Question Locked

old HD in USB Box - vista asking for format

0 helpful
18 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Hi all,
After my computer died I went out and bought an external case like I've seen suggested here. The drive spins up, the computer recognizes it but when I double click on the drive its asking me to format it.
I want to get the old data off the drive.
Any suggestions for me?
I'm running vista.
Thanks,
Kelley

18 replies

by the scummy one

was this the main drive (boot drive) from the old system?
What 'died' with the old system?

If it is IDE based, try making sure the jumper is set to Master position (instead of cable select or slave). See if that helps.
But usually, I would get the data from a broken MS install by using a Linux system.

by larryd4

Sorry but if that HD from the old Computer is a Fat32 or below format, Vista will not be able to read it. You'll have to access it with a WinXP or a Win2K PC.

by willcomp

Vista will read and write FAT16, FAT32, and NTFS drives.

by larryd4

Nooo really.. Am I thinking that it just can't install on FAT32?

Yes I was wrong... :/

It can't install on Fat32 but it can read the drives.

by rob miners

Click Start and in the Run box type in cmd and press Enter.
type in chkdsk ?/r and press Enter.

? = the drive letter assigned to the USB drive.

Keep us informed as to your progress if you require further assistance.

If you think that any of the posts that have been made by all TR Members, have solved or contributed to solving the problem, please Mark them as Helpful so that others may benefit from the outcome. ;) :D

by kotchfam

Ok, I hooked it up to the laptop running XP. When I double click on the drive it asks me to format the drive.
The same thing Vista was asking me to do on the other system.
The box itself is vista compatible. Vista reads that the drive is there, it just wants me to format it before it will open it.
If I format the drive I will lose all the data right? Is there a work around to get the ghost info off there if I do format it?
I want the pictures and the music off this drive.
Thanks,
Kelley

by rob miners

of the chkdsk was there any error messages.

Write down all fixed Disk and CD/DVD drive letters so as not to delete them. DO NOT delete any of the fixed hard disk drives or CD/DVD optical drives registry values.

1. Login with Administrative privileges.

2. Disconnect all USB or FireWire storage devices.

3. Open Registry Editor by typing regedt32 in the Run box and navigate to the following registry key: HKEY_LOCAL_MACHINE\SYSTEM\MountedDevices

4. Under HKEY_LOCAL_MACHINE\SYSTEM\MountedDevices there will be registry keys with the name that resembles the format of \DosDevice\X: where X can be any alphabet letter which corresponding to your physical system drive letter.

5. Delete all possible USB drives, FireWire drives and external drives which have a drive letter.

DO NOT delete any of the fixed Hard Disk Drives or CD/DVD optical drives registry values.

Exclude \DosDevice\A: which normally reserved for floppy disk drives.

Shutdown and restart the PC with out any USB devices attached. Then connect your drive and see if you can access it.

Keep us informed as to your progress if you require further assistance.

If you think that any of the posts that have been made by all TR Members, have solved or contributed to solving the problem, please Mark them as Helpful so that others may benefit from the outcome. ;) :D

by oh smeg

Quite often a Jumper is not required in a NB but when you add a IDE HDD to an external Caddy you need to replace the jumper to set it to Master.

When there is No Jumper on a IDE HDD every Windows and quit a few Nix OS's see the drive as unformatted and want the drive formatted before they will attempt to read it. If you try to format the drive I don't think that the Format will actually work that is providing that the HDD is actually working.

If you suffered a HDD Failure in the old computer placing it into a External Enclosure will not make it work now.

Have you tested the HDD with the Makers Testing Utility as well?

You can find the HDD Makers Testing utility by looking here. Just click on the HDD Makers Name and you will be prompted where you want to download the Testing Utility to.

http://www.tacktech.com/display.cfm?ttid=287

Col

by oh smeg

Depending on the type of HDD that you removed from a Dead Computer there are a couple of things you need to know before using it.

IDE Drives need to be set to Master not CS Cable Select or Slave in an USB Enclosure.

SATA Drives generally speaking Do Not need any Jumpers set unless this was a new SATA Drive and it's been fitted to a older model Enclosure then you may need to limit the Drive to the SATA 1 Standard.

Was the USB Enclosure you bought Vista Compatible? It needs to say Vista Compatible on the Box as some Chip Sets used in the Interface between the USB and HDD are not Vista Compatible.

Is the Power Adapter if supplied with the enclosure plugged in to both the Mains and the Enclosure properly?

If this is a 3.5 inch HDD it requires the use of a Power Adapter to work as USB only supplies 5 V DC not the 12 V DC required to run a 3.5 inch HDD.

If it is a 2.5 Inch HDD then you need to look at the size of the Drive and the USB Lead where it connects to the computer. This is a General Rule but it varies with the different HDD that have been made over the years the older Drives do not conform to this rule so you need to remember this. Any 2.5 Inch HDD under 80 Gig can be powered from 1 USB port so if you have a USB Lead with a Y Connector at the computer end you only need to use the USB Connector away from the end of the lead. The last USB Connector on the Y Lead is a Power Only Connector and doesn't transfer any Data through it.

If the HDD is old or larger that 80 GIG you need to use Both of the Y Connectors at the computer end of the USB Lead & plug them into different USB Ports. You [b]Can Not[/b] use a USB Unpowered Hub Here or a PCMCIA Card to run one of these drives off you need to use 2 of the USB Sockets in the Computer to provide enough power to run these External HDD's. This is because a USB Port is limited to 500 Milli Amps Current and this isn't enough to run the Older Power Hungry NB Drives or those above 80 GIG Capacity.

If you didn't get a Y USB Connector Cable or a Power Adapter with the enclosure you need to replace the USB Lead with one with a Y Adapter on it's Computer End or purchase the Optional Power Adapter.

Now for the last bit depending on what was used previously on this HDD Vista may not be able to read it. This happens because Vista uses a different Security Protocol to Read Partition Information. If you are having an issue with the Partition Information and Vista being unable to read it you need to copy the Data off this HDD to something on a computer either running XP or use a Live Linux on your New computer and copy the Data off the Old HDD to the New HDD in the computer. You can get a Live Linux as a Cover Disc on a Linux Magazine at your Local Newsagent or download one of these Live Linux's.

http://www.frozentech.com/content/livecd.php

if you have access to a computer running Windows XP in any form you can use this to copy the Data off this HDD and then plug it into the Vista Computer and Format it there. you can then copy the Data back to the External HDD if there isn't any form of Local Area Network Involved and then when the copy is finished transfer the Enclosure to the new computer and copy your data to this from the External Enclosure.

If there is a LAN involved you can copy the Data across the LAN to the new computer.

I hope that isn't too confusing.

Col

by kotchfam

I'll try hooking it up to my laptop that still runs XP. The old hard drive (about 3 years old) ran on XP so I'm hoping thats the issue.
I'll let you know how it goes!
All the other stuff checked out. :)

by larryd4

The post I made here last night is a classic example of why no one should answer any question on TR, while they are on their third pint of Guinness..

by oh smeg

Probably a good reason why Gokoo never grew any bigger.

While he's a greedy little sod consuming things as he feels like it but even Guinness is too powerful for him. :0

[b]OH Look these girls are so poor that they can not afford any cloths.[/b] :D

Col

by larryd4

Been a big DB and DBZ fan for awhile.

Goku

by oh smeg

Called Dragon Ball.

if you look at Larry's Avatar you'll see this charter's picture there. :p

Bad OM did you miss that one? :D

Col ]:)

by rob miners

it can't be used with Vista.

Partition Find & Mount

http://findandmount.com/download/

Keep us informed as to your progress if you require further assistance.

If you think that any of the posts that have been made by all TR Members, have solved or contributed to solving the problem, please Mark them as Helpful so that others may benefit from the outcome. ;) :D

This discussion is closed to new replies.