13 replies
by danielt17 Accepted solution
by m61 Accepted solution
as it's just being used so all 12 computers can share one internet connection, that should be fine, but if you are doing some advanced routing, then you might want to look at something a little bit "bigger"
also, you might have to make sure that all the computers keep their virus definitions up to date and same with spyware
by michael kassner Accepted solution
Are you going to use the wireless? If so you may want to get a wired router and an access point. That way with SOHO devices you maybe able to better serve that many users.
If you are locked into the price bracket of a WRT54GL, that model would be the best 802.11b/g Linksys device as it has more memory and better hardware than the other Linksys routers. I might suggest the Buffalo routers as well, reason being is that you can then install third party firmware such as DD-WRT on some models of Linksys and Buffalo routers that will enhance the router's abilities. If one of my clients demands to use this class of router, I strongly suggest that they get one that will allow DD-WRT.
http://www.dd-wrt.com/wiki/index.php/What_is_DD-WRT%3F
Now that I have said that there is one 802.11n router, the Nfiniti by Buffalo that is what I personally use right now. It is exceptional and fast. It also allows 802.11b/g clients to work better with the multiple receive and transmit paths
Too bad you could not extend the contract on the WatchGuard though as that is a great device.
by danielt17 Accepted solution
The reason I'm looking into switching routers is because on the Firebox X15, only certain local IP addresses can access the internet. For example 192.168.0.3 can access the internet and local network (server, printers, files etc.) while 192.168.0.5 can ONLY access the internal network. I've seen no pattern and it drives me off the wall. lol
I've looked though all the settings, manual, and I've even tried to call WatchGuard tech support but they keep wanting me to purchase a contract even though it expired like 1 month ago.
The old tech guy that I replaced is no longer available. And it's really frustrating.
There is no need for wireless, and the last thing I want to support is people who do know how to use wireless internet. I'm dealing with people who think their computer crashed when all they have to do is turn on their monitor.
by michael kassner Accepted solution
I would be curious to see what the route print looks like on that computer as well as the host file.
I guess I would still recommend those two brands as DD-WRT is a very powerful firmware even if you do not use the wireless aspect.
I just always like to try and convince people to use business class devices as they just work better and bother you less.
by michael kassner Accepted solution
Hello Daniel,
I was curious about the config file. You asked about 192.168.0.3 and0.5 in your first post, but the Firebox DHCP server starts at 0.10.
Also the Firebox has three interfaces? Exactly what are 0.X, 2.x, and 112.X for? Also 112.X does not have a DHCP server setup for that subnet?
by danielt17 Accepted solution
This is odd, lol. The admin before I set up a DHCP server on the firewall even though we use static IPs for everyone in the office. I am currently set at 192.168.0.3 (get internet access), while 192.168.0.5 does not get internet access.
192.168.0.X is the local network for all the computers.
192.168.2.X is the connection to the Bell Router. (yes, we r using the Bell SS6300 router. The router/modem acts as such. It is configured for some reason with two levels of router-ness. (router at the bell modem/router & at the firewall.) This is all the workings of the previous admin.
192.168.112.X is the optional network. we are not using it.
Regarding the Bell Modem/Router. I put in an order for the MODEM only. So by the end of this week that silly Bell SS6300 is gone. And if worse comes to worse, i will just reset the router and configure it from scratch.
by robo_dev Accepted solution
My opinion is that you would be going from an Acura to a Kia. Linksys stuff is OK for SOHO gear, but WatchGuard is more like Cisco than most of the smaller players.
I've never found a lot of stability in Linksys gear. I would look at some of the other mid-tier players like sonicwall or even Netgear first.
by jdclyde Accepted solution
and would recommend the sonicwall, hands down.
I have had the watchguard for 4 months now, and it sucks ass.
By default, it does NOT allow windows updates, even though ALL pc's on the LAN have FULL internet access.
The interface is not something you can just sit down and use, quite unlike the sonicwall.
It MIGHT have more options, but for usability, I can't WAIT for this to end of life out on me! Maybe a good lightning strike or something.....
Oh yeah, you pay for support, and that ALLOWS you to call them UP TO three times a year? WTF is THAT about? To make matters worse, when I DID have a problem, they assigned a tech in a different timezone, so I had to wait three hours for them to call me back in the morning, AFTER the four hours they give you to take your friggen call in the first place.
Watchguard sucks, both the product and the company supporting it.
by dumphrey Accepted solution
is that the linksys will not perform as well as you hope. Though I do very much agree with the wired router wireless AP set up.
Another thought is to build the "router" using IPCop or Smoothwall (very easy to do).
Any old computer with 256 MB ram will work just fine (I am using a 266MHZ pentium with 2 ISA 10 Mpbs lan cards). All management is handeled through a web page settings manager only available on the LAN, and password protected access.
Both can handle 3 network cards, LAN, WAN, DMZ/Wireless/Network2.
An old computer, a wireless AP, and a linksys 16 port passive switch... I think you would be quite happy with the results.
by danielt17 Accepted solution
The network is very small. Only 12 computers (not even) and they are not all on during the same time. I don't even have a rack mount. I also have very limited space for the server area. It is shared with the Sharp photocopier, folding machines, fax machine and the room is smaller than a prison cell.
What do u guys think about the Linksys WRT54GL in my current network environment?
by dumphrey Accepted solution
with what we end up with :)
very few of us have the luxury to choose exactly what we want.
If YOU like the WRT54GL, then by all means use it =)
I see no problems overall with it, you may need to reboot it more then your current box, or maybe never at all. But thats life ]:)
And besides, in the long run, if it becomes obvious its not going to work, you can replace it with an IPCop box.
by danielt17 Accepted solution
This discussion is closed to new replies.
Trending Networks posts
Sort by Trending