Discussion Locked

Programmer To Project Manager

0 helpful
22 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

2 questions:

1) Anyone have an opinion as if it's a "good career move" to switch from being a programmer to a project manager? It sure seems like programming is A LOT more competitive these days than it used to be. On top of this, it seems that managers get paid more than programmers for doing a much less technical job. On the downside, it feels like there is less security because it's not as much of a "definable skill".

2) Anyone have any resume advice for attempting this switch? Should I list the computer programs I worked on or the project management skills I feel I gained while doing them?

22 replies

by dc_guy

A certain percentage of the workforce will ultimately move up into management, the ones with the right qualifications: various people skills such as written and oral communication, diplomacy, the ability to spot a con, knowing how to train and motivate staff; budgeting and scheduling; multi-tasking of headache proportions; and most of all to see the "big picture."

At some point in your life people will be suspicious of you if you HAVEN'T made the switch, so it's definitely a good career move, IF you have what it takes.

You talk about "attempting this switch" as if you're initiating the process. Normally the way it works is that you've done good work without requiring much direct oversight, given a few interesting presentations, written some good documents, demonstrated your teamwork and big-picture perspective at staff meetings, and been given some choice assignments involving leadership as a stepping stone.

If you're project manager material your boss should have already brought up the subject. This is a by-invitation sort of thing, you don't just sign up for it. Getting your first project manager posting by applying to a company that never heard of you with a resume that lists no project management experience is pretty unlikely.

Work on finding and seizing an opportunity where you are now, among people who already know you and know what you're capable of.

If the people you work for simply won't consider you, then either you haven't impressed them with your abilities, or they just don't have any openings.

It boils down to two choices for you. Stay where you are and attempt to hone the skills you lack (if that's the problem -- get some training on your own time and your own dime), or wait for one of the great project managers to leave so you can fill in behind them.

Or, choice #2, you can jump ship. But don't expect to be hired in as a project manager. You'll be doing the same thing you're doing now, but hopefully in an environment where you'll be more recognized, expand your skill set, and have more opportunities to move up once you've proven yourself. Variety in your background will almost always enrich your skills and attitudes.

The job security in either position has its pros and cons. I wouldn't let that be your deal breaker. Managers tend to get paid more but they suffer a lot more stress. That is the deal breaker for a lot of 55-year-old techies.

by aaron

Management definately has its share of headaches and one needs to be certain that the ride is worth the fare.

Project management can be frought with greater stress because these days one often ends up managing virtual teams where the people working on the project do not report to the project manager. This is a very difficult and dangerous place to be.

Also, while this is usually by invitation, letting your current manager know that this is an area of interest and career growth for you may help you get some opportunities that otherwise might go to others.

by virtualgardener

One thing though, If you think Programming is competitive. Wait till you get into management. Secondly, it may be a mistake to assume PMs get paid more than technical types. I personally am in State government, and I can tell you that it is very, very common to find technical positions being paid far more than their supervisors. Kind of depends where you plan to work. Good luck!!

by youraveragemanager

DC_Guy is on target. I would add that pursuing the PMP certification is a process of learning and that PM?s you work with could be good resources. This breaks the ice because we all value knowledge in IT. Pursuing PMP will create its own opportunities because you are involved and asking questions. Also consider that portable knowledge has a higher market value. If you join a local chapter then your professional network expands as well. Many PM?s do not have the hands on skills in programming that you possess. Can suppose that would make you more valuable. You need not be in a manager position in order to manage projects, but management skills are necessary. People skills will turn out to be more important.

Right now the IT Market is placing hands on programming skills before all others. Even within programming the language is important. So, if your language is legacy system oriented, start the transition there too. I know some people that could not make the transition mainly because they were generally disinterested in the field all together, simply burnt out.

Wishing you an easy decision along with good fortune.

by ashtank

thanx DC_GUY for valuable comments. In reference to that, allow me to ask you something for advice. I have been into IT for the last 7.5 years with career spanning in companies with 2500+ manpower to as low as 25. As usual, i started as an engineer and gradually graduated to lead small teams though i kept my fire alive for programming and coding and still doing it. Of late, there have been offerings from the gud organisations for the positions of either "Project manager" or Business Analyst" which only invlove around 20-30% of being into core IT and more of strategy making and managing teams, etc. now, do u feel that this is something a team leader profile like me shud follow? Also, i m anyway going thro the stress of project mgmt, though not that stressful as in large organisations, do u think its the right time of my career to switch to project mgmt?

by skipperusn

What do you find passion and challenge in - Technical or Management. IT is slowly realizing that some people enjoy technical and will do that their whole career - others enjoy the switch to management..

So figure out your passion and challenge - then go for it - we can't tell you which way to go, you must figure that out yourself... As for the resume - it will all depend on the answer - I want the Technical - or - I want to be Management...

Best of luck - to you and your choices..

by eurogistic

I think that this move depends on two things. Firstly, age, and secondly, the level of programming and/or applications.

From a personal view point, it gets harder to keep up with programming the older you get. This deterioration in concentration is obviously gradual, but noticeable after the age of 50.

Again from a personal view point, I found that very large programs, say 20,000 lines of code plus were difficult to maintain or change. I know the arguments for many small modules, but the original programmers of applications like BPCS were clearly not convinced.

Project Management on the other hand must be a natural transition from programming, and I, for one would question the ability of a PM who had no previous coding experience.

It is, however, a different landscape. You can immerse yourself in coding a complex programme to the complete exclusion of everything and everybody around you - as a PM you cannot be so unsociable, if you are to succeed.

It is also probably a one way career move only. After a break of six months or more as a programmer, it is unlikely that a prospective client or new employer would consider the gap to be beneficial, so a return to programming from project management could be difficult.

To make this career move, should, ideally, require some re-training, possibly for suitable qualifications, but if you are a contractor, you have to weigh up the course costs and time away from earning a living against a fairly competitive job scene.

I also think that the mindset has to change as well. It is reasonably easy to convince other knowledgeable people of your programming ability, but project management is a much more grey area, and difficult to move into without experience.

If you are currently employed and your employer sees this as career enhancement for you, and will offer the necessary training, I would say, grasp it with both hands - other than that you may well struggle for some time unless you drop lucky.

by bridget_huck

I would advise any programmer thinking that they can switch to project management for more money to be very cautious. Project management requires some entirely different skills than programming. Yes, you do have to be detailed oriented just as a programmer must be but you have to also be able to truly look at the big picture. You also need to be able to do the following:
1) Deal with difficult people (both outside and inside your project team)
2) Track and manage multiple budgets (I have by far found this one of the most annoying parts of project management.)
3) Facilitate good design sessions with end users as well as with data modelers or programmers. I really think it takes practice to get good at this, but it also takes patience (and a good mentor is always helpful.)
4) Really monitor the quality of testing, regardless of whether you have a dedicated test team or not. In the end if the testing is not good and the product is buggy, it will be the responsibility of the project manager.
5) Delegate those tasks that can be handled by members of the team. This one always sounds easier than it is, because once again so much comes back to the project manager so sometimes we just want to do things ourselves to make sure they are done right but we also know that we can easily get in deep and that puts all of our tasks behind.

I have been a programmer for over 10 years and started managing projects about 3 years ago but I continue to program and even learn new programming languages so that I do not get myself stuck in a corner where I don't want to really be. I really think my boss sees a lot of value in my being able to wear both hats. This allows me to truly be able to spot the B.S. when it is coming from our programmers.

Bottom line, would be that you should be cautious before switching completely because I have seen some great programmers fall flat on their faces as project managers. What always annoys me is the fact that their management seems to forget what great programmers they were and only focus on the project management failures so it is hard to rebuild their careers without leaving the company.

I am trying to avoid turning completely to the dark side by keeping my grounding in programming.

by pmpsicle

I'm sure you've seen the ads ... asking for 10 years of project management and describing a role which consists of dealing with people (usually called relationship management) ... then ending up with a list of skills appropriate to a programmer.

Those jobs seem to be open for a long time for a reason ... or reappear in about six months.

I've noticed the same problem occurring throughout this discussion ... a confusion in skills required for the PM role.

Bluntly, the skills needed have far more to do with a BA's skill set than they will EVER have with a programmer's skill set. (Not to mention the additional PM skill-set).

Sorry, folks ... in over 15 years of official PM and almost 10 years in un-official PM, I have NEVER used my programming skills (except in a very general way). Sorry.

On the other hand, I have run JADs, I have used documentation skills (not pgmr doc, technical writer type documents), and I certainly have used my negotiation skills.

The problem, of course, is that management doesn't really understand that a resource manager has far more need of programming skills than a project manager. Which is part of the reason for the PMO's appearance.

The point is that you're going to get hired based on skills B & C. But skills A & C are what you need to succeed. If you don't already have skill set A (PM, & B/A), you're setting yourself up for failure. And the HR & IS/IT managers are hiring for failure (which is frustrating believe me).

Glen Ford, PMP
Can Da Software
IS Project Management
Business Process Improvement

by hmsdes

I'm glad to see your response to this as I totally agree. Project management is an entirely different skill set from a programmers. The job functions and responsibilities are completely separate. Just because you have programming experience in no ways guarantees success as a PM.
In order to succeed moving from programming to PM, you'll need to ensure that you've been given adequate training in the managing of projects. You're going to look at running a project differently than you would as a programmer.
A valid point was made in that once jumping ship, it's harder to go back into programming unless those specific skill sets are kept up to date.
Good luck.

by mollenhourb9

You will never lose your programming ability, so that is your hedge against unemployment (hard skill will get you a new job faster, albeit at a much lower wage). Certifications like PMI can help show that you are a "real" project manager, not just some guy who was put on the hook for a project.

Highlight your project management skills, even if you aren't yet PMI certified. You'll get more "hits" on your resume. The more technical skills you list, the more you will be thought of as a "techie", not a professional.

The higher you get in the pecking order, the less security you have. That is just how the world works. That does not mean however, they you still don't have a secure job.

Good luck, I hope your new career choice works out well for you.

by michaelpo

The answer is where do you want to go with your career? After a certain point, adding one more project to your programming resume has little value. Showing you can be a successful project manager in addition to a programmer is valuable. As to your resume, again it is about where you want to go. If you want to continue as a Project manager, be more general in your accomplishments as a programmer and more specific on your accomplishments as a project manager.

by prefbid ii

Is PM a good career move? Only if that is the career that you want.

In some ways it is like choosing a major in college. There are a lot of unknowns and the temptation is to "go where the money is". However college is just long enough that most people can only really survive by majoring in something that they find interesting or enjoyable. Well, if you thought 4 years was a tough survival trek, then a 30 year career in PM is going to be much worse.

Jumping off into PM is not a complete one-way street at least for the first 5 years of being "only a PM". I recommend getting a dual-hat position for a year or so to see if you like the work. If you don't like the work, don't go -- it will kill you. If you find it easy, but boring -- you may have just what it takes to go on to management. If you find it exciting, you might be the kind of person that is destined for a career as a consultant or a professional PM. If you find it difficult, annoying, or excessively aggrevating, then you'll probably want to jump back to programming.

Before you go, make sure you have the credentials to land on your feet if things don't go well. I recommend that you have at least a BS. Programmers usually do, but you absolutely must have one to survive more than one company as a PM. Also, make sure you have a rock solid programming resume. You do not want to be in the position of only having a single language or single program background.

For your resume, you need to emphasize any leadership time that you have had - even if it was just "led a 3-man team in completing version 3.1.2 of some anncillary program". And do not lighten up on the programming skills. You want to emphasize that you are a top notch programmer.

by palisadesp

The demand for Technical or Sr. Technical professionals has increased over the past 10 years. There is a necessity to have a bridge or liaison present on projects requiring both the so called soft skills with a technical venue. One can carve a future by attaining skills in the technical arena also the project/program management areas. Keep in mind market demand and trends relative to the skills and tools. Longevity is in learning, applied experience and some luck. So, diversify and cross over (in either direction) based on your enjoyment and fun.

by best_john_j

First you do not mention what you you have been doing as a programmer. But I would say there are other "Technical" jobs above the programmer level. Architects, strategists, process experts can still allow you to flex your tech muscle in design/definition of applications and put all the pieces together. In smaller companies these may be rolled into one person, but larger ones will likely have individuals tackling these functions.

If you are still set on PM, working towards a certification would help. PMI (project management institue) offers an organization to support PM's as well as two certification paths. Depending on the scope of your "Programmer Role" - if you were a guy at a small company who does some/all the requirements, estimating, for your projects in addition to the coding - you may have enough "PM Experience" to get started with one of the certification paths..

by mpicknell

I see it as a natural career move for some people. After programming embedded devices for industrial automation for 10+ years I have moved to project management. I have found it to be a new set of challenges, first is the dialog with the customers and end users and then translating that into technical design for the engineers I work with. With project management you switch from salesman (gasp!) to designer to mediator to cheerleader. The position requires you to use those "soft skills" everyday. I don't get to do much actual coding anymore, which I miss, but the occational project for friends fills that in. In a resume I would focus on how you pulled different people/departments together to stay on schedule/budget or to solve a problem to meet everyones needs.

by ronwah

I have over twenty years engineering experience in telecommunications. After being laid off two years ago and finding the telecom job market still in a crater, I decided certification as a Project manager with PMI would be a good career move because:
- Project Management skills and methods are useful regardless of the job.
- Show potential employers I am innovative and self starting.

Now that I have a Project Manager job, I find that "project Management" is very much a defined skill: has the project been completed on time and in budget? If not, why not?

My engineering experience gives me the ability to better plan technical projects and liase with project team members.

In summary, Project Management skills fit with pretty much any job to enhance your contribution and value.

by tatarelli

Hard to know at what level you are, but if you are working as a programmer with no team/project lead responsibilities then team/project leading would be the next step in your move into more solid project management work. This would let you know whether you would enjoy the work and not let go of the technical side completely.
Another option would be to specialise in business/systems analysis as this gives experience on larger projects in writing lots of documentation, leading teams and dealing with a lot of people issues. Project management can be the next step from there also.

There are a lot less PM positions available and so the security is less, but its probably proportional to the numbers of PMs out there.

Good luck with your next role!

by vkl

Project Management can be seen as a natural step up for programmers who are wanting to take on more responsibility or wanting a shift from technology to management.

What is really important to note here is that some good programmers turn out to be lousy managers. Programmers to Project Managers is a step that needs careful consideration. Ask yourself these questions: Do you have an eye for the big picture or are you more than comfortable with your module or isolated piece of functionality? Are you able to get things done rather than see it done yourself? Are you in a position to monitor progress, avoid risks and be able to steer clear of any threats to the project? Above all, are you able to manage people and not just put up, but get work out of eccentric nerdy coders?

In my experience, it is a lot easier to manage technology than people. Project Managers getting paid more than programmers is something we cannot generalise -- it varies from company to company. Technical guys are valued a lot without doubt. Project Managers have a lot more responsibility and headache. So if things go wrong, the PM's neck is on the chopping block.

So my advice would be to talk to some project managers and check if the work that they do is something you would be happy doing. As someone mentioned, getting back to programming from project management may not be easy. Apart from making a beginning in project management (perhaps under a mentor), getting a PMI certification could help line up more opportunities.

Good luck!

by valeednaeem

As project managers are actual person who is controlling the whole performance of the team. This post is also responsible for handling each and every person working under. So, the person needs to know all the functions and capabilities of the personal. The programmer can not shift directly from the programmers post to Project Manager, the person should be capable of working with programmers, designers and analists, which are the core personalities of the software development team. The software engineering and other capablities or the concepts are pre-requisites for this post.

by herbert_mendoza

i think go with the programming is a better choice
because opportunity is wider than of being a
project manager..you're correct..managers earn a lot than of programmers but remember for every project there's only one project mgr that assume
all responsibility that's why they receive higher pay.. but if you want to at least reach i may say such prestigous position then why not..but be ready for so many complicated situation and dilemma you may encounter along the way..no harm
of trying if you are into a more challenging
job..

2.) yes! you may include your projects you worked on but put much emphasis on the benefits that
a certain company/entity has availed using your
programs..its more impressive that the reader
of your resume may appreciate what have you done..

by krishkur

1) There is no definite/concrete answer to this question if 'becoming a Project Manager is a good career move?'. Basically it's totally up to the individual involved to arrive at a decision by taking look at his priorities, capabilities and interests. A Project Manager role calls for altogether a differnt set of skills(especially soft skills) and less of technical skills. The most important question an individual finding himself at the crossroads has to address is "Will I be happy doing a job that doesn't leverage much of my technical capabilities or expertise?". Off late many organizations have woken up to the fact that "Not many Project Managers are/need to be Technically sound and Not many technical experts make good Project Managers". It's for this reason they offer a parallel individual contributor roles for technically oriented individuls which offer the pay/glamour of the Project management profession.

This discussion is closed to new replies.