Discussion Locked

Performance Appraisal Metrics

0 helpful
6 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Warm, humid Texas greetings to y'all!

I'm an engineer/systems analyst for a small network integrator down here in Houston. Our clients call us when they have IT problems, and we fix them at an hourly rate. Simple so far...

The company owner/president wants me to agree to a job description that bases my performance upon my billable hours. I'm balking at the notion because I can't control them directly... that's the job of a salesman, right? If I don't have a task from a client, I can't generate billable hours!! (At least, that is my thinking)

I think my performance metrics should be customer satisfaction, implementation of proper fixes, cost-savings, etc... things I can control. Am I wrong in thinking this?

Does anyone have any documentation regarding my situation? (ie, performance appraisals for billable assets?)

Your thoughts/comments greatly appreciated!!

Joe - Houston, TX

6 replies

by tennessee tuxedo

Sounds like your company owner is more concerned with his bottom line ($$$) than the quality of work you put out and doesn't want to give you a good review (thus bonus) unless you make him big money. Not good. Plus, your customers are going to start looking elsewhere if you're billing them 8 hours for something that you're obviously qualified to do in 4. It might look good at first, but take it from someone who's experienced it..I dropped a company for just that.

by txnetman

Thanks for all the kind words... I'm glad my thinking was justified, at least in other's eyes!

Now... does anyone know where I could find some industry studies or credible sources to back up these assertions? I've searched the 'Net but have been unable to find anything really 'tangible' that relates to this topic that I can present to my boss to support this claim.

Ideas?

by prefbid ii

I'm surprised that it is so hard to find on the web. It may be that you are not using the right search words. I have heard the saying for so long that you evaluate to standards and not effort that I have just assumed that it was a generally understood truth.

Maybe that's the problem. It is a generally understood truth. So much so that no one bothers to mention it anymore. I'd suggest hunting some more. I'm sure its out there.

by prefbid ii

One of the things that should never (make that NEVER) be done is to base performance on "effort." Effort is always easy to cheat on, especially in a service industry. No one can ever say that you are putting in "less than your best" if "best" is not defined.

Would your current boss appreciate changing your salary scale to "time spent at work" instead of "time working"? Is is acceptable to just show up and do no work? How does he know the difference? He only has a few tools available andall the good ones will be based on some standard. Measurable goals that can become standards are:
1. Results of customer satisfaction surveys.
2. Number of repeat customers for new problems. (You should get no credit for having to fix the same problem twice).
3. Number of customer referals. (If your customer tells someone else about you, then obviously they like you).
4. Decrease in or lack of service complaints.

If you do well on these, you will not have a problem with billable hours.

by james r linn

One of the companies I worked for had a management bonus which was based on meeting improvement goals in two areas: Customer Satisfaction and Employee Satisfaction.

There are many studies which show the correlation between the two - happy employees do a good job at making customers happy, in short. Its also alot more expensive to find a new customer than to keep an existing one satisfied.

In short, from my observations, it worked well.

James

by jcyt

What we do with our Performance Appraisals is identify and weigh Performance Objectives. These objectives are derived from job descriptions and align with the stated goals. Each Performance Objective lists the performance expections for each identified category. For instance, Process Management is the category, with subcategories of Problem Management, Change Management and Internal Processes. Each subcategory defines expectations. Expections are clear, concise, specific, measurable and attainable.
If you perform any type of interaction with customers, then Customer Service should definitley be a category for you. I'd also include Interpersonal/Professional Goals (leadership, professionlism, and teamwork); Planning & Organization (time management); and of course, continuous improvement i.e. maintaining/updating skills, improving problem resolution ratio, etc...
I'm sure to implement this type of change to your Performance Appraisals, you'll have to make the case with HR too!

This discussion is closed to new replies.