Question Locked

Need to scale a UPS solution

0 helpful
29 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Greetings, just me again. :D

I have submitted via APC for their free calculator, but looking for more input to scale a UPS solution.

I have four servers, two monitors (one LCD, one CTR).

A switch, a cable modem, and a firewall.

Currently have a single APC Smart UPS 1500. I have been told the batteries were replaced two years ago.

Two of the servers, the switch/modem/firewall should be up for a few hours, while the other two servers only need to go about 15 minutes and do an orderly shutdown.

Ideas?

Thanks,

jd

29 replies

by darryl~

Our server room isn't that large (about 12' X 20') our self contained A/C unit doesn't have any form of power backup, when we lose power & are running of the UPS (which we can do for about 5 or 6 hours) the temperature goes through the roof & we end up starting to shut down the servers in a couple hours unless it's winter & we can get some doors open.

Just something to think about.

by jdclyde

We have a closet that is about 9x4. I just went today to get an exhaust vent/blower to install on the back wall that will suck the heat out of the room and kick it into the utility room on the other side of the wall.

There is a direct A/C duct going into the room, so just pulling the excess heat out should resolve that issue.

Before this, there was nothing done about heat.

We talked about the fan and if it should go on one of the UPS's or not. If we have half the servers automatically shut off, I don't think it would be needed.

by gadgetgirl

1. Look through the documentation and find the max and min temps for the servers. Dymo tape 'em to the rack for future reference.

2. If the closet has a window, hang a temperature gauge where it's easily seen. Mark the max and min temps on the gauge so that anyone passing can tell if there is trouble. (This actually WORKED where I am now - a passing staff member called the help desk, reported it and it was sorted without downtime)

3. If the closet doesn't have a window, think about a temperature alarm with a loud sounder. If you go this way, make sure you give yourself a couple of degrees leeway - it's amazing how many people wait a few minutes to see if the alarm stops by itself.....

Just things I've learned over the years....

:D

GG

by robo_dev

to keep two servers running for several hours.

What are the power ratings of your two servers?

off the top of my head, a pair of servers could easily top 500watts, to get two hours would take something like one 3000VA UPS per server, no?

by jdclyde

that is why I am asking.

One server is an HP ML110, the other is a DELL PowerEdge 2900 with redundant power supplies.

I haven't heard from APC yet for their calculator to start getting a base line required.

by robo_dev

Kill a watt:
http://www.p3international.com/products/special/P4400/P4400-CE.html

http://reviews.cnet.com/soho-servers/hp-proliant-ml110/4507-3125_7-30705200.html
HP mL110 uses 350Watts, roughly

www.dell.com/downloads/global/power/dell2socket_vs_hp4socket_vmware.pdf -
Dell uses 450 watts, roughly

so that's rougly 800watts, or around 7AMPS at 120V, or around 1280VA....a bit much for one 1500va UPS, you really need two 1500s or one bigger unit of some sort

At full load one 1500VA UPS with an additional runtime battery pack for each server would keep those going for around 20 minutes.

http://www.upssizer.com/

more guestimating says that a HP Rack-Mountable R5500 UPS with one extended runtime battery modules could provide 170 minutes at 1000w

http://www.lscwarehouse.com/af426a.html

http://h18000.www1.hp.com/products/servers/proliantstorage/power-protection/rackups/r5500xr/index.html

by darryl~

APC 3000va UPS with 2 additional 3000va batteries for 2 blade servers (I'd guess the servers would be around 800 watt's combined without going & looking)....like I said earlier, we normally start shutting the servers down after about 2 hours because we lose the A/C....I think APC rated them for 5 hours for what we have on them.....2 IBM X-series blade servers. We're very pleased with them, work great, remote login.

by shasca

Why two hours? Why also the router/modem/FW?

by jdclyde

Two hours is my guess to this point.

I have sent out an email to the three people that have a say in this sort of thing to get their opinions on the time frame.

As far as the router/modem/fw, that is to keep our web server available for customers to check their orders. This will be one of our highest priorities. Secondary priority would be keeping the servers available to the remote locations.

Depending on cost, I wonder about getting a gas powered generator?

by robo_dev

While a small 5KW generator would be under $3K, the cost of the automatic transfer switch and associated wiring/site prep would more than double that cost.

My guess is that you can do this with a big UPS for around $4K or so.

Don't forget that you need enough UPS capacity to keep the servers running until UPS starts. But then you need less runtime, obviously....

there still may be a cooling issue, as someone else posted....

by shasca

How were you able to get buyin on all these. expenditures of late? Did you layout a need list when you got hired? You have said they have no clue of what is necessary to DR a network infrastructure.Did they have a needs list? Your aren't spending your way out of a job I hope. There is always a long wishlist for all of us. I'm not judgeing, I would think others here would like to know your secret for so many dollars being approved for the new guy. Do tell do tell..

by jdclyde

$1500 to keep the critical systems up for 10 minutes, until a generator can be kicked in.

$4766 to keep it up for two hours.

Wonder how much a generator costs?

Of course, that only helps during normal business hours. :D

by mjd420nova

For the extended period units, the 1500 sounds adequate but that CRT is going to drag it down quick, however, I don't use a monitor at all on my server unless I need to monitor it or doing backups or updates. The other units that just need an orderly shut down could be seperated out and out on a smaller UPS unit and be more cost effective. How often has the UPS been used in the last two years since battery replacement? I routinely exercise the UPS for my server by yanking the power once a month and allow a discharge of fifty percent to gauge their usage times before shutdown would be required.

by jdclyde

and power has gone down about 2 times a year from what people remember. (I have only been here a month). The last outage was about 2 hours.

Got a kvm switch to run the systems, but the Dell 2900 turned out to be USB only keyboard/mouse, so I have to get USB>PS2 adapters before I can add that into the KVM and get rid of the CRT.

Looking at doing the "yank test" in a few weeks when I can focus on this more. Just getting the basic information together before it is needed to get a jump on it. That way I can pretend to know more about this than I do! :D

by jellimonsta

I would not put the CRT monitor on UPS at all, that way it will not draw any power that could go to server uptime. I think at this point you have an idea as to the UPS you will want to use (and additional battery pack). Do you have UPS at each users desk to protect them against brownout or short blackout?
If there is no UPS at the desks, then you don't need to keep the majority of the services up to much past 10 minutes. You will want to focus on protecting the area of the business that is revenue generating. So, if online orders is it, keep up your Internet connection and public WWW server.

by jdclyde

I will be looking at something to just protect against surges/brownouts, not uptime for desktops.

In an emergency, our key app can be run directly on the server.

So yes, the online status requests is my #1 priority.

by darryl~

I didn't notice a tape backup library there. I forgot about that.....it's on our UPS as well. If we were on UPS when the backups kicked in it would kill the battery life pretty quick. Our backups take a few hours....we have to shut that down also...Michigan gets a little worse weather than Nova Scotia in the winter....a bad storm can take us out for over 12 hours sometimes.

by jdclyde

so they are factored in.

As for weather, in Mid-Michigan other than cold, we don't typically get anything devastating. A few feet of snow is just another day for us. B-)

by jdclyde

is mostly feeding the need.

They hired me because they wanted to expand and knew a part time consultant wouldn't be able to get them where they need to be.

They told me where they wanted to go, I showed them the way. B-)

Oh, and because I am not tacking on a 55% markup, EVERYTHING I have purchased to this point added together still costs less than the last server the Consultant set them up with. They are in reverse-sticker-shock. :D

Keep in mind, this is a SOHO setting, so many of the purchases are very affordable. Largest office is where I am at, and there are three other users in the building.

I do make sure I explain the pro's and con's of each purchase, and leave it to them on if they can live with the cost of NOT spending the money in the short term based upon the long term impact.

by jdclyde

The first thing I did was look at our service providers. They hadn't been talked to for years.

Between the three locations I am saving them over 2k a year, every year. What I am saving them has come close to paying for myself. B-)

Two things to look for, how to save money and how to make money, and everything is geared towards one or both of those goals.

Just went shopping for an exhaust vent yesterday. It wasn't that the heat is bad for the servers, it is to keep the servers running faster and higher availability so the users are not waiting on the equipment.

I dumped a bunch of RAM in half of the system. Gee, no more bluescreens.... (WinXP) Amazing the difference a gig of ram makes over 256 megs. :p

by jdclyde

I am keeping a spreadsheet with a list of my accomplishments.

I am also keeping track of all savings/earnings I have done.

When it comes time for my 6 months review, I will be ready to state the case why I deserve a mondo raise. B-)

by jdclyde

used the HP calculator to come up with that.

Two servers,
firewall,
cable modem,
switch.

by cg it

if 100% uptime is needed.

If you have different offices in difference locations all with Internet access, you can use URL redirects.

Just an thought.

by jdclyde

for the database lookups.

:(

The web server allows the customer to know in real-time the status of their orders, as well as place new orders. The status checking is the big issue.

That is why I have two servers I need to keep live.

by jhudmon1

You should just call CDW or login to their website. They have a tool where you tell it what type of devices you have and how many. The tool will quote you a APC unit.

by jdclyde

but I always like to double check anything that points me to a single product line.

I do know I have NOT had good luck with Triplite, and will NOT be considering them as a product line. Minuteman was always dependable for us though (at my last job).

by shasca

It's been fun watching your growth in a new job.
The planning before even the interview. Keeping Scummy at arms length, and letting him swing away.
The fact that they have a need to grow is the ideal scenario to get into. Plus it helps when you spend wisely, and find cost savings that can offset some purcheses.
I don't think any of us will be surprised if you kill your six monther from what you have shared here. Thanks for the play by play :-bd
(your favorite emoticon)

by jdclyde

flipped me off again! :p

When I got hired in, I told them two wages. One, the wage I was worth, the other the wage I would start at until I had proved to them that indeed I WAS worth the second amount. B-)

If the major project I am working on is successful, there is a good chance at full time. :D Woo Woo!

This discussion is closed to new replies.