Discussion Locked

Moving to Network Printers: How to Justify the end of Personal Printers?

0 helpful
21 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Good Morning Everyone,

We are a local utility with roughly 80 PCs spread out across a handful of sites. We currently have a few network printers (various brands), but have a much larger number of personal/desktop printers.

I'm currently working to build up a case to get rid of most of the personal printers, and instead use a handful of network printers. So far, I've created a spreadsheet that compares the cost of a personal printer to a network printer for a given number of users over a given amount of time. I've tried to include as many costs as I can think of (ink, paper, base cost, user time) but would really appriciate any advice from anyone who has already pulled this off (or is currently doing so).

I would even more appriciate any answers folks have to the usual user complaints such as lost productivity, inconvinience, etc.

Thanks,

Casey

21 replies

by charliespencer

Toner costs for personal lasers are outrageous. If you're going to lease network printers the cost of toner and staples is often included in lease cost. Sometimes the leasing company will track use and resupply for you. Standardizing on a couple of models instead of a variety of individual units means fewer types of toner to keep in stock.

Do your help desk techs spend much time repairing personal printers? Leased network printers usually include service calls.

Lost productivity? Where I work printers are often surrounded by unclaimed pages. If its the same where you work, how are people losing productivity on something they apparently didn't need? Inconvenience is usually offset by the savings.

Depending on the units you get, you can also ditch desktop scanners and copiers since many network printers will also perform those functions.

by cmccracken

My number one reason for going away from personal printers is the support it takes to maintain them, but a close number two is the cost. I'm looking to purchase the printers, but include some level of maintenance agreement.

On the few networked printers we have, they do collect unclaimed pages, so I'd say you are correct.

The printers I've been looking at (HP LaserJet CM2320n) do copy/scan/print so they are a nice replacement for the current personal all-in-ones.

by charliespencer

by selling the old personal ones to employees.

Our few remaining personal printers (HR and Finance) are all the same model. Our purchasing dept. has orders to buy only the toner used in that model. We have a few 'unauthorized' personal printers but the users understand the care and feeding is their personal responsibility.

Oh, regarding lost productivity: point out that when a network printer goes down, the users can switch to another one. When a personal printer goes down, the user is screwed. Make a point to install at least two network printers on each client so they'll be ready when their default crashes.

by notsochiguy

The first thing you may want to do is speak with someone in accounting, and figure out how they handle depreciation of assets; and if there is an organizational preference towards leasing or purchasing capital assets (and seeing what dollar threshold they consider to be a capital investment...as different firms handle that differently, too).

Using that information, you can start running models showing the current cost per page printed in the organization vs. a set of alternatives (purchased network printers, leased, hybrid model---which is what we use).

If you can demonstrate a considerable cost reduction by moving to network printers (which you should easily be able to do given the information you provided), most of the intangibles (productivity, confidentiality, etc) will get glossed over, in all likelihood.

Speaking of confidentiality, in every firm I've been at that has switched from a distributed printing model to a more centralized one (many to few), that has been the #1 argument against moving forward. So, to head that off at the pass, I'd advise you to look at printer models that can be made to require an access code to print out certain print jobs.

Best of luck!

by cmccracken

I've tried to apply some type of dollar amount to each "task" I can think of a user doing with regard to a printer (replacing paper, ink, walking, etc) to help show that the "perceived" problems really aren't there.

The confidentiality is an interesting one I'll look into. At the moment, I had intended to just have a dedicated printer for the finance department to run checks and other confidential items, but the pass code bit sounds pretty slick.

by notsochiguy

If you issue each user a code, you can see who has printed how much. Helps eliminate romance e-books from getting printed at either 7:30 am or 5:15 pm! :)

by jck

i'd say look at long term cost...toner, paper, electric (newer being more efficient?), and most of all...replacement/repair.

by larryd4

The numbers are your strongest ally. It is cheaper to run network printers then personal.

Granted you shouldn't be considering taking upper management personal printers away. Upper Management needs to print things out for their eyes only and you don't want to negate that.

But you should be stressing the cost savings as the biggest benefit.

Then the administrative benefits.
Then the repair benefits

You can even go in to the ability to monitor the jobs on a network printer and the ability to detect abuse.

But don't go in to this trying to convince. It should be more of an IT directive to bring down your overhead.

by cmccracken

What you say makes sense, and those are my heavy hitting arguments. That said though, our IT department doesn't really have the clout to force the issue, so I have to be prepared for some persuasion.

by larryd4

Any location business, government, utility, or private corp. that doesn't give serious weight to the opinion of their IT department is just asking for all types of problems.

Good luck then..

Here in our State, ITO came down and made a clear cut plan to eliminate all personal printers, aside from Managers and obvious need for privacy areas.

Worked just fine.

by the scummy one

with the ability to print with a code (for secure documents), they need to punch in the code to pick it up. This negates most 'secure printing' requests.

If the printer has a mailslot, then it can be setup to print into the different trays, making it easier to go through who printed what.

people will complain if it adds anything to change their ways. However 90% of these complaints will not be truly legit, just not wanting to change. But before you go through with it, there likely will need to be a few exceptions (like a program needs a local or specific model printer to work, etc.). So, you should have a meeting with the managers to weed out these needed exceptions before removing local printers completely.

Also, be prepared for bottlenecks on the printer. Keep an eye out for some printers being overloaded, and in that location, or nearby setup another printer.

by the scummy one

make sure to have a couple of MFP printers that can send to email, these will help out a lot.
Also, since a copier costs less per print (I am told) than a printer, get at least 1 copier and make sure people use it over a printer when making several copies.

by jessie

We've got several copiers at my place of business that are also network mailbox printing devices. Users can queue up several print jobs in their individual mailboxes, then when they're ready, go over to the printer/copier, punch in their code and print all the docs at once, thereby INCREASING productivity.

by cmccracken

You've read my mind. I'm starting with one of our managers that already prints to a network printer, and having him take a look at my arguments. My hope is that I can build a base of support within the supervisor ranks, so that when I present it to the full set, I already have support that will help bring the rest along. From there, I'll get them to help identify special needs to prevent any issues.

So far all the printers I'm considering buying (one model obviously) are MFP, so that should help in terms of being able to say "Look at all the great services that are now a few feet away!".

Casey

by charliespencer

Depending on the OS of your intended print server, it's not difficult to set up a printer pool. Put two or three printers in the pool and the job goes to the first available physical device. Small jobs don't have to wait on the Annual Shareholders Report.

by cmccracken

I had planned on allowing users to keep their existing personal printers until they break, to try and help "ease" the transition, but selling them is an idea I'll bounce around.

I've been writing down my official top list of reasons to migrate and I was just about to write the ease of switching to another network printer when I read your comment. Glad I'm seeing my ideas line up with the thoughts of others.

Casey

by charliespencer

You'll just keep buying toner forever. I've got HP LJ 4 (the only model of personal we have left in use) in storage that still function.

by cmccracken

These are all some flavor of HP deskjet all-in-one. I *will* be slowly stealing them away for some of our remote sites that don't have enough people to justify a network printer.

This discussion is closed to new replies.