Question Locked

Replacing hard disk and effect on drive letter allocation and applications

0 helpful
7 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

I've a Win 2k pc. It used to have one hard disk, then I added a second. When I added the second, I wanted to put the OS on the second disk. The way it turned out, the newly added disk was given subsequent drive letters to the original. So, my original drives C and D (one disk formatted into 2 drives) stayed as such, my CD and DVD drives stayed E and F and the new disk was divided up into 3 - G H I.

When I loaded the OS onto G, all applications referenced this as the root drive when setup. I now want to get rid of my old drive which shows signs of failing, but I don't want to have to reinstall my OS and applications. If I remove the old drive and put a new one in, what will happen to the drive lettering. Most importantly, if my G drive is given a different letter, will this have an adverse effect for applications which expect to find needed files on the G drive, when they are in fact on a differently lettered drive?

I'm wary of just removing the old drive only to find applications don't work. What is the best way round this, if I'm right in guessing that it would be a problem.

Thanks

Chris

Anyone able to help please?

7 replies

by thumbsup2

You're right in guessing that it would be a problem. You're in trouble.

Basically, by installing your OS on drive G, you have guaranteed failure if you mess with the drive sequence. Even IF you manually assign a drive letter to that drive so that it would always remain that drive letter when you remove one of the others, IF you remove drive C, you WILL experience problems because it can't FIND C.

You should ALWAYS install the OS at the root (drive C) and use the other drives for other programs and data.

I think the only way around your problem is going to be to remove the old drive, let the system assign the new drive letters on reboot (hopefully the one with the OS gets the C designation), then reinstall the OS over the top of itself to reset the paths in the registry. Then, you'll need to reinstall all software to reestablish THEIR paths.

Frankly, if it were me, I would back-up all of my data, f-disk and start over with a clean install. But, that's up to you.

by ashij

Further to ThumbsUp2's suggestion, can I suggest an "in-place" upgrade. This should fix all references.

Ash

by c_j_m

thanks for comments and suggestions. Looks like I'll have to set aside some time to do a complete reinstall of the OS then.

I'm wondering, though, what is an "in place" upgrade and how would this apply to my situation short of my doing a complete reinstall of OS and all programs?

Would I just reinstall the OS then see if I could access individual programs and upgrade them, at which point I make sure the root directory is correctly referenced? If so, sounds like there might be a risk of some programs working like this and others not. Also, might I not get a messy situation if I then tried to uninstall programs that I couldn't do an inplace upgrade on, where automatic uninstallation failed because of the changed root directory reference?

by ashij

Ok, Let me ask you on question, have you tried taking out the hard-drive out yet?
Microsoft states that statically assigned hard drive letters DO NOT change, and are not affected by any additions/removal of drives on the computer. If you can boot into your current partition on G: and all your programs are install on the same drive (or reference to it). Then you should be ok. If this is not the case, then please specify the problem, along with any error message that you might encounter

Edit : I was thinking something else of the problem.

Ash

by c_j_m

Ash,

I haven't taken out the problem hard drive. Before I do this, I want to make sure I'm taking the best course of action. Also, I'll need a quieter period to do it.

I note what you say regarding Microsoft indicating that drive letters don't change if 'statically' assigned, when drives are added or removed. Could you clarify what is meant by a 'statically' assigned hard drive in this context. Are we talking of any drive letter assigned to a hard drive with Windows 2k as operating system?

Finally, could you let me have a link to where Microsoft states that assigned driver letters do not change so I can read around the issue a bit further

Thanks for your help.

Chris

by ashij

I kinda had a hunch You'd ask the question (microsoft:static drive)

I forgot exactly which links.. I had marked two but for got was working on friends computer.. so here is one that i found:
http://tinyurl.com/y8ewdc

This should answer both your questions

Edit: There are other methods as well (registry), but that depends on your comfort level

This discussion is closed to new replies.