Pros and Cons of Windows
This is page 4 of the discussion. Read the opening post
Windows Forum
This is page 4 of the discussion. Read the opening post
by morphen
While windows is used in the professional world it shouldn't be. I agree its a games platform 1st and foremost.
What's the difference between windows and a virus?
You can get rid of a virus.
by fatfinger
Mr Thompson,
My opinion about this matter is that it will be most cost-effective to select the Windows XP operating system. If you or the company you work for has chosen to use a Microsoft solution, then XP is definitely the way to go. Unfortunately, no matter how good any of the previous versions of Windows may have been, Microsoft just won't actively improve the older products and support is almost non-existent. XP is not without problems, but some of the show stopper-type problems have been reduced in comparison to other operating systems. I have personally used and supported every version of Windows you made mention of as well as various flavors of UNIX and Linux. My experience with Windows XP, XP SP1, and XP SP2 have resulted in some of the conclusions listed here:
1. Stability of the operating system is mostly reliant on how much testing is performed with the installed software package(s) or image to ensure that all components are simultaneously functional. Test everything first before spending company funds or making recommendations that can come back to bite you in the rear. If you know there is a problem with a particular piece of software, regardless of whether or not the software in question or the operating system's poor handling of it is the problem, reject it and move on. If you have any control over what software is used, reject any software that demonstrates problems in operation. Any operating system can be halted in a matter of seconds by someone who either doesn't know enough about what they're doing to understand the consequences of their choices or someone who is proficient enough with a given operating system to clearly understand its limitations. Poorly designed or implemented software just makes this much more likely to happen and unfortunately, the possibilities for the introduction of severe problems, if not show stoppers, are endless. It's funny, but you actually have to know a lot about the users and what they are likely to do to be a good administrator.
2. The greater the technical expertise of your administrators, the easier any software upgrade or migration will be. I believe one of the members who made a post here stated that Windows actually requires a greater level of technical expertise than a comparable Linux- or Unix-based workstation OS. I am in agreement with this. Your administrators will actually have to have fairly in-depth knowledge of the Windows API, how the OS uses memory, and how Windows works as a whole to understand why it has the problems that it does.
3. The level of security of the system can be inversely proportional to the usability of the system. It doesn't have to be. It seems like everything today is, at least in part, a web-application of some flavor. With regards to Windows, most of these web applications are designed to be used by Internet Explorer. Most of these web applications make use of many of the nice features of IE that enable it to provide the rich experience that it is capable of providing to the user. The catch is that many of these features also make the operating system as a whole much less secure and prone to problems that would not otherwise afflict Windows. Again, don't run software that hasn't been thoroughly tested on your network. You can't prevent or even expect that users will act in a rational manner when suspicious or potentially invasive, yet enticing pop-ups or other crap appear on their screens. The best security doesn't even give the user or the system a chance to behave in a manner that is prejudicial to its good working order. A good anti-virus/spy ware catcher/firewall setup is an absolute necessity with any Windows-based solution. There is also software available that will allow you to sandbox IE. Mail handling systems must be protected, too. Patch all of your systems in accordance with DoD CERT guidelines. Read and understand NSA's guidelines for securing and monitoring Windows XP systems.
The management, monitoring, and configurability of XP and Office 2003 are where the latest and greatest offerings from Microsoft really shine. The suite of security features available to XP is much richer than in any previous version of Windows. Just so you know, Windows has never garnered very high security ratings when subjected to tests that the US government uses to define the security of a given operating system with regard to their system for classification of "secure" operating systems. Your administrators will need to know how to enforce security policy compliance with any machine that will be part of your company's networks. There is quite a bit of documentation on GPO settings and the effects of their implementation. Again, test every piece of software you intend to use in the desired environment. If security of the network, integrity of the transactions, and reliability of the operating system are paramount, then reject the introduction of any software into this environment that will compromise it. Security violations will still occur. Be prepared for this. Here's a little secret that you'll never here from a UNIX or Linux Network Admin, they occur all the time on these systems, too. When security really gets tested on any system that has any useful functionality for the user, you will find attendant security flaws. It is somewhat less prevalent with UNIX and Linux because UNIX was designed by DARPA for the DoD and Linux is a derivative o UNIX. DoD requirements for their computing environment are not the same as they are for most corporations or home users. Windows wasn't designed for or by the US government and neither was Linux. XP, however, is a step in the right direction and has won some favor because of this. The most glaring security violations are almost always poor coding, but some of the more subtle stuff is due to basic design flaws with Windows (for the sake of backwards compatibility or not wasting time rewriting "useable" code) and the fact that there is so much code associated with Windows that even a machine couldn't find or predict every possible problem with it. Unlike Open BSD, Windows doesn't come secure by default. You must make it so.
4. The average knowledge level that a user must have to perform basic user-level tasks is significantly less with Windows XP. Once the users are familiar with the interface, they generally enjoy the enhanced features and simplified- or graphically enhanced-interfaces. Some of the users will be more familiar with older versions of Windows and want to use the NT/2000-style GUI. This is fine. XP has this feature built into it. Expect that the majority of your help desk calls will be problems related to the functionality of IE and exploiting all the nice little features of IE, XP, and Office 2003. I tend to think that the richness of the feature set is such that few users will ever fully exploit all of them or even most of them. It is nice to know that they are available, should the users be inclined to use them. VBA/VBS provides them with an easy to learn (relative to C or JAVA) feature set that will enable them to make their lives easier by automating repetitive tasks. Yes, Linux has a compiler included with it and, yes if the users had the inclination to learn how to use it, it is possible to do a lot more with Linux, but very few users have the inclination to learn how to use it. In my mind, the greatest selling point of XP is that users who do not really have the inclination to learn will find that it is the easiest to use of the entire series of Windows and still has all of the features that any business may need to conduct its operations. Previous versions of Windows were fine for their time, but were of limited usability in more technical environments.
5. There is a practically limitless supply of third party software for virtually any line of business application you can think of. I don't know what your company does, but the companies I have supported use just about everything you can shake a stick at. For business critical applications, remember that open source applications, by their very nature, are subjected to more testing. I did not say better testing, more rigorous testing, or more realistic testing. I try to break everything that I test. I generally succeed. A few good questions to ask here are as follows (this is not an all-inclusive list and the questions aren't in any particular order of importance):
If this application fails, can my business continue to operate?
If this application fails, what does my business consider to be an acceptable failure?
If this application fails, is the result of the failure financially acceptable to my business?
If this application fails, do my people have the expertise to resolve the failure if outside support is not forthcoming?
If this application fails, can a full recovery from the failure be affected or will I lose irreplaceable information?
If this application fails, will the integrity or security of the data in the transactions be compromised? If compromise is unavoidable, what is an acceptable compromise?
You get the idea.
Basically, how important is this application's availability and operational integrity to my business?
These are just a few basic questions that anyone who is looking into purchasing software for a company should ask themselves. Unfortunately, Microsoft didn't ask themselves some very basic questions like this. If you had an infinite supply of money and expenditure of funds on IT assets was of no consequence, then it wouldn't matter. No company I am aware of, including Microsoft, has limitless resources at its disposal. Even the government doesn't have unlimited funs to expend on computers. This is one of the big cons of Microsoft software. If we are looking at your choice of operating systems as part of an overall solution to a problem, then this is where we start to have problems with every version of Windows, but to a somewhat lesser extent with XP. I personally find IIS an unacceptable risk. Just like those who look at past performance as an indicator of future success, I would say that Microsoft just doesn't provide the entire solution. This isn't so much a con of the operating system as it is the entire solution, but it is bothersome, nonetheless. Web services are a core part of any business and IIS has a security track record that is far from stellar. If there is any weak link in the chain, with exception of the insecure default installation, this is it. Web service availability and the integrity of transactions conducted by your web server is a lynchpin for most businesses. Apache, very simply, is a superior product to IIS. In a perfect world, if we pay good money to have a group of bright young lads or at least well-paid young lads produce something useful for us, we would expect to be presented with a product that is dependable and comparable to other current offerings. Such is not the case here. This is just an example. SQL Server is another product that is not without its problems.
6. Windows XP requires a lot of memory in comparison to any other operating system. Does this mean that it is a lumbering pig? Depends on who you talk to and what kind of hardware you have to work with. The system I'm writing this on has over a Gigabyte of memory and it doesn't matter if I run Linux or Windows on it. I have both optimized to take advantage of the resources that it has available for its use. If you can't afford to buy at least 512 MB of RAM for each machine, perhaps you should consider Windows 2000 or an entirely different OS altogether.
7. Windows XP is not cheap. I had sticker shock when I first saw XP come out. Every Microsoft product is mildly to egregiously overpriced with respect to what you get. Just the operating system is enough to make you jump from the pinch you'll feel in your hind parts. The latest Office system is even more grotesquely priced than the previous versions. Does the software have nice features (from a user's point of view)? Absolutely. Are they worth it? I don't know. How much money are you willing to part with?
8. Decent support from Microsoft and the other third-party software vendors that you'll use for the software load that you've chosen to accept cost much more than it is actually worth except for the one instance where you couldn't figure out the problem and didn't feel like reimaging the machine or rebooting didn't help. On that note, a reboot means that there was some problem with memory that really couldn't be rectified by the user or administrator, so the solution was to ignore the problem. I think Microsoft did this far too much instead of actually fixing the problem. This all finally came to a head when their customer base demanded that this be addressed. This happens a lot to users and in places where this is acceptable, it really isn't as much of a problem as the Linux crowd makes it out to be. It takes my system roughly 20 seconds to boot Windows XP. If I do it five times I've wasted a whole minute. I could have typed a sentence or two in that time. Obnoxious? Yeah, after a while it is.
9. Purchasing of cheap, off-brand hardware is inadvisable, if more economically feasible. Let's face it; plug and play was designed to enable mainstream hardware to function passably. This means that you shouldn't expect Brand X devices and XP to play nice with each other. One of the quickest and easiest ways to bring XP to a grinding halt is by installing incompatible driver software for Brand X hardware. I find it funny how often administrators just run through a procedure knowing nothing about it and never bothering to read the instructions or any of the documentation from Microsoft or the vendor concerning the setup/install of the software.
10. If irreversible damage occurs to the operating system, it takes a long time to just reinstall or reimage and patch the OS. I have only had to reinstall software on a few occasions because I can repair the operating system in nearly every case. This is time consuming, though. It is like one of the people in this discussion said. You get to figure out what the problem is without all of the tools necessary to figure it out. It's as real a challenge as any, which is perhaps why some Linux users hate Microsoft so much. When it comes to their products, you'll have untold fun figuring out the more obscure peculiarities of their products (or not in the worst cases). XP has more code than any of the previous operating systems, so more chances to figure things out. You also have to read through a serious amount of documentation from DoD CERT, Microsoft, and the independent software vendors just to know what patches and so forth to install, never mind what the patch actually does or the effect of the patch on the OS and installed software packages. There are ways around this, but sometimes it is not desirable to install certain patches for whatever reason. You won't know what requires whatever else until you start patching. On that note, I hate patches and patching.
11. XP is, like every preceding OS from Microsoft, immature technology. It just happens to be more mature than the previous versions and is what Microsoft currently supports. Think of an operating system like a high-performance military aircraft. When the US government tests an aircraft, they spend hundreds of millions of dollars, tens of thousands of flight hours, and millions of man hours perfecting and testing the limits of every component, whether it moves or not. Think of the code inside an operating system as a bunch of moving parts. Together, they form a machine. Though every component is relatively simple, the machine is quite complex. Most aircraft have hundreds or even thousands of moving parts. Most of the time, through the care of the engineers who look after them, everything works just fine. Sometimes, those components fail. Most of the time, the failure is relatively minor and a recovery can be effected by replacing a component (analogous to reinstall) or repairing a semi-functional component (analogous to rebooting). Sometimes, the failure is catastrophic and the machine is lost. It could be due to pilot error (like user error), or it could be because of a flaw in the design of one of the machine's components (like poorly written code or code that will cause failure under a given set of conditions). Either way, the machine is lost. All you can do is build another one. At this point, the most valuable thing we have to reconstruct the accident and salvage what we can is the data that remains. The reason Microsoft wants to put a data recorder in Longhorn is to find out what's going on underneath the hood of their own machine because they don't know. Let me qualify that remark. The engineers who designed it know but the support tech you spoke to on the phone is probably clueless. If XP were to be considered for production on the same grounds that a military aircraft is, it would still be in the EMD phase. NT and all previous versions of Windows would still be in the experimental phase even though they have been around longer. This is because the company stopped working to mature this technology. The only OS that has a testing program comparable to a military aircraft is, you guessed it, a military operating system (UNIX) running on very specialized hardware. Nothing nearly so complete or methodical has ever been attempted with any version of Windows, but XP has had a greater amount of testing behind it than any previous version of Windows. All of this says nothing of the fact that they test an aircraft for five or ten years and then put it into production. All of these OS versions were tested for what? Six months maybe? An aircraft only has a few thousand or even tens of thousands of moving parts. An operating system has millions. They regularly crash military aircraft several times a year and one in every ten or so is a mechanical failure of some sort, even if pilot error aggravates the problem. This aircraft has ten times the amount of testing behind it, many, many more man hours of design work, a set of proven or familiar general operating principles, a highly trained and selectively picked operator, and a network of support personnel who spend tens or even hundreds of hours maintaining it for every hour that it is in operation. Insofar as operating systems are concerned, few have any comparable advantages. Imagine how this might affect any operating system, no matter how well designed. Now think of XP like a high-performance machine. It is highly capable, but requires the attention of the operator and the administrator.
11. XP, despite being user friendly, is far from idiot proof. Let's go back to our aircraft analogy. An inexperienced user can easily find more ways to mess things up in a F/A-22 than he or she could in a Cessna. The sheer number of things to mess up, never mind their complexity, ensures this. Anything capable of going faster and higher is going to have more problems that present themselves more unexpectedly and with more dire consequences. If the Cessna runs out of gas, you can generally glide to a relatively safe landing given a few thousand feet of altitude. In a F/A-22, you'll fall out of the sky like a brick, even though you have an enormous wing surface, by way of comparison. The F/A-22 has a bunch of features inside and can pack a considerable payload. All these features mean that it weighs more and without its pair of incredibly powerful engines to power it, all that weight just means that gravity will tug a little harder.
12. Proprietary means that the source is not available. This means that even if you knew how to resolve a problem with some code that someone at Microsoft wrote, you couldn't because you don't have the source. I find this bothersome, but trivial in some cases. Really, how many administrators took the time to read the source code to determine what, precisely, caused a problem? Relative to the number of admins out there, relatively few, I would bet. If Microsoft truly stood behind the integrity of their product, they would publish the source. Your average user has never even seen a compiler before. Likely that they will compile there own OS and thumb their noses at Microsoft when it's time to pay for what they use? Not likely. Any legitimate company will show that they hold the licenses necessary for the software that they use. Illegitimate businesses are, by definition, in violation of the law. None of the other companies out there would touch anything from Microsoft with a ten foot pole. The only reason that Microsoft didn't get off scott-free in the anti-trust battles with the government was Bill's abhorrent attitude towards the judge and the people who use his products. Public scrutiny means improved code... period. It won't matter if Microsoft won't rewrite something that's poorly written. Someone else will.
XP is a wonderful product for those who want something powerful and customizable who are in a business that does not consider security or stability to be of paramount importance. Don't use it as a server of any sort and don't use it to run business applications that absolutely must be functional 24/7, regardless of what happens. It'll never happen, so don't get yourself into trouble by attempting to make XP do something it wasn't designed to do. It has problems and so does every previous version of Windows. The problems are just well-known, fresh in everyone's minds because they're currently using and supporting it, and there is a lot of documentation out there about it. Not with the actual product, mind you, just out there on the Web and in book stores. Not everyone will agree with any or all of what I've said here, but I've been an admin on some pretty big networks that run everything from Solaris to XP. I know from experience that every OS, regardless of its configuration, will have a set of attendant problems. The real trick is to find something that you can support, afford, and grow with. Windows is greatest at growth. I say this because their products are capable of all but the most specialized tasks. Linux users like Linux because they can do anything they want with it (and they can bash Microsoft products). This means that you'll also have to know everything about what you are trying to do. Ok for me, not ok for someone who just wants it done. Mac users like their OS because they don't have to know anything about it for it to do whatever specialized task that it is best at (multimedia). Windows users like it because if you know a little about it you can do a lot and if you know a lot about it you can do pretty much anything that a business would need you, as a user, to do. Office is something every Windows user is familiar with and the latest versions of Windows and Office make administration and security tasks much easier than previous versions did. Hopefully, future versions of Windows will only be released when they are mature. This is Microsoft's prerogative, though. XP should be supported for at least several more years and you will have enough time to learn or train a support staff that can cater to the needs of your users. Don't sweat the reboots and know that your job is safe, regardless of which version you decide to use. I've learned to love Microsoft. Without them, I'd still spend hours fiddling with UNIX servers instead of desktops. Windows has more problems and is more fun to troubleshoot. XP is the best of them all, so far.
by aberzo
by jaqui
send any m$ formatted documents back with the statement:
sorry any file type that can be infected with viruses is not accepted, plain text only if you want me to do anything with the content, pdf allowed if only want me to read it.
and if the email is html formatted send it back with corrputed format, plain text email only.
make sure thier boss gets a call telling him that since his staff are sending virus laden files in virus infectable emails you are sending them back requesting specific formatting, make them change to correct practices.
by apotheon
by hal 9000
Star Office if you are willing to pay for an application. It is the Big Brother of Open Office and has more features, generally when a new version of Star Office is released the old version gets released as Open Office.
It would give you a bit more functionality and a lot more processing power available than even the resources used to run MS Office not to mention Windows.
Col ]:)
by cardinal
1. Buy a USB 3-button mouse (mine's a Philips with scroll wheel,
too)
2. Plug it into a USB port on the PowerBook.
3. It just works, straight out of the box.
I enjoy some of these forums, and get some good info from them. However, it gets irritating to have to sift through bunches of personal attacks, paranoid fantasies, and general horse manure to get to the good stuff. Can we keep these things on a professional level, and try to stay on subject, or at least close?
That said, here's my two cents worth on the actual subject:
Windows has its problems, but it works reasonably well. I've learned that educating users to a Linux-using level is a losing proposition. If you want your users to use computers, it has to be easy; Windows does this. And, as one other participant said, it's here, it's ubiquitous, and you'd better learn to deal with it.
by rzimmerman
by davemori
The Windows-only folks do not know what they are missing.
I have everything at home. Windows XP, LinUX, Mac OS X Tiger - even a Solaris server. The smart professional embraces everything so he/she does not become a one-trick pony. Every OS has its place and value to the home user, school user or enterprise user.
Crossplatform skills have kept me and my crossplatform savvy friends all employed at better than market salary, even during the times
from 2000-2002 when everyone was downsizing and the job search market was flooded with very skilled Windows-only folks.
History also shows that becoming a high tech Luddite who only wants to go so far with technology and rejects anything new or different is not a sound strategy.
Market share of a company or technology is not a wise rule for all decisionmaking. The technology market is very fickle, and very dynamic. Today's information professional is like a person trying to run up a very fast moving, down escalator. Stand still and get swept away.
Wordstar, MultiMate, VisiCalc, Banyan Systems, Novell, IMS, CICS and countless other products, vendors and technologies all had their day with large market shares. Yesterday's "Safe" market share choice is not necessarily a smart one today or tomorrow.
by hal 9000
What do you do them?
Col ]:)
by noorman
TRUE remark;
An 'ordinary' user can't make head or tails of it without a massive book and lots of time at hand !
by noorman
they are coming ...
[Mac mice with more than 1 button]
by apotheon
by yanli64
by catadmin
FYI. Bill Gates didn't steal DOS from IBM. He bought it from some poor guy (for $10,000) who didn't know how much it was going to be worth later on, then teamed up with IBM, selling them a "use license" for DOS.
That doesn't make what he did with Apple's windowlet feature or Xerox's mouse any better, but in this particular instance, it wasn't theft.
by rzimmerman
by kevaburg
Nice one about the 15 year old comment! Why do some of these people bothering speaking if they have nothing to say?
I have found that Windows servers from W2k up have been remarkly stable. Maybe its just me but the one thing that I have found helps more than anything is keeping the patches up to date. I know its simple and boring but it really is the truth. Blowing out the servers once in a while with air help prevent the "hotspots" that can can servers to crash.
But apart from that I have some personal ideas that mean I prefer the "hybrid" type of network.
I think the one big thing that has help in my design of networks is the fact I don't use Microsoft products for everything. Cisco routers, Sonicwall firewalls and VPN solutions and other products mean that if you want to hack into the network the first thing you have to do is find out what equipment is stopping you. If everything is Microsoft then the solution isn't too far away.
The second reason a predominantly Microsoft environment is inherently insecure is because an unpatched flaw in the operating system becomes apparent everywhere that the operating system is in use. And that happens without it being propagated throughout a network: It just happens.
If you are slack in updating the patches and anti-virus solutions then you are asking for trouble.
I think alot of the trouble and negative feedback comes from people that rely on one technology too much and (please don't take offence those that this applies to!) MCSE's are among the majority of those responsible. I know because I was like that once!!!
What needs to happen is for admins to take the blinkers off and realise that multiple (sensible) technologies in a single environment are a better option than relying on as few as possible.
by dfneal
Pros, It easy to use and has some easy trouble shooting features
Cons, Needs a better recovery system, Such as for loading only what parts of the operating system that is fragmented or damaged. Need some type of refresh of the operating system with out losing setting and data. This would keep the operating system fresh at all times.
by synkoptik
One con about Windows is that I can't "Run As..." everything. Hitting Ctrl-L everytime to switch users is time consuming. In Linux, one can become a SU (Super User [Administrator]) with one easy command, there is no need to switch or log off and on with different users.
I like Windows, Linux and other OS's. My point is not which one is "better" then the other.
by mark.paris
Speaking from the perspective of programming continuously in 18 computer languages on more than a dozen operating systems....Windows should be sold at Radio Shack, next to the $9 R/C cars.
The nearest thing to a stable Windows platform I have ever seen is Windows NT, prior to the 4.0 release. It was originally developed by a small team of very sharp people at Microsoft, for the DoD, and used in places like Cheyenne Mountain. Release 3.51 was the first "public" release, and for servers. When MicBill decided to put the miserable W95 GUI onto it and abridged the previously-stable HAL and kernel in the race to add "plug-n-play", instability began. It has never gotten better since then.
Uninformed individuals sometimes try to use Windows with automation machinery (or Space Shuttle missions - remember Colorado School of Mine's famous "Please reboot the PC" request to the astronauts in 1999?), which is my primary profession. I have seen 100% failure of over 50 systems thus derived, solely because Windows cannot run 24/7, not in any form (W95-XP). I have replaced a few critical Windows-based (NT/2000) server OSes with $10 Linux, only to receive stellar performance and 24/7 reliability OUT OF THE SAME PC WHERE WINDOWS USED TO BE.
If that doesn't clear things up concisely, nothing will....
by apotheon
by gateway2
Here we are Microsoft Bashing and guess what?...3 out of 4 people are MS users...The root of evil is not Windows, it's us...Pure lazyness! How many of you say that Windows is unstable, while you make it unstable by using each 3rd party "utility" that you can afford online?...Registry Scanners, System Scanners, Pop-Up Blockers, Firewalls...and the list goes on. What happened to old fashion technical savvy using the build-in facilities of the OS and an UNDERSTANDING of the registry?
Stop moaning and buy a different OS if you like, I did...came back to Windows tail between legs...The grass is not greener on the other side :)
peace out
by jmgarvin
Why should we NOT install third party apps? Windows doesn't have a decent firewall, pop-up blocking is a joke, and "system scanners" are needed to check for everything from malware to run away processess.
The registry is the problem, along with tons of other memory issues. Windows isn't built right...The grass IS greener in the *nix world.
by beninpb
Sounds pretty secure to me!!!!
Go unix and gnu based software!!!
by apotheon
If you're running Windows without some third-party protections in place, you're betraying a substantial lack of understanding of the necessities of maintaining a stable and secure computing environment. Are you really trying to tell us to use Windows without firewalls, registry scanners, spyware blockers, virus scanners, and the like? If so, I think we can discard everything you have to say about computers from here on out.
Yes, I've hacked Windows registries by hand quite extensively in the past, and still do a little of that from time to time for clients' machines. That doesn't stop me from using registry and spyware scanners to make my job easier.
I jumped the fence to Linux and the grass is fine, here. I'm not going back to that withered, brown, dead crap on the Microsoft side for my own use any time soon.
by apotheon
by apotheon
"[i]these windows guys really don't understand the power and flexibility or choice options of linux do they?[/i]"
No kidding. With nothing more complex than "aptitude install [packagename]" I have about 15,000 unique software packages in the Debian archives at my fingertips, and most take a few seconds to install. There's none of this Windows crap with days of waiting for an application install CD to arrive by mail, hundreds of dollars to buy it, and an hour or two installing it, and aside from that I've never even seen 15,000 applications available for Windows. Where do all these people get the impression that there's a lot more software available for Windows? Nothing could be further from the truth.
by hal 9000
When they pick up one of those nice color broacher's that have the Sales in them they only see Windose software for sale so obviously there just can not be any applications available for Linux or Walmart would be selling them right?
Col ]:)
by apotheon
by apotheon
That's hilarious. You've got my respect for the patience required.
Of course, it would probably be cheaper to buy a replacement CPU than to pay four hours of my rate.
by jmgarvin
I've see a few pins bent, hell I've even seen a whole corner bent, but EVERY SINGLE PIN!!??
Where they trying to cram it into the CDROM? ;-)
by apotheon
I suspect the imbecile in question was trying to stick a CPU into a ZIF socket without opening it by swinging that stupid little arm up. Other, similar explanations involving complete and utter stupidity and a ZIF socket are also possible.
Ultimately, though, it's possible that this tower of intellect (accidentally, one would hope) stepped on it when it had been set aside, or something like that.
by nmeyer
I use a PC every day. I make money for my employer on a PC (or at least I'm very productive). My job does not require that I use a PC or a Mac technically - except the corp standardized on a specific range of PC's - so it's all about internal support. Having been in in that gig - I get the point.
I also know that Macs are about as easy to support in large network environs - and are equally cost effective. The HW typically has a longer lifespan so you get good ROI on your cap ex. But PC's are the rule and PC savvy techs are a dime a dozen (and getting cheaper - sadly). You want something that works and is easy to administer? Mac is a good choice. You want something that a lot of I/S people know and won't talk smack on? Get PCs - but plan on higher support costs.
Let's talk $$$, time and performance.
I made a lot more money on PC's running MS when I was a consultant. Yes - I am considering the fact that Macs have a smaller installed base. On a per machine basis the Macs cost less to my customers to support than MS boxes running either AMD or Intel. Good stand alone - didn't scale as well. Security and admin was so-so.
The BSD boxes that we set up just never died. Basic unix admin required. Good stand alone - never went beyond that.
The Novell boxes were solid - but sometimes freaked out on upgrades. Security and admin was a snap. The network scaled well.
MS Servers could be tweaked a lot so that they were stable but you had to know what you were doing and had to invest some serious time in prepping the box and cleaning up after install - still flaked out more than BSD, Novell or Mac. Patches and upgrades were a nightmare. Security was a logistical nightmare - AD didn't help much.
by apotheon
Why does everyone do it? I could sit here and bash linux, windows, mac os and anything else, but that is just pointless and pedantic.
The point is every operating system has it uses. You just need to choose what best suits your needs.
As for comparisons of Windows versions, consider doing a matrix comparison. Find the most common features of the latest OS and then work backwards to see if those features and functions are in previous versions.
You could start with Windows XP Sp2 version and then list the common features of it such as:
Firewall
Security Centre
Native Wireless Networking Support
and so on. Then with these you can check of what appear in previous versions of Windows. This should provide a good comparrison of all versions of Windows to date.
Anyone who claims to hate Microsoft Windows, Linux, Mac OS or any other operating system is not a true techie or network guru. You don't ever bash the OS, in fact if the OS crashes then it's your fault not the OS; Why didn't you make sure that it was using the right drivers, or the hardware is compatible or blah this and blah that, and so the list goes. Any OS crashes for a reason, not because it just feels like it. Compatability is there for a very good reason, why support something that is old when you need to keep moving forwards. Example, all leaded petrol car owners here in Australia can no longer purchase leaded petrol, they are forced now to use unleaded and an additive. Why? Because those cars are so old and they are few and far between now because unleaded cars are cheap enough to buy second hand as your first car. Get my point there?
by apotheon
There are problems with your "matrix comparison" method of comparing Windows versions: it doesn't differentiate between good features and misfeatures.
The problem with anti-bashing statements like yours is that "bashing" is a subjective term. What one person might consider a clear-headed assessment of the comparative advantages and disadvantages of two different things, another might consider bashing one or the other of the compared subjects.
by hal 9000
Here, Any OS crashes for a reason.
Well that is sort of right but I've seen numerous Windows installations crash for no reason at all and the only solution is a Hard Boot to get things up and running again.
But the ones that where really scary where the MS Patches when they where installed trashed the entire computer and required a complete reload from scratch. Like a brand new P4 with XP on it and when SP 1 was applied on the reboot you got the POST screen and the No Operating System Found insert Disk to continue. Every MS Compatability test showed they every piece of hardware worked perfectly with XP but when SP 1 was applied the MBR's disappeared on every HDD in the computer. After reloading the thing several times and numerous phone calls to the MS Support line resulted in "Well I don't know what's going on let me know when you work out a solution!" Eventually I replaced the DVD player and everything worked perfectly but prior to that I had reduced the unit to 1 HDD, removed every plug in card except the Video Card and disconnected the CD Burner which just happened to be the same brand as the DVD player.
Now is that a Hardware problem or a case of badly written software?
While I don't "Hate" any product there are some out there that are very hard to actually like a lot and Windows in any form falls into this category. It means that I have to work far harder to make it work than I should be doing as even a clean install is only the beginning and then you have to spend time locking the installation down, add some form of memory management if the system is going to be constantly running as Windows doesn't manage memory all that well and has a habit of not releasing memory when you stop an application. The number of times that I've seen Out of Memory Error Messages on a Windows Box is outrageous particularly when you consider that there is nothing but Windows and an AV product running. Sure if you reboot the machine it works properly again until you have opened several programs used them for what you need and then shut them down and attempted to open a different application to do some different work.
Forced reboots are not normal and they should not be treated that way either the fact that they are so common with any Windows version only shows just how badly that the code behind it was written. So why you do not have to Hate Windows you at the same time can speak your mind and demand that MS produce something better just getting their memory manager to work would be a vast improvement, instead they are wasting time attempting to get WINFS working again they started out with this file system on the NT product and couldn't get it to work then and are still trying. Just how long should we tolerate their need to produce things that make their products even more hostage like and at the same time less usable?
Or the number of times that I've had phone calls about a computer not shutting down it works properly until they come to shut the thing down and then after they have clicked the Shut Down Icon it freezes. I have one customer who rings me wanting a replacement unit every time something goes wrong and there as yet has never been a actual hardware problem every problem is a Windows Problem and he's now asking why I agreed to supply him with Windows XP Pro just because he wanted it I should have insisted that he have something different that works!
And that is only on the Desktop I'll not bother to mention the Server side of things.
Col ]:)
by hal 9000
I already knew that there where a lot of MS Zombie computers out there broadcasting Spam and other junk but to actually realize that MS has succeeded in doing the same thing to the people who work with their product. I hadn't realized that things had got so bad, but then I remembered the last MS Partners Meeting that I attended and overheard a couple of people talk about just how great it was to produce something in Front Page and then edit it with VB. The penny should have dropped then but I just put it down to inexperience.
Silly me. :(
Col ]:)
by hal 9000
The individual concerned actually sat in it pin side up so it left a lasting impression on them. :)
I had a guy once who I had made an official complaint about because he kept me waiting for well over 4 hours for a replacement case fan that I had picked up 14 hours previously claiming that it wasn't the same one that I had picked up the previous day or at least one of the ones that I had picked up the previous day after all the thing was only $16.00 AU.
So to get even with me when I had to return a faulty M'Board he insisted that it was the RAM which was faulty so I pulled the 2 sticks out of my top inside pocket and handed them to him in their nice little plastic container, then without batting an eyelid he then insisted that it was the CPU so I went to the car got the box with the CPU in it that I had stapled the plastic back on and handed it to him he then took it all away and eventually returned with a new M'Board and said that they didn't need to open anything else. When I got back to the site I opened the CPU Box and found that the packing plastic had been opened and all of one side of the pins had been bent over so I couldn't return it for Warranty Replacement so I used a 20 Thou feeler gage to straighten all the pins out and fir it to the ZIF Socket other wise I would have been up for the cost of a new CPU which is what the guy wanted.
You just have to love these people who seem to think that you are attempting to rob the company blind when you return faulty stock within a few days of receiving it as the customer must have broken it. I actually stood there and watched him almost reduce one guy to tears buy insisting that he was totally incompetent, then he hit me for the Bloody case fan and insisted that I had not fitted it correctly and all that was wrong with it was that the LED's where not working I'm still unsure how you can fit a case fan wrong particularly when all I had done was plug it in to test it before fitting it to the plastic retaining clips that came with the case, but if I had of known just how long I was going to waste there I would have forgotten about the bloody thing. ;)
Col ]:)
I have two clients that I work for, one uses Windows ME, the other 98. WinME, although it's the newer OS of the two I believe that 98 is the better. Yes, ME has better features, like System restore and tighter securety but it dont handle drivers well. I have more device conflitcs with ME that 98. Also, 98 handles dialup better than WinME. Now I suggest 98 if my clients dont want to go with XP.
Good Luck with your paper.
George
I have made the jump altough I was satisfy with the previous version of XP I have no complain as my Motherboard is made by ASUS and with a AMD Sempron 3000+. This is quite stable altough I am sure it is not as stable a linux, I have to use XP because my High End SB Audigy II Platinium can't work all the feature with Linux and I am sure it is because of fear of providing the source code. Once Linux overcome thing like that with high end hardware that cost half of a e-machine well I will do the jump but mind you I am not ready to pay for third party drivers as I saw for alternative.
I would love to go linux all the way but if you have out of the mainstream hardware meaning high end sound card etc you can't go linux without losing some fonctionality unless the card was built with linux drivers at first.
The drivers are the main reason why home users don't do the jump, give all the drivers and you get the customers coming.
by hal 9000
The first involves which was the better version of Windows and which can be used now.
From the very beginning Windows 3.11 was probably one of their best products as it was easy to network relatively easy to use had a small foot print and low overheads. The cons with 3.11 was it was hard to setup a Dial up Internet connection and not really all that user friendly.
Windows 95 was an improvement in User Friendliness but it came at the expense of stability and was never really cured.
Windows 98 was an improvement and the finial version of 98SE was fairly stable easy to use worked with most hardware available even now and was accepted by most users as being able to work with easily. The cons with 98SE is that there will be no support for this very soon so it effectively becomes a dead horse and any security issues will not be addressed as they come to light.
ME was a complete disaster and I've replaced ME with 98SE on most of the computers that came loaded with ME. But saying that there are some people who just love their ME OS's and will not accept anything else.
2000 was fairly good an improvement on 98 SE in the stability stakes and more USB compatible that 98 Se was, the down side however is it has a much bigger foot print higher overheads and requires far more powerful hardware to run. But it produced the BSOD less often and didn't require the 3 finger MS Salute as often.
XP Pro as I've never touched a computer with Home on it is a fairly usable OS has a lot of nice eye candy for the end user, mostly it is easy to install new software on has a better file system than the previous versions of Windows except 2000 and the NT range and is highly acceptable now and really is the only option to use if you consider security in any form at all important. Cons it's too easy to use has too much eye candy has a much bigger foot print and much higher overheads requires something much more powerful to run on and a lot more memory as well. It has some major security issues and with SP2 was more of a rewrite of the Source Code rather than a patch, but the worst thing is that by MS standards it is now nearing the end of its Product Life Cycle without anything new to replace it with.
Also backward compatibility between different versions of Windows and the applications that ran on them can leave a lot to be desired particularly if you have some mission critical software that is not mainstream.
NT3 whatever was MS first attempt to get into the Server market and was based on a product that MS designed for the US DoD so it was reasonably stable fairly easy to use and had the NTFS file System but it did lack a lot of user friendliness and just was not scalable enough.
NT4 was an improvement of NT3.X and a bit more user friendly but with the improved user friendliness came security issues and it also had a much bigger footprint and slightly higher overheads but it did retain the NTFS file system which was just so much better than the FAT that came with the domestic versions of Windows. Again it just was not scalable enough for a proper server market but for small 2 processor Servers it did work quite nicely.
Y2K Server was an improvement of NT4 and again it retained the NTFS file system but made it mandatory to use and retained the same scalability issues that NT4 had although it was slightly better on the Server side.
Y2K Professional was the first real Desktop application of the NT range of Windows which was worth having there where previous desktop versions of NT but they never actually where accepted too well and most places retained 98SE for the desktop. It had a much more user friendly interface and was quite well accepted and worked with a lot of the Domestic Software that MS was then producing. The down side it had a much bigger foot print and higher overheads didn't run a lot of specialized applications that NT4 did and again required more powerful hardware to run.
2003 ES So far the Best Server OS that MS has produced so far but it still has major security issues major scalability issues although these have allegedly been improved to cover up to 128 CPU installations according to MS at least although I've never actually tried to run it on this type of Server so I'm not actually sure that what MS has claimed is correct. It requires a much larger foot print and much higher overheads to actually run properly, has Licensing issues with bigger networks as there is a limited number of computers that can be attached to it as a Server without incurring increased Licensing fees.
As time has gone on the Licensing of MS products has become more complex and with XP which was at its release supposed to integrate the Domestic and Commercial versions of Windows into a single product family has become very confusing and lead to a lot of home user misconceptions particularly the bit about XP Pro being able to be used on 2 CPU's which a lot of Home users took to mean that it could be installed on 2 computers for the one fee where it actually meant that it could be used with Dual Processor M'Boards without incurring additional licensing fees. In the commercial environment the Volume Licensing has become more complex as well but with the Advent of Software Assurance it was now possible to have employees take home a copy of the software and install it on their Home Computers to train on for work {in AU anyway as I'm not sure that this applies world wide.}
Currently Windows remains the OS of choice for the Desktop mainly because MS has got so many of the other software houses to write software for Windows so it has become the default OS. On small servers NT and then 2000 and 2003 have been used extensively and this growth has been increasing for a while now but currently it seems to have reached its peek as the bigger Server OS's make a larger penetration into the small Server market and don't have the same Licensing issues that Windows Server products have so in a lot of places they are being accepted over the Windows products for the same job.
Col ]:)
by jvitka
Word never made any sort of impact on the PC Market until they bundled it with all their other second rate Office Applications into Office and made it possible to share data between different applications which was not all that easy previously.
before that there was a great office suite called ENABLE, that intergrated wordprocessing, spreadsheet and a datsbase quite well. This was the DOD standard in the 286 days and was quite an advanced App. The functions in the all three apps were outstanding and make the competition look awkward including at the tome Lotus, Dbase wordstar etc. However the company sat back on it DOD contract and never tried to market to the public. In fact it is so overlooked a google search for history of office suites, wordprocessors, spreadsheets or databases overlooks it completely!!!!
by hal 9000
And thought that there was no future in the PC market. :D
But most likely it was something to do with that DoD contract which prevented them from going public with it.
But I thought I was being nice I only mentioned Windows in the above didn't I?
Col ]:)
by apotheon
Linux won't run Photoshop, Painter, Illustrator, Dreamweaver, or Fireworks, except in a windows emulator that would slow them down too much for my taste or patience (and I can't afford powerful enough hardware to make an emulator run well). I need these programs like I need air or water. If they were ported to linux to run natively, then I would consider switching, but not before.
"that rat's-nest of software Microsoft is churning out"... yes maybe so in some ways(FrontPage certainly), but I love long writing sessions in word 2003...love the grammar check which is amazingly sophisticated at this point. The annoying stuff can be turned off. Rationality requires admission that some of what MS turns out is good.
Anyway, that's my .02...don't mock me too much, as I'm a graphics and writing type, not a programmer or sys admin and I don't know 1/4 as much as most of you (and I don't mean that sarcastically).
On second thought, I am a linux user (in my Directv Tivo) and it's cool and stable there, except I'm totally disgusted the USB ports are disabled and that it would take a computer science degree (I least from my viewpoint), or about $200 minimum, to hack a fix for that.
by hal 9000
That is why M$ has done so well they have got the major Software Houses to write code for their product "Windows" only and go to great lengths to stop them from changing this like what happened to Corel.
Incidentally Word Perfect still is better than word it has a better Spell & Grammar checker as well as a lot of other nice features that MS still has not come close to emulating. AS well as being able to be opened in either WP or Word mode it works seamlessly with Word which is a lot more than can be said for the MS offering when you convert WP Documents to Word you loose a lot of the formatting.
Col ]:)
by apotheon
I don't know for sure what alternatives are available for all the applications you've indicated. I do all my web development by hacking the code directly, so I've never bothered to find out whether there's a functional equivalent of Dreamweaver. WYSIWYG web design tools haven't been high on my list since I stopped using Dreamweaver three years or so ago. I'm not really sure what illustration tools there are, either, or what tools there are for GIF and PNG animation. For direct image editing, though, in the style of Photoshop, I use the GIMP. I have yet to run across any indication that the GIMP is lacking in comparison to Photoshop and, in fact, I prefer the GIMP's interface over that of Photoshop because the tools aren't hidden the same way they tend to be in Photoshop. It also requires considerably less system resources to run the GIMP than Photoshop these days.
I'm sure there are a number of specific tools for which there aren't analogs in the unix world, but they are few and far between. In fact, now that Macs are running a unix-based OS, that may not even be true of any graphic design tools any longer. Now that most of the major issues of MacOS have been ironed out by migrating to a unix kernel, you might want to think about moving off Windows if all you're missing on Linux is web design related tools.
In specific cases, there may well be a couple applications here and there on Windows for which there don't exist acceptable alternatives on Linux. In my experience, though, there are far more applications (and servers) that run on Linux for which there aren't any acceptable alternatives on Windows. I never meant to suggest that individual vendor-specific applications that ran only on Windows didn't exist.
Obviously, if you need a WYSIWYG web design tool, and if there isn't a worthwhile alternative available on Linux, you should stick with something like a Mac or Windows box where it is available. I never meant to suggest otherwise.
Of course, I would definitely suggest that between MacOS X and Linux all the functionality of Windows has been covered.
by hal 9000
I only used Walmart because so many US Peers say nasty things about it not being in the US I really wouldn't know but being so big I thought of them. :(
Col ]:)
by jaqui
this is exactly the mindset that I was lambasting in the programming discussion a couple of weeks back.
where I pounded people's concept that scripting a macro in excel is application development to crap.
same mindset thinks it's great to use flatpage to create garbage code then edit it in vb.
by jaqui
my brother in law packaged and shipped my wife's computer to us.
even though he assembled the system he did not secure the hard drive into the drive bay.
he did not courier it.
he shipped it regular parcel post.
no insurance.
the hard drive bounced out with the usps handling of the package.. ripped the floppy cable ( and a pin ) from the mb, ripped the heat sink off the cpu, ripping cpu from socket at same time.
the entire side of the case was dished in so severely there was no way to flatten it for re-attaching the side panel.
me to cheap to buy new cpu, or pay for someone else to fix, so manually straightened every single pin with a pocket knife and tweasers.
the pins looked like spaghetti before I started.
but not one broke off, or even cracked.
clips for heat sink were snapped from the sides of the socket...so no means of securing heatsink to cpu.
( wish I had a machine to do it like Col did )
but my wife still useing that cpu, she hasn't upgrades from the cyriz 600 mhz chip.
( she's as cheap as I am. ;) )
by hal 9000
A 20 Thou Feeler gage is hardly a machine it was all rusty to {those cheap rubbish Snap On things again perhaps after 15 years in a tool box I should consider replacing them. ;)}
But I did it under a magnifying lamp which was a great help as I could actually see what it was that I was doing and when I bought it I was very sternly asked "What the Hell did you buy that for?" Now I can't drag her away from it whenever she wants to read something it's hers. :(
Col ]:)
by nmeyer
by hal 9000
I'll have to have a look at Flatpage it's loaded on this box along with all the MS stuff but I never actually use it I only opened word the other day to save something because WP locked up on me.
Funny really as I've paid for that MS stuff sort of anyway as it comes yearly with the kit and they want it on every machine here for demo purposes but then again no one is brave enough to actually touch this machine after the last guy that did accidentally wiped my Windows boot drive when he was formatting up a new HDD he was told to use the one in my office which was supposed to be the old Quad 200 MMX that didn't have any covers on it so he pulled my box apart plugged in an IDE drive and thought that because the Board would Auto Detect the Drive he was safe, unfortunately I've switched off the IDE controller on this unit and just use the SCSI's he pushed in a floppy typed FDISK and then proceeded to FDISK disk 0 pity he didn't look at the partition or anything else. Then he tried restarting this machine and promptly went out for the rest of the week to avoid me and allow me to cool off {It didn't work! :D}
But then again I didn't realize what he had done until I tried rebooting it to run Windows and wondered where the Dual Boot option had gone it just loaded up Debian. There is something to be said for having a bulk number of SCSI drives in a machine but it doesn't help when others who are not supposed to use my machine and don't know how I have it setup mess with it. Well it was only a Windows Boot Drive and I still had all of my data on it so no biggie other than when he got called back in I told him to reload the Bloody thing and had a pile of CD's 2 foot high ready and waiting for him. :^O
Actually this poor thing doesn't know what's going on as I've had XP running for a while now mainly because I started forgetting just how it works as I've been using Debian far too much lately so I'm doing a refresher course in Windows. Now I wounder if this unit will run the production version of Longhorn it only has 2 Xeon's 16 GIG of RAM It just might be powerful enough to run the next generation of Windows when it eventually comes out but I'll probably have to fit an IDE drive to it so it will work. :) But you should hear the MS techs when I give them a description of this workstation firstly they do not believe me and then insist that it's a server not a workstation. But it's my workstation and doesn't have anyone else able to connect to it. :D
Col ]:)
by apotheon
by apotheon
by apotheon
by hebbeson
Let's see, as probably the de-facto standard in O/S'es, it seems that we are forced to use Windows in some form or another. I say we just do it and interface our way into successful business.
I have experience in many different O/S'es and frankly, love/hate Windows, depending on what I am trying to do.
I personally like Windows, as well as MAC O/S, Novell, and a couple others, depending on what I am doing. Windows is the standard and seems to run fairly well and is stable when configured correctly. I suppose that is the key right there, you have to CONFIGURE it correctly. I set up networks and fix others almost daily and there are the ups and downs.
My main machine at home is a Win2K Pro box and it works just fine. I also have a couple of other machines at home that are still Win98SE, but they are not used for much ther than the web and WP stuff.
I have also tried Novell, Linux, Mac O/S, BeOS, OS/2 and others and I still move towards Windows for most things, because of the availability of stuff for it. It depends on what you do with it.
Truly, the first real O/S from Microsoft, was the MS-DOS stuff (on which I started in computers back when DOS 2.x was the O/S). I have watched it grow, get good, go bad, recover and get good again.
To me, here are the O/S'es from Microsoft:
DOS
Windows NT 3.5
Windows NT 4.0
Windows 2000
Windows XP
Windows V1, 286, 3.x, 95, 98(SE), and ME were simply glorified file management systems over DOS anyway.
For those that still have this deep-seated hatred at Microsoft for whatever reason, maybe should just actually learn how to configure it and learn the workarounds for the parts that don't work maybe like they should. Every O/S out there has its ups and downs, and I do not hear many complaining about how Linux or MAC O/S does not do something right as loudly.
Let's just all get along. Additionally, if Windows is so bad, then why does everyone seem to be writing stuff to interface with it? I'll tell you. It is because they are the biggest and the most widely used. Good or bad, they have the market.
That's my take on it.
by hal 9000
"Let's just all get along. Additionally, if Windows is so bad, then why does everyone seem to be writing stuff to interface with it? I'll tell you. It is because they are the biggest and the most widely used. Good or bad, they have the market."
M$ is constantly making it hard for other Software Houses to move away from Windows as their base OS. When Corel tried it MS bought a heap of stock called an Extraordinary General Meeting of the Share Holders and insisted as a Share Holder that Corel Cease & Desist in developing any Open Source Applications. They got their way as most of the shareholders knowing no better than MS being the Biggest must be right voted along with MS to allow MS to get their way. Then after MS got its way they sold off their stock holdings or the bulk of them anyway at a loss.
While I don't mind Windows too much I do dislike the manner that MS does business and the vastly inferior products that they are fostering on us and then insisting that we change as they change.
Currently 98SE still has a major user base in the Corporate World but support for the Product is ending very soon and even if we follow the standard MS Life Cycles XP should be ending soon, after all it's now been out over 5 years and 5 years is the Max support for MS products according to their Web Site. Currently the next version of Windows is about 18 months to 2 years away and that is even doubtful if it will be released by then.
Even if it is do you want to be one of the first to have to use it and find out all the quirks that it has? Like most business they allow any new MS Windows product to be living in the market for a couple of years or SP/SR before adopting in on a wide scale.
As for not hearing too many complaints about OSX or the others you should try attending MS Partner Meetings just about everyone there is complaining about these OS not because they are bad but because they are affecting their sales and if anything are too good. The last MS Meeting that I attended was the first time I even heard Apple Mentioned and even the MS guys well the techs anyway just brush over the TCO of Linux and other OS's they just say here are our numbers you can take them or leave them and get on with their presentations.
Col ]:)
by jaqui
to she who must obey's tweasers and my pocket butterfly knife it is.
~L~
by mschoenberg
by hal 9000
NT range of Windows which both 2000 in all its flavors and XP are built upon.
Also as both XP & Y2K are newer they should be a lot more stable but you totally failed to address the memory leaks that do occur within these products. But then again I suppose if you are working with small business who doesn't leave the machines running 24/7 and are willing to accept the down time for the monthly patches you most likely wouldn't be seeing these problems.
Now the big one what is going to happen at the end of this year when Y2k goes to limited support and XP soon follows with no replacement OS yet available?
I understand that MS will continue support for XP until the next version becomes available but will they continue it long enough for us to work out the bugs and quirks that will be involved with the next version of Windows or will we all be Beta Testers?
Col ]:)
Users have not changed much since the early days of DOS, they never have known how to configure things and usually get some one else to do it. the early MS wizards allowed you to easily do things manually if you wanted - lazy programing in the later versions meant that you had to be highly technically skilled to get around the wizards. However, other O/Ss are available that are just as user friendly but of a higher quality performance simply due to better code writing and design practices.
I have several people whose applications work well with XP SP1 but crash with the installation of SP2 despite the apps being certified XP compatible by MS. I have found SP2 to cause some machines to be less stable than if left with SP1 only. Probably these will be fixed in the next SP.
Admittedly I have not had much expereince with 2003 server but what I have had shows them to be less stable than the 2000 servers they replaced; also they are not mentioned in the list asked about.
Users need to set aside 50 GB of a new drive for recycling and restore? having the default settings at 2% and 5% would be more than sufficient with a modern drive and still provide user safety. And yes it is easily changed by it would be better to have the default at resonable levels.
yes I have seen what some of the Linux support costs are, and they are still less than MS for overall cost. Also for small to medium organsiations the savings are very significant, at least here in Australia they are.
I have tried compatibility mode and they still do not perform properly in XP.
Please advice us what advanced features Windows have that are very useful and not available in Unix, Mac or Linux.
And you just reminded me of the biggest problem with Win XP - change the hardware and you will usually have to reactivate the software. I am all anti piracy effort into making a better and less vulnerable product they would be better off.
by apotheon
"[i]Microsoft gets this, and makes one of the most user-friendly Operating Systems, in my opinion[/i]"
This isn't so much an error as a red herring. These days, there's a version of pretty much anything available on a personal computer that is as user friendly as Windows ever was. For a Linux example, take a whack at Ubuntu, Xandros, MEPIS, or Lycoris some time. SuSE and Red Hat have workstation offerings that rank up there as well, and in fact you can make a more user-friendly system out of pretty much any Linux distro available if you know what you're doing — some of them are just slightly beyond geriatric luddites for installation and configuration purposes.
"[i]Are you just showing your inability to correctly configure Windows Firewall?[/i]"
I, for one, know how to configure it. It's a simple three-step process:
1. Turn it off.
2. Turn off the stupid little system tray alert that tells you it's turned off.
3. Install something that works. Even ZoneAlarm provides outgoing protection: the fact that the Windows firewall doesn't is just ridiculous.
"[i]Folks, don't believe the drivel that SP2 is unstable, because it is not by any means.[/i]"
Actually, this is 100% correct, technically. The problem with SP2 isn't in its stability, but in its incompatibility with a lot of hardware, and its incompatibility with a lot of software, and with the scads of useless "security enhancement" cruft that it throws at you, some of which is actually worse than nothing. The Windows firewall comes to mind.
"[i]Sure the alternative Operating Systems may cost less for the installation files, but you will pay much more for lack of support and non-standardization.[/i]"
You must have been drinking the MS kool-aid. This sounds like one of those ridiculous TCO arguments in all the Windows ads that is based on faulty statistical reporting. Do you have someone on-hand that is a competent administrator? Are you willing to hit up a bunch of friendly experts for free help now and then (on a LUG mailing list)? Fine. You've already got better support than you'll ever have with Windows, and all you're paying for support so far is the wages for your admin — and you'd need one anyway to run a credible Windows network.
Besides, picking on Red Hat for support fees as compared to Microsoft support fees ignores things like the level of support you get and the fact that you don't have license fees coming out your ears, not only for the OS itself but for all the other software that runs with it. It's pretty difficult to run an enterprise network on Windows without paying licensing fees on every major application you're running. It's almost impossible to run an enterprise network on Linux and have to pay for major applications at all. PostreSQL, Apache, and Squid, for instance, put MS SQL Server, MS IIS, and MS Proxy Server to shame, and they're all available free.
"[i]why not just run VMWare Workstation or Microsoft Virtual PC to run your 98 OS in a Virtual Machine. This is a much more stable solution than WINE will ever be.[/i]"
That's asinine. There are Linux applications more compatible with legacy Windows applications than the new versions of the same apps. I'm guessing you've never actually used WINE. "[i]Of course, if you had any business sense you would have thought of this already, right?[/i]"
by davemori
There are also a number of third party hardware accessories and add-ons that either work as-is without need for additional drivers (all types of disk or optical or flash drives, I/O cards, pen tablets, keyboards/mice/joysticks/trackballs -- even printers, scanners, digital cameras, monitors, etc.).
PCI and AGP slots are there, USB and Firewire, and I have yet to find anything mainstream that does not work.
Anything with a USB 1.1 or 2.0 interface or Firewire interface basically owes its existence to the popularity of the first iMacs in the late 1990s. USB was going nowhere on the PC. Firewire (IEEE-1394x) was an Apple invention.
Many video cards run as-is, or have shareware drivers or drivers written on contract by the manufacturter to companies like ProSoft Engineering.
Industry standard memory was adopted to whatever the prevailing standard was, basically back with the first Power Macintosh, in the early 1990s. Even going down to the power supplies in the case.
On-the-motherboard, built in graphics support generally comes from ATi or nVidia - same chipsets in use by many PCs, and it has been this way since the late 1990s.
Monitors were supported through adapters and dongles until about the mid to late 1990s when the 604 based PowerMacs and first G3s came out.
Apple engineers have been sitting on nearly every industry standard committee since the 1980s.
If you examine the logic board of even a 1996-1998 Mac, you will see something like 85% component level commonality between whatever was on the logic board of whatever was commonly used on PC logic boards at the time.
The other 15% was ASICs, which basically had to be different due to the use of IBM and Motorola PowerPC processors -- the frontside bus speed, of which, also dictates the speed of the memory used.
The Mac Mini is a perfect example of being able to use off the shelf USB keyboards, mice, monitors, etc.
What comes out of the Mac is also pretty standard. I don't know of anyone who still does anything with AppleTalk. That was gone in the late 1990s. All of the Mac connectivity is via IP.
by lensdoc
There are a load of nerds around, but take me I am a doctor and have been fiddling around ever since IBM got thrown out of India a long time ago.
Yes! I do not remember anything from that time, until it was possible for me to progress from an electronic typewriter, a canon to an XT.
I am 54 now, and have never really had a formal education in IT as you call it now, however I did not miss out on email, data processing etc. When Windows came out in India,( Who could afford a Mac!)it was a boon for those who had more fun getting things done rather than sounding clever typing silly DOS commands. Any fool will tell you that a GUI, convenient to use with a lot of very useful tips for the common man was the object of choice, and that is why I use it.
YES! Even in medicine not everything heals! Most "cures" only heal symptoms and not the cause of the disease. For healing you will have to look inwards and the healing is there, but then you go to a local doctor and get a quick fix do you not!
Operating systems are required by all, but the nosy buggers who have to have their noses in unmentionable places usually find what they are sniffing for!
The problem is not with engineering or computer science, it is with the marketing blackguards that promise the world and take your soul. There are many ways to do this and it is true in the world of medicine also, there is a cure, but will the drug companies allow it?
In computers and cyberspace there can be amity, but then there are always the good guys and the dirty. So I love the idea of open source and God bless Linus Thorwalds and his followers, but for sanity at a price, maybe Windows has done what it had too, opened the cyber world for us who do not have time to learn too much techie stuff now, we have our children and our retirement to think off.
May all the OS's grow but for heavens sake! Let it not be the story of photography were ever lens needed its own socket! What a waste of time, energy and money, just so everybody used your product. It did not work neither will this present philosophy so my dear freind, do your study, but do it well and give us concise and clear details about the saga of Windows!
It may be hard to put up with an ageing man with some beer in his hands, but it is much more difficult to listen to you @#$%^ who try to sound clever and wind up losing anyone who wants to listen. The only thing you actually do is reiterate that your ego is the reason that you are an AH!
Dr. Nicolas Rao
Retired from clinical practice but very involved in Remote processing, Medical Transcription requires ears, eyes and the brains to put gibberish together to make a legal and sensible document. For this we need computers,networks, firewalls, antivirus and everything from your perineum to what makes you what you are!
I am available most times at nicolasrao@yahoo.com or nicolasrao@gmail.com. There are other places but that is when we are better freinds.
by papawhiskey
Nicolas, though it appears English is not your first language, and your attempt to comunicate your thoughts in English is not perfect, your point has been made quite well. Your statement:
"It may be hard to put up with an ageing man with some beer in his hands, but it is much more difficult to listen to you @#$%^ who try to sound clever and wind up losing anyone who wants to listen. The only thing you actually do is reiterate that your ego is the reason that you are an AH!"
is priceless.
I run a network consisting of a Windows 2003 server, an SCO Unix 5.06 server, a Linux RH8 server, and numerous Windows XP Pro machines. Our Windows machines have run flawlessly, but last fall our Unix server crashed hard due to file corruption, and we had to completely rebuild it. Also, one year earlier our Linux server died (but that was due to a hardware failure).
The Linux guru's who like to slam Windows do so because of their need to feel superior. It's the same behavioral characteristic that befalls Apple users. I have no problem with Linux, I think it's pretty cool, but does it have to be so cool that it requires using a less than intuitive interface so as to confuse those who have not devoted their lives to it, thereby making the guru's supposedly superior?
I don't want to see Linux, or Windows go away, just the people who think one or the other is superior.
by lyon3422
Thanks for these last two replies...I becoming saddened by the overwhelming biased hate going both directions here, and the last two posts helped my sadness immensely.
I too run a mix of Windows 2000/2003, Linux, and Unix. I admit to having more experience with Windows, but I am not partial to any. If you know what you are doing, you can make all of them run well.
Unless you are connected to the internet, and have to worry about the patching, a Windows box can run for years.
I enjoyed PapaWhiskey's final two paragraphs, because it reached the crux of the matter. We all want to feel superior...it is the basic human fault of pride.
Obviously, a majority of the Linux lovers and Windows haters have not had any success getting Windows to run...they choose to blame their inability to properly administer Windows on Microsoft, Bill Gates, the hated Microsoft stock program, the MCSE program, you name it...
The same can be said of Linux haters...they see command line and go bonkers...
My take on this whole issue is that everything has it's place...frankly, much of my job as a System Administrator involves people interaction, security documentation, other miscellaneous documentation, policies and procedures, etc.
Beween that and an active personal life, I frankly don't have time to memorize every Linux command line tool and how to use them. I do what is necessary to get my service to run.
At least with Windows once you figure out how to do something with the GUI, it is easy to remember when you have to go back 6 months later and do the same thing.
Some people will say that my reliance on GUI is due to my lack of intelligence...maybe so. But with everything else on my plate, every little shortcut helps.
So, Hats Off to those of you ingrossed in re-compiling kernels and all the other neat stuff that Linux allows. I am just happy when my servers do whatever job I am asking of them no matter what the OS is.
Hence...I say get back to the basics. Computers are there to provide a service to our users. It is the SERVICES that count, not the OS. If I can provide the same service on a Windows box, securely and in 2 hours, that would take me 2 days of research and 8 hours of command line bungling to provide on Linux, then which choice do you think I will take? Once again...that depends on the service, mission criticality, whatever!?
But OS Hate will never influence my decision...
by hal 9000
by deejay54
Is there some definition of stable that all can agree upon, or is it as elusive as which is the 'best' operating system?
Here's my shot: stable means that the system doesn't blue-screen, shutdown or reboot without user intervention (pull the plug, press the reset the button). Unstable means that an operation causes a blue-screen, shutdown or reboot (open program, print) and is reproducible on two or more 'identical' systems (same chipset, same driver versions, same patch version).
by apotheon
stable (adj.): 1a. Resistant to change of position or condition; not easily moved or disturbed: a house built on stable ground; a stable platform. b. Not subject to sudden or extreme change or fluctuation: a stable economy; a stable currency. c. Maintaining equilibrium; self-restoring: a stable aircraft.
(from the American Heritage Dictionary of the English Language)
[b]stable (adj.): resistant to changes in operating state that are not triggered intentionally[/b]
I tailored that [b]bolded[/b] definition specifically to relate to use of the term in describing operating systems. Basically, an unstable system changes system state in unintended manners, and at unintended times. For instance, gradual loss of RAM because of memory leaks, tendency of a GUI subsystem to wedge or crash, and unexpected process termination are all examples of instability.
So your choice of OS is based on your skills and experience.
Makes perfect sense to me as long as you accept the reverse
If I can provide the same service on a 'Nix box, securely and in 2 hours, that would take me 2 days of GUI fumbling and registry hacking and 8 hours of research, then which choice do you think I will take?
I don't hate windows, I despise ms marketing and I'm contemptuous through an unfortunate level of familiarity with any claim to stability, security, compliance, design or efficiency of the bulk of their products.
by oldmicro
the chief pro to "billy world" is scale of marketing. It is out there with millions of uesrs.
the chief con is that you are locked into "billy world" from which there is no escape. M$ system, M$ applications, M$ browsers, M$ compilers, M$ tools, and none of them are even compatible with previous versions of themselves. All of them use undocumented hooks and private entrances into the others. I am just paranoid enough to believe that the "bugs" are at least somewhat intentional, being hooks that have gone bad.
M$ wouldn't be a bad choice if it were open and not a top to bottom monopoly.
by sepius
o.k. my reply. starters I am a user of W95,W98,NT4,W2k,XP,OS7,Linux(Mandrake, Fedora, Debian, Lycoris, Mepis)OS2 and BSD. I feel I can comment on the pros and cons. I will not say that any other is superior, but I do use other OS's more than the M$ range.
PRO - The shipped package management is easy to setup in poledit, if required. The preship setup is good as well and easy to teach other techs. XP is smooth for the novice. Many people had trouble going from 3.1 to 95/8 to XP. Being a linux user,it is an easy transition, so time between changes is a pro and is an easy migration. XP is the best they have produced. Off the shelf purchasing of software. hardware compatability. portability is the biggest pro. Good selection of games.
CONS - Cost. Way to high, no wonder they are pirated and hacked all the time. limitations in optimisation. lack of legacy support. Licensing to hardware vendors (causing driver incompatability with older versions) outdated the instant a new box is put on the shelf, XP is good, but it is now old and archaic. Current network security is too tight (actually the method to deal with it is wrong, they just shutdown the feature). Middle point admin is to complex, I spend more time explaining the feature than actually desecuring XP to make it easy for staff. Having to logon before network starts, unless 3rd party software. Poor swap file management. And my biggest CON that peeves me the most, no packaged calander and the time management is totally ignored. it is crap, sorry, non existent, this should be fundamental in any OS, oh thats right it is except for one!!
by pkdesi1
Pros- I have been using it forever.
Cons_ I have been using it forever.
by swilk67
Having read thru some of these threads and replies, I'm amazed that we STILL have the nix/open source v MS argument! I?m very tired of the intellectual snobbery and one-upmanship that passes between IT pros, gifted geeks and diehards of one platform over another. Let's face it, this industry is still VERY young and is STILL finding its feet. Make it (IT/using a comp)easy as poss. and more people will ultimately help it develop, unix/linux is not easy to master for a newbie. I've found that there is a huge amount of unconstructive dialogue against a smaller amount of constructive dialogue on this site. The situ is that windows is here to stay 4 the foreseeable, and has provided standardisation the world over, albeit a bit(sometimes very) rough and unstable pre nt/xp. xnix is making inroads into industry and the home but requires computing/OS knowledge and has so many variations on package installs it's no good for the average Joe to use. At least average Joe can go to the shop, pickup a MS box and within a few months can utilise it almost to it's fullest. That is a good thing. If Joe went and bought a xNix box from the same shop, he/she would be tearing their hair out when they come to install their 1st package (once they'd deciphered which package to use)!! That's a bad thing. Ok, apologies for the rant, but say something that is of use please. My take on it all?, Like MS for its
logical, steady approach, love nix for it's drive for perfection (& stability of course) at the expence of new distro's every 5 minutes. :-)
by pig fooker
Pro: Microsoft makes me a butt-load of money. Great for developement, .NET and SQL could keep them alive if needed. Large partner network.
Con: Microsoft makes my clients spend lots of money. Microsoft needs to go back to the drawing boards on what could be potentially great products but seriously flawed at the present e.g. Exchange (get rid of Jet technology & use SQL instead).
Either way, I'm sticking with what feeds me until something better comes along. I don't care whos better, as long as I get paid!
Now I know why all of you are Techs. Obviously not a single one of you have bothered to look at the number one thing.
Why do businesses exist? To make money! That's it. Plain and simple. To make money. There is no point in a business providing a service for another individual if they aren't going to line their pockets with money. (if you disagree take intro to business and economics) Everyone needs to get back to the focus of the discussion. That is which OS do you prefer.
Aside from a few statments about stability and alot of crap about paranoia and conspiracy, no one has provided any insight as to which of the two is better.
Just a bunch of himming and hawwing about one or the other. Based on everything I've read I'd pick the MS operating system over the LINUX because of the same reasons why it is the leading OS in market today.
These reasons are:
1. A "paid" certified professional developing/repairing the code from the company that created and designed the software. If everything was open source you would have to train every new network administrator that is hired to the changes you've made in your source code. This takes away any kind of working 'baseline' for an administrator and increases the amount of burden the company has to bare in finding an adequate new hire.
2. MS dominates more than 90% of the PC market. If their product was that inferior and they have not had any intent on making it the best, how did Microsoft make it this far? (you can't control the consumer vote. Let's not forget we are in the business to make money and if that means cutting out your competition then do it.)
3. There are plenty of virus' and spyware written for LINUX. You are more likely to hear about attacks to MS because it has 90% of the market share. Anyone who thinks they can't be attacked send me some basic info (that which can be found just as easily as I request it here) and I know people who can hack you.
4. Anyone with any kind of brain can use windows. Whether you think some people should be allowed to touch computers or not, the fact is everything requires PC knowledge. You can barely drive a car without knowing how to use a computer. I would rather that car be as easy to ride as a bike than difficult to piloting like a rocket ship. With the economy going global the number of 'stupid' people using these PCs has increase exponentially. This makes complete since.
5. Companies with legacy equipment (that means mainframes for you nubes)are facing a serious challenge. This challenge is to be able to find qualified people who can understand, let alone operate, these systems. The same is true for Windows and LINUX. The fact is the two OS's are quite similar. It's mostly the shell and the interface that is different (even the command lines follow the same logic). Businesses find it difficult to utilize open source software for these reasons.
All of these reasons are significant business reasons to choose MS over LINUX/UNIX, whether you want to agree with it or not. In a market where executives can't see real measurements of productivity with IT, these issues are predominately the first to come to mind and ultimately many executives final decision on this subject.
by jmgarvin
1) Huh? Assuming this made sense, you are saying that somehow any change made to ANY app or the OS is so large that it changes everything. There is a baseline and that is that an app is still the same app, even with tweaked source code.
2) MS hold 93% of the desktop market and about 53% of the server market. Businesses are moving away from MS and to *nix because that install base is growing!
3) Ok, name 30 virus and spyware that can have a major effect on the system outside of the specific user space.
4) If 4 was true, everyone would use a Mac. The GUI is far easier to use than the Windows GUI AND it is designed for grandma to use. (I think Macs are just expensive toys, but flame away)
5) Huh? If Windows and Linux are the same why is it difficult to utilize open source software?
The market executives had better not be choosing my IT stuff. It is easy to measure increased productivity with uptime, traffic metrics, server metrics, security, and usability. You are focusing on the dektop not on servers or IT infrastructure.
Everyone has a choice what kind of software they want to put on their machine. I keep hearing about the apps do this and the apps do that and that's why we like LINUX/UNIX is because it doesn't have as many apps.
In a corporate business environment I promise there are no unnecessary apps running on machines unless the network admins don't have a clue. I only install apps I need period. And I disable most of the standard services and change many of the standard ports.
The only virus I got was one that I opened from a friend before I really knew where the power button was. The only spyware I've gotten is spyware I've downloaded through 3rd party software and I didn't read the EULA. Once I developed an understanding for the way a PC works and how viruses, spam, spy-ware, and worms affect them, I've never had a problem.
Don't blame a corporations product because of a lack of knowledge by home users. Learn to be proactive rather than re-active. Learn to make valuable decisions instead of feeling "stuck with no choices".
by jmgarvin
If you can solve this, you'll make millions.
The problem is that MS doesn't split user space into user space and kernel space into kernel space. It is all globbed together.
As far as the no apps for Linux. What apps aren't available that you need?
by paul
why do i have read through hundreds of forums to finally get answers from people that really understand the decision making processes in IT.
Understanding this process is more than just being able to point fingers at problems. The process involves maximizing productivity without impacting profitability.
seeing as you are still not paying attention.
I'm one of these people, is the only thing I need to know where the start button is ?
Yes I do know programming, so yes I understand the ms have made a conscious decision for a low quality broadly applicable OS in order to successfully grow their business.
However I don't want to write low quality programs, I don't want the quality of the software I write to suffer a low quality OS. I'm not interested in being dumbed down, what do I get out of that ?.
Quality code can be written, it is not impossible, it is simply less profitable.
Everytime I'm forced to sacrifice quality for business expediency it hurts, because that drive for quality is what I enjoy and what makes me good at what I do.
Good enough has pervaded our business for far too long. What's seems to be happening now is IT business's are again starting to differentiate themselves on quality. These business's will survive, the get rich quick bodge it merchants will move onto some other scheme leaving a trail of failure from their last venture.
The fact that THEY made a profit from said failure is a very narrow and counter-productive measure of success.
nobody's life is on the line here. If it were then we could sue microsoft if necessary.
After reading most of your posts to this arguement I understand that your problem with Microsoft is actually a deep rooted problem within yourself and your expectations of things. The industry is being dumbed down because the technology makes it easier to do. Let's copy and paste (let's not bother to check what we've copied and pasted) and then we can use spell checker to make sure we don't sound like a bunch of idiots. Then we can blame the software for not catching our grammer usage because we've relied on a software written by imperfect people for only about 20 years or so.
For hundreds of years man has attempted to conquered nature through utilization of technology. In the process we have become lazy and don't care why something does what it does. We just want it to work. We don't care why it won't, just that it doesn't.
While I am not of the same thinking the really sad truth is that most people just don't care. If they can just do a restart and the problem goes away, who cares?
While I can appreciate your desire to be known for your absoluteness and brilliance, and I can appreciate that you notice our standards being dumbed, I can't understand how you run a successfull business without at least a basic understanding of this. And if you do have this basic understanding where do you mention it to your users? For someone who provides IT support, consultation, and services it escapes me how any company would ever take you serious. While your knowledge of PCs and OSs far surpasses mine nothing you have said is convincing either way.
LOL
Poor software is a waste of money and does not maximise productivity.
Maximising Productivity and profitability in a business are laudable goals, they could be sensible ones as well, all you have to do is think past the next period end.
Lets write low quality crap so we can make a profit now and if we achieve market dominance for evermore is a very hit and miss strategy and in the long term doomed to failure.
of procedure. They found it convenient to leave the system open to posted exploit. They gambled and it didn't pay off.
Presumably you are aware of the %age differences in cracks on nix systems compared to windows ones ?
No doubt your come back will be it's a better target because there's more of them, which to a certain extent is true, however more worrying is that it's easier.
Windows has many strong points, security is not one of them and by ms's own admission not high on their list of priorities.
Not the highest thing on the agenda for these FSF chaps either by the sound of it.
by d_romasanta
by zwayne
I'm not a great fan of Microsoft as a company, but let's face it: Windows (finally) works. I am ONLY referring to 2000 and XP. (Don't throw in the 95/98/ME red herring and then say that Windows is not stable.) I am also not addressing enterprise computing issues (AD, sw deployment, security, server os, etc.) That's a much bigger kettle of fish to discuss.
With Windows you will not be tearing your hair out trying to get a sound driver to work (Alsa anyone?), you won't have to go through loops configuring screen parameters (X), USB device recognition is automatic and seamless, no problem getting the driver for a printer or camera or scanner or legacy device, you are shielded from a myriad of configuration files in numerous locations and with complex parameters, etc. And what about gamers? Is anyone in their right mind going to recommend Linux to them? Linux has come a long way, but it is still not a desktop solution for the average joe.
by data_bear
Let's face it. MS owns the market and controls it. Linux should be better than it is and so should Windows. Windows is a corporate money pit. TCO is out the roof and MS doesn't help anyone but themselves. They do keep me working as you do need an education and a hefty budget to keep a Windows network operational on a corporate level.
Win2K in my experience is the most stable. XP was looking good until SP2 hit the streets now I hate it. The OS in windows is buried very deep in there with IE and all the other built-ins.
Another downside is when there is an error the event log may or may not point you in the right direction for resolution. Calling MS for support is usually frustrating.
Windows Server 2003 is quite the resource hog like every new version of Windows. The requirement to upgrade and pay at least every 3 years I think is uncalled for. MS likes to rake in the $$.
PROS - it keeps me employed, comes on almost every PC sold in America and most people are familiar with it.
Sort by Trending