On NTFS partitions, freespace is actually located in 2 different areas - INSIDE of the MFT Reserved Zone and OUTSIDE of the MFT Reserved Zone. The Microsoft defrag api's prohibit disk defraggers from using the freespace INSIDE of the MFT Reserved Zone. On NT 4, the Reserved Zone is a fixed size. On Win2k, it is dynamically allocated on partition mount. This means that even you you appear to have (for example) 1gb free, 500mb of this might be INSIDE of the MFT Reserved Zone and unusable by defraggers - leaving you only 500mb of freespace for a defragger to work with.
The MFT will do nothing except for grow and grow. Every file that gets created has a file id # - which is a 64bit number. About 2/3's of this number is the actual file id and the remainder is a sequence number that gets incremented. When a file gets deleted, the file id is retained, but marked "not in use". This file id won't get re-used until a really really large number of files get created - at which time it will roll back around and start incrementing the sequence number. Unfortunately, there is no easy way to reduce the size of the Master File Table itself - aside from doing a backup, re-format, and restore - which is a temporary solution at best because as soon as you start createing files, the MFT will start to grow again.
- Greg/Raxco Software
Disclaimer: I work for Raxco Software, the maker of PerfectDisk 2000 - which is a competitor of Diskeeper's, as a systems engineer in the supportdepartment.