Question Locked

RAM Recognition

0 helpful
7 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Hello folks. First time poster. I'm having a RAM issue with Vista. I have read all of the information about how Vista reports RAM, reporting 3GB or 3.5GB or so when 4GB are installed, etc. However, I think my issue is a bit unique. If not, I'd like some further clarification.

I currently have 3GB of RAM in a test system. I upgraded from 1GB when I installed Vista. I have 2x1GB and 2x512MB. Vista only shows that I have 2GB of RAM. I had been concluding that it was a result of kernal utilization, etc. as had been reported on numerous websites. However, it shows 2044MB of RAM on the system, and something kept bugging me at what a convenient number that was. So, I pulled the 2x512MB out of the system and booted back up. Windows report on RAM...2044MB. So, Windows sees 2GB of RAM if I have 2GB of RAM in the system, and 2GB of RAM if I have 3GB of RAM in the system. BIOS shows 3GB, Crucialscan shows 3GB, cpu-z shows 3GB, but Vista and a few RAM utilization tools I downloaded while trying to figure this out, all show 2GB of RAM. Can anyone offer me any insight into this, or tell me of a tool that will report all RAM alocation, so I can test further? Thanks in advance.

7 replies

by hal 9000

This would probably be the best place to ask any Vista Related questions as most of us haven't had much experience with Vista as yet and I for one am planning on keeping things that way. I got caught with XP when it was released and don't intend to repeat that fiasco.

http://tinyurl.com/yt8adb

This is a M$ Hosted Site and while it is owned by M$ there seem to be a lot of End Users attempting to help other end users sort out the problems that have been introduced with Vista so you may not get an answer and have to resort to ringing and paying M$ Tech Support.

Col

by thechas

While you think this might be an OS problem, there could be other causes.

I think we should start with details of your system. Make and model of system and / or motherboard.

Details on the RAM modules you are using.

Any other hardware detail that might be unique or pertinent about your system.

1 thought is RAM speed differences.

Another is that Vista may be reading the upper RAM as operating marginally, and blocking it out.

You could also be impinging upon RAM addresses that the BIOS locks out for system functions.

Chas

by thephpdeveloper

Im not sure. but from what i know, different systems display different values based on the programming. For example, your BIOS might show 512MB, some other BIOS might show only 448MB. And then your OS says you've only got 440MB of RAM.

by sleepingghost

First off, what board are you running in this Vista-based system? Secondly: How much RAM is 'on' the video card(s)? It seems that all versions of Vista include the on-board RAM in video cards as total RAM in the system. God help you if you're only rolling with 32-bit Vista...

Say for example you have 2 of the 8800 GTX installed in your PC: Vista Ultimate 32-bit version will read only 2.5 gigs more. I just built a C2Q system for a client and first had four 1GB sticks of OCZ Platinum - then we tried the Corsair XMS in the ASUS stryker board... BIOS would recognize the 4GB but once you popped into Vista... 2.5MB of RAM were recognized...

It took a week of dicking around with the system to come to the conclusion that Vista was reading the on-board RAM as well... This might be the problem.

by bbizzle1

Well, I found out what the problem is. Unfortunately, I own a Dell XPS600. With this, and virtually only this, specific model, which uses an apparently Dell modified nvidia chipset, the motherboard will only allow a 32 bit OS to recognise 2GB of RAM and a 64 OS to recognise 4GB of RAM, even though the BIOS will see and support up to 8GB of RAM.

by thechas

I suspect what you are seeing is not so much a limitation in how the RAM is used, but differences in how the RAM is being reported.

Many chip-sets do have limits as to how much RAM they can use in 32 bit mode. The upper limit is seldom more than 4GB. Even then, not all of the 4GB is available to the OS as some of the upper RAM space (up to 1GB) needs to be "reserved" for system resources.

In a similar way, the 4GB versus 8GB for 64 bit mode also makes sense. 8GB of 32 bit memory will effectively be 4GB of 64 bit memory.

Chas

This discussion is closed to new replies.