Discussion Locked

Noody NEEDS welfare

0 helpful
24 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

After speaking with several people here over the years who believe that nobody really NEEDS welfare or similar social assistance, I thought I'd post a story from Behind The Blue Line that I ran across today.

The reason I take this issue seriously is because I know people who have slipped through the cracks, one having been heavily medicated on just about anything you can name and by dozens of doctors for over 25 years only to find out that the medication was a toxic concoxtion where proper disgnosis was to finally remove ALL medications and the person has been living a fantastic and normal life since. That diagnisis was by the last social worker she could get in to see and actually have hear her out. Now she feels she has been robbed for 25 years and lost a huge portion of her life due to a nervous breakdown that many years ago.

People are so easily forgotten or left behind by a system that is concerned about costs and helpign others at a taxpayers expense.

However there are those that remain with some compassion for mankind and neighbours, who are finding that there are still great holes that need much closer attention which are easily dismissed and forgotten by most.

[i][b]Through the Cracks[/b]

Posted on July 6, 2009 by Sandra in Code Four - Stories from Patrol
A certain part of our society is always in danger of slipping through the web of services, assistance and care designed to keep people healthy, functioning and safe. Be it because of mental health issues, lack of economic income or by choice, this percentage of our citizenry is constantly monitored.

But still, they slip through, even if only for a short time.

Years ago, my partner and I were sent on a call to cover our Mental Health Car, a unit pairing of a police officer and a mental health nurse. They were checking up on a patient who had been deemed ?appropriate for outside living? as long as he was monitored bi-weekly. The unit had received a call from the building manager of the rooming house where the man lived, complaining of the weird noises and smell coming from the man?s room.

Upon our arrival at the front desk, it was clear the manager was glad to see all of us. He further explained that he had not been able to get John (not his real name, but it?ll do for this post) to answer his door in the last several days. With only a sink and no toilet facilities in the room, the manager said the reek coming out from the room was horrible.

John?s room was up two flights of stairs in the T of a long hallway and as we approached my partner turned to me, his nose wrinkled in disgust. We were still 20 ft from John?s door and the manager was right - the stench was awful and I feared John might be dead.

We gathered outside and stood quiet for a few moments. From the other side of the door was a faint buzzing, like a radio tuned to static. The nurse knocked and called out John?s name. The only answer was the muffled shuffle of something moving along the floor, so the nurse knocked again. Nothing. Just another bump.

Taking the key from the manager, one of us unlocked the door, calling out John?s name and telling him we were the Mental Health Car and the police. As the door swung open the stench from inside exploded out in a black cloud. Flies. Hundreds of them.

Not a good sign. So imagine the look my partner gave me when a man?s voice croaked out from inside the room.

John was very much alive.

Tucked into a corner, sitting with his knees bent up to his chin, was John. He looked to have been in the same spot for days; the floor beneath him was stained with urine and feces. His were clothes stiff and filthy. Flies buzzed about him, alighting on his arms and face. The room was in complete disarray, with food rotting in the sink, garbage littered everywhere, and what must have been a honey bucket, tipped over and spilling it?s rancid contents across the floor in a splash. I had never seen such conditions before (or since), and that someone could actually survive for days was a wonder of human tenacity.

The nurse, paying no attention to the smell, went forward, bending low so as not to startle John. The nurse was a big man with a gentle spirit, and he softened his deep tenor voice to speak soothing words to John. In the same way music tames a wild beast, his voice had the same effect on John, and John?s eyes blinked alive.

________________

The smell of death ingrains itself into your skin, your hair, and your clothing. Even after a shower and a change of clothes, the odor of decaying flesh lingers in your sinuses. In this case, John was still with us, and was transported to a hospital for treatment of the gangrenous wounds to his legs caused by poor health and hygiene.

I drove home that night, deep in thought about the future of humanity when such atrocities exist among us. John had slipped through the cracks.

We must do better by one another.

We must.[/i]

I've personally known thre epeople in such a situation over the last few years, one an ex accountant for a mjor airline, wound up dead last spring. Tow others, one who nobody has had contact with in many months and is presumed dead and another who once had a house and family of four, after a divorce was found homeless and shortly after lost his job an dnow lives on skid row until he will finally die from intravenus drugs. Unable to pay rent in a normal apartment, he was stuck on low income housing in skid row, a place VERY few ever recover from, though I know of one that has and later died of Aids from IV Drug use while on skid row.

Nah, nobody NEEDS welfare or other public assistance programs, they are all just as capable as you or I.

24 replies

by deadly ernest

line are meant to be sarcastic, I'm in 1,000% agreement with you. I've worked the dirty back streets and the nice clean psychiatric ward of a hospital. There are lots of cracks and it's too damn easy for people to fall through due to neglect, or just not knowing; and everything in between.

by notsochiguy

...helping those that need it. My problem with government assistance programs stems from the systematic abuse. Here's a wonderful example of my tax money (actually, all US citizens', since these programs in Chicago are backed by TIF funds) going down the tubes:
http://www.suntimes.com/news/watchdogs/1686294,CST-NWS-watchdogs27.article

Granted, the guy was caught...but by a newspaper investigation, and not through some sort of internal auditing. Unacceptable.

When I was growing up in the city, my family was on public aid. Without going all Afternoon Special about it, let's just say that the government helped fund my mother's drug addiction. Had she been forced to take a drug test as condition of receiving the funds, or been made to actually seek employment, things may have been different.

How we treat the least of us says a lot about us as a society. However, so does federally subsidizing criminal activities. Call me an idealist, but I don't think we have to turn our backs on the less fortunate in order to weed out those that are simply milking the system. All that is necessary is a strong will and strong efforts.

Of course, being able to do something and actually doing it are two entirely different things...so I won't hold my breath waiting for the changes to occur.

by shellbot

I worked for a Homeless Charity for 3 years, and I took away two things from that job.

1. There are always those who will try and take advantage of the system. They take and take, never giving thanks or "something back".

2. There are those who need that helping hand, and they often fall through the cracks because they sometimes do not shout as loud as those who are busy taking all they can get.

I've a hundred stories, but I won't go into details,due to confidentiality clauses I signed.

I have no problem for those that need it, but I abhor people abusing the system as it it takes away from those that truly need the assistance.

Lets take my ex..him or his wife haven't worked in years. Kids are in school.. living on welfare. Disgusts me to no end that the money they are taking could be used for people who are truly in need.

Enough said..

by jdclyde

The scammers get while the people really in need, that are doing the best they can, are pushed aside.

Been there, done that, won the prize on the top shelf.

by tonythetiger

[I]The scammers get while the people really in need, that are doing the best they can, are pushed aside.
[/I]

They're just like us!

by tonythetiger

that "the cracks" are artificially created by those with more power than the people who fall through them.

You see, it is cheaper to pay them to stay down than it is to honestly compete with them.

by shellbot

If you want to whine about that type of stuff..go to the Resume Type o's thread..

they having fun ripping on me in there..
pissants..

I'll stomp on em all!

by shellbot

Personally I don't give a rats..
I've bigger things in my life to worry about :)

Just thought I'd have some fun with them though ]:)

by maxwell edison

Oh, silly me. That would be the Canadian government.

1. You create a government run system.
2. You point-out and complain about the obvious flaws.
3. You argue for more of the same.

Sounds like insanity to me. Perhaps we can get the government to decide on how to treat it.

Personally speaking, I'm all in favor of a system that's run by more competent people - those OUT of government.

Edit:

P.S. Speaking as an American, regardless of political party preference, anyone who wants the President, the Senate Leader, and the Speaker of the House of Representatives to decide ANYTHING about how one should live one's personal life is a fool. I'm amazed at how people simply yield such decisions to those people, and let the decisions be made for them. And I'm disgusted at those who won't admit to yielding such things for themselves, but they presume to speak for others.

P.P.S. Think about this. Fifty or sixty years ago, the United States would have sent troops to foreign lands to protect the freedom and liberty of people whose government was doing the same thing to them that the U.S. government is doing to American citizens right now. Financially enslaving them, denying personal property rights, taking over private companies, violating privacy rights, dictating how one should live one's life, etc.

I wonder when the United States military will invade the United States to restore OUR freedoms? (Or will it eventually be used to further deny them?)

by deadly ernest

US military hardware systems running on Windows that when an attack does come the systems will have a breakdown and attack each other instead of the dangerous flight of two thousand migrating Canadian Geese flying through the US air space. The resultant media response will cause politicians to resign en mass as their bribes take dramatic cuts.

THEN things will start to improve.

by shellbot

I don't think it matter what country your in... "the system" ends up being flawed and abused.

Maybe there are countries out there with none of these problems? If so..I stand corrected.

by maxwell edison

You said, [i]"After speaking with several people here over the years who believe that nobody really NEEDS welfare or similar social assistance........"[/i]

Speaking for myself, I've NEVER suggested that [i]nobody needs assistance[/i]. I've always questioned, however, the prudence of relying on government to provide it. Anyone who believes that relying on government to solve social and individual problems is the best solution to such problems, is a very foolish and misguided person (in my opinion). Or, in some cases, they're simply feeling guilty about their own success, and to relieve such guilt, they build a facade of [i]caring[/i] and pass the buck to government.

You have NEVER represented my (political) position accurately, Oz. I wonder why that is? After all these years, you continue to debate the straw-man.

by jackofalltech

The Bible says that those who CAN work must work but that we do have the responsibility to take care of widows, orphans, and those destitute without hope.

Unfortunatly, the American and European churches dropped the ball and let the govt take over these services.

by jdclyde

as a way to gain power and buy votes.

"vote for us and we will give you money from the evil rich".

This discussion is closed to new replies.