As for your problem have you thought that the PS may not be compatible with the M'Board? It is possible that everything works by itself but once they are put together they do not. You need to test this out of the case with the M'Board on an Anti Static Surface or if you don't have one of those some clean white paper. What can happen is that a PS changes it's values and goes out of tolerance so that it no longer works with that Particular M'Board but it may run another M'Board that requires less Power or Current. It may originally have been above it's design specification through a combination of Manufacturing Tolerances but over time these Electronic Components had gone off slightly causing this unit to no longer be sufficient for that particular M'Board.
What is important here is to make sure that all the Power Connectors to the M'Board are correctly plugged in that includes the Supplementary 12 V 4, 6 or 8 Pin plug as well as the 20-24 pin ATX Plug.
Also check for bent pins on the CPU or the CPU Socket as here I'm assuming that the CPU was tested on a different M'Board. While you have the M'Board out of the case check the front panel switches with a multimeter if there is no resistance through either the Power On or Reset Switch the one with no resistance is either stuck in the On or open position or has failed.
Something I have seen several times with the cheaper cases is that the Reset Switch Cover gets clogged with Dust and other airborne Crud and along with a poor molded Plastic Cover causes the Reset switch to stick in the On Position. The cure here is to remove the reset switch from the front panel and then the plastic cover/button and file away the rough edge on the molding till it can not longer stick. You could to double check this remove both the Power & Reset Switches from the M'Board and plug the Reset Switch Leads onto the Power On Pins of the M'Board and see if that turns the computer on. If the system starts as soon as power is applied that switch is sticking in the On Position.
The other thing you can do here with a small screwdriver and both sets of leads for the Power & Reset Switches unplugged is to short out the 2 pins for the power switch and see if it starts now. If it does one or both of the front panel switches are sticking in the On or Open Position. You should also test these switches to see if they are working when they are closed there should be no circuit through the Switch and when pressed in there should be no resistance through the Wires or Switch.
If you could be more specific with the Make & Model of the M'Board, CPU, RAM & Power Supply we may be able to be much more specific as to where to look. ;)
Col