Discussion Locked

Purchasing Server, Firewall, for medium size company

0 helpful
30 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Currently, our company has about 15 employees working in a central office. We have a single file server for sharing various documents, this server is a Dell Poweredge.

We have 2 websites which are currently being served by GoDaddy, but we would like to host the servers ourselves. We also have 10 retail locations around the company that need to be able to connect to our websites continuously throughout the day.

So, we need to purchase one server that will be powerful enough to host our two websites and run a powerful firewall on it. We need another server to be used for file sharing around the office, which may be the currently used one.

My question is, what type of server should I buy and what else is needed to successfully roll out this procedure? What type of firewall needs to be purchased to protect such a server. Should I get a simple, cheap Dell PowerEdge or would something more powerful be needed. What type of firewall is needed? What backup mechanisms would be beneficial to have in place and what hardware would they require? What other components will be needed as part of this purchase and subsequent roll out?

I realize that this is a broad question, but any advice would be helpful.

Thanks,
Paul

30 replies

by blckspder

Setup a LAMP server for the websites. Use an operating system like Fedora or Gentoo.
The company I work for has a server that has 2 CPUs, handles ECC RAM and hot swappable SATA drives. It uses a software RAID and has fedora as the operating system with Apache and MySQL to run the website.

We backup using RSYNC to an online storage company.

Since we in-housed the website and server we've noticed an increase in performance, however this may not be the case for you.

by ohm.paul

I've only had limited Linux experience, so I don't think that I could effectively run a network based on it. Is windows so bad that it can't effectively run a network or website?

by hal 9000

If you are hosting your own Web Sites you tend to want a bit more security than Windows can offer though.

Probably why all the better hosting companies don't use Windows.

I'm also taking it for granted that you have sufficient UPS Capacity to keep things running smoothly in the event of Power Outages right?

Col

by robo_dev

Your questions concern me.

Hosting a web server yourself and not getting hacked is not a trivial matter these days.

Running a software firewall on a web server is like thinking that smelly aftershave will prevent herpes from that skanky gal at the bar.

You need a fast HARDWARE firewall, or you'll get hacked quicker than Mike Vick at an ASPCA convention.

For a firewall, you need something that's very high performance, yet not overly costly.

The three that I would look at would be either one of the low-end Cisco ASA products, an appliance like the Watchguard Firebox, or one of the SonicWall or TrendNet boxes.

www.cisco.com
www.watchguard.com

Here's an article:

http://www.3fn.net/guide/Own_website_hosting_-_risks_and_advantages.html

by ohm.paul

Thanks for the advice, I will definitely look into the firewalls, and I imagine that a high performance server will be required as well. Would a higher end Dell server be sufficient?

Also, are there any other things that should be included in this roll out that you might not think of initially. I would like for it to go as smoothly as possible.

by ohm.paul

The cisco ASA 5510 seems like a reasonable solution...does it have the security that we would need?

I also looked into some of the watchguard products, and the X Peak x5500e series is upwards of $5000 whereas the cisco ASA is around $2400.

Is the watchguard X peak necessary in my situation or should I look more into one of the lower end watchguard devices such as the x core series.

Please bear with me in this area as I am not very familiar with how vital each feature that these routers carry in a practical sense.

by dumphrey

you kill me
"Running a software firewall on a web server is like thinking that smelly aftershave will prevent herpes from that skanky gal at the bar."

I needed the laugh! But your dead on. We host our own site, but its traffic volume is tiny.

A few points to think about, volume, what volume of traffic are you expecting?
I would recommend a BSD server running apache if your comfort level allows for that, or you have the time to plan it out. An inexpensive power edge would handle traffic for 2 sites, if they are low volume, static pages.
If you have a database back end and expect a constant volume, I would invest in something more powerful (a rough approximation could easily be had with another forum question on just this).
As for firewalls, we have a PIX 501, not sure they still sell this model, and its running like a champ. That being said, its a major pain to change settings sometimes. The Cisco PDM web interface is useful, but limited sometimes. But the tech support they offer is excellent. And they will make config cahnges for you if you just do not feel like (or comfortable) doing it.

by ohm.paul

For the next year or so, I would imagine that our site would have a limited volume, with probably our 10 retail sites being logged on each day plus 50+ other customers being able to log on. The hope is that this will increase to about 100-200 simultaneous connections each day.

The company's site is database-driven. Customers will log on, make purchases, and check updates on products multiple times daily.

As far as running a BSD server, we have already committed to Windows since we do not have anyone with the required Unix knowledge. Same goes for linux.

In looking at PowerEdges, how much should I look to spend for a sufficient server? The server will need to host this website, but we would also like to use it as an Exchange mail server.

I am currently looking at the PowerEdge M605 with two dual core AMD opterons (2.2ghz), 2 GB ram, two 150GB 10k HDDs with Raid 1 and it's coming out to about $3500.

Would this option suffice for the website hosting as well as the Exchange mail server? Or would it be better to get a separate server to host the mail server. We already have a low end PowerEdge for the in-office file sharing. How much power is required to run an Exchange mail server?

Additionally, I am looking to get a backup device, perhaps tape storage...is this a good option?

I am looking at the firewalls in the range of $2000-3000. Specifically, I am looking at the following options:

-Watchguard firebox x core x750e at around $2500
-Cisco ASA 5510 at $2400
-SonicWall NSA 3500 at $2400

These products seemed to have similar features, and are offered at similar prices, but is there one that is better than the others? Or should I change my scope completely?

by robo_dev

Nobody ever got fired for buying Cisco...

(But some admins DID commit suicide trying to figure out how to configure VLANs).

Cisco is sorta a love-hate thing. It's solid reliable gear that can sometimes be overpriced. It can sometimes be a bear to configure, but there are tons of Cisco experts out there, and if there's a problem, Cisco WILL fix it, period.

For some folks a more 'idiot proof' security appliance is more fun, but in the long run as you need more capability, you will end up having to replace it sooner than a Cisco.

by ohm.paul

we have a couple APC units that would keep the servers up and running in that event.

We will probably go with Windows for this one, and I suppose if it proves to be too insecure (we are planning to have a hardware and software firewall) then we'll consider the transition to linux.

As far as hardware, what brand and specs should I look into for a server? I'm looking for reasonable solutions, not just the top of the line machine.

by hal 9000

Mainly because I want better hardware than is offered by the Major Makers. You may look for some specialist System Builder that supplies Servers to resellers for business.

But as a basic Spec I would be looking at a Dual Processor, Dual Core Xeon with as much RAM as can be fitted to the M'Board, you're going to need it believe me.

Throw in a Mirrored RAID Array with decent sized drives as Windows is bulky and you can never have too much space. While not the fastest it offers the best reliability available. If it can be run headless so much the better as you don't need to waste money on Video Cards/Monitors and the like and it allows you to have fewer cables lying around to mess things up.

As for APC's you need to remember that as you are now Hosting your Web Site you need [b]Full Time 24/7 Up Time[/b] any down time is going to cost bulk loads of money. Places that I consult for typically have Down Time Costs measured in the Several Million $ per minute costings so it needs to be totally redundant and this costs a lot in Hardware & M$ Licenses.

You'll also need some Backup Solution and depending on how much Data is involved you'll most likely need some Auto Backup Solution. My Personal Preference is Tape Auto Loaders but they aren't the cheapest option and take up space that may not be available.

Without knowing more of the situation it's hard to say much more here but that's a starting point.

Col

by dumphrey

to plug in routers, switches, etc into a UPS as well. We run 2 24/7 buisneses, our core switch can run for 45 min on its UPS, and that does not include the 25 min (more if neither of the AC/HEAT are running)on the building wide UPS. But, if lack of access is acceptable during a power loss, then a surge protector will do the trick.

by hal 9000

While AMD make decent CPU's they shouldn't be used in any Mission Critical Server as they are just plain & simple no where near as reliable as the Intel Servers using Intel CPU's and Chip Set M'Boards.

As you are hosting your Web Site you need the Reliability more than speed and currently Intel has the speed over the AMD's so it's a loose, loose situation relying on these servers.

The only advantage is price and that's of very low importance when it comes to servers as they are throw away items after 4 years so the less you pay now the less you have as a Tax Write Off for the life of the unit. Talk to the Accounts Department on this one and don't skimp on the initial Specs as it's going to hurt the business for the life of the server.

[i]Edited to add[/i] Server Costs for the initial purchase should be measured against the cost of Down Time so with a Big Business 15 Seconds of Down Time is the cost of 1 Gateway Server and this can be stretched out to the cost of 15 minutes of Down Time is the cost for a Gateway Server for small Business. It's rough & ready but a good starting point. It also points out just how cheap these units actually are compared to the business and just how important they are for the business.

Col

by dumphrey

own experience or from some research? I like AMD on the desktop, but have had some random compatibility issues in the past. So have avoided AMD servers.

by hal 9000

One company that I do work for insisted that a Dual AMD unit was supplied apparently the Son of the Owner was doing CS and as the AMD's where cheaper they where better. That 1 server cost the company over 12 Million $ in down time in a 3 month period.

At the 3 month mark without a single week of uninterrupted running and effectively 3 new systems in place they pulled out the Server replaced it with my recommended unit and it's been working ever since without a single second of unplanned down time.

The AMD unit was taken by the son and from what I hear is still failing on a daily basis just playing games for the kid who started complaining about it a few weeks after getting it. I think that his father is inflicting that unit on him to keep him out of the business. :D

But the AMD server should have been good it was on a Tyan Dual Processor Server Board with Corsair RAM and Seagate Drives. At first I thought that I got a faulty M'Board but after swapping it out twice along with everything but the bare case I came to the conclusion that it had a fairly major problem. I hope that they have got better since then but I don't know anyone willing to try one now.

We've had a couple of Trial AMD's in use for up to 3 months and they where no where near as reliable as basically the same Intel units that we had running beside them.

That however was a few years ago now when AMD was pushing hard to get into the Server Market in a big way they gave the machines out on a semi permanent loan to push the idea of better value for money. The hope was that the business would buy the machines after the testing period and not want to return them. It didn't pan out that way though and I haven't seen one single AMD Server here with the companies that I deal with since.

Seems that the word got out and ever since then no one wants AMD Servers. Well with the clients that I have at least.

Col

by dumphrey

do not put exchange on a server with any other database type (Domain controller, SQL, web)... It will eat your ram, trash your disk and choke.

For Exchange 2008, and entry-level dual core processor will do the trick. (Unless you have several hundred regular users, then mid level processor at least) but throw RAM at it like no tomorrow. Exchange uses RAM to cache messages, and then writes them out in a bulk operation to keep disk thrashing to a minimum. Also, it?s preferable to keep the Exchange database off the same physical disk as the OS page file.
We run exchange on a poweredge 2850 dual core Xenon (2.8 GHz?) with 2 GB ram, for 35 people. Serious overkill in terms of processing power, but we could use another gig of ram...

But if your hosting your own mail server, you will also need a spam filter. Do not buy any Barracuda below the model 300, as they are SERIOUSLY underpowered. For the same price as a model 200 you can buy an Iron Port c150, which is barely warming up to filter 250000 to 400000 spam a day for us.

ACK! Rambling Alert! Long story short. Keep Exchange on its own Box. (SBS is an exception, but it limits the total number of addresses possible). Keep your Web server on its own Box. On firewall suggestions, I would go with either the sonicwall or cisco. I have never been a fan of watchguard (no real reason for this either, its just the way I am).

Backup: How much data per day will you need to back up? A simple NAS to act as a cache for the backup software, and then back that up to tape is what I would recommend. That way, its on tape, off site, and on the NAS for quick access, as well as writing to disk is usually quicker then to tape (but then our tape drive is old). Restoring from the NAS is 1000x faster then from tape though =\

by ohm.paul

Our current file sharing server in the office is a SC440 (xeon 3050 2.13ghz, 2GB ram) and runs SBS 2003. It uses Sharepoint to share its files with the workstations around the office. Would this be a plausible option for the Exchange server if we added some ram to it? If not, would an additional SC440 or some cheap poweredge with a bunch of ram do the job for the mail server?

The Barracuda spam filter is around $2000, which is almost as much as the main firewall that I will be putting in front of the web server, is there a software spam filter that could be affective for the mail server that would be less costly?

On that note, should I put the main firewall (SonicWall NSA, Cisco ASA, Watchguard X) in front of the entire network or just in front of the web server?

As for how much data will be backed up, it is difficult to say. The website in itself is only <1GB right now, but is expected to grow when further features are implemented. I'm sure that a basic tape backup would be OK. And for the web server, I would certainly have a backup HDD which would be mirrored using RAID 1, but would it be necessary to have say 3 or 4 HDDs connected to it so that it is double or triple backed up?

by dumphrey

Exchange 2003 like a champ, and 2 GB ram is fine, unless you have tons o users.

As for a less expensive spam filter, you could build something with linux, but that would not be less then the barracuda solution. This would be an excellent question to post.

We used a barracuda 200 for 4 years. The first 3 years it ran fine, the forth year it beagn to slow down, then began to seize up. Its "rated" for up to 200 users. Reality: the spam volume in todays environment for 35 users was enough to use up all of its tcp/ip connections and put it in DoS. We upgraded to an IronPort 150c ($2200ish). Its the exact same hardware for 10 users as for 1500 users. The difference is licensing. Currently our filter is stopping avg 300,000 spam a day. Comes out to about 3.5 messages per second (spam). That kind of traffic would slow down an internal mail server to speeds to make users whine. Iron Port also does not have yearly fees. The support contract covers all updates. With Barracuda, you had to pay yearly fees for updates, and extra fees for instant replacement support. For our agency, a Barracuda 300 would have ran $4200 (3 year support/updates) as opposed to the $2300 from Iron Port. Trust me, if you run your own mail server, you NEED a filter to do spam at minimum and preferably to add anti-virus. Once again, this could be a whole question in and of its self =) (note: Exchange is not cheep. At around $100 per user in licensing (server access and exchange access) plus the cost of exchange and server 2003, your looking 3-5Gs for 70 or so addresses (depending on deals and hardware).

You asked about the firewall, do you not have one now?!?!?! how do you all access the internet? The firewall should go in front of the entire network, and ONLY allow http/https traffic from the internet to go directly to the web server. BTW, do you have static or dynamic ip addressing for your WAN interface? Because all of the firewalls you were looking at can create permanent vpns between locations, and route that traffic. So if the web server is for internal use, it would have no need to open ports on the firewall.
Also, do you use hosted e-mail or standard use SBS? And are you sure you want to host your own email? Its a big chunk of new responsibility (and every time email gets bounced back, the recipient wants to blame your server, even when the bounce says their server was unavailable/dead/AWOL/etc).

As for the Web server, have the main OS on A mirror partition, then have a SECOND set of mirror or (raid 5) disks to hold the server root and content, then use backup software to take the data off that computer and put it on either a tape drive, or a NAS and then to a tape drive. For absolute most reliability you would want raid 1+5 meaning you would have all data on a raid 5 being mirrored to another raid 5. But thats expensive in terms of controllers and hardware (min 6 drives), and then back that up, but thats crazy for most of us.
Hal9000 gives good advice, read what he says and ask him specifics. And Robo_Dev seems to have his head on straight as well. And I am starting to get this way off topic...
Firewalls, you NEED one, it should be in front of your network. It will control incoming and outgoing connections. Server backup, spam filtering, Exchange set up and monitoring are all topics just as big. Anyway, feel free to PM me if you want the full rant =\

by Member 32601021

If it's not already, Exchange will be one of the most important parts of your IT infrastructure. Depending on the number of users of course, I recommend dedicating a box just for Exchange - if for no other reason than to keep it running and free from conflicts with other apps.

For antispam, look at Commtouch - it's extremely effective, inexpensive, and has almost zero false positives.

For routers, I'd stay with Cisco ASA if you know anything about Cisco devices. If you would rather keep it simple, avoid the Watchguard too - I tried it and hated it. Way too complicated for a device that's supposed to be simple. Go with the SonicWall if you want it simple and web interface. Having said that, Cisco is the best. You can buy their smallest ASA5505 and get the support pack, and an inside host upgrade so you have more than 10 internal hosts. Call cisco's excellent support, have them set it all up for you.

RAID is absolutely required. NO Raid5. Raid 1 or 0+1. Also, if your budget is low, use NT Backup, and backup to a cheap NAS like Maxtor or Linksys or something.

by ohm.paul

We are not hosting any site, and only have about 10 users. So we have a cheapo linksys router hooked up to a dell PowerConnect 2324 switch where all the connections go. So we have very limited security right now, but there isn't much being protected either.

So you think that the SonicWall NSA 3500 would be sufficient, and the T1 coming in would go straight to the NSA 3500. Then it would connect to the switch, and from the switch would come all users and the servers, one of which will be hosting our website, another which will be hosting our local files and possibly an exchange server.

Great info, and thanks for the advice.

The server hosting the site would have two dual core processors, 2GB+ ram, 4 HDDs, one of which would be used to mirror the OS partition, and the others to mirror the website partition (raid 5). Sound about right?

The PowerEdge 2900 III is what i've been considering for the website server. As for the Exchange server, combining it with our current local file server (SC440) seems as though it may be a little difficult, but we would add a GB ram to it.

Another thing, how advanced would the NIC for this server need to be? I was looking at an intel pro 1000pt dual port server adapter for around $200 although I dont think the dual port would be necessary

by ohm.paul

That's about all I needed to convince me that I'll stick with intel. I'll probably be going with the PowerEdge 2900 III with 2 quad core processors, 2GB ram, and a number of hdds backing things up.

by ohm.paul

I have read that SonicWall's interface for configuring the firewall is pretty good, and like you said, Cisco's can be troublesome. Because of this I am leaning towards the SonicWall. Do you know if they have comparable support to that of Cisco's?

by dumphrey

in the long run. Given the choice between sonicwall and cicso, I would take cisco. But I also have experience on their PIX, routers, and switches. I can see how some people may want a better web interface, sometimes being able to poke arround your self is much quicker then calling tech support, getting them logged in and set up to make a minor change.

by ohm.paul

Now I have reports of SonicWall having a good web interface, but not performing as desired...and I have reports of Cisco performing well but needing to call tech support for minor issues. Hmmm, now the decision is tough. I took a class in Cisco that involved some configuring their routers via a telnet connection, so maybe I would be alright with that. I will probably go with Cisco in that case.

by dumphrey

but very believable. I LIKE AMD chips and even I have to admit they compare poorly to Intel, and always have. Now that the price of Intel chips has come down, there is no real reason to buy AMD.
All AMD had going for them at first was price and 64 bit computing. Now Intel can match them across the board (except price, but whats $20 difference between "competing" chips?).

by ohm.paul

Yea I have always favored them, I suppose just cause they were the underdog. But back when I started building PC's, I would always go AMD (Athlon XP baby) cause, yes, they were cheap. My most recent laptop purchase was an AMD actually...and it's not doing all that great, sad to say.

But in this case, it's not even much cheaper, so I'll be sticking with the reliable one. Thanks for the tip.

by hal 9000

No one has ever been fired for buying the product and it just works though it's overpriced compared to the competition.

The other side of the coin is that everything is compared to Cisco as the Standard to see how they compare. Some are easier to setup but I've yet to see any comments that imply anything is better from a reliably point of view.

IBM has some really Cool Blades and a excellent Pricing Option. Things like a 2000 CPU Blade and only 3 wires coming out the back they look so neat and tidy then the price is seen. But they do work well and are a joy to play with. :D

Col

by ohm.paul

The Cisco ASA 5505 is about a fourth of the price of the 5510, (5505 - ~$600, 5510 - ~$2400) and looks a lot different. Is there a large difference between the two models? I would imagine that if it is that much more expensive, then it would provide much better security. The 5510 is certainly within our budget, (the budget for this whole upgrade is in the $10-15k range) but if it doesn't add much, then there's no reason to spend the extra $.

I was planning on setting up a RAID5+1 setup with 5 hdds with the main HDD being backed up on the second HDD (RAID1 mirror) and the following HDDs backing up the rest of the files on the server with RAID 5. If this is within our budget, do you recommend against it?

Thanks for the advice
Paul

by ohm.paul

Are there any network management softwares that would be recommended for my situation? I've always been skeptical of these pieces of software, but are they recommended for such a situation?

This discussion is closed to new replies.