104 replies
by prefbid ii
By minorities, do you mean blacks and latinos? Do you mean women?
I see plenty of Indian and Asian people in the IT world -- probably much higher than their proportion in the general US population. Blacks and Latinos are very low and that maymake for a good discussion.
Women are certainly under-represented, but I think the dynamics of that group is likely to be different than the dynamics of racial minorities.
by jmottl
by lance.gillis
by ayoshi
by road-dog
I am at a loss as to why pocket protectors are such an effective female repellant, but the dearth of minorities in high tech fields is readily explainable.
Minorities are geographically concentrated in urban and rural areas served by the lowest quality education institutions. Individuals coming from 3rd and 4th rate high schools haven't sufficient exposure to quality math and computer studies. Ethnic parity will not occur in high tech fields until schools serving these groups improve enough to allow minorities preparation for higher education and high tech fields in greater numbers.
by road-dog
Perhaps the wording of the kick-off might have been better, but the intent is good.
In order to address a disparity, discovering the root cause is a major part of the solution. One might argue that the low percentage of minorities in this business is not an issue requiring a solution.
Personally, I do think it is a problem, as the percentages indicate a gap in the american dream. Obviously, the quota approach solves nothing, and acts to further divide us.
America is a sum of its parts multiplied by x, x being the ability of ordinary people to accomplish extraordinary things. Anything that hinders any facet of us hinders us all.
by barre m2
by prefbid ii
I thought it might be interesting to get this conversation started with some numbers (Us IT types like numbers). Source: www.itaa.org
% in IT % in Workforce
women 41 43
black 9.1 10.7
Hispanic 5.4 9.2
Asian 8.9 3.2
Amer. Indian 0.2 0.7
From the numbers on ITAA, I don't know that you could make a case that women are under represented at all. Blacks are somewhat under. American Indian and Hispanic are significantly under. Asians are way over represented.
by prefbid ii
Well. I did not realize that columns of data are not allowed.
Women in IT 41%
Women in workforce 43%
Black in IT 9.1%
Black in workforce 10.7%
Hispanic in IT 5.4%
Hispanic in workforce 9.2%
Asian in IT 8.9%
Asian in workforce 3.2%
Amer. Indian in IT 0.2%
Amer. Indian in workforce 0.7%
by packratt
Except that the source is the most despicable organization of corporate lobby tools in existance, the same people who brought us forced unpaid overtime and the H1B program and it's accelerated approval process as well.
I trust anything from the ITAA as much as the paper it is written on is tasty. Needless to say that I don't find paper tasty.
Not that it matters in this discussion since I really don't see race as a deciding factor in any personal or professional decision in my life since I look at the person and not the outward appearance.
by rebelrsr
Okay, have to step in. I am a multi-ethnic from a working-class background woman, who is currently working full-time and going to school at night to hopefully get a degree in software engineering.
Women -- not underrepresented??? What group of women are you talking about? White European women, and of these women, what are their positions in the so-called IT world? Administrators, secretaries, salespersons, etc.? Get my drift, women of Color(s) are underrepresented. When you mention Natives,Blacks, Latinos, Asian and Pacific Islanders etc., does it ever cross your mind that there are women in these groups who probably have even less of a chance -- due to socio-economic, educational access, and any other lacking resources -- than the men in these groups???
Wake up folks, it's a new millenium and nothing really has changed....women have just been directed into lower paying, humdrum, service-oriented jobs.
rr
by jackzero
by horseyjanet
by prefbid ii
If you assume that IT is just one of several "extra brains required" jobs available, you may find that IT does not have the prestige of other brainy jobs. If you are a first generation college grad (first in your family lineage to go to college), Isuspect you are more likely to aim for the more prestigious brain jobs of medical doctor, lawyer, or head coach at Georgia (not!).
Jokes aside, IT has an appeal to Asian immigrants who tend to read and write English well, but may not speak it well. It is easier in IT to be brainy and not have to communicate as much. I think the Asian community therefore looks on IT as a good career path and have set up a culture that respects it.
For almost everyone else, there is a direct relationship between speaking English and reading and writing it well. Those that overcome their social standing are going to speak, read, and write well. For them the whole world is open and IT is just one option.
It does not take much to find out that ITstill has a dumpy reputation. Go to any social party and watch the reactions the doctors and lawyers get versus the computer types. Usual reaction of most people when they hear you are in IT is: "I got a computer for Christmas. I haven't figured it out yet. It keeps losing my email."
I just had to say it in the title. I think that it is just rude; nobody would ask a doctor at a party.
"Hey doc every time I bench over 300 lbs my back hurts what can we do?"
Back to the subject at hand.
Diversity has no color, no background,and no differences; this means we are all human and all equal.
What really gets me is you want to separate us by skin, religion, oh and sex.
Why can we go to the place that says the best human get the prize?
by prefbid ii
I don't think it is possible to go to just let "the best human get the prize" because there are still people who discriminate based on outward and non-relevant criteria like race and gender.
So the root question in my mind is still -- is the disparity that we can see indicitive of a problem or just random variations due to differences in human choices?
In the original Star Trek TV series, the crew of the Enterprise was very diversified. However, there was one thing never mentioned – the racial differences of the crew. They simply did not see race. Race didn’t matter. Each person was defined only by his or her position on the crew. I remember only one episode where race was mentioned, and that was one where racial struggle was the story line. The Enterprise came upon an alien who was fleeing racial persecution as well as struggling internally with his own race. The alien’s pursuer was outraged when Captain Kirk didn’t notice any difference between them. Kirk saw them as the same, but they saw themselves as entirely different – racially different. One of them, you see, was white and black, while the other was black and white. That focus on their differences ended up destroying their civilization.
When will we, as a society, stop seeing racial differences? After all, isn’t the real goal to judge(and see) our fellow man (or woman) based solely on the content of their character, not by the color of their skin? As long as we continue to categorize people by any particular race, there will continue to be racial divisions. If people continue tobe consumed by racial differences, how can we possibly become a society that doesn’t see racial differences? How ironic that society continues to be the very thing it strives to overcome. (Let’s all go down to the bar, have some beers, and discuss how we can stop drinking.)
I hope the day comes when the color of one’s skin is as insignificant as the color of one’s eyes. Gandhi said that one should become the change they see in the world. And since I see a world where a person’s race does not define that person, I simply don’t see the race of that person. Instead, I try to see only the person.
Therefore, to answer the initial ques
Therefore, to answer the initial question, I hadn’t really noticed.
Maxwell
by packratt
Yes, we actually agree on something...
Sometimes we would all be suprised about how similar we all are if we all looked a bit less and listened a bit harder.
As long as man does not love his fellow man there will be racism and war. If you love each other you will not kill each other.
Racism is reality just like WAR. We don't want it but we have it.
by tomsal
Yeah I guess racism is like war. And you are right unless your "love" your fellow man you'll always have racism - thus war.
The problem is WHO and HOW do you stop the vicious circle? Teachers, parents (well the decent ones at least), relgious organizations, etc. will tell you things like you stop the hate and the violence by practicing peace and respect and love towards others.
Which all sounds great at seminars, on pulpits, or at PTA meetings - but putting it into practice in our ever hateful/ignorant/selfish/sadistic/violent society is clearly another issue altogether.
If someone hates someone for their race and forces a gun in their face, for example, you can be as idealistic as you want to be but all the love/respect/ect. youshow that criminal (because that's all a person is who does that) isn't going to stop him from pulling the trigger - at least based on current crime statistics.
So what happens is the circle continues. If you try to break it by not fighting for yourself - you just assure a more painful existence (figuratively and physically). And since you are fighting for yourself a criminal will be like "how dare you fight back" and thus the circle continues even more.
My Kwan Ji Nim (grandmaster) has taught us class after class that the true power of the martial artist is inner peace and self control. Because, he says, the world around you can not be controlled. Though you must be ready to react, never seek or travel the road of violence.
Why would a company need to take steps to "diversify" the workforce?
The question implies a disadvantage based on race, ethnicity or whatever!
Just exactly which set of minorities are missing..hispanics, blacks, asians, indians, orientals, Cuban-Americans, Italian Latinos, Black-American Asians, Scottish-Vietnamese or Ethiopian Jews?
What happened to celebrating individuals rather than groups?
by ferocious
If we assume that some groups are "underrepresented", then that implies that other groups are necessarily "overrepresented". Since every group in this discussion is defined as a minority *except* for the white male, that clearly implies that there are too many white men around.
As a white man who has never had a bigoted thought in his life, and who would hire a lime green person so long as they were technically competent -- this kind of thinking frankly offends me.
I guess that makes me the last angry white male.
I happen to think that the individual is more important than the group, whether the "group" is CommunistsIndiansAsiansWomenGaysBlacksDolphinsAngryWhiteMen or whatever. Individuals should look out for themselves, instead of relying on identity groups for artificial support.
I'm in favor of measures that increase individual potential, but I'm not into racial favoritism. ("We need to help poorly educated inner city youth, but poor white kids from some rural backwater can go to hell" -- bad statement. "We need to help all underperforming youth, *because they are underperforming, and not because they are a certain color*" -- good statement.
I don't care about people because they are BlackAsianFemaleWhiteHinduWhatever, but because they are people.
Modern racial identity politics is divisive.
by tomsal
"bushwackerking1" - well said. I agree exactly.
There's nothing left to say on the matter.
-later
by tomsal
"bushwackerking1" - well said. I agree exactly.
There's nothing left to say on the matter.
-later
by bobhunt
Most of the minorities I see on the job are the hard working, intelligent type. Too bad there aren't more of them around. Shouldn't we be hiring someone because they are the best one qualified to do the job?
BTW - bush, you are right on target.
by garion11
by prefbid ii
So far I see a lot on why the problem does not exist or should not exist. I agree that it should not exist -- I will take profound exception with those who claim that it does not exist. The solution may start with individuals who are color and race blind, but as long as individuals refuse to see that there are disparites, then the real problem will not go away or will take a very long time to go away.
A question that needs to be explored in this realm is: Are these disparities due to innocent factors like cultural or genetic differences or is there something more sinister still at play?
I think that some of the disparity may be cultural, but I have not seen or heard anyone prove that the sinister element has been eliminated. I have met lots of people who hate blacks for no reason other than their skin color. I have met too many blacks who hate whites for no reason other than skin color. Funny thing is, though, I have rarely heard that same level of hatred between any other two racial groups. If I have met them, then I suspect that they exist in the IT workplace too.
Now, how do we make sure that these racial bigots do not become a cause of the racial disparity problem? More laws? More oversight (like EEOC)? Morecorporate penalties for abuse?
There are a lot of laws on the books regarding discrimination..all that it leads to is preferential treatment.
special rights for special groups
Because a disparity exists doesn't mean a sinister element is the cause (that's not to say sinister people don't exist).
There are a lot of Asians in IT, should companies take steps to discourage them so that the workplace become more diversified? Should whites be barred from IT because there are too many of them?
BTW..have you seen Hispanics vs. Blacks and vice versa..not pretty, not pretty at all.
by jackzero
I will agree that people are brought up to hate each other. Whites, blacks, Jews, Germans, and who ever else fills oppressed.
Here is some good advise for bigots and haters.
If you like your job, if you do not want to be known as, and if you getthe chance.
CHECK THAT SH*T AT THE DOOR.
This means your attaude, your so called pride, and
your useless anger. You don't want it, what makes you think we do?
CAN'T WE ALL JUST GET ALONG!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
RRG
The idea of white being right and if you are black step back is very much the order of the day. Racism and unfairness is a reality. But,
when people are discouraged from pursuing a specific career (like IT), it becomes a disparity
impossible to erase.
Your analysis doesn't account for Orientals and Asians who are well represented in IT.
I am sure they faced obstacles such as discrimination and mastery of the English language, yet here they are.
by jmottl
by road-dog
Unfortunately, a lot of whites have heard this issue many times before, and the answer is almost always racial quotas(which help nobody). This discussion is often turned into the same tired liberal "color over qualification" justifications.
In a perfect world, color wouldn't be an issue, but companies are forced by EOC requirements to hire minorities strictly on color alone. This is racist by nature, and does not move us closer to the color-blind society.
Racial disparities need to be addressed at the source(the failed education system), not at the result(the work force).
by vwil103
The authors of the comments posted that do not want to discuss this subject, and suggest that by allowing "individuals" to prove themselves..., are for the most part, I'm sure, from "the majority", white males.
I am a rare find in the IT industry, an African American female IT manager with 20 years experience. I would love to network with others like myself, like you do, and take for granted that you do. Problem is...they (experienced miniority IT managers/employees) like myself are few.
by barre m2
by tomsal
Give me a break. Calm down man. The guy said nothing derogatory about ANY one, he's merely seeking feedback for a story/editorial.
My God, some people go off at the drop of a damn hat.
No wonder so much is wrong in society today! ;)
by lance.gillis
by road-dog
by tomsal
I salute your service to our country, sir. I have friends in the Marines (most are actually finishing up their 4 years now), I had several relatives in the Army (WWI, WWII, Korea and Vietnam). Though, I don't agree with how *some* ex-military behaveonce they enter civilian life, I do respect and admire what they stand for and what they do for our country.
(Just had to get that out of the way first)
On your post: understood its cool. I was actually a bit stressed out that day (from peopleat work) when I posted that as well. We are very multi-cultural/racial (what is the PC term for that anyway?) at work - blacks, whites, puerto ricans and even asians - until 6 months ago.
Thank you for your reply.
And as "they" say...
Semper Fidelis
by garion11
Whats holding back minorities in IT?
Answer: Themselves.
by jmottl
I come from a poor school district, and prior to the advent of the "PC" and networks. I only became interested in technology at home, when I was a kid, taking electronics apart because I was so intrigued on how they worked. I got my first whack at computers in high school: Old tele-type machines. This was not a class, but a voluntary after-school lab. I had the initiative because I was intrigued. This was a military brat school, so we had many differnt cultures and races (and we didn't care!). But gee, with all the diversity of our military schools, guess who were always in the labs? White boys. It was rare to see blacks or females in the labs. Why was that? Everyone had equal access, who do you blame in this instance?
What teacher "encourages" or discourages students in certain subjects? I thought they just taught mundane subjects we were forced to take. I hated math, but I was still good at it...It came naturally to me. I also saw many girls do better than me. I've never seen anyone "discouraged" LOL!! You know I don't believe in most if not all "studies". Studies are done for a purpose and that purpose is an agenda.
If you're going to point out obscure studies however, I'd like to see a study (and I'm sure there is one)where there are equal amounts of students of different races and gender in a school, and see where they flock. WHo's in the computer labs? The white, male, "geeks". Who's on the basketball court? Who's on the football field? Who's cheerleading? Who's in the math club? White or black? Many questions, but a very simple study, with cut and dry answers. Then you'll have no one to blame but the kids themselves. Just as Garion11 had said....
I've worked in IT shops that whenever a new technology comes in, all the non-colored personel are selected to work on that project, leaving all the colored personel to work on the legacy stuff.
This also lends itself for faster promotions based on experiance.
by garion11
by ferocious
In fact, she was the only female MCSE I had ever met. She also looked like a lady. That is to say, the other women in IT I have seen remind me of Janet Reno.
She had a whole bunch of other certs..she clearly loved what she did. Her eyes wouldlight up talking about routers.
She impressed a lot people and I seriously doubt she was EVER turned away because of her skin color.
Meeting people like her reaffirms my position that attitude and ability comes first, it trumps all. "Diversifying" is bunk.
by mdmeyers
I have to disagree with your characterization of reality. There are many Asians and Indians in the IT field that started out FAR WORSE than any black man in America ever has. I will counter "perceptions" with facts any day. The race card gets pretty pathetic after a while and starts to sound like petty whining.
"Education is the antithesis of ignorance" - anonyous
by jackzero
by jackzero
by james r linn
that doesn't mean much.
From my reading, Scientific American level, race is primarily a social construct - we aren't that physically different - we tend to see skin colour and to some extent religion dividing us, when skin colour aside we aren't that different from each other, and religion is a social construct.
But that doesn't mean that our society has totally bought into this yet. I see evidence of racism everyday.
So there is a chance of society imposing systemic racism on us, and thus impacting people based on race. Which logically speaking would require a remedy based on race.
While I hope we can get to where bushwackerking wants to be(which sounds alot like MLK), and I will do what I can to advance that agenda, I can't turn a blind eye to what is today.
I am not suggesting every employer is racist, or that even most are. I am suggesting that to explain the disparity between the makeup of society, and the makup of IT, you have to look at alot of societal issues -it goes to educational opportunities, child poverty, urban versus rural etc. and some of those issues have race components.
In another discussion, we talked about why women may be underrepresented in IT(particularly at senior levels), and one of the reasons I hgave was the result of some studies which showed that women were just as capable as men at math, but the way math was traditionally taught favoured men, hence more men went into higher math and into computing.
There may be similar analogies. I am old enough to have gone to school in a public board where not only did we say the lord's prayer but had weekly religion courses(protestant based). This was certainly prejudicial to the non-christians - it set them apart and gave them amessage.
Can we say for certain that there is no link between the societal demographic distribution, race issues and IT demographic profile? I am not sure.
James
by prefbid ii
Racism is part of the landscape of this country.
In other words, this country evolved under very extreme racist conditions. Our laws are racist
and favor one race over another. How can we implement change to eradicate racism? Love covers a multitude of sin and it never fails.
(refer to 1 Corinthians Chapter 13 in the Holy Bible.)
by generalist
When you think about it, racism IS slowly declining in the United States. If you want an example of this, look at the number of 'minority' Hollywood stars today versus the number in the 1960s.
We do have to keep aware of racist beliefs though. And we do have to remember that not all racists are 'white'.
by hmsardenberg
by ferocious
by greggen
Look at "IT" and other occupations and you will find, as a general rule, as the pay increases, the diversity decreases. Always exceptions to the rule though.
And you could break "IT" into job specific categories and find different levels of dievrsity as well.
I'm a white male computer hardware technician, and there are have no female or other minority co-workers in my shop. But if you look at different departments in my company, the Helpdesk, or Software Support, you will find that white males are the minority in those areas.
Also, I am one of the younger people in my shop, in my 30's, where the average age of my co-workers is 50-something. I have worked for companies where I was the oldest as well.
This discussion should not be just about minorites in "IT", it should be just about diversity IMO.
My comments are from personal experiences. I'm
African American and some of my best friends are Asian decent. Being Black in America is like no other experience on the face of this earth. I have many horror stories I can tell just because I am Black, no other reason.
by generalist
Part of the problem may be cultural. I've heard that in some cultures you dishonor your parents if you try to be better than they were. At the same time, in other cultures you show your parents great honor if you are a greater success than they. That difference can make a big difference in where people end up.
Poverty and related side effects also play an important part in any disparity. The so called 'cycle of poverty' requires exceptional effort to break. And since some minorities have a higher poverty rate than others, they are likely to have fewer representatives in IT and other high end fields.
Of course the poverty factor isn't limited to minorities. Anybody who has been part of the 'cycle of poverty' can run into the problem of needing money to gain the skills to make money. Even more insidious is the mindset that can sometimes be part of being poor. If you're already at the bottom of the heap, then drug use and crime are easy ways to get some relief from poverty.
They are also a dead end for people of all types.
by jim5gomez
As a Chicano Jew - We're into IT and soaking it in for ourselves (company). Thank you very much.
Jim Gomez
by xpertdragon
As an Irish Mexican Half-breed, I agree with you Mr. Jim Gomez.
I Live, work and play in the Southwest (New Mexico), where a large percentage of I.T. workers are hispanic/chicano. So naturally, I am used to seeing many co-workers from Computerrelated job to job being hispanic. Most hispanic I.T. workers that I have been employed with come from Non-degreed backgrounds and have learned many of their computer skills from practical hands-on work experience, and a will to learn + being givena chance = opportunity.
I myself, am in a different world. I have struggles on both sides of the spectrum. My last name is Chavez, considered by many to be quite the minority last name, but my appearance is not that of a typical minority. I still feel that I am disriminated everyday however when searching for I.T. jobs, and a hiring manager knows me only by paper, and has the ability to judge first hand wether I am company material.
Paul M. Chavez
by kkousky
The Boston Consulting group presented a study of contributors to SourceForge and found that over 90% were male.
The IT industry has lots of issues and diversity is a central one that shapes the culture and eventually the creativity of our work.
There are a few efforts beginning to address these issues directly including the work of OpenUmbrella. While it's working in the Open Source area there is ample room for work starting in K-12 education!
by wlb
by mpeeling
First I have to say that I believe it is unfortunate for anyone to have to classify groups of people rather than looking at an individual?s skills and qualities.
Having said that I also have to ask why when people do speak of minorities they normally only concentrate on race and gender. What about the disability card?
I personally feel that many organizations both large and small miss out on the opportunity to employ yet another group of people, the disabled. These people normally have the ability to be very creative and innovative given their circumstances.
I personally have been a paraplegic since 1986 after living the first part of my life as an able bodied person. I am currently working as a VP of IT for my organization and Ibelieve am very much in the minority in this industry.
If there is one thing I have learned from seeing both sides of the fence that is having a disability you must learn to quickly adapt to a situation. How does a disabled person adapt so quickly? By being creative or innovative. It is not that the disabled person cannot do something; they simply have to find another way to do things. Now that is what I call being creative and innovative.
So I ask you, why not use more of these minorities in the work place? These people live their lives being creative and innovative a quality that will get an individual and a corporation a long way.
by robeaver1
I am a Native American in IT. I've been at this for 25 years at the same company and a few years before that in school.
I've seen, heard, experienced the same type of discrimination, at times even worse, here at my work, that goes on outside of work.
Talk goes on about how we want a diverse work force, but it's only talk and really never starts at the top with the CEO.
Since I'm limited here, I'd be willing to talk further about Natives in IT.
Richard Beaver
by ehenry
by hermine_linz
by ayoshi
I have interviewed many people for positions in the IT department at mostly non-IT institutions (one bank, one oil-company and one IT consultancy), and the people that I have hired have always been the best candidate available.
I did not, nor would I, base my choice on race, color, sex, sexual pref, height, age, beauty, place of birth, etc.... One of the biggest reasons for a disparity may be that it has been unusual for me to interview a minority. It may be that the resume was not outstanding enough, or it may be that I simply did not receive that many resumes from qualified minorities.
Make your own conclusions.
P.S. I am a white male, my wife is Asian/Latino, and of course my kids are all of the above.
by gallegui
The IT field places high demands in people skills and a thorough understanding of what makes people klick. Minorities are mostly unaware of the many prejudices and secret agendas a particular IT job position may be inmersed in and are caught unawares in many situations. Take for example the situation when a CTO hires a minority for an IT position. If the minority reports directly to the CTO there will be lots of jealousy from coworkers, specially if it is perceived that the new hire may some day be promoted to manager. The results are predictable. Constant sniping, constant cheap shots and underhanded false complaints to undermine the minority's chances of promotion and success in the position. Most of the time the CTOs, busy with other things, will give in to the majority demands and dismiss the minority and hire one who is more "accepted," which means a member of the same racial group.
Since the push for affirmative action is now dead, at least for minorities, there will be little improvement in the IT hiring of minorities. For minorities who are hired in IT, my advise is to talk to everyone in their department early in their job assignment. Particular attention should be placed in getting to know key members of their departments to establish a close relationship. I recommend daily visits to the CTO who hired them. Minorities should be very carefull that they are invited to pertinent meetings and that their responsibilities are well defined and are not given secondhand assignments in which someone ahead of them routinely interferes and half completes the assignments. This last situation is a favorite tactic of those who wish to sabatoge the minority's work through delays, hiding of manuals, software etc. Silence or quiet work will not do. All accomplishments should be loudly announced and constant feedback asked at every opportunity from managers,coworkers and users.
That's all that was fiberjet. Pure fishdung. I duuno where you come from, but where I live we don't care what color you are, sex, religion, or whatever else you like to do, as long as you perform as expected. You act like it's an minority inquisition! Let's see, you blame "no improvement on the hiring of minorities" on Affirmative Action. Are/were "you people" so dependent upon Affirmative Action to get jobs that now you've lost all hope? Are you saying then that to rely on pure skill and luck like the rest of us, that you cannot compete? That's very sad of you to say...Sounds more like a personal problem to me though.
Scenario: Two gals go up for an IT job. One black, one white. Both have equal skill/experience/education and APPTITUDE.Affirmative Action is in effect. The black girl gets the job (lauhging at the white girl saying, "Payback!") The white girl goes without a job, needless to say. But that's fair, somehow.
Now second scenario: Same as first, except no Affirmative Action. White girl gets the job. Why? Neither one of you know why. Maybe it's because the whitey has a better attitude. Maybe her perfume smelled good. WHo knows? But the black girl cries "Descrimination!" Oh my, but what if the interviewer is black? WHat then? Maybe the outcome was based on purely logical methods! Would she be a good team player? Has she exemplified professionalism?
Scenario three: Same as the second, only the black girl gets the job. Black interviewer. The white girl thinks,"Racism". A natural reaction? Depends upon the person doesn't it?
We can all only hope that employers and interviewers take only professional quaities in mind when hiring. That goes for both sides. No special treatment for anyone. No, I discountyour suggestion that the majority of people are racist. Racism happens still in all forms. I've seen India companies in India hire mostly Indians. Chinese the same. Black, the same
Scenario three: Same as the second, only the black girl gets the job. Black interviewer. The white girl thinks, "Racism". A natural reaction? Depends upon the person doesn't it?
We can all only hope that employers and interviewers take only professional quaities in mind when hiring. That goes for both sides. No special treatment for anyone. No, I discount your suggestion that the majority of people are racist. Racism happens still in all forms. I've seen India companies in India hire mostlyIndians. Chinese the same. Black, the same. White, the same. The only way to abolish these few pockets is to come together, not seperate issues based on race or anything else.
by barre m2
by barre m2
by barre m2
by bobhunt
by barre m2
Affirmative action is not a "quota" system, not "preferential treatment," not a club for bludgeoning employers and educational institutions into accepting unqualified workers and students. It's a strategy for curing what ails our society's institutions, which are still plagued with discriminatory attitudes and practices that exclude millions of qualified and deserving people from the American mainstream. Affirmative action is an instrument of inclusion, a means of bringing all Americans into society's mainstream as equal competitors in the race of life.
Affirmative action is still needed. Although women and people of color have come a long way in the decades since the Civil Rights Act was passed, discrimination persists. Fairness requires ending biased practices, not perpetuating them, and that includes ending the unjust advantages traditionally enjoyed by whites and white men. The conscientious effort to hire or admit women and people of color is a way for employers and schools to break their habit of favoring whites and males, and a way to facilitate the transition to nondiscriminatory practices. Restructuring a discriminatory status quo to create a nondiscriminatory environment isn't "reverse discrimination," but it may feel that way because something is being lost: White people are losing the favoritism they so long enjoyed in a system that discriminated on the basis of color and sex.
What would you do differently than "we" would do (since you insist on seperating us, based on color and gender, I must remain in your context-I use 'you vs. us'). How do you propose to get more of "you peoples" into the IT business?
Can't we alljust get along?
Here's what I would do. The problem is APPTITUDE. The question is first, why aren't there so many women (I will only drill down to this level-women-, and not get into color, shade of color, language, origin..etc) in the IT field altogether? Do you think maybe it's because they aren't interested, or even better, don't have the APPTUTUDE? I know a lot of women in the IT field one or two that was worthy, (just like the men). EVERYONE cannot be in the IT field. People CHOOSE whatthey want to do in life, and as long as that choice is free, it does no good by bringing up silly racial profiling. Seperating yourself either by race, gender is indicative of seperatism. It is not "us" who want to be seperate, it is you. BUT, I believe the best thing WE can do as AMERICANS is to be sure EVERY single AMERICAN has EQUAL access to all technologies. This then allows us/them to figure out where their APPTITUDE lies and the directions they'll take in life. Surely, many people in life grow up with things others do not. It is stupid to try and force those that do not into something they have neither an interest nor an APPTITUDE of doing. The key is mostly in self-motivation/discipline. Second comes access to technologies. And we all are doing something about that!
by barre m2
Closing the "digital-divide" is not solved by video classrooms. Here in Iowa, we have the largest state-wide fiber-optic video network in the country. So, all it accomplishes is to save money by providing less teachers to more students.
Closing the digital-divide involves getting people not involved motivated, changing their attitudes about life, giving them goals, raising them to be productive and ethical, and then they have to have the APPTITUDE. Closing the digital-divide involves gettingoff your a$$! Black or white.
When I went to a Texas Tech college, there were 38 ppl signed up in my class. Two were black, 1 male, 1 female. The two black kids did not want to be there. They had no desire to work hard or study, and they were notinterested in the field. They came from a "Vocational rehab" program. Programs that FORCE people based on skin color into places they neither have a desire nor APPTITUDE to be. The two kids dropped out after the first semester. We graduated 8 out of38. I was 27 when I graduated, so I was a little more wise than most as to what I wanted to do in life. After having spent 4 years in the Marines, 3 years driving a truck, Border Patrol, McDonalds, Policeman...then college. Saved money from previousjob, got loans. I come from a poor background, yet somehow I managed to stay out of trouble (luck) and have goals in life.
No matter what 'equipment' you have at this obviously racial HBCU, you still need the people to use it. You can force them in, give them money and all kinds of other freebies, but they have to first WANT to do it, then have an APPTITUDE to succeed in that education, not to mention some form of ability to read, learn and comprehend. WHen you bring people in who have a history of not caring about learning, especially about learning about technology and other topics that require a lot of study, how do you expect them to be successful?
by barre m2
by cclark
by prefbid ii
Maybe its just the way that I was brought up, but why does anyone need an inspiration to enter a field of work? I understand the need for a spiritual leader, but why does work require one?
I'm not asking this to put you down for your choice of making a living. There are many things that need to be considered when choosing a career. Money should just be one small part of the rewards that you receive. The fact that you can squeeze half your salary into the realm of job satisfaction is a wonderful testimony to your character. The world will be a much better place eventually because of you and people like you.
I'm still curious about the inspiration requirement, though. I was raised to believe that I could do anything if that was my desire and my goal. In order to achieve my goal, I had to "pay some dues" along the way. Eleven years in the military in order to get an education was the most significant "dues" that I have had to pay. In that time I met a lot of people. Some I thought were good at what they do, but none of them "inspired me" into a career in IT. In fact most inspired me in a reverse logic sort of way. I figured if they could make it in that career and be that dumb, then I wouldn't have a problem.
If no inspiration is needed, according to Barre, Affirmative Action is all we need to "Inspire". Therefore we don't need people like Barre.
I do however, admire Barre's objectives, if they are to inspire. Inspiration through role modeling, since role models seem to be in short supply in many communities. It's a good thing to do. I ALSO come from a poor background, yet look, both Barre and I have somehow found our careers. We may not make it to the top, to even TOUCH this so-called glass ceiling, but we're successful in what we do. And of course maybe we will make it to the top.
Inspiration indicates a lack thereof. Wasn't that what I've been saying all along? "a computer lab on campus, only white-males ever visit it....." I would call that a lack of inspiration. Are you going to be there for ALL these people?
What am I going to to do? Why should I help lazy people? White or black? And why should I discriminate against who I help and who I don't help? Does Barre help (inspire) only black people? Probably, typically...it is racism. I do my part however to help anyone I can. Especially those interested in my field. I have no racial preference as to who I help however. That's the difference between Barre and me, he sees problems with black people only, blames them on white society. I don't discriminate, I see the world's problems. I see poor people of all colors and sex.I help anyone I can.
by barre m2
Wait, is it inspiration or Affirmative Action you need Barre? It goes along with what I've been saying, "A computer lab, but only white boys take advantage of it..." Do you really think super-Barre can inspire ALL his own people to get in those labs?
What about those other fields? What about farmers? What about teachers? What about nurses? What about doctors? What about truck drivers? What about accountants? What about hockey players? By golly how are you EVER going to manage getting equal amounts of "your people" in each and every occupation known to man? Aren't we going to have to pull people from this field to fill that other field because there aren't enough blacks to go around!?!? Do you see, when you look at our entire country, how this IT Field subject pales in comparisson? Do you see that such a goal may be counter-productive? What about that other black man who is trying to insipre "his people" into his occupation? Gee, when you take one (into IT), someone else loses him/her! Maybe this person wouldv'e turned out to be a youth counselor! Or a pro-golfer!
I do admire you wanting to be a role model and inspiring others "of your own race". They may need a role model. Sounds like you are discriminating in your inspirations however. I tend to inspire whenever I can, people of any color. I don't seperate, or discriminate. I came from a poor background as well. It's no excuse.
Anybody can do anything they are capable of doing.
Wait, is it inspiration or Affirmative Action you need Barre? It goes along with what I've been saying, "A computer lab, but only white boys take advantage of it..." Do you really think super-Barre can inspire ALL his own people to get in those labs?
What about those other fields? What about farmers? What about teachers? What about nurses? What about doctors? What about truck drivers? What about accountants? What about hockey players? By golly how are you EVER going to manage getting equal amounts of "your people" in each and every occupation known to man? Aren't we going to have to pull people from this field to fill that other field because there aren't enough blacks to go around!?!? Do you see, when you look at our entire country, how this IT Field subject pales in comparisson? Do you see that such a goal may be counter-productive? What about that other black man who is trying to insipre "his people" into his occupation? Gee, when you take one (into IT), someone else loses him/her! Maybe this person wouldv'e turned out to be a youth counselor! Or a pro-golfer!
I do admire you wanting to be a role model and inspiring others "of your own race". They may need a role model. Sounds like you are discriminating in your inspirations however. I tend to inspire whenever I can, people of any color. I don't seperate, or discriminate. I came from a poor background as well. It's no excuse.
Anybody can do anything they are capable of doing.
I really love posting the same thing 3 times and watching it disappear....
Barre is it inspiration or Affirmative Action "your people" need. BTW, "your people" doesn't mean every black person, because most don't need your help. Many are actually capable of working hard and succeeding! Can you imagine that?
Look, just because YOU were inspired by computers doesn't mean others will be. I had labs in my school too, but only the white geeky guys showed up..I ask you why? We had a big mix in our school (army brats). I'm telling you that most people are not interested. What about those black doctors who want more black doctors in the field? Do they turn suburbian schools into hospitals? Add to that the millions of other occupations!
Ibelieve this was the one where I stated how counter-productive it was for you to inspire others only towards one particular occupation. What about doctors, lawyers, trash collectors, farmers, truck drivers, cab drivers, accountants, hockey players and all 3 million other occupations? How are you going to fill each and every occupation and why the IT field? Every one you inspire to your occupation takes away from another. We also need trash collectors, nurses, teachers, counselors (mentors), short-order cooks, or are you just interested in the high-paying or prestigious jobs? Why are you discriminating in the people you inspire? I like to help ALL people.
I grew up poor. It's no excuse. I worked hard. I worked in dirty jobs. I had no problem doing it either. I saved enough to get me started in college, and when I was 27, I graduated, with a 3.92 GPA.
Anybody can do anything they want, with a little effort.
BTW, Barre I admire your wanting to help the community. I think the best thing we can promote is FAMILY, and mentoring those w/o (good parental) guideance.
Yes, my posts are written w/o the benefit of using a computer to do my spelling. But not to worry, most kids, when they have nothing substantial, will resort to attacking the post. I'm used to it as I have seen it done to many others. Maybe one day you'll grow up.
Affirmative Action is racism, hence the reason it is now outlawed. The Supreme Court recognized that as well. I spent a lot of time here telling people that forcing minorities into positions they have neither no desire nor aptitudeto be in is a waste of everyone's time. I just spent some time giving real life scenarios where minorities and all have a computer lab sitting in front of them and that it is only the white guys taking advantage of it. So we like it, and when there's money involved (IT salaries) all-of-a-sudden, you racists bring up the race card. Because instead of working for it or even instead of recognizing that there is a price to pay for success (working hard to get there) you want a free ride. You want to be equal, without the effort. The3 reason u like Affirmative Action is so that you WON'T have to rely on hard work, you'd rather get it all for free.
You know, most minorities never have a problem reacing their 'realistic' goals. It's the lazy and the reacist one's who love Affirmative Action. Which one are you?
Glass ceiling. Gee, the men who built these corporations, they're going to just give up their seats in the name of Political Correctness? LOL!!! And I suppose black people who own companies don't have a glass ceiling? Women? Gays? Glass ceilings, it is a selfish subject. "Hey, why can't I be CEO?" We're not buying nor do we care about your glass ceiling theories because we know it's all about "ME ME ME" and you'll never be happy until all "majorities" are working for YOU! WAAAH!
How many times are you going to post this same dribble.?..Sounds like plagerism.
Affirmative Action is racism. Fact. Hence, illegal. White men founded, built, conquered (for good or bad) and ran this country for centuries. Is this the way I woudl've done it? No. Can I help it that I have to live in such a capitalistic society, forced to work my butt off just to provide for my family? NO!
Now you black people come in, after being sold here into slavery by your own people, none of whic wasmy doing (I'm a first generation French-American), and expect a free handout in the year 2002, blaming it all of some past social issues. The problem is that most Black DO make it w/o your help. They ARE successful in their endeavors. I KNOW MANY! You're just looking for excuses for your own failure.
I replied, but it disappeared, a moderator is being highly discriminating.
A.A. is racism. That is why the Supreme Court no longer upholds it.
Glass ceiling, gee I guess I could use the same excuse, except there's a lady in mine. Glass ceilingis another poor excuse for failure. It is a selfish concept, it's all about "ME ME ME". Do you ever hear about the glass ceiling at the local trash company? "Hey I want to be head-trash-collector!" No, it's all about greed and selfishness. And the Bush report is nothing but feel-good propoganda, to make the liberals like you happy. Nothing will ever become of it :).
Let's face it, white men founded, built and nurtured this powerful nation to it's existence today, by whatever means necessary, good or bad. You or I may not agree with it, but we have to live here. Black folk were later sold to people here (sold by their own people). None of this is my fault, especially since I'm a first-generation French-American. What do "the majority" do, step down so that YOU or a few other privilidged minorities can have a shot? Then they make their own little "good ol girls/boys" minority club? I consider myself a minority in this case since I was never "privilidged" (poor upbringing, poor parental role models). The glass ceiling exists only to those who make it up. There are way too many factors in such theories to prove anything. (ie...person has a bad attitude, person is difficult to work for/with, person has bad work ethics, person is not qualified...etc)Discrimination is illegal. Prove it, then sue. It's everyone's right. Glass ceilings are a myth.
by jackzero
by barre m2
by ccalloway
by prefbid ii
I'll admit. I never heard of an Associates in Programming. I'm not sure that it would impress me enough to put a resume in the "look into it further" pile. I can't guarantee that I would look at a BS in Programming any differently.
Being a woman, though, would not even come into the picture. Age may indirectly play a role. What you did before you went for the degree? If you can leverage that experience into the IT position, then you have something that the young people don't have. If you try to present yourself as a "new" person with no experience while at the age of 45, you will have a hard sell.
Trending IT Employment posts
Sort by Trending