Discussion Locked

Reckless IT gets you Life in Prison Now?

0 helpful
3 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Last Tuesday, the House Judiciary Subcommittee on Crime revised the Cyber Security Enhancement Act expanding who can get life imprisonment for a criminal technology offense. It was an 8-0 vote. Previously, it stated that offenders must "knowingly attempt to cause death or serious bodily injury" through electronic means in order to receive life imprisonment. Now if offender "recklessly" puts a person?s life at risk they will receive life imprisonment.

Get the original document here:
http://216.110.42.179/docs/csea.smith.amendment.022602.pdf

So, can this be taken too far? Will our jails fill with IT types who are not threatening to society and yet we as taxpayers will have to pay for the additional expense this entails? Will it makethe internet a safer place? If you do not report a threat such as a dDos attack or virus that is then launched against a hospital which renders someones ability to get proper care and they die is there potential litigation? i.e. will it be considered "reckless" to use a system besides MS or to have an open mail relay in the future?

Is anyone concerned or particularly happy that this was changed? This seems like a major event to our profession and yet it doesn't seem to exactly be the talk ofthe town..... What do you think?

3 replies

by ptw

Don't you think that people using systems upon which others' lives depend, should be accountable for any neglect of that responsibility?
If a hospital worker ignores company policy and introduces a virus, and this leads to the inappropriate care of a patient, to use your own example, why shouldn't they answer for that?
It is too easy to forget what is at the other end of the cables- many people do not just work on an isolated computer system, and people's lives do hang in the balance of the correct use of many systems.
Planes, trains, hospitals, oil rigs... so many systems are dependant on computers, that users of the relevant systems should be just as answerable for people's safety as the pilots, drivers, doctors and so on. They should face the justice system if their actions result in a negative result.

by admin

Yes I do think that people should be held accountable for their actions. Definately. Life in prison for someone who deliberately assists in killing with technology and is putting society at risk because they may do it again is a good idea in my book. However, did Kevin Mitnik's crimes, for example, warrant life imprisonment in retrospect? Is it worth overcrowding our jails more and paying for putting people away for life when they have made a technical mistake either intentially or without intent or possibly even without any malice?
Drunk Driving and killing someone will probably get you less than life and yet inadvertantly messing around on the internet may now get you this?
If hospitals put their patients at risk by sloppy internet policies and procedures then they should be accountable for their choice of using a worldwide vehicle for business.

If a hospital chose to drive their ambulances on roads where people were unlicensed and there was no internationl standard of conduct, I think they should be accountable for this decision. This is why most businesses choose strong protection for any internet traffic and rely on private networks for the stuff that really matters. It is a shame in my mind that IT people would make such poor choices as to put people in harms way and then blame others for their problems. I think that especially Microsofts poor coding practices and aggressive marketing of technically inferior products has had a lot to do with creating this problem. I do think that people should be held accountable, but that it is just, equitable, and a lot cheaper on the taxed wallet to make sure that the people or organizations causing the problems are the ones held accountable and also that the punishment is suitable for the crime.

by generalist

A lot depends upon the definition of recklessness. If a person writes a virus and ignores standard security measures, allowing the virus to get out into the 'wild' where it hurts someone, they are reckless and should be charged with a crime.

Butwhat if the IT person for a small organization fails to install the latest and greatest security measures on the systems they manage, allowing the systems to be used for an attack that harms people? From a pure security standpoint, they are being reckless. But they may be running into a problem of not having enough resources to keep the systems functional for the organization AND apply the needed security measures. Would they be considered reckless under the law if they chose functionality over security?

Things could get even more interesting if the IT person goes on vacation and leaves the systems in the hands of someone that knows the basics of managing the systems but doesn't know all the tricks for discovering unusual events likean attack. Is the IT person being reckless in this instance?

Hopefully the definition of reckless won't be too extreme. I'd hate to have to spend all my time keeping track of security measures while the definition of reckless reaches higher levels.

This discussion is closed to new replies.