Question Locked

Problem with USB External Hard Drive

0 helpful
13 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Hey there,
I just bought a Western Digital My Passport Essentials 250GB External Hard drive 2 days ago. I connected it to a Windows XP Desktop computer, but it just kept plugging and unplugging. Eventually, it stopped unplugging, and I copied all files on my laptop hard drive to it.

When i tried to connect it to my laptop (that's been formatted just yesterday and has a Windows Vista Home Premium OS), it keeps plugging and unplugging and in the 2 seconds it's plugged, Windows Vista cannot locate the device driver and can't find any update to it on the internet. The device is seen as an unidentified device. There is not even any signatures identified on the drive.

I tried to connect it to the windows XP computer afterwards, but it plugs and unplugs and i can't see the drive in My Computer and the "Hardware installation problem. The hardware device will not work properly" error is pops up. The Drive just appears in the "Other Devices" in Device Manager with no drivers whatsoever related to it.

i tried to look for the device driver on the Western Digital website, but nothing'd there.

What can I do?? I really need that information. It's four years worth of work! So i just can't format. That is, even if i have a chance to do so, i still can't.

I know it all sounds too boring and that i'm talking too much, but plz plz plz help me!!!!
I don't know what to do!!!

P.S. it's almost midnight in my country.

13 replies

by ---tk---

If it has a power adapter plug it in and cram your ear against the external drive. If you hear clicking odds are that the drive is shot, but it you just hear a humming sound your drive should be fine... take the external case apart, find out if the Hard drive is IDE or SATA. then surf the net for a new case that will work with your HDD... Ide has alot of PINS vs SATA drive the connection is about an inch... for ide....
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16817145133

by rob miners

If it is the WD Elements Portable you will probably need to use a Powerd Hub as you might not be providing enough power to run it.

If it is the WD Elements Desktop check the power outlets that you are connecting to. Try another outlet or powerboard.

There have been a few reviews on this product and apparently there have been a few problems with them. WD will replace them for the same model.

If you are feeling adventurous follow tkrl26's advice or you may be able to connect it internally to your desktop PC as a Slave if it is IDE or by using a Sata conection. Get your Data off it and put it back together and have it replaced under Warranty.

Keep us informed as to your progress if you require further assistance.

If you think that any of the posts that have been made by all TR Members, have solved or contributed to solving the problem, please Mark them as Helpful so that others may benefit from the outcome. ;) :D

by ---tk---

I over read the part about purchasing it two days ago... This is probably better advice for you.

by rob miners

I would be trying to get the Data back. Warranty or not. I just hope that OM is right for the users sake and the user hasn't deleted the Data from the Notebook. :D

by older mycroft

That you COPIED all the files from your laptop to this external drive?

Have you checked that these files are not still in existence on your laptop?

If they're not, - why did you delete them? ;)

by ---tk---

I would think that the user kept their stuff on the notebook.... hopefully... that's a seriously ruff way to go down... complete irony

by 45geek

Sorry to hear about your situation...the biggest problem with these external usb hard drives is that the hard drive controller is part of the box. From what you have described the controller is failing, or again your usb port is not supplying enough power. I agree the best way to try and retrieve your data would be to mount it into another box or tower after you have removed the hard drive from its original box. Retrieve you data then put it back together and get it replaced.

I Also agree with the other post if you didn't delete your old files you should still have them or if you sent them to the trash you might still be able to retrieve them.

I always tell everyone if they are going to use an external usb hard drive to use it for a couple of months to see if you are going to have any problems before storing anything important on them. But is also points you back to the old adage if you have important data that you cannot afford to loose back it up frequently...if it is critical data back it up twice...and put one copy someplace else that is not effected by the same surroundings.....good luck...hope that you recover your data.

by teema195

okay..it's obvious that I'm new to that kind of stuff.

I never imagined that there mught be a problem with the external hard drive...so I put all my files on it. And I formatted the device.... yes i did.

I guess u thing that's stupid...but i didn't know better.

now, i don't really get the part of me removing the external cover from the disk??!!
How am I supposed to do that?
It's not like it's a SATA device I had put in a hard disk enclosure.

u might think me dumb, but.... i don't really get it.... it's not like there are instructions on how to take off the cover in the manual.

what does anyone think?

Help!

PS I really appreciate it that u ppl actually took the tme to view my post. Thanks

by oh smeg

But that is exactly what it is only difference is that the maker fitted this to an External Enclosure not you.

HDD are only 1 of 2 types here either IDE or SATA. The difference is the USB Interface between the USB Lead and the HDD.

Now for the facts here External HDD's are 1 of two types doesn't mater who fitted what to the Enclosure it is either IDE or SATA. These devices need power to run. If it is getting it's power from the USB Port you need to use both of the USB Plugs at the computer and plug them into Different USB Ports not into something like a PCMCIA USB Card which doesn't have enough power to drive an external HDD.

With the 5 V DC HDD's that is a 2.5 inch Drive if it is over 80 GIG Capacity you defiantly need to use both of the USB Plugs on the USB Y Lead as they require more current that any one USB port can deliver.

When you look at the USB Lead where it plugs into the computer the one furtherest from the Enclosure is just a Power Plug it doesn't support Data Transfer it is supposed to be plugged in to provide additional Power nothing else.

If the computer can not provide enough power for this HDD you need to use either a Powered USB Hub like the one shown here

http://www.mittoni.com.au/usb-20-powered-7port-hub-p-1920.html

Or a Power Adapter for the enclosure. As this is a Propriety Enclosure you need to look at the Optional Accessories for this device but the maker should provide either a Docking Station that has a Mains Adapter or a straight Mains Adapter that plugs into the Enclosure.

Now as you have performed a format on this HDD you need some form of Data Recovery Software. Ranging from Seagate's File Recovery for Windows available here

http://services.seagate.com/promotion1.aspx

To the On Track Easy Recovery File Repair Option available here

http://www.ontrackdatarecovery.com/file-recovery-software/

here is a short list of other available Data Recovery Software.

http://tinyurl.com/273ay5

http://tinyurl.com/rmvrv

http://tinyurl.com/yvrsl

http://tinyurl.com/yyk8cm

http://tinyurl.com/382vm

http://tinyurl.com/ynwnel

http://tinyurl.com/nc4kx

http://tinyurl.com/2wox7l

http://tinyurl.com/374d8b

http://tinyurl.com/djw6u

http://tinyurl.com/f73se

http://tinyurl.com/8bd3f

http://tinyurl.com/afu2j

While the last 2 are from the same company they are very different products. Win Hex should only be considered for use by someone who knows Hex Inside Out while Davory is a great cheap General Purpose Application.

Personally I prefer the On Track Option but it's anything but cheap. However because I use this type of software a lot it's paid for itself many times over by now, for a cheaper option Spin Rite from Gibson Research or Stella have both very good reputations by other TR members.

Col

by teema195

thank you for your advice.

I have a Question though...
The external HD worked on 2 of my friends laptop computers without the need for any other cableand I successfully made a copy of the data on it.

One of my friends and I own Toshiba laptops... our friend owns an HP.

Why did it work on their laptops and not on mine?
If it has to do with USB hubs then it shouldn't have worked on the other Toshiba laptop, beacuse they have the same hubs and the same configuration, right?

Right now, I'm working on making my Vista OS identify the HD, beacuse it cannot locate the driver. What can I do?

Thank you for your help again.

by oh smeg

Just because it worked on another computer of the same make doesn't mean that it should work on every computer of that make. Particularly if the other Toshiba is older or a Business Class Product.

With new NB's that have longer run times on Battery they get this by cutting down the amount of current that the device uses. This includes any USB Devices. Normally with most USB Devices there isn't a problem but with HDD's this is a different story as it is Mechanical as apposed to Electronic. They require much more power or current at the USB port to actually run. So if it is still working you need to increase the amount of Current that the device is getting. If you leave it in the Undercurrent condition the Motor in the HDD will burn out and there will be other damage done as well.

It is the same as running any electric motor with Low Voltage the motor gets damaged. Here the USB Port is supplying 5 V DC but lower than the Standard 500 Milliamps of the USB Standard. Even then 500 Milliamps isn't enough to run most HDD's but when they are considerably bigger than the max 80 GIG Limit you need to connect the HDD Enclosure to 2 Separate USB Ports to get sufficient power to run the HDD. If the NB in question is providing considerably less than the 500 Milliamps even 2 USB ports may not be sufficient to drive a HDD.

Col

by rob miners

the driver by directing it to one of these locations.

C:\windows\system32\driverstore\filerepository\usbstor.inf_bb2778a0

C:\Windows\winsxs\x86_usbstor.inf_31bf3856ad364e35_6.0.6000.16478_none_465c5f209ade1e53

Keep us informed as to your progress if you require further assistance.

If you think that any of the posts that have been made by all TR Members, have solved or contributed to solving the problem, please Mark them as Helpful so that others may benefit from the outcome. ;) :D

This discussion is closed to new replies.