Question Locked

Need help with server memory upgrade - speed / matching

0 helpful
17 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Greeting all hardware specialists out there.

I have a Dell PowerEdge 2900 running Windows Server 2003 R2.

Currently it has 2 gigs of 533 ram.

Usage is sitting around 1.8, so I have to upgrade.

The 2003 server will only support 4 gigs, right?

That gives me three options.

I can buy 2 gigs of 533. 2 gigs of 667 or 4 gigs of 667. (each sold in two units, 2 one gig, or 2 two gig sticks)

The 2 gigs of 533 would run me $137
The 2 gigs of 667 would run me $144
The 4 gigs of 667 would run me $200

For that little difference, I have a hard time buying the 533, even if the 667 will run at the 533, right? Or should it match for best results?

If it SHOULD match, that would make the 4 gig purchase the way to go?

And of course, is there a measurable difference that a human could detect between the 533 and the 667?

Thanks!

jd

17 replies

by jdclyde

Note to add, prices are for Kingston memory specific to the 2900.

by tonythetiger

the maximum memory address space is 4 gig, but some of that space is used by hardware, bios, video, etc, leaving usable space for RAM at something less than 4 gig (Server 2003 reports 3.5 on ours, as an example). Of course, 3.5 gig would be a weird amount to install... so go with 4 :)

All of the ram is going to operate at the same speed. That speed will be the lesser of the slowest memory or the upper bus limit.

In the old days, when FSB speed was directly linked to everything else, it might have made a noticeable difference, but I don't think you'd notice it today... changing from 10K RPM disks to 15K would probably do more on a server.

by jdclyde

So yeah, 32 bit.

That is why I wasn't worried about going over the 4 gig mark.

by jdclyde

Would you upgrade with Kingston or go with Dell?

by jdclyde

on the Dell site, they sell Dell memory AND Kingston for this server.

Interesting, they have 2 gig of Kingston listed for 89.99 instead of the 144 that Kingston is selling it for.

by jdclyde

I do deserve at least one.... :D

I looked and it is the same part number as what is listed on the Kingston site.

by jdclyde

I will assume that means standard, correct?

But for now, if I am using 1.8 gigs of ram, going to the 4 gigs from the 2 I was at should take care of me for a while. Gets me from 90% used to under 50%.

by peconet tietokoneet

It will tell/show you what system you have 32/64 bit etc. Then you will have a good idea of which way to turn. If you have 64 Bit then go for the full whack of memory that the server can take. The software can take what ever, but you will be limited by your motherboard.
Download Belarc here:
http://www.belarc.com/Programs/advisor.exe

For your memory you can use the crucial memory tool:
http://www.crucial.com/server/index.aspx

http://www.crucial.com/systemscanner/

Hope this helps you out.

by jdclyde

The same Kingston memory that was running for $144 on the Kingston site was $89 on the Dell site. 2 one gig sticks.

when you go into "System" it tells you the OS installed. It would specifically say 64 bit.

Because of the app running on that server being 32 bit (not tested for 64) and being a few years old, the consultant that did all the work would not have gone 64.

For my new HP piece of crap server I just got I was going to go 64 (server2008) but the vendors were against the idea. So I bought that one with 2 two gig sticks.

by peconet tietokoneet

I have tested that software out and it is brilliant. First shot it picked all of my computers that were on-line, and it is fast,
but slow at booting up for some reason, but I am not complaining, I did download it for free for testing. Nice to know all is ok.

by jdclyde

just did the 32 bit install instead of the 64 bit.

So far, so good.

Of course the first stumbling block was figuring out that it installs IIS6 AND IIS7. IIS7 has to hand off to the IIS6 for compatibility and to connect to the SNTP.

by peconet tietokoneet

Updates i can see why it boots up slowly, but sometimes it is slower than my Vista. But working on it is brilliant. I have two books on Windows 2008, the thick (read slowly book) and the admin (faster reading) book of which is a god send.

This discussion is closed to new replies.