Question Locked

Routers and Share folders

0 helpful
16 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Hello all. This is my first post here. I hope I'm putting this in the right section... Anyways,

I have 2 computers. A desktop PC and a laptop (XP and Vista in that order). My set up involves 2 routers. One that connects all the computers in my house via ethernet cables to the internet. We'll call this router 'Main'. Also connected to Main via ethernet cable is another router which provides wireless connectivity to all the computers in the house.

My problem is I'd like to be able to share files and folders between my laptop and my desktop. I've assigned both my laptop and desktop a workgroup name "Workgroup" but they still cannot see each other. How would I be able to make it so that the computers can reach one another and transfer data between them.

Thank you very much,
~C

16 replies

by animatech

Running IPCONFIG /all are you on the same network and subnet?
Did you checked that only 1 router is running DHCP ?
Also check the router firewall and make sure it is not blocking communication between you wkst's

by 1bn0

You will get a more detailed answer.

My first question would be why are you using two router devices. If the Wireless router also has wired ports just use it and eliminate the wired router.

If you need to use both you may be able to configure the wireless router as a bridge instead. This will still require it to be configured so the setup is compatible with the the wired router.

Brand and Model information might get the attention of someone familiar with your equipment or someone may have time to do a research into your problem for you if they know what equipment you are talking about..

by c-sinner

Ok. Sorry it took so long to reply.
The first router (the one hooked up to the internet and is NOT wireless) is a D-Link DI-604

The other is a Linksys, 4-port with 2 phone port router (RT31P2). It is NOT a wireless router but rather a Mac airport is attached to it. (I didn't know this until today. I just recently moved in.)

The reason for the messed up network layout is because the landlord owns the main router and doesn't want us playing with it. The second router is simply attached down from the main router. The Airport provides us with wireless connectivity.

I've found out that my laptop (connected wirelessly) can ping my computer (wired) but my computer cannot ping my laptop.

I've been looking at static routing tables, however, looking at the D-Link router's manual (downloaded online) it gives a different screen from the actual router screen.

(Dunno if we're allowed to post offsite links but...) in the manual: http://www.dk-tv.dk/Admin/Public/DWSDownload.aspx?File=Files%2FFiler%2FDi-604+manual.pdf

Under the Advanced > Routing section there is a pic of the Advanced section having 7 sections including "Routing". But in my actual routers display there is only 5 or 6 sections and none of them are Routing.

Are static routing tables what I'm looking for? The idea of making the Linksys, a hub sounds really good. Will that work? How do I set it up?

by 1bn0

I don't play with Vista but your problem sounds like it is a firewall coinfiguration issue with Vista. Search the forums for related posts.

If your laptop and p.c. can both reach the internet then I beleive the firewall is the problem. Vistas default security is much more closed than previous versions of windows.

by c-sinner

I've tried pinging my vista laptop from another laptop connected wirelessly to the same router.

I could ping my vista laptop from her laptop. However going back to my vista laptop I can't ping her laptop. To top it off I also can't ping her laptop from my main computer.

Any ideas?

by cg it

I'm amazed at the # of people who go out and get 2 routers and have no understanding of networking, then wonder why doesn't it work.

2 routers = 2 networks. If you have 1 computer on one network and one on the other, traffic back and forth between the 2 must flow through the WAN port. WAN ports are protected by the build in firewall.

forget the trouble, get a wireless access point

by c-sinner

While I do appreciate any recommendation I assure you that I do not have 2 routers for the sake of making my life difficult.

As I stated earlier, the router is maintained by the landlord with NO wireless connectivity. I cannot replace the first router.

While I do not claim to be any kind of networking guru, I certainly wouldn't say I have no understanding of networking.

Windows XP firewall is disabled. The Vista firewall is also disabled. Furthermore the router that is connected to the Airport has it's firewall disabled (The only router who's WAN port is between my computer and the laptop). Lastly, your firewall theory does not explain why my friends' laptop can ping the other from the same wireless access point, but I can't ping my friends'.

Thanks for your post but as I said it is not possible for me to replace one of the routers. So if someone wants to tell me if I'm barking up the right tree when I say static routing tables, that will be splendid.

by cg it

This was your initial question:

"I have 2 computers. A desktop PC and a laptop (XP and Vista in that order). My set up involves 2 routers. One that connects all the computers in my house via ethernet cables to the internet. We'll call this router 'Main'. Also connected to Main via ethernet cable is another router which provides wireless connectivity to all the computers in the house."

"My problem is I'd like to be able to share files and folders between my laptop and my desktop. I've assigned both my laptop and desktop a workgroup name "Workgroup" but they still cannot see each other. How would I be able to make it so that the computers can reach one another and transfer data between them."

If one of the routers is not available to you, and one of the routers is your router, connect all your computers to YOUR router [assume "your" router has a built in 4 port switch as well as wireless capability].

Once "your" computers are all on the same subnet, you'll be able to share files and folders between your computers.

This is the simpliest way in which to share data between your computers.

by churdoo

I've read the entire post and I think I understand the setup. Hoo-boy and I've said many times, that our jobs would be sooooo boring if not for the personalities we have to deal with.

Your first problem is your router. I understand how your landlord has the place wired all to the one router. Taking the wireless devices out of the equation for the moment, any of the wired ethernet devices should be able to share files with any other, as long as firewalls are disabled (or at least exceptions checked for file/print sharing), and you've run the handy-dandy Home Network Setup Weez-ard.

Now the wireless. Your problem is that you have the airport hooked into the LAN side of your linksys router. I'm not sure if you're using the linky router with the phone adapter for voip phones, and if you are, leave it assuming that part is working. However for the Airport, it should NOT be plugged into the LAN side of the linky router; find an unused landlord-wired jack to plug your Airport into and your problem goes away (same comment above applies for firewall settings and Home Network weez-ard for wireless lappys).

If you are close after the above but still no cigar, then the only remaining thing to do will be to be sure that you are using matching username/passwords on all of the machines that you're trying to share files amongst.

One last suggestion, albeit not really significant, is to use a different workgroup name than WORKGROUP. WORKGROUP is a default used by many other devices and may cloud the waters a bit by trying to network with others in the same building.

by c-sinner

I see what you are saying now. I didn't specify. All the wires have been run through the house to each of the rooms in order to provide a wired connection to every room. To wire each computer to the one router would require rerunning these wires, which the landlord will never agree to, or else leaving long exposed wires everywhere, to which the residents (myself included) would never agree to.

I do understand that this is the simplest solution, but if I were looking for the easiest solution I would not have turned to the vast wisdom that could be provided to me by tech republic.

Thank you for your input, but I have already considered this possibility and rejected it out of hand, due to the overhead, and general lack of elegance in this solution.

by sgt_shultz

"I have already considered this possibility and rejected it out of hand, due to the overhead, and general lack of elegance in your post"

by 1bn0

You may be able to configure your router as a bridge to the rest of the network.

Check the manual. Page 24.

Diable NAT, this will also disable DHCP.

NAT acts as a firewall between the Internet port and the LAN ports. You are already inside the router connected to the internet so you shouldn't need this.It will prevent the other computers in the house on the main router from connecting to the machines on your router.

I would suggest you use DHCP on thte internet port but the wa y the manual reads this gets disabled along with the LAN dhcp server.? shouldn't be related. LAN side is local server, WAN side is client to "internet", in this case the Main router.

If you can't use DHCP on the "Internet Port" set it for an unused address in the same range used by the Main router.

You might need more info but I can't think of what right now.

by cg it

you keep adding in more complex parameters to your initial question as each person submits a suggestion.

Junk!

by animatech

I have just made a list of your problems:
You can ping your PC from your laptop.
You can ping your PC from your friend laptop
You can ping your laptop from your friend laptop
You cannot ping your laptop from yor PC
You cannot ping your freind laptop from your PC
You cannot ping your friend laptop from your laptop.
You are running Xp and vista.
I also assume that you have checked and there is only 1 DHCP on the network (You have access to the landlord router i hope)
And that all IP & Subnets are correct.
Looking at this I would say that you have 2 problems.
1st is with your PC ? since at any case you cannot ping from the PC I would have check firewall (wkst and both routers ? pay attention to any access list).
2nd (which will not be the problem once you have solved the first) is why you cannot ping your friend laptop.
Going back to static routes I dont think this wil help you if you cannot ping each other then setting static routes wont help you (Connectivity is the 1st thing to resolve).
If I may ask what stopping you from taking the wireless router and conneting it to the point at the wall next to your PC then connect your PC to that router via the wire port and then testing if all is working.
Better then that you can eleminate things by just pluging your PC to the wireless router (Without pluging this router to the landlord router) and then checking that you can ping each machine if yes then problem is with the landloard router if not then problem is with your router.

by c-sinner

Thank you for your very helpful reply. I've got some hints about what else may be wrong from your post. I'm going to try a few things, and I'll post if I'm still having trouble.

Thanks again!

This discussion is closed to new replies.