Discussion Locked

NewSID and Windows XP, Necessary?

0 helpful
2 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.
Is it really necessary to change the SID of XP computers if you?re connecting only to a domain and not a workgroup? Info from NewSid 4.0 readme file states "Duplicate SIDs aren't an issue in a Domain-based environment since domain accounts have SID's based on the Domain SID". Thanks

2 replies

by sgt_shultz

is rhetorical question, yes? you want a domain, you want unique sid's imho. microsoft says duplicate sid's are security issue in the case of REMOVABLE media. maybe a fine point? me, i would stick with unique SIDS. sid # consists of hardware, domain and user and group info. maybe newsid knows better. can you talk directly to them? i think they are not telling whole story. meanwhile, check out horse's mouth article from support.microsoft.com about cloning XP in domain environment:
----314828 The Microsoft Policy concerning disk duplication of windows XP installations---

by curacao_dejavu

2 reasons you need unique sid's.
1: I ran in an ocasionally error message (when starting to clone 2 years ago) that there was another machine with the same sid.
2: When you start logging security issues it will be also be based on a sid, and with multiple sid's you can not know which of the duplicate it really is, and therefor your proof will be less sound.

Leopold

This discussion is closed to new replies.