Discussion Locked

Not everyone's meant for management

0 helpful
10 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.
Tell us what you think about turning down a management position, as featured in Monday's Career Advice e-newsletter. Have you ever turned down a promotion? What were your reasons? How did it affect your current position at your company?

10 replies

by mgfyo01

The problem is as follows : you learned technics and you are good at it. When you go upstairs on the career ladder, your problem is no more "do" but "organize so that it will be done", in other words "manage". You have no more to deal with technics but with people. That is also technics but not the same kind of technics. May be you never learned this one. May be you are not minded at it.
How would you react if your boss told you "OK,now let the computers and take a file and steel and work on mechanics" ?
You would understand it is not the same kind of technics. May be you will say "Right but I first need courses to learn how to do" or "No, this is of no interest for me".
So why do people jump from technics to management so easily ?
I am a graduate chemical engineer. I learned technics at school and had to deal with people (what I never learned) as soon as I entered industry. It was not very difficult because when you are a young post graduate, you may do any mistake you need to dountil you learn how to do your job. It is much more difficult when you walk a step up on the career ladder in the same company.
My first son is just graduate from a Management school. When I had a glance at his courses, I understood why I made so many mistakes. Now I am sure, management is not only "guts" as I was told but also technics.

by iglover

When I was entering this field I thought management was the way to go. Could not understand why my brother would turn down a management position. After working for myself and for some else, I have decided that management is not for me. To me it is meetings upon meetings that accomplish nothing. I like to produce and learn technically every day. I have a hard enough time attending a meeting. People want to go into management most of the time because that is where the money is to be made. I always said it's not if I would be a good manager or not, because I would be good at anything I set my mind to doing.
The big question is would I be happy? That answer is no. My boss understands this and needs to have my technical expertise around to solve problems. It works out well.

by tkrin

I feel the same. I have never had even the slightest inkling to pursue management. I find most meetings to be mostly unproductive, exluding meetings that I have setup w/ "customers" or users, to discuss explicit technically related agenda, which is far different than the regular staff meetings which I get called to attend.

I am a technical person and not very much a people person in the respect of wanting to manage a team. I have no problem managing my own IT projects but by pursuing a management position, I loose the part of the job that I enjoy; techincal learning, implementation and troubleshooting.

by discordian

I have not been employed anywhere that had an environment where I could succeed as a manager. It's difficult for me to even consider becoming a manager in it's own right because of my belief system, but when you pair that with in-fighting, politics,and the complete lack of respect and communication between departments and within the IS department itself that I have experienced everywhere that I have been thus far, it makes the choice to become a manager pretty obvious.

So, when I have refused any promotion that was obviously a step towards scapegoatdom, I have said no because I felt that I was more useful to the organization as a technical person, not managerial. So, I could be truthful and tactful at the same time. Of course, all of this is while I have my resume out, looking for someplace decent to work at just in case the management can't take no for an answer.

by abomoaathe

I was once pure Senior techie. Re-structure took place and I was given the choice either miss the chance to go-up higher or a semi know-nothing will suprevise me. So had to accept it , but didn't get the chance to practise it as a major merge took place and was back as a techie.

by jhyiesla

Nick, I think you gave excellent advice. I am pretty good at what I do. What I do is the technical side of things. I feel as though I am well respected and pretty wall paid for my skills. I do a little management, but that is mostly organizing and following up on projects. Could I make more as a manager; sure. But I think that I am more valuable and that I perform better right where I am.

by fluxit

I have turned down management jobs many times for various reasons. Relocation not desirable, pay inadequate, and office personalities undesireable or the corporate climate is poor.

I get particultarly frustrated while intereviewing for a position and the interviewers attempt some kind of psychological game. At this point I usually toy with the interviewer knowing that I do not want the job. I think it is so absurd to conduct these silly games with what I once considered a serious opportunity.

In one management job interview I went from reporting to the CIO to 2 levels below him. The CIO asked me silly questions that I would ask a entry level person. There was also a mismatch in that I was there in my meeting to learn of their issuesand how I could help them. They were there to K-mart interview me.

Rarely does the opportunity effect my current position. Only once I was offered a counter offer but I never intereviewed with anyone else and was not looking. I left that job 3 months later. I usually keep the meetings/interview quiet.

by timseery

Over the past few years I have had the opportunity to move into management. About two years ago I decided it was time. "Why fight it?", I said to myself. The pay was better and I have the chance to shape the organization.

But was I happier, the answer was No. Somehow I had gone from tech guru to a psychologist/recruiter/lawyer/accountant, working longer hours and I was quickly falling behind technically.

So when my company was purchased and it looked like job was going to “realigned”, I immediately started to retrain and update my certifications. I only pursued non-management positions, even if I had to take a pay cut.

As it turned-out my new position ended paying more and I was able to make an immediate positive impact. I would not trade my time a manager because it has given me a better perspective, allowing me to see the big picture. Also I can take solace in a comment from a former team member “I was an one of the best managers they had worked for”. A valuable lesson I learned from all of this is that if work closely with management, I can stay technical and shape the organization without limiting my salary potential.

by fluxit

Too many people when entering the management circles attempt be the techie guru and run the department simultaneously. The very thing they hated in thier bosses they often become.

All too often people never really develop management skills. They seem to think its always being prudent and politically saavy. I would say that is only 15% of the game. Management comes in many colors but always relates directly to day-to-day operations of the company. Managers embrace policies and procedures of the company and develop thier own polcies and procedures. Yet managers know when to break them and the potential outcome.

On occasion managers use vision and provide leadership. Rarely are managers given the big picture. They are given fragmented pieces of it.

I have argued against human management in other discussions as I have run the management gambit. It has fried me and rewarded me alike.

It is my hope to move into a leadership position and business ownership. I have a vision in which my business is a social organization caring for people, empowering people, and doing it with minimal management.

by admin

He is greatly respected (probably the most liked and respected) worker in his office. I have great respect for him in this too. At first he made less money, but now he is also paid at management levels although he is not a manager. This took a lot of time.
I, on the other hand, have taken every increase and am a good manager.

I would say the greek maxum is still the best guide: "Know Thyself"

I would add a second: "Trust Thyself"

Basically, you will always do the best in the position you really want and know.

This discussion is closed to new replies.