Question Locked

OSX v. XP brain teaser: toshiba laptop hard drive

0 helpful
5 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

So I got an 0x00000024 error (NTFS_FILE_SYSTEM) on my Toshiba Satellite that's running XP, and neither chkdsk, chkdsk /r, fixboot, nor fixmbr could do anything to help me get back.

Through a miraculous happenstance I discovered that all my data was intact. The happenstance was that a SATA-USB converter enabled me to open the drive on an apple computer running OSX. I had a hunch that deleting a few files would solve the problem as only 1.3 gigs remained on the 80 gig drive. But, as you know, NTFS drives are read-only for OSX. So I bought a SATA-USB enclosure and hooked up my drive to a number of PCs and all of them gave me the same business about the volume being corrupted or unreadable. With the same enclosure, however, I can open it with OSX.

Can anybody explain away this enigma? And if you think it's not the fulness of the drive, any idea why it happened in the first place, or other ideas of possible solutions? (Recovery install only allows me the option of formatting the drive all over again!)

Thanks for your input and good luck with the puzzle!

Josh

5 replies

by the scummy one

and I do not have a reason for it. Linux seems to be able to work with NTFS in some situations when MS systems (even Vista) fail to find anything. However, the opposite is true as well, Vista fixed a problem that neither Linux nor XP would. In Vista, all of the data just appeared.
Like I said, I do not have the specifics as to why, however it is completely about how the file system/partition is read.

So, to be able to gather data from drives going out, use Linux or Vista as a first line (or OSX apparently), if those do not work, pull out the toolkit and expect a long night

by .martin.

connect the HDD to the Mac, and try recovering as much data from the HDD (save it to the mac) (My Documents can be located at [drive letter]:\Documents and Settings\[user name]\My Documents) then reinstall windows

by oh smeg

A Live Linux to attempt to recover you Data. A Live Linux is burnt to a CD and runs off the CD so you need to set the Hardware to Boot off the Optical Drive first. If you don't have one you can download one from here

http://www.livecdlist.com/

Or go to your local Newsagent and buy a Linux Mag with a Live Linux as a Cover Disc.

With this drive in the enclosure try accessing your Data and copying it to another HDD or similar Storage Media that will hold it all.

As for what's wrong here I would say that the Drive is too full if you only have 1.3 GIG of Free Space as a Slave Drive there is no room to run the Page File for starters let alone any of the other things that Windows relies on to work. Check it for Infections as a Slave drive if you have any software capable of doing this.

Col

by joshuas.ear

Thanks, great help!

Is there any way to delete files from the recovery console?

THanks

This discussion is closed to new replies.