Discussion Locked

Open Systems Standards Here To Stay?

0 helpful
4 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

In previous posts to this site, I have been harping about the fact that the IT industry has been unwilling or unable to move to open systems standards across the board and has been insisting on locking customers into proprietary solutions in order to maximize profit. In other words – the vendors have been in control! This has been the pattern for the last 30 years in IT.

Having read a few articles lately about where the major vendors appear to be moving, I am slowly becoming convincedthat there is hope on the horizon after all.

If I can believe what I am reading, the HP/Compaq merger, for example, may be the result of their respective managements believing that customers are now taking control of the industry (finally!) and are demanding end-to-end standards-based enterprise applications, application interconnectivity, and integrated shared data. If the appropriate international standards existed, all of these goals would be achievable at much less cost and effort than today. Application development and integration are engineering processes and demand uniform standards, and it would appear that we may finally be moving in that direction.

Power to the customers!

4 replies

by generalist

I'd say that the migration to open source is a matter of cost, quality and perception.

Open source can provide a cost advantage, a fact that attracts financial decision makers. But these same decision makers are somewhat conservative and will often take a sure thing over the untried.

That is where the ever improving quality and quantity of open source comes into play. Early risk takers have shown that open source works and have added to the 'library' of open source solutions. Big name businesses have noticed this and have started jumping in, also adding to the 'library'.

At this point, the perception of open source changes and the more conservative financial types start approving of open source solutions.

A similar thing happened to the PC back in 1981. That is when IBM 'blessed' personal computers as legitimate business solutions by providing it with three special 'features' that Apple and the TRS-80 didn't have.

Those features were the letters 'I', 'B' and 'M', with appropriate formatting.

by prefbid ii

I think standards based computing has always been the direction. The problem is that standards take a long time to develop and companies need to make a living while the standards are being set.

The shortest route to a standard is to jump to open source. However, that is not the only route. There is less money in the open source route for the developers and therefore they are more likely to balk at the idea of using it just for the sake of quick standards building.

I believe that the quest for standards helps drive both the open source movement and the market. If a company becomes too proprietary in their software, the market reacts by finding an alternative. For a short period of time (if you think of a decade as a short period of time), a company may get away with choking the market, but that will not hold forever as the market finds ways to free itself of the stranglehold of a monopoly. The pursuit of standards is part of that release.

For proof, look at VAX andUnisys. They are proprietary systems that at one time appeared to be heading for market domination. VAX is all but dead -- mostly because they thought they could become the standard rather than working with the standards. MS will go the same way. They are acting as if the market can not shift gears. The reality is, the market can and will shift gears, it will just take a while for the market to move.

by arjo renthro

Just to clarify my original post and question - I exclude open or free source code for software products (e.g. Linux) from "open systems standards". By open systems standards I mean all national or international IT standards excluding free source code.

by generalist

I'll assume that groups like W3C and ANSI fall into the category of open systems standards. I know there are a number of groups that work on these standards and there are a number of software companies that brag that they meet the same standards.
At the same time, a lot of the open source organizations could also be considered to be defacto open standards. Consider OpenPGP and OpenSSL as a start. While they may not be as formalized as ISO or ANSI, they do provide some guidance for those areas.

This discussion is closed to new replies.