Question Locked

Problem booting into XP or Vista on the same computer.

0 helpful
18 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

After successfully installed XP on a computer after Vista. I tried both EasyBCD 1.7.2.exe and bootsect.exe and managed to enable Vista. I then found I couldn't get back to XP. Subsequently I fixed the XP by using an XP CD and the recovery console to do a fixboot and fixmbr to enable XP. When I repeated the process again to enable Vista, again booting into XP became a problem. The situation just repeated itself again and again. When I did a fixmbr on the recovery console, the system responded and said "This computer appears to have a non-standard or invalid master boot record." and so on. I wonder if it was because the Vista which was on drive C: but not on the partition 0. It was on partition 1, the second partition.

When I did "bootsect -nt60 all" after booting into XP, it said about drive D: where XP was installed "Updated NTFS filesystem bootcode. The update may be unreliable since the volume could not be locked during the update: Access is denied." It was successful on drive C where Vista was installed. I got the same messages when I did the same bootsect command after booting into Vista.

After booting into Vista I did " bcdedit -create {ntldr} -d "Microsoft Windows XP Pro" and it responded "An error occurred while attempting the specified create operation. The specified entry already exists. I opened the msconfig -> boot and Computer Properties found only Vista entry, no XP entry was found.

Now I can't boot back into XP unless I go to the recovery console and do the same thing again.

18 replies

by peconet tietokoneet

Why have them on the SAME drive?
Just put them on separate drives, that way you do not balls up the MBR by going back and forth between the two. You can then switch the drives in the bios, or have an application for the switch.

by healer

I have only one hard disk on the computer. I would like to be able to select which operating system I want to boot into. That's why I chose multi-boot.

How do we switch drive in the bios? Do you mean I have to go to BIOS and activate the drive I want to use every time I want select the alternative operating system? What application is available for the switch?

by balge

hi
BIOS is to select boot device eg HDD or CD or floppy,
the boot loader is where you select which OS to boot from, every time you boot you select Vista or XP. or set a nice quick select time and default to your preferred OS (so XP then..)
cheers

by healer

I don't understand how one could choose which hard drive to boot from on the BIOS though. When I get to the BIOS of a computer that has more than one hard drive I can see only one hard drive and it doesn't let me choose an alternative drive. I am aware that one can select which partition to be active on the computer properties though.

by balge

hi
in BIOS generally under 'advanced BIOS features' then 'select first/second/third boot device' remember HD0 is first disk, HD1 is second etc.
cheers!

by computechdan

a number of modern bios allow u to press a key to select boot device during post

by healer

Thanks for your information! I haven't come across one. That would make multi-boot program redundant, wouldn't that?

by healer

Thank you for your advice. I have the problem fixed already.

by healer

Thank you!
I have fixed the problem with EasyBCD version 2 beta.

by tmalo627

When installing multiple Windows operating systems, start with the oldest first and work towards the newer. In the case of XP and Vista, separate partitions are also required.

by healer

I checked the Advanced BIOS features of a computer with two hard disks installed I couldn't see anything like what you suggested. I then checked another computer which I bought lately. It has only one hard disk but I couldn't see anything which could provide such feature.

All the boot sequence referred to CD ROM, hard disk, floppy and so on. Nothing let me choose which hard disk to boot from.

by balge

hi
well you got me, I just checked 3 PCs, all allow alternative disk booting via that mechanism - however as they all use Phoenix/AwardBIOS setup it may be a manufacturer setting - but it definitely allows you to select which of up to four HDD's to boot (HD0 to HD3) and in which order, the bootloader then boots to a preboot environment where you can select which OS to boot up to
that my understanding, anyway!
cheers!

by healer

The computer I have two hard disks installed has AwardBIOS and the newer one has American Megatrends. I wonder if I have missed anything. I did go under Advanced tab as well. What do the options say on your computers?

by balge

hi
its just a dropdown for each position in boot order, selects floppy/CD/HD0/HD1/HD2/USB etc etc
YMMV
...just a thought it may not show SATA drives in there,
cheeers

by healer

Thanks for your patience and tolerance. I am checking both computers again. On the one with AwardBIOS, there is no drop-down menu at all. On the Main page it shows the drives of Primary Master, Primary Slave, Secondary Master and Secondary Slave. I have hard disk installed on both primaries. When I move the cursor down to the square brackets where the drive is and press Enter, I go to another page with more information and setting. Nowhere can I see I can set the drive where the intended active partition is. On the Advanced page, there is no setting about drives. On the Boot page.. Alas I FOUND it. I believe I saw it before but I just didn't notice it. I thank you again.

I can't tell if the other computer which is much newer and has a SATA drive installed would provide the same thing. I shall wait and see. I thank you again for your kindness and perseverance. Have a good day!

This discussion is closed to new replies.