Discussion Locked

One or multiple domain

0 helpful
7 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Hi,
I presently have 6 windows NT domain that has a one way trust to another domain. Each domain is located in a diferent location using wan link of ISDN to T1. I would like know if it's better to keep one domain per location, meaning that I'll still have multiple domain to manage, or just to restructure all the domain to have only one domain and then add some site/link location.

7 replies

by michael2

The directory database of a domain is limited to 40Meg in size (although larger ones have been documented it is not recommended). If you can get away with one domain and no trusts your life will be a lot easier. Initially the work involved to go to a single domain with BDC's at remote sites may be overwhelming. Once it is set up properly you will save work in the long run. Beware: politics may prevent you from taking away domains.

by tony.colgrove

It depends on your administration model. Do you have admin in all locations, or do you admin them all from a central location. If the later, then maybe a single domain model works better. If you have administrators locally in all the locations and they keep different security policies, you would then need multiple domains.
I will read into your statement that you have a master domain model with 6 resource domains. The general rule is to consolidate and create sites and OU's for the resource locations.
Unfortunately an AD design cannot be determined from a single paragraph. There are other questions that can play into the design.
Used bandwidth of the sites, client software, existing services, application programs, and so forth.
Good Luck and Plan, Plan, Plan

by mckaytech

Personally, I prefer the single domain model but it really should parallel your administrative structure. However, the cool thing in upgrading to W2K is that you can still partition the domain to allow local administrators to do their thing while maintaining some degree of centralized control.

paul

This discussion is closed to new replies.