Question Locked

New PC reads OS from secondary HDD....

0 helpful
8 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Well, after finding my mobo dead on my Dell Dimension 8300 (see my other post here), the boss bought a new PC from CompUSA. Nothing fancy (Pentium D 925, 2GB RAM), but it runs fine, so I decided to put my new 250GB Western Digital IDE HDD (from the dead Dell) in for back-up storage. Problem is, the new PC runs a 160GB SATA HDD, so I put the 250GB on the only IDE cable the new mobo has (sharing with the resident CD/DVD drive), and now when I crank it up, it wants to read and boot from the Windows XP2 OS on the 250GB drive, and totally ignores the primary SATA 160GB drive with the XP Professional OS on it (which I really want to use)...the CompUSA folks said I could do it, but it ain't workin'...should I strip the Windows XP off of the 250GB drive BEFORE I re-install it, to keep the blasted thing happy?
Thanks,
Rob

8 replies

by scott_heath

Boot off the Windows CD and try fiddling with bootfix and such. I don't have a CD in front of me, but if you list the commands once it's loaded you should see a few boot related tools

by thumbsup2

Did you go into the BIOS and tell it first boot device is CD, then 2nd boot device is SATA primary drive and 3rd boot device is IDE drive?

by treborsnikwad

I'll see what I can do about fiddling with the boot sequence in the BIOS and let you guys know...
Rob

by treborsnikwad

Well, I finally got my secondary 250GB HD up and running by plugging it into the other IDE controller plug (under the CD/RW drive), and it was all roses and candy until today, about 30 minutes ago, when the PC quit reading the secondary HD, and even dropped the drive letter designation from the My Computer tree list. Hoping for the best, I plugged it into the spare Dell we have here, and it worked fine (it was recognized). I plugged it BACK into the new Systemax PC, and it won't read it. What could be causing it to do this all of a sudden?
Should I just can the IDE drive and pick up a SATA version for my secondary storage?
Rob

by scott_heath

It's kind of hard to tell what the problem is, but if you can't see it in the BIOS then it's the motherboard, cable, or drive. You've eliminated the drive, I doubt it's the cable, so that only leaves motherboard. Double check your jumper settings (yes, I agree, if it worked for a month then it most likely isn't jumper settings). Swap cables with the CD drive. Update your BIOS!

I bought a BioStart P4M900 Mobo (I know, I know, I am too cheap\poor to get a new CPU, so I bought a Mobo that supports my Socket 478 clunker but has SATA, DRR2, and x16 PCIe) and the first one I got wouldn't boot with my IDE HD plugged in. With just the SATA it was cool. Anyway, the Mobo stopped recgonizing the RAM all together (yay BioStar) so I had to get it RMA'ed. The replacement Mobo sees my IDE drives fine and there has been no issues with booting up.

Well, that's my two cents and paltry advice, let me know if I can be of more help.

by mayhem1969

They sell a ide to sata converter that converts the ide connector to a sata connector. That is probably a lot cheaper then a new hdd.

I have seen several issues with ide and sata together and none of them seem to have anything in common. There is no reason you shouldn't be able to do it, but it clearly causes issues to some. One suggestion was to change the boot order to scsi from sata first. Another was to make sure ide drive was set to master, cd rom to slave. Another said to pull the jumpers on the ide drive. I also saw something that indicates your sata drive should be moved from auto configuration to advanced. There is also something said about MSI boards not running sata and ide drives at the same time. So check your motherboard info.

I would work on the boot order first in bios. I would then fool with the jumpers on the ide drives, alternating between master, slave and none.

by treborsnikwad

It turned out to be the drive. Although it's a new one, when I plugged it into the other PC again, it was "whirring" and "clicking" and "buzzing" like nuts...then, there was no recognition by the O/S. I rebooted, and took a magic marker and tapped the top of the drive as it spun up, and as I did so, the PC started a scandisc operation and found numerous bad sectors on that drive; now it "works", but I don't trust it anymore for data storage. I put a new 320GB Seagate SATA in my Systemax PC, and now it has blistering performance. Problem solved...thanks for all the tips!
Rob

This discussion is closed to new replies.