscribe to the "global warming" nonsense. (Yes, my choice of the word "nonsense" was an intentional bit of editorializing.)

No, I don't want industry (or individuals) to pollute our water.

Yes, I want to find a way to have cleaner air.

And if I ever see you throw trash out your window while driving, don't be surprised if you get the "evil-eye" from me.

Separate the desire for a cleaner environment from the "global warming" theory, thereby separating a real issue from a questionable one, and one basking itself in fear-mongering and deceptiveness, by the way, and there will be a lot more people on-board. Moreover, I believe that not only is the "global warming" theory seriously flawed, but the proposed solutions by the "environmental radicals", and they're the ones driving the issue, are a threat to free markets and personal liberty. If the "global warming" threat is real, and I've seen just as much evidence to question it as to support it, then free market solutions are the ones to seek, not socialist ones.

by fluxit

Global warming threatens Earth bound life by heating up the surface to critical temperatures killing life. It achieves this by the expulsion of pollutants namely CO that seeks a free O radical to stabilize itself. The CO attaches to the O making CO2 the infamous greenhouse gas. ChloroFloruoCarbons used as propellants and in cooling systems also contribute to the process of increasing CO2 on the atmosphere.

How is this than distillates and other contaminants that polluted the lakes and rivers causing fish kills and destroying water tables?

It is unsightly to see the crap floating on our rivers and lakes. It is irrating to smell the stuff. Likewise, it is just as irritating to smell auto emissions or see smoke stacks dumping crap into our air that causes the so called green house gases.

The difference being that I think we are past the days of widespread clean up and environmental scares. It is a matter of maintenance now. Global warming is more politicized than the earlier environmental issues and less of a real issue.

by jimhm

That will never happen - the RED - Greenies will never permitt that to happen. If it did they would loose the power that "Global Warming" has. Because they tied it to a Clean Environment.

There is a difference - Global Warming - Flawed Science - no scientific evidence - no repeatable therom (not even in computer models - unless they cheat) - Where as a Clean Environment - means a healther ocean - better drinking water - safer land - cleaner air ... which is repeatable - has a sound scientific base -

Yes - I call them RED - Greenies - because they are basically a Communist organization under the cloak of environmentalist... Their ask for direct scientific proof that global warming is a fact - and they will hand you flawed evidence. Because there is no evidence. To be scientific fact the therom must be repeatable - and they can't do it even in a computer model! Not without added a bunch of variables..

Global Warming - Flawed Science
Clean Environment - Something Everyone wants
RED/Greenies separate the Two - Never

by wiremaster

@ JimiHM:
I don't wanna start a quarrel here and i hate unpolite posts; moreover i think that you have a look on the U.S.A. situation but maybe you don't know much 'bout every green fellow or organization allovertheworld.
So i just wanted to point out that not all the greenies are children eating, stalin worshipping communists! A lot of them i know just don't care about red or black or purple 'cause they think that our only planet to live in is MUCH more important of my, your and anybody's politics.
In other words they think that whatever party you support pollution CAN kill you.
So i think it would be wise to give environment protection the maximum priority and beware of fake greens who only care about the chair...

by oz_media

Max, there is one area where we do see eye to eye, our wildlife and forests.
"And if I ever see you throw trash out your window while driving, don't be surprised if you get the "evil-eye" from me."

I usually follow them to the next light and sometimes I lode it at that point.
One time near Stanley Park, Vancouver's main attraction, I saw a guy in a rental throw his A&W bags and cup out the window.

At the next light I got out and (I used to carry 20" piece of 3/8" rebar on the floor beside me), walked up to his car. He saw me coming and tried to leave by driving through the red light but before he could get going, I had already removed his side view mirror and created a nice bill for him to address at National Car rental.

Don't come to MY city and throw YOUR garbage in MY park.

Now you may be able to get away with the evil-eye, but these idiots just piss me off to no end. How dare you pollute in MY world.

So as I expleined my focus is more environmental in my last post, I will detail that I do believe we re harming the atmosphere, yet it is still questionable as to the extent. The atmospheric layer when seen from space look SOOOOOOOO thin, like an eggshell.

The issue we need to resolve, is how klong do we wait for proof we ARE harming the atmosphere?
Until it has a week to go and they say, DAMN!!! It's true!

or do we act concisouly all the time?

No major life changes, just awareness and conciouseness(is that a word, it looks wierd?).

I see extremes on both sides, happy polluters and over 'green' save the world types. Must there be an extreme either way? Wouldn't just a general and global awareness suffice?

by maecuff

I too am appalled when I see people throw trash from their car. However..I had an incident a few months back. We were driving along when my little one announced that he was going to throw up RIGHT NOW. The only thing handy was an empty McDonald's bag. I shoved the bag in front of him, he puked, and I was left holding a bag full of McPuke. What do you think I did with the bag? That's right, it went out the window before seepage set in. This woman in the car next to us rolled down her window and was shaking her finger and screaming at me. I was leaned over the seat, trying to get Joey completely cleaned up and trying not to get sick myself. I swear to god, I wanted to follow their call and smack her. In fact, when I saw them heading off the expressway, I casually suggested to my husband that we stop and stretch our legs. He said, "you just want to chase that woman. I'm not stopping." The moral is.. while I will agree that littering is almost ALWAYS a lazy, inconsiderate thing to do.. it could be that someone has a bag of puke in their car..

by garion11

and some interesting conclusions/questions can be drawn from there. For those who haven't seen it, its about Man's burning of fossil fuels and the coming of a second Ice age when the troposphere gets "sucked" in to our lower atmosphere or some other crap (the science was so flawed it amazed me that some people take thsi seriously, although the special effects were cool).

But my point was, and its a general statement, the wooly mammoths and the sabertooth tigers didn't have these "global warming" inventions and an Ice Age still occurred. A volcano when it explodes (which there have been several in the 20th century) spews out more harmful toxins into the atmosphere than all the nuclear bombs put together, etc, etc.

Its kinda of funny to see these debates on global warming and Ice ages and other stupidity when us humans should realize that we are nothing in Mother Nature's world. We are little speck of dust that if she wanted to she could wipe us out without any problems whatsoever. We are so insignficant in the eyes of nature that it appalls me when someone says that Joe shmo driving an SUV or using a hairspray can kill the ozone, lol.

by maxwell edison

.
Against my better instincts, I paid the Hollywood elite a few bucks to see their propaganda film. And I must say, they did more to discredit themselves with that movie than anything anyone else could have possibly done.

What a joke.

by oz_media

Yes nature can completely erase the human race at any time, the Earth is going to spin well past my lifetime.

You are missing the point though. WE cannot survive even if the world can. The Earth doesn't care if it is too hot or if the oxygen is depleted, just everything living on it dies.

The idea behind global warming and environmental awareness is not that the Earth is going to die, it will become uninhabitable by the existing life that relys on Oxygen, light and rain to grow.

If YOUR great great grandparents had done what we are doing today, you would be living in a much different world than you are today and would be bitching constantly about the ancestors who turned it into a hot dump.

I don't care at all if it doesn't concern you, perhape you could actualy think of someone else for a change and see that THEY don't aprpeciate your garbage.

by colink.ltd

I agree that I like my clean, grean, and relatively unpolluted country and I dislike people that attempt to reduce it to the level of their own. Fair enough.
One of the governing pracitices today, and a total misconception, is that markets (economy, population) must grow to be sustainable.
Rubbish. That is the biggest problem that we face. Contain that and you can contain global issues such as warming, cooling, loss of forestry and wildlife, loss of fish, and so on.
Making manking responsible for himself would be an achievement, and would give your children a viable future.

by oz_media

I actually see a great effort on Vancouver Ilsnad in the small communities. There is abundant wildlife, a massive foestry industry and also MANY protected marine parks, forests and seaways (large whale populations). I moved from Vancouver where even though they are more aware than other cities I've lived in, it is still a cement forest and quite depressing.

This brings to mind another pet peeve of modern society, over development. I hate to see so much development in cities that slowly spreads to the outskirts and makes the city overgrow. I really prefer small town living, people are more concious of thier lives and the environment. They believe in supporting local business (which is mainly operated by neighbours)and just being more thoughtful overall.

Perhaps this is why I have moved mentally from being in support of corprate big business or capitalism to actually resenting it for what it has become.

There's just too many people in the world wanting too many things, time for me to start thinning out the herd I think, or maybe I'll just leave it to nutcases and gangs.

by jimhm

You're correct only USA Greenies are the ones I know or have read about.

by hal 9000

In New Scientist but as I've said I never took it all that seriously anyway. What is interesting with what you've dug up is that they are on the other side of the coin from what I imaged and I think it is the correct way to approach any potential problem like "Global Warming" if it even exists.

All to often we see the multi nationals just take what they want and forget about what they destroy in the process the "CEI" actions seem more in keeping with good land care practices and common sense than anything else. They sound like a very interesting place to visit.

Thanks Max for the URL I'll add it to my favorites and have a regular check up on their actions.

Col

by oz_media

First of all what do WE consider global warming, everyone has a different take.

Now as far as the earth's atmosphere thinning to allow us perpetual sun and eventually frying up inder tha sun, well that's probable but not in my lifetime. Just like the ice age etc. the universe and the plantes are constantly changing, no Earth won't be the same in several hundred/thousand years. I think we ALL agree here.

As for OUR emissions speeding up this process, it is pretty dim to believe otherwise, of course emitting unnatural gases in to an atmosphere is going to change the atmosphere, that's grade 2 logic and not something for debate.

As for OUR emissions (from vehicles actually killing us Armaggeddon style, well I don't think I'll have the luxury of seeing that but who knows what future generation will do.

So now we must think, if we aren't going to destrot the planet in the next 100 years, why should we be so concerned about emissions and industry.

Answer: LIFE

Life cannot thrive on exhaist of ANY form no matter how well filtered.

SOME emissions dissipate at high altitude and become harmless gases. SOME do not, such as Carbon Monoxide. CO is the biggest problem with vehicle emissions and is the main focus of the California air care act as BC's Air Care inspection.

When you walk through downtown and get a headache, it is usually not vehicle noise, it is CO. Carbon Monoxide cause carboxyhemogloben that will eventually suffocate your body and YES you will die, it happens more and more each year. Police officers in heavy smog towns are given respirators for traffic control as they were dropping like flies. You blood is starved of white blood cells and you literally suffocate.

Next, ANIMALS. In BC, there is no smoking in bars and restaurants anymore, the workers compensation board raised hell and a law was passed to protect workers in bars and restaurants from the patrons second hand smoke (my take was if you don't smoke and smoke bothers you, don't look for a job in a bar) but it was passed all the same. So we have found that our OWN personal emissions kill each other, this IS dyring my lifetime.

So what about the animals, trees, plants, lakes, and the entire eco system that must also be subjected to harmful human emissions?

Yes we pollute the world something nasty, yes we should be mroe aware and do whatever is in our power to stop the harm we cause to our planet. It was the samething when trees were at stake, awareness and action has seen most logging companies move into a system where they are simply cutting their own growth after 5 years, so the forest is constantly in a state of replenishment.

It is gobal awareness that keeps our world alive, not us, we have doctors to keep us kicking as long as possible, what about birds, critters, sealife and plants?

We either care or we don't, there's NO middle ground, there are no exceptions.

If we are going to be aware we then must act conciously. If not, then let's just all stop having children as they will have nowhere to enjoy life.

Why does it have to be proven that we are harming the planet in order to improve?

Can we not do what's best for LIFE ion the planet without needing to support it as a way to save the atmosphere and ultimately save OURSELVES?
If WE are in trouble we must confirm it and then address it. If the rest of the Earth's life is introuble, who cares, as long as winter comes?

by maxwell edison

.
I would usually say that seeing a litter-bug makes me want to throw-up. But in your case, seeing throw-up made you want to be a litter-bug.

The moral of the story is...............

by tomsal

Reading through these threads I see a lot of points I agree with and a lot of good ideas.

HOWEVER, I wonder to myself -- everyone here who is posting about how they are concerned with global warming/pollution do YOU really actively participate daily in ways that help to protect mother earth?

Do you recycle? Are you anal about not wasting resources -- water, electric, gas, oil, etc.? Do you make sure your a/c and other appliances are well maintained, energy efficient?

In short I'm jabbing at what I feel is the main problem...like with main issues we all share as humans living on the same planet...many people talk the talk, but they don't walk the walk.

I HATE recycling at my house, it frankly pisses me off -- especially when I'm doing a major house cleaning and have lots of junk..but I do it.

I make an effort to conserve and not waste as well -- mainly, I'll admit it, due to the fact that it costs money because I support myself and pay all the bills.

So yes...should we has humans be more responsible for mother earth? Of course we should. Do we as a society (especially us Americans) waste a helluva lot, yes we do.

But how many folks REALLY "go out of their way" daily to slow the process of pollution/damage to our planet....not very many at all.

by admin

and yet I recycle both curbside and taking stuff to the recyling center, bicycle or walk when possible, garden organically and conserve tons of water, fuel etc. These things are in my control, where Global Warming is no more in my control than where the continental coastlines are. We could try and do tons about it and a natural occurance can render our efforts moot at any time. We can all lessen the amount of resources extracted via recycling however.

Sometimes I think Global Warming is an easy target for people to be for or against that don't want the trouble of actually doing something in their own backyard -it's a smokescreen of sorts, an armchair pro football player at best. I applaud you for your commitment to recycling and energy conservation on a personal level. :>

by admin

Probably the most scientifically plausable reason the Dinosaurs died out right after pretty much all sea life ceased to exist was due to a global warming. First some major volcanic activity in what became Russia, a 5 degree worldwide increase precipated a huge release of methane from the seabeds and a second warming due to this raised it another five degrees. Almost all life was wiped out, but of course it was a good condition for the rise of mammals, who could also make it through the bitter cool periods that followed.

One wouldn't think ten degrees was a lot, but the huge layer of Carbon-12 in the rock at the time shows otherwise. Whether it began with a large rock near Mexico, massive lava flows or whatever we are still collecting evidence and theorizing, but the theories all stand on the evidence of a massive warming. Man, of course, wasn't even around yet to cause this change.

I am glad that it is warming significantly slower right now, and that no asteroids or huge seismic\volcanic activity are accelerating it today. Is it happening? Most probably yes. Do we contribute? Probably yes. Are humans the most powerful things on this planet yet? haha.

:>

by oz_media

Now i understand when kisd say I'm gonna puke, it means RIGHT NOW, not "I am starting to feel ill."

In my case, I would have either returned the bag to MacDonals and complained that it was cold or simply pulled over and dumped it. Going back to MacPukes with a bag of puke sounds like fun though, I'm gonna have to do that one day, I love shock value!

One day I was driving along and the guy in the back seat started tossing his garbage (fish and chips remnants) out the rear window. I had NO idea he had done this.

A car drove by me and started throwing garbage at me as they passed and a napkin landed on my windshield, being typical me, I booted it and when in front of the guy, started to throw EVERYTHING I could find out my window, finishing off with a large shake that completely cocvered his windshield. Well the chase ensured I stopped and my friends and i got out to see what these A**holes were trying to do. One of my friends (the one in the back seat)was just hysterically laughing. He had seen the whole thingh unfold, he had thrown his garbage which landed on the other car, they retorted by throwing it back at me and I ended it with tartar sauce and a large large shake. Anyone that is dunb enough to throw garbage out of my car (and it's been a LOOOOONG time) will find me slamming on the brakes and forcing them outside to go and pick it up.

Oh ueah, the two guys who had followed us and made me stop were not exactly a match for us so they just shrugged and left, with my other friend still curled up on the sidewalk laughing.

by maecuff

pulling over wasn't an option. It was all too quick and on the interstate, not to mention, that bag was not going to hold long. Again, I am vehemently opposed to throwing trash out of a car, but in (almost) every situation, there are shades of gray. But not in my hair :)

by colink.ltd

I live in New Zealand, in the South Pacific. We have a different view of the world, in many respects, because of our distance from anyone else,and our relatively small population. Weather from the Pacific Ocean and the sub-Antartic dominate our country, although dust and smoke from fires in Australia do occasionally reach us.
Because of, or perhaps in spite of, the above we are conscious of our world - and that means the whole world - economically, environmentally, and socially. Our economy is geared to exporting products to all over the world, and ensuring they are the best value and quality. We take very seriously what others may ignore, and we tend to be generalists rather than good specialists, although paradoxically we have produced some of the worlds best thinkers and leaders in amny fields.
Global effects are cause for concern for us for many reasons. We look at the whole world and search for patterns and effects, not just narrow economic or scientific concerns.
The evidence is that the world is changing. Pollution of the Atlantic noted in the '50's in the Kon Tiki expeditions is now being noted widely in the Indian and Pacific oceans, and even in the Artic and Antartic seas. Much of this pollution is man-made and based on mineral oil products. Fish stocks are reducing rapidly and fish catches of even 10 years ago are becoming scarcer everywhere. El Nino and El Nina events are causing more extreme weather fluctuations in macro and micro events. The first ever hurricane has been recorded in the South Atlantic this year - normally too cold to support this weather. The ozone depletion in both poles is becoming extreme enough that even seals and birds are dying because of over-exposure. Water tables everywhere are reducing and saline intrusions are causing large areas to become arid where they were fertile before for centuries. Weed growth in the Indian Ocean is occurring rapidly and altering shipping lanes. Massive overuse of fresh water in many parts of the world is causing rivers and lakes to dry up, creating follow-on effects to the environment.
Does this mean the Earth is warming, or is this a consequence of mankind's arrogance? At present the thinking is divided, but becoming a combination of both.
When will the global effects be felt - you blind yourself if you cannot see any of the above. It is happening, but nature has a great capacity for absorbing changes for long periods before a radical adjustment.
What form will that adjustment take? There are theories - the film 'The Day After Tomorrow' is based on one theory predicting an Ice Age as an example. Others I have read predict a rapid escalation in temparature yet to come. Most importantly all valid theories acknowledge the capacitor effect in nature. Economics as we know it will be adversly affected, and huge populations will suffer. We have too many political, social, and theological differences today to make a truly global effort sustainable to avoid this, regardless of the abundance of food and water in some areas.
In answer to your question - Who is Right and Why?
Your question seeks blame instead of answers, causes division instead of concerted effort. We have many issues that need addressing in this world today, and not nearly enough effort is being made to address them. Technology provides some answers and some solutions, but not nearly enough. Just as the space race galvanised the USA into a massive effort in the '60's a new race - to make the world a sustanably habitable place - must take place. That means changing the hearts and minds of billions into actions that will change their lives, traditions, and living places forever. Can you realistically agree that can happen? Will humanity overcome humankind?

by maxwell edison

.
I'm happy to see a New Zealander reply. I've always been interested in New Zealand, and although I've never been there, it has been a place I would consider living if I ever left the USA (based on what I've learned about it). Perhaps it's time for a visit.

Nonetheless, you bring up some great points, articulated them quite nicely, and asked some interesting and very thought-provoking questions. I'd like to dwell on some of your comments and reply at a later time.

by oz_media

Well that was a thoroughly interesting post to read on TR, what a well versed and accurate explanation.

Without offense, I will not be dwelling on it as I agree wholly with your points and feel the same on many issues already, you really spoke volumes.

Thanks for your thoughts, I certainly look forward to more of your comments in the future,
OM

by jimhm

If we believe the weather forcasters (which are normally 80% wrong on a 5 day forcasts) then (and I don't believe in global warming - it wasn't that long ago 1970's when they said we were headed for another ice age) it has been thousands of years in the making. Do you really think that in 10 years or even 100 years there would be any marked difference.

The hydro-floro carbons - that are being used today have been found to be more dangerous than the CF's of the past. Hum

Then they say that the Methane from cows is helping increase it - gee is that what kept the warmth with the dino's - those piles had to be the size of 2 cows. Hum again

So where is the hard fact's where is the repeatable evidence - where is the scientific proof - its all theroy and cojector - they have shown that the earth goes through a cycle of warmth and cold - from core samples of the artic/antartic - the hole in the Ozone they project has been there for thousands of years and also has a cycle. Hum a 3rd time..

If the Global warmers would separate the Polution from the bogus theroies of Global Warming - they wouldn't have anything to argue - and the anti-polution folks would have a stronger position.

So with flawed science of the Global Warming crew - what you ask is - Never in a million years... would you go back to the way your great grandfathers lived - or move forward with technology?

by oz_media

Have you heard Denis Leary's song A**hole? Not implying YOU are an A-hole Jim, but the song is about an American pig who drives the biggest car he can find, "with baby seal eyes for headlights".

"Folks, I'd like to sing a song about the American Dream. About me. About you. The way our American hearts beat down in the bottom of our chests. About the special feeling we get in the cockles of our hearts, maybe below the cockles, maybe in the sub-cockle area. Maybe in the liver. Maybe in the kidneys. Maybe even in the colon, we don't know.

I'm just a regular Joe with a regular job
I'm your average white suburbanite slob
I like football and porno and books about war
I've got an average house with a nic hardwood floor
My wife and my job, my kids and my car
My feet on my table, and a cuban cigar

But sometimes that just ain't enough to keep a man like me interested
(Oh no) No Way (Uh-uh)
No, I've gotta go out and have fun
At someone else's expense
(Oh yeah) Yeah yeah yeah yeah yeah yeah yeah

I drive really slow in the ultrafast lane
While people behind me are going insane

I'm an asshole (He's an asshole, what an asshole)
I'm an asshole (He's an asshole, such an asshole)

I use public toilets and piss on the seat
I walk around in the summertime saying, "How about this heat?"

I'm an asshole (He's an asshole, what an asshole)
I'm an asshole (He's the world's biggest asshole)

Sometimes I park in handicapped spaces
While handicapped people make handicapped faces

I'm an asshole (He's an asshole, what an asshole)
I'm an asshole (He's a real fucking asshole)

Maybe I shouldn't be singing this song
Ranting and raving and carrying on
Maybe they're right when they tell me I'm wrong

Naaaah!

I'm an asshole (He's an asshole, what an asshole)
I'm an asshole (He's the world's biggest asshole)

[Spoken]
You know what I'm gonna do? I'm gonna get myself a 1967 Cadillac El Dorado convertible, hot pink with whaleskin hub caps and all leather cow interior and big brown baby seal eyes for headlights, yeah! And I'm gonna drive around in that baby at 115mph getting one mile per gallon, sucking down quarter pounder cheese burgers from McDonald's in the old-fashioned non-biodegradable styrofoam containers and when I'm done sucking down those grease ball burgers, I'm gonna wipe my mouth with the American flag and then I'm gonna toss the styrofoam container right out the side and there ain't a God damned thing anybody can do about it. YOu know why? Because we got the bombs, that's why.

[Spoken]
Two words. Nuclear fucking weapons, okay?! Russia, Germany, Romania - they can have all the Democracy they want. They can have a big democracy cake-walk right through the middle of Tiananmen square and it won't make a lick of difference because we've got the bombs, okay?! John Wayne's not dead - he's frozen. And as soon as we find the cure for cancer we're gonna thaw out the duke and he's gonna be pretty pissed off. You know why? Have you ever taken a cold shower? Well multiple that by 15-million times, that's how pissed off the Duke's gonna be. I'm gonna get the Duke and John Cassavetes...
(Hey)
and Lee Marvin
(Hey)
and Sam Pekinpah
(Hey)
And a case of Whiskey and drive down to Texas...
(Hey, you know you really are an asshole)
Why don't you just shut-up and sing the song pal!

I'm an asshole (He's an asshole, what an asshole)
I'm an asshole (He's the world's biggest asshole)

A-S-S-H-O-L-E Everybody! A-S-S-H-O-L-E

[Barking]
Arf Arf Arf Arf Arf Arf Arf
Fung achng tum a fung tum a fling chum
Oooh Oooh

[Spoken]
I'm an asshole and proud of it!"

Stereotype yourself much Jim?

by mrafrohead

I can say from what I have been reading... The world isn't actually getting warmer, but it's actually getting colder.

The reports that are posted on global warming are false and misleading.

I can say in my neck of the woods, it sure as hell seems to be getting warmer, but looking at who all is saying it's getting warmer, well most of them, why would I trust them???

;p

by hal 9000

But you should believe the increases in your insurance premiums! At least some of the corporate world takes "Global Warming" seriously even if it is to only line their own pockets.

So should we all launch a "Class Action Suite" against these insurance companies because they are using "Flawed Science" to justify their insurance premiums? Or just accept the fact that weather conditions are getting more extreme and costing people around the world more every year?

Currently here in Australia we have a drought going that at present shows no signs of breaking and it is our very poor top soil that is being blown away as there is no longer anything there to hold it in place. So even when it does rain again there will be less of what we actually grow with left to use. Then when the drought breaks these are normally followed by massive rain falls that cause flooding which again washes away even more of the already limited soil, if this continues there will be very little left other than a desert in the heart land of Australia which will rival the Sarah for its vastness. Incidentally I might add that a lot of the dust storms that we have here actually blow so hard and long that it is a common occurrence for what dust is being blown away to reach further than New Zealand. So it is a really serious thing and along with salinity increase we are facing a reduction in productive land that is truly massive in comparison to what was here before "White" settlement.

Col

by admin

...and I was hoping the entire west coast would be submerged so I could have beach property :)

by thechas

Max,

I had a new thought on this subject.

From a pure business standpoint, it makes sense to fully embrace the concept of global warming and move for a complete change in how America derives and uses energy.

Hear me out.

The manufacturing and energy industries only stand to profit form a complete restructuring of Americas energy addiction.

New vehicles,
New appliances,
New energy production plants,
New energy distribution lines,

Embracing global warming could do the same thing for the entire US economy that the introduction of the Compact Disk did for the audio equipment industry some 15 years ago.

US businessmen are only looking at the cost to them if they have to make changes to deal with global warming.

If they embraced the concept, and started producing "must-have" products that "reduce" global warming, the potential profits would be enormous.

Chas

by tomsal

Sorry everyone its my fault this Global Warming thing.....

I had Pintos and Beans last night with my Tacos...

;)

by jimhm

Ah thats the Global Warming problem - Fartman - to many humans with farting problems - need to keep it in -

by jamesrl

The one line hit home.

Yesterday I was a coward. (See I admit my faults).

Coming out of the Canadian equivalent of Barnes and Noble(Chapters), I go to my car - parked next to the handicapped space. Now important to note that all the handicapped spots were full.

In the space next to mine(which was empty when I arrived) was an SUV. With a bike rack. And two extremely healthy and non handicapped individuals loading up their bikes on the SUV.

I am a coward because although I felt like saying something, I didn't. I regret that. My mom has a handicapped sticker because she gest short of breath and has bad arthritis. I don't know if any handicapped people were inconvenienced by these guys, but they could have been. And they would not have been overly inconvenienced to take another spot.

I have spoken up in the past, when people made racist or sexist remarks. Not sure why I didn't yesterday, probably too tired.

James

by oz_media

At a bank near my New West office I always see poepl parking in the handicapped spots because they are close to the bank machines. I suppose the mentality is that they aren;t going to be long, even though a handicapped person may ALSO need the banmk machine.

So I was standing out front waiting for a friend and an Asian family in an SUV (one of those rinky dink SUV wannabe's by Honda or Suzuki)one person got out and went to the bank machine, another went next door to Starbucks (ick). I walked up to the driver and pointed to the handicapped sign while saying "Who the F*** do you think you are, this is a handicapped spot?" ( I should add that the spot right next to him was free and was not a handicapped space(narrower). He smiled with his grin of gold and shrugged as he didn't speak English (or pretended to anyway). I then saw his daughter returning from the bank, she got in and waited for the other boy to return from Starbucks. 5 minutes later he appeared from Starbucks, got in and they ALL sat there and started drinking coffee. Again I walked up to the window, this time the younger girl's and asked if they were staying here long or if they were planning on letting handicapped people park too. She smiled and said "We were using the bank, we can park if we want to." So I pointed out the handicapped sign again and walked away in disgust.

Meanwhile, the bank manager (a Chinese man) had come outside for a smoke and saw me, he shrugged and said "they do it all the time, then they just shrug and pretend they don't understand you."

So I guess no matter what we do ourselves, there is always some moron who refuses to show any public courtesy. It is to the point nowadays that it is easier to just ignore people and let them do what they want, but then again it is this feeling that is going to see coutesy go out the window as less and less people care.

Don't kick yourself, they would have probably just smiled and waved.

by maecuff

I love denis leary, he is funny. I'm gonna have to watch no cure for cancer this weekend..

by oz_media

I have some Denis Leary, George Carlin and others on disk and keep forgetting to send them to a TR peer. Thanks for the reminder!

by jimhm

Either your unemployed or someone is paying loads of money for you to toss off during the day..

Ah - just prove my point from another post ... bater or is that master

by oz_media

The time to copy and paste song lyrics? If it takes more than 30 seconds, you shouldn't have a job. As for time, you know I have as much as I choose.

by oz_media

What kind of comment is that anyway?
"for you to toss off during the day." Did you not just find the time to post THAT comment?

"bater or is that master"

I may be worng but I believe it is "BAITING".

And what's with all of the toss off and masturbate commnets? Are you running out of sensible retorts?

by voldar

That's a tricky question, with lots of issues.
Let me try to answer it.
As you are very aware, anything a person does has a response from another person or thing. Any action has an reaction. As Japanese say, there is no emptiness without a ?fill? (sorry for my lack of English, I don?t find a better word for now).
We all have (even without our knowledge) influence onto the environment we live or work. Why not thinking and maybe taking into consideration that maybe we have our share from that percentage that influences the climate as well?
I don't know about your life experience, but all I can say is that since some 10 - 15 years the climate has changed, drastically. In Eastern Europe for example, the 4 seasons (spring - summer - autumn - winter) became 2 and a half (winter - summer and some late autumn). We never had snow in May, but since some years, well, we do. And summers never last till November!!
As I learnt when I was in school (some very long ago) the ?atmosphere? consists of gases that are in a very fine proportion mixed, so that life as we all know could exist. If you change 1% of each or only one of these gases, well, reactions start and sure something changes. The main problem of "warming effect" is the CO, as you surely know. How and what can be the natural cause that spread the CO into the atmosphere? Unless flowers and trees (during the night). None! Or well, there are also volcanoes, but they don?t count. Who is the one that can take the CO from the atmosphere? Flowers and trees during the day light. It?s obvious that the air in big cities is not the same as the one on the countryside. Pollution is a fact. How pollution affects the atmosphere, well, I don?t know, but saying it does not, seams a bit stupid from my point of view.
If you will ask scientist, well, there will be always two approaches about this fact:
1. - the quantity is insignificant
2. - there is a real problem that we have to deal with
Both answers seam to be accurate, because both are based on science, but well, science is not that evoluated so that we can always use it as an umbrella. I remember when in early 1900s, someone said that car will never run over 20 miles per hour (human body can?t stand such speeds), and well, that really happened even in the time when that man who said that was still alive.
The problem of warming - which is right or not ? is not my concern, but if there are studies made to prove once for all that something changes or not for natural/non natural causes it would be better to know.
And I always thought about something, that bothers me since a long time ago. The car engine as we know (the principle I mean) appeared almost 100 years ago. What in the hell stopped the evolution of it? Could that be the Oil?
We all know that computers change every 3 to 6 month, new solutions, new features, and new structures. Imagine what a steep curve of progress personal computers had since their born (1980). But not cars!
That's a good question I would like to ask. What would it be if cars would run with water or electricity?

by oz_media

I se eyou are aware of CO emmissions too, we die when we inhale CO, that IS a proven fact. Cars emit CO, THAT is a proven fact. Therefore vehicle emissions are killing us, again a proven fact, but what about more sensitive life, plants, trees animals etc.?

"What in the hell stopped the evolution of it?"

Now i know you are suggesting that auto manifacturers can build better cars and they can, they can even build FAR better combustion engines. The bottom line though is that with ALL of our advances in technilogy and industry, nobody has made a more eficient propulsion system than an internal combustions engine. They tried the rotary engine, adopted from WWII aircraft and severla others but they all relied on the same principals as the piston engine and were more expensive and more troublesome.

Clean cars are eternal revenue, EXCEPT when we use our limited supply of nonreplacable oil. Once the crude is gone, it's gone, that's it, no more gas. So either we drill the heck out of allof our resources and burn it up so these oil companies have to find new acenues for revenue or we simply have to force them to build more efficient gas engines (like they did in Europe) while exploring other avenues topropel motorvehicles.

There is a car rental dealer in Richmond that rents exotic cars, Prowlers,BMW's, Ferrari's Lamborghini's etc. They also have a little (wierd looking) electric Toyota that never gets rented. I am thinking of renting it just to have some fun but I'd probably get a major charge when I return it after tearing it down for a closer look.

by maxwell edison

.
First of all, I assume you mean CO2, not CO.

CO is Cobalt. CO2 is Carbon Dioxide.

CO2 from vehicle emissions is killing people?????

That's a "proven fact", as you suggest?

Will you please provide proof of that?????

How many people die every year because of CO2 inhalation?????? (Not the suicide whackos)

Give me a number please.

Plants and trees die from CO2???????

They do??????

I thought plant life absorbed and thrived on CO2??????

Silly me.

And if you really do mean CO, please explain.

by hal 9000

When Europe switched to unleaded fuel there was a unknown side effect and that was "Acid Rain" as the main product of combustion included H2SO2 which combined with 2 Oxygen atoms in the atmosphere and came back down in the rain as H2SO4 or Sulfuric Acid for those who have long forgotten their Periodic Tables. While there has been virtually no development on internal combustion engines this isn't from the want of trying I can remember Porsche introducing a car in the early 90's that beat the proposed 1996 Emission Laws that the US auto makers said was impossible to do. The US Government took it all around the country to show exactly what could be achieved when proper engineering is used and the Accountants kept away from the manufacturing procedure and it was going very well until some one noticed that there was no catalytic converter on the Porsche. Of course there was legislation in place requiring catalytic converters so that Porsche had to have one fitted and the emission levels went through the roof from what they had been previously.

What I'm trying to say here is that the development of the internal combustion engine has been hindered by Government Regulation rather than enhanced so we are in the current position that we find ourselves in. But I'm betting that when fossil fuels start to run out there will be a switch to Hydrogen as a primary fuel and the current oil companies will be the main suppliers.

If Hydrogen was adopted a a primary fuel the only by product of combustion would H2O which would make no difference to the atmosphere and possible be a massive improvement. It is a simple matter to produce Hydrogen quickly and cheaply from water and requires less energy to produce than is currently used to "Crack" fossil fuel into what we now use.

But until there is some form of finical incentive this will just not happen as the fuel companies have a vested interest in keeping the Status Quo.

Col

by jimhm

Val - you are doing the standard Global Warming BS - mixing air polution with Global warming. There is no correclation between the two.

That is what is killing you movement - 90% of the world (that is educated understands that) - there is no scientific evidence to say that polution and global warming are linked.

Get you head up open your eyes - there is no evidence of global warming - yes there is evidence that polution kills - but there is no link between the two...

It is a flawed theroy that doesn't hold air -

by oz_media

The issue is that we are being told that oru emissions create global warming, which has been contested by both side offereing valid arguments.

What ISN'T in question though is that our industrial emissions ARE killing US though. So for those that say the Eatrh will be around forever, they are right, WE WON'T though, unless we make a concious effort to reduce emissions.

Global Warmin is probably not proven enough fro mist to but it, they then complani about the efforts to reduce emissions and clean up our industry. That may or may not effect global warming BUT it most definitely does help to sustain life on our planet. We MUST make a concious effort to reduce our emissions from autos and industry, we are simply killing of life as we know it, for us AND all the animals, sea life and plant life on the planet.

So next time someone complains about pollution and global warming, don't look up and roll your eyes, think of it on a more local level and see that we need to clean OUR air regardless of the atmospherical effects,

by voldar

I never said that Pollution IS the Global Warming, but I can always wonder if there is no link between them, whether you like or not.
If you will be capable to prove without doubts that gases from the pollution field do not have any influence on the atmosphere's "fine tuning mix", well, I will always have a doubt. THIS does not make me be a GREEN, hell no! I am not and never will be!! It was just a free discussion, and I put my thoughts on-line, that's all.
This is the problem with scientist in fact. They want to "touch" things, and maybe, then they will believe what they touch, but I don't think that is the best approach.
Remember, great ideas and discoveries were born by mistakes, by hazardous happenings, nothing that a "scientist" would ever thought about before it happened.
So, to conclude, I am not a doctor in science to say that the Global Warming is BS (I assume you are when you say that without having any doubts at all), but this will never stop me thinking that maybe some "stories" might be right. And I always disliked people that think they know all very well, that they are the "all mighty ..." because in my life experience they were in fact little nothings that imagined themselves as gods. As for myself, I know I don't know everything (and I don't even like to know everything), and I like to ask questions, looking after answers. If I am wrong or not, well, why would anyone else care? I am not that ROCK that breaks the WAVES on the ocean shore.

by maxwell edison

.
Go ahead, make your point.

Follow the money on the other side of the coin, and what do you find?

Quite frankly, if you're suggesting that those scientists who question man-made global warming are in the pockets of the auto industry and such, I'm all ears to hear your proof. Go ahead and look for it. But I don't think you'll find it.

by voldar

I am not sugesting that, cars! But let me be the advocat of hell. Imagine that another type of engine (water engine) is developped.
Lets imagine how world economic would look like if oil goes off of the picture, if the actual poor countries (that pays a lot for oil) change their status because of their reachness in water. Wouldn't that be a haos born? Or at least some major changes I am sure would take place.
And I stop here.

by oz_media

I can see what you are saying Vlad, but I don't think the petroleum companies would go anywhere, they would just capitalize on the opportunity available to other countries, if they weren't allowed to use it, they would create a reason for America to take it anyway.

by oz_media

Cobalt is actually Co not CO.
CO is Carbon Monoxide, CO, causes a reduction in white blood cells (oxygen carrying cells) and literally starve your body of oxygen. This is as condition known as Carboxyhemogloben and is very common in traffic cops, highway workers, street vendors (hot dog stand etc.) and people who work in busy cities.

Side effects start with headaches, usually at work or while shopping, which many be eqated to stress or traffic noise then hypoxic injury to brain, liver and renal tubules.

So yes I really do mean CO.

by oz_media

I almost forgot to answer all of your questions, I get really focused on the emissions issues. Since I became Air Care certified for vehicle emissions testing, it's a sore spot with me.

>>"First of all, I assume you mean CO2, not CO."
No I mean CO and not CO2

>>"CO is Cobalt. CO2 is Carbon Dioxide."
No. CO is Carbon Monoxide. CO2 is Carbon Dioxide

>>"CO2 from vehicle emissions is killing people?????"
No. CO fromvehicle emissions is killing people.

>>"That's a "proven fact", as you suggest?" This is a combo question along with "Will you please provide proof of that?????"
Yes. 'If you inhale CO, it gradually replaces oxygen in the bloodstream, eventually causing suffocation. Mild CO poisoning feels like the flu, but more serious poisoning leads to difficulty breathing and even death.'
http://tinyurl.com/2s4j6 (in your home too, that's why they sell CO detectors AND smoke detectors)

>>"How many people die every year because of CO2 inhalation?????? (Not the suicide whackos)" Again a combo question, "Give me a number please."
'a current average of 534 deaths, annually, in the United States. Between 1995 and 2000'
http://tinyurl.com/2s4j6

>>"Plants and trees die from CO2???????"
No. "Silly me(you)"

>>"hey do??????"
No. "Silly me(you)"

>>"I thought plant life absorbed and thrived on CO2??????"
Yes. It does.

>>"Silly me.""
Yes. You are.

>>"And if you really do mean CO, please explain."
I did. Last post.

OM

by oz_media

Maxwell lives in Colorado (state abbreviation, CO).

I was joking with Max about how he live in Co and made a mistake about Co, CO2 and CO. Then added that he even LIVES in CO, meaning Colorado. If you read my other posts, god help you, you will se that I actually understand emissions quite well, moreso than typing that's for sure!

by jardinier

as your knowledge of chemistry seems to have been adversely affected by ferrous oxide.

But not to worry. As the Greenhouse Gas Effect is a Commie, Leftie, Greenie, Weenie myth, all the hot air which you have expended in this pointless discussion won't contribute to global warming.

Actually, what is the purpose of this discussion? I guess you are trying to make some point or other, but I am not sure what.

by voldar

CO = monoxide of Carbon
CO2 = bioxide of Carbon

At least that is what I learnt at school. They are different but yet the same in a way. CO mix with O in atmosphere and the result is CO2 - used by plants in the photosyntezis process.

by maxwell edison

.
Please disregard the message titled, "What are you talking about". The author of that message is, obviously, the one who didn't know what he was talking about. That was his worst TR blunder since.........well, that's not important.

He must have been suffering from a brain fart, brain freeze, or perhaps was the temporary victim of some gas inhalation poisoning. He has since been given some O2 treatments, has been ordered to drink plenty of H2O, and is resting comfortably in CO. A full recovery is expected.

by oz_media

It was referred to earlier.

Max is IN CO.

I will accept the brain fart though, we all have them and Max's ability to stand up and realize he made a simple mistake is almost honorable.

Good form Max.

by cialis

It's not fair to play with the nature. Human beings if suffering because of their own mistakes.Lets try and make this world a place to live. Lets make it a better place.cialis

by jimhm

Sounds like the old Coke comm -- I like to teach the world to sing - remember the earth has been around for millions and millions of years - man has been a small pimple on its butt cheeks for only a few hundred thousand...

So - Mom Nature can take care of herself - like who ever said man has to try and help mommy nature fix herself - when she's been doing it for millions of years... I guess we know best even for nature ... yepper - The Uni-Bomber was right - get ride of technology - back to the stone age - with Fred, Wilma, Barney and Betty - and dino power - yep that will be the way to live ... baby elephant disk washers and us liberals can fix anything include mother nature...

Hog Wash

by jamesrl

If you think that Mother nature can take care of herself, try living beside the Love Canal, or near Chernobyl or some of the other places that are unihabitable because we have been lousy stewards of the planet.

If you let nature take care of herself, we wouldn't have any eagles or falcons(DDT), no whales(over fishing) etc. We wouldn't have lost the carrier pigeon or the Dodo.

The fact is that we do have a negative impact on the environment, and the only way to overcome that is to regulate ourselves. If we humans all died off, mother nature might be able to recover in a few thousand years.

We need to treat the planet the way we treat any precious commodity - we have to conserve it, and not spend it foolishly.

James

by oz_media

Nature creates it's own harmful emissions, the world is able to cope with these emissions to a certain extent, although the planet does change as a result.

WE don't need to create our OWN emissions that nature cannot deal with in order to prove a point.

This ha sNOTHING AT ALL to do with getting rid of technology, it has everything to do with awareness, which you seem to refuse to have. You refuse to accept responsibility for your own actions and pass it ff that you will be dead long before the planet in uninhabitable, so what, why ease the destruction of life (I forgot you enjoyed killing people didn't you)?

If you know you are going to die from smoking, would you then just shrug it off and say, 'I'm going to die anyway, who cares if I live longer?'
Nice defeatist attitude.

How did you reach the conclusion that just because we need to reduce emissions and pay more attention to our messes, this then means we should go back to the stone age, as the Uni-bomber apparently suggested? How does this relate to the topic at hand? It doesn't.

As for saying Us LIberals can fix anything including mother nature, think about it for just a quick minute.

Nobody is trying to FIX mother nature or anything to do with nature, your point is invalid.

We are trying to fix what WE do to harm mother nature, not fix it but protect it from our OWN mistakes. Mother nature will do just fine, why should we conciously destroy our own lives and everother life form on the planet because we CHOOSE to, not that we have to, we CHOOSE to.

Cars don't have to emit high CO and HydroCarbon levels, they do because it's cheaper that way. Like I've said before, NOrth america could learn some valuable lessons from Europe in that we need to demand beter cars, why buy a substandard and inefficient car when you don't have to? I am not talkin gelectric or hydro cars but gasoline engines that are more efficient, just for a start.

We dunmp huge masses of oil in the ocean, oooops, "cleanup on aisle 5." Well what about the masses of marine life and birds that are destroyed by OUR mistakes, it has nothing to do with natures natural cycle, we have created this horror ourselves.

Sure Jim, write it all off as hogwash, just do it on your own planet okay? Some of us actually care about how our actions effect other life. I don't care how far left or right someone is, if they don't care they are just stupid or ignorant.

by jimhm

Again - Jim you are confused - we are talking Global warming and not polution. Which those places of which you speak are from Man's inability to control greed. The other to which you speek is man's inability to conserve - to hunt a species to exstication is not logical...again nothing to do with Global Warming of which we are speaking ..

You need to stay on the topic - Global Warming - not Polution or Exstication - but Global Warming -

As I have said before - without other valid science Global Warming doesn't have a foot or feet to stand on by-itself.

Global Warming - Hog Wash -

by jimhm

Again Oz you and Jim are arguring Polution - with me - Thats not what we are talking about her ... we are talking Global Warming - Not Polution or Exstication -

Get with the program - they are separate science and without the other two - Global Warming hasn't a foot or feet to stand on by itself - its black science - faulty that is - no glue - no substance - Hog Wash ..

by oz_media

This has nothing to do with Pullution except that POLLUTION is also an issue behind global warming.

It is said that OUR emissions are speeding up global warming, or cooling or whatever side you believe. Now because this isn't proven to enough people yet, we can say screw it, who cares?

Well these same emissions that we are clamiing speed up global warming (which may be questioned) are withoput question harming our lives directly. So yes, it has VEERYTHING to do with pollution. Pollution is the problem that is said to be speeding up global warming, you may contest this and say hogwash, there IS no global warming, FINE, no global warming. This doesn't mean we cam do what we want to the planet because a failure to reduce the 'global warming' emissions is actually killing our own lives, and that is NOT hogwash nor a contested scientific fact, it is a fact.

So if by reducing our emissions, we are guaranteed to live healithier and preserve life on Earth, who cares about global warming? We are already helping our planet by reducing emissions, if we find out in 10 -20 years that global warming IS a scientific fact, then we will already be doing our part to help.

So as they are different topics, one leads to the other and they are related in many ways. The whole action/reaction thing.

by jimhm

How do you argue the point when you have no evidence - because you say it don't make it so... Where has these facts you say have been stated - been repeated in any type of scientific model.

You say your not talking polution - but you are - there is no evidence to say that to much cow poop is causing an increase in methane gas which is a cause of global warming - I say what about the piles of dung left by the dino's - it is a scientific fact from artic core samples that the earth goes through a warm / cold cycle every few thousand years... could we be starting a warm cycle ???

So argue Global warming not - Polution - which again is different - show me where there is scientific evidence that -

by voldar

yes and no. I never thought about countries, America is a great country, and I love it! There is not a "country matter", and yes, I agree with you - what is strong will be always stronger and what is poor will be always poorer, but hell, that's life. And I love life as it is! It gives you oportunities, or you made your own oportunities :P.

by oz_media

Unfortunately we cannot control the universe's natural evolution. We CANM crontrol out own harmful emissions though. Let's just permit nature to take it's own course and not coaz it along. We KNOW we polute and that this pullution may or may not have an effect on global warming, BUT it DOES have an effect on all life forms and the atmosphere.

Do we wait 30 years for proof of global warming even though itr is proven that we are the most destructive force upon the Earth?

Do we wait for proof of global warming before we save ourselves AND every other form of life on our planet from extinction de to our own pollutants?

What does it take for some people to see we are killing each other and the world around us, if this is also causing Gobal warming then so be it, but there is NO question that unless we get our act together every form of life will be extinct long before we find out about global warming.

What more proof do we need that we are killing ourselves and everything else around us? This we know, this we can stop, this we try top stop, this MANY ignore.

by voldar

.. you are right now .. u see .. once u explained, I get it. So, from now on, I will state : "CO" for carbon monoxide, CO for Colorado state and Co for cobalt .. okay? :D

by oz_media

Jim, I said there is NO solid proof of global warming. To be more accurate there IS solid proof but there are also solid arguments against it.
We just don't know YET, but will it be too late if we do?

Everyone knows that the Earth has cooled and warmed as it has orbited the sun over time. This is not in question.

There is a possibility that OUR emissions effect the atmosphere in a way that speeds up, global warming and therefore we need to reduce our industry emissions.

As you say, methane gas is naturally created by our livestock. Well this would be NATURAL evolution and a possible cause for an increase in global warming, again not scientifically proven as you have said, nobody has argued your point here Jim, therefore you have nothing to defend.

So the big issue regarding global warming is reducing industrial emissions, as you say taking us into the stone age again. Well, thet would be an extreme and I have yet to see someone suggest we drop technology to stop global warming, other than the few whack radicals out there.

so why reduce our emissions if we can't prove they are harmign the atmosphere?

Because we ARE harming ourselves and every living thing around us, this is NOT in question ad IS proven beyond a shadow of a doubt.

Therefore, I will once again conclude that by reducing emissions that we KNOW are kiling life as we know it, we may also be in turn reducing emissions that we find out later actually DO cause global warming. If not, at least we saved ourselves and protected all life on Earth.

As I would see it, this would be FAR more imperative than even providing Iraq with a democracy and helping all those Iraqi citizens, we could actualy save the WHOLE world as a global force! How about a global war on emissions? At least we know everyone benefits and heck, it doesn't even cost as much to save the whole world as it does to save one country! Now if GWB came up with that one, I would definitely be supporting him, that is a valid and global stand for anyone to take on.

So as they are not YET related because global warming in your mind is not a reality and nobody can prove otherwise, they may well be on day but it may also be too late. If we are concious of saving the life that we know we CAN save, we MAY in turn save the future of the planet.

So I suppose they MAY be related afterall, we just may not know until it's either too late or we will find that we have already taken apropriate measures to reduce the effects our emissions have on global warming.

Th whole stitch in time theory. Not, wait until it's proven and then decide if it can be corrected or not. Saving ourselves may well turn out to be saving the planet.

by admin

A normal man might have considered himself to have done enough for society by taking: "the initiative in creating the Internet" but not Al, I see. Creating the internet is not enough for one man. I don't know how he's going to "resanctify the earth" though, I think it may have already been sanctified. :>

by gunnyd

For those of you who think the Earth is not warming, it is. For those of you who say that "WE" are the culprits, we are not. In either case, we are helpless in stopping it from occurring over and over again for the next 4 billion or so years. Even if we had completely stopped burning fossil fuels 50 years ago, the Earth would still be warming. This happens about every 10,000 years or so; all weather is cyclic, as tends to repeat itself a lot like some people I know, including myself

Try blaming all this on our wobbling axis and our not so stable orbit around the sun. We wobble on our axis between 22 degrees and 24 degrees, when we are at 22 it is cooler and when we are at 24 degrees, at the present we are at 23.5 degrees.
Small changes occur all the time (geologically), and occasionally there is a big hiccup and we start to freeze over. Some years are colder than other years, take 1779-80, from anecdotal evidence; the Cumberland River froze over from bank to bank. It does not happen that often, the people in that area referred to this incident as the Hard Winter, same with the Ohio River.

The year 1066 was a warm year; it is mentioned in the history of Hastings. The year 1066 was the warmest year in more than 250 years.

Before we start pointing the finger at others, the industrialized world let us say. One needs to ask the right questions. Such as Sun angle, distance from the sun? Why does the highest carbon dioxide readings emanate from third world countries?

I am sure there are some hard headed people out there who will never see the light, but these people are just a little too xenophobic outside of their sphere's of influence.

by oz_media

Amd yet this theory, as scientifically accurate as it is can also be equally contested as all theories surounding global warming. I have noticed the seasons hve shidted, seem to be nearly 1 1/2 months. Spring is a little later now, summer and fall have also eemed to move ahead a month. Can we also start to disprove the calendar year? No, what would be the point.

So in as much as I whooly aree with you, you must understand that equally supportive information is available to the contrary, it just hasn't been proven either way.

So do we just turn a blind eye, pollute and not care anymore? or do we try and make a positive effect on what we DO know is harmful to US and all other life, industrial emissions.

in the end we may even find out that we HAVE protected the Earh's Ozone payer, if not from global warming perhaps something else we haven't yet discovered. It is not an excuse to permit industrial pollution though, especially when we don't have to, these guys could easily spend the money needed to improve our factories, cars and by products of manufacturing. They don't have to so they won't, but they will contest global warming and stand for the leftie/greenie slagging as it will save them money, not neccessarily life.