A good way to start would be by answering the question, what does success mean to you?
I dont know what kind of projects you execute, but consider this:
Project Success Could mean -
1. A 30% net profit
2. Percentage Rework...by phase ofthe project
3. Percentage of reuse.
4. Frameworks/reusable modules created
5. Delivered on time
6. Delivered within budget
7. Follow-on business was generated.
8. Mean time between failures (MTBF)
9. Mean time to fix defects (MTTF)
10.Defectleakage...where a defect occured during the life cycle, and where it was fixed.
11.Defect Density (across various phases of your project)
12. Cost variance, schedule variance etc.
Or, all of the above and many more...
Some parameters are available for measurement right from the moment your project starts, many others will manifest a few months after your project is completed.
There are tools that will let you measure these parameters at different points in time with respect to your project life cycle, so you have the benefit of current as well as historical data.
Also, your metrics are not very useful without benchmarks. First start with industry-accepted benchmarks for various parameters. After generating metrics a few times, you will know which make sense for your organization and what the benchmark should be, from your own experience.
Hope this helps.