Question Locked

One Computer + Virtualization + (four)keyboards + (four) Monitors = ?

0 helpful
6 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Has anyone used Microsoft Server 2008, or any other OS that allows virtualization along with multiple keyboards, mice, and monitors?

I'm thinking about multiple users using one machine.

I have seen these links but wondered if anyone had something more current:
http://www.networktechinc.com/kmspltpc.html
http://linuxgazette.net/124/smith.html

6 replies

by oh smeg

Yes those things should work but you would need to configure different user accounts on the Host Computer.

You however may find it easier with a Windows System to use Thin Clients rather than something like this that is described in your post.

Col

by narf u

But thin clients you still have to invest in some hardware, that doesn't quite a flexible solution. With a Computer that is setup to have 4 users your saving money. One computer + four monitors, keyboards, and mice.

Wouldn't this be good business solution where you already have 4 people in the department doing the same job in cubicles right next to each other?

I would think you would have greater flexibility not using thin clients. If you buy thin client hardware, then that's all you can do with it. Your business shrinks, your stuck with a (difficult to sell) machine with only thin client capabilities.

I'm thinking that Microsoft should really push this kind of platform, since they don't have that much of a vested interest in hardware sales. Put this on Windows 7 Professional, and their sales would be sure to increase, THAT IS IF IT WORKED SMOOTHLY. Marketing would love it, "Buy a computer with Windows 7 Pro, and we'll throw in an extra monitor, keyboard and mouse."

As it is right now, I have no interest in Windows 7. Give me an offer where I can buy essentially two computers for the price of one, heck yeah, Windows 7 here I come!

by oh smeg

If anything they would make considerably less as there is on one license involved per machine. With new hardware the biggest single component cost is the M$ Software. It costs more then the rest of the computer added together with the Low & mid range stuff so cutting back their sales by having 1 computer servicing several end users is actually costing M$ money in lost sales. As things currently stand M$ gets paid for 2 OS's on many new systems particularly for Business use where they come new loaded with Vista and this is removed and replaced with XP. The companies who do this charge for Vista and then charge again for XP and use a new XP Pro License with the reload.

With many Business systems XP is required because many Specialized Applications are not Vista Compatible I am supporting some specialized Business Software that was not rewritten to run of XP so it runs on NT4 and it is going to continue to be used because it saves a considerable amount of money for that business. Vista is still relatively new and it isn't backward compatible with many specialized Software applications and a lot of Mission Critical Hardware like Network Printers so XP is still the King of the Hill for the OS in business. It's not because it's better but because it works with the existing things being used by that individual company.

Now as for your idea that splitters like this are a better option well for very short distances like a few feet they may be suitable but if it's any longer some distance like say 10 feet or more Thin Clients are the better option and as for reducing the number of End Users a Thin Client isn't all that expensive and you still would have the most expensive part the Monitor with this system.

I've used both and the business that I support prefer Thin Clients as they offer a better ROI it's really that simple.

I however I think that this is funny as when I worked Main Frames the business at the end where breaking their necks to get away from the Dumb Terminals and these same companies are the ones embracing Thin Clients like they are something new and exciting. They are just a glorified Dumb Terminal really. :)

Col

by narf u

Thanks Col,
You make some good points. Businesses do tend to lock themselves into an OS with specialized software.

It is pretty crazy to see the prices of computers (especially laptops) drop so low. MS has to conform to the new order of things or get pushed out by other cheaper options like Linux. But I'm sure they are looking at Apple and wondering why it isn't necessarily working with them. The answer I come up with is Apple is more diversified than M$.
This is really what I was looking for, someone whose had first hand experience with either Thin clients or the split up computer, and you have experience in Thin Clients, so I'm happy.

So you say the ROI on Thin Clients is good. How many years of use are we talking about where you get a return on your investment?

by oh smeg

Generally in the range of 3 to 5 years for Desktops/Thin Clients. 5 to 8 for High End Servers and as little as 12 months for NB's.

The main problem with Sharing a system is the inability to spread out any real distance. With Thin Clients there is virtually no limit tot he distance that they can be from the server the CAT Cable is cheap, easily sourced and fitted.

Attempting to spread out a Shared Desktop Environment is far more expensive doesn't have the range of premade cabling required and is just generally messier to do. After all 1 CAT 5/6 Cable can feed any number of Thin Clients through Daisy Chained Switches at the end of the Run where as you would have to run at the very least 3 multi Cored Cables for a shared Environment. The Video uses 15 Wires the Mouse & Keyboard use 5 Wires and have a limited length that remains usable. The longest you can run a CAT Cable is 175 Meters I personally wouldn't want to extend a Video Lead over 5 meters and even then I would require a Shielded Cable which just adds to the expense. :)

Col

This discussion is closed to new replies.