Discussion Locked

Of "Enterprise" and "Andromeda", which is more true to Trek's vision?

0 helpful
3 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Having watched both shows, I have my own personal opinion on this, but I won't state it here, lest everyone simply echo me in an effort to "appease" me.

In "Enterprise", we saw a lot of canon-busting moves (more than I can count) that reduced the believability of the series for the long-term fans.

In "Andromeda", which seems almost to be a post-apocalypse variant of Trek in some ways. We see a single ship struggling to survive and revive their system of government.

In "Enterprise", there seemed to be a marked lack of chemistry between the crewmembers, and there were scenes thrown in by the TV execs and the producer that just Didn't Work to increase ratings.

In "Andromeda", the crew simply worked together well, despite differences they might have had off-duty.

I'm sure there are other comparisons to be made. Will leave that to the rest of you. Let's have some fun with this one.

3 replies

by charliespencer

I'm sorry, I can't recall having heard of Andromeda. When did it run, how long, and what network? Maybe it was during that period I didn't have cable.

Obviously I'm not going to be able to contribute to the primary discussion, but I'm mystified by not having any recollection of an entire series.

by neil higgins

although I have to admit,I only watched a few episodes.I posted elsewhere about Star Trek,stating,more or less,in my opinion,that it lost the plot a long time ago.
I do remember Farscape though,and watched quite a few episodes.However,Battlestar Galactica (season 4 in production),has gripped my attention for the last few years.Although,even that is beginning to run out of ideas,hence this season being the last.

This discussion is closed to new replies.