Question Locked

Raid or not, 1,5,10

0 helpful
7 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

I am trying to figure out how to make my system run better. I have a Quad 4 Duo processor, 8 gigs Ram, 512mb video card. 2 250gig hard drives. Windows Vista 64bit extreme.
I am not seing a difference between my last system and this.
I do run som Cad programs, And art work stuff, I was told that I should go with a Raid 10, with 4 500gb hard drives.
Is it really worth it?
At the moment my drives are ATA not Raid configure.
Thanks

7 replies

by Former member

If you want a mini server then go for a raid10, but if you go this route then hotswap drives are a must, the last thing you need when a harddrive goes down is to POWER down just to swap a harddrive in/out.

by sebastian zdrojewski

You can always start with RAID 1 with 2 drives, and if your controller allows it you can add drives in future and extend your RAID 1 drive to a RAID 10 one (scalability).

RAID 1 and 10 has much more performance compared to RAID 5, so if you need high throughput on the disk subsystem, you for sure need a top-performance subsystem itself (starting with a good controller and disk drives). If you need *really* good performance, well... maybe you need to consider SCSI disks instead of SATA (for example if you are going to work with 3D rendering or video editing).

by reb00t

I would use RAID 0 (stripe) if you want speedier disk access, but don't care if you lose your data due to a failed hard drive. I would use this on a machine that's easily rebuildable.

I would go w/ RAID 10 (mirror + stripe) if you want speedier disk access and you want data redundancy. Cost is obviously 2x that of RAID 0 due to needing a second set of disks.

Also, your RAID controller will play a big part in what you go with. Personally, I like RAID 10 if you have a good write cache on your RAID controller if you do lots of writes to disk. If you want even better redundancy, use 2 seperate RAID controllers in your server/workstation and have one array going to one and the other going to the other RAID controller.

by kgwagner

RAID is for hardware fault tolerance, not performance. Regardless of what the marketing weenies and gamers will tell you, there is almost never any performance benefit to a pure RAID 0 array, which would be the only one where it would be possible. On desktops, the benefit in performance rarely exceeds 3% to 5%, and is often zero or less. Artificial benchmarks will tell you different, but reality is where you live. On top of that, a pure RAID 0 array will double your chances of failure, in which case you lose all data.

If you feel your rotating storage is a bottleneck for you (and it always is), the only way to improve it is with faster drives. Currently, the highest performers for desktop usage are Seagate's 7200.10 series, and WD's Raptors.

It's likely that even with your improved hardware over the last machine, you lost some performance by using Vista. It's more of a massive application than an OS, so it's a tad resource-hungry. As a result, you're just breaking even in performance.

by bata212

Thanks everyone for the replys. Beside performance i wanted to make my hard Drives dual boot. With all the Software and Hardware that Vista Doesn't support I need to add Win. Xp.
Thanks
Bata

by reb00t

RAID 0 is always faster than a stand-alone drive. Why do you think databases like SQL and Oracle recommend it so much? With disk I/O, RAID 0 will ALWAYS be faster than RAID 5 or RAID 1 or any othe RAID level.

Personally, I use RAID 10 for the speed and fault tolerance, but I completely disagree w/ you on the point of RAID 0 giving no performance.

This discussion is closed to new replies.