Question Locked

Routing

0 helpful
10 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

I am trying to add static routes on a Bloomberg terminal(that is on a 10.50.x.x subnet) so that it will route to certain networks using a certain default gateway. It needs to use this particular gateway so it will use the route going over the dedicated T1. Right now, it is going over someone else's T1 and they want us off of it. I tried adding the following route as requested by the network admin:
208.134.161.0 MASK 255.255.255.0 12x.12x.52.22
but it failed with "the route addition failed: Either the interface index is wrong or the gateway does not lie on the same network as the interface. Check the IP Address Table for the machine". Does anyone have any ideas as how we can get this to work?
Regards,
Gene

10 replies

by synner

Where are you applying this route at? Applying this route at the bloomberg terminal does nothing for you, since the bloomberg terminal only knows how to send traffic to the subnetwork that it is on or the default gateway. When you try to apply this route on the bloomberg terminal, you would get some response in the way of "no route to host" which is what the error you get is telling you. This route needs to be added at the router that is directly connected to 12x.12x.52.22 and then redistributed it back into the network if it needs to be.

by robo_dev

That might explain why a static route might be needed.

But it would make more sense to add the route in the router....unless the network admin is somewhat 'IP Challenged'.

by gkscala

I am trying to apply that route on the boomberg terminal, but that was my understanding as well, that the gateway address must be reachable on a locally connected network for a static route to work.
Let me give you more information. This is a quote from our network guy about the 12x.12x.52.22, "It is the External Feeds Firewall that you need to go to and it is on our private network. If you are unable to add a static route to point directly to that Firewall, I don't know how we are going to get this to work. Unfortunately the default routes on the network all point to our user Internet firewall". Also, he is telling us that he cannot add another static route because there is already a static route for another business unit that routes over the 12x.12x.57.0 network, so that's why we need to add it to our bloomberg terminal.
Thank you very much for all your help,it's greatly appreciated.

by synner

http://webpages.charter.net/abaddon/bloomberg.jpg

Because I'm really bored today...

Now... assume your network looks like the diagram in the jpg in the link above for illustration purposes.

Because your bloomberg terminal subnetwork is attached to Router R1 which is attached to an internet facing firewall, you need to add a route for the 208.134.x.x/24 on router R1 towards the external feeds firewall. On the external feeds firewall, you need to add a route to that subnetwork towards R3 router and on the R3 router, you need to add a static route to the same network towards the far end. The other end needs to add routing to your subnetwork as well.

You will be in a world of hurt if your network guy doesn't know what he's doing and from the sound of things, he doesn't know what he's doing.

by gkscala

I meant to reply to you SYNer, but I wanted to thank both of you for the great information, suggestions and help!!

by cg it

I think what the network guy is saying is just add a static route to the first hop router. From there, that router will forward packets on to the next hop and so on.

The gateway would be the routers interface that the bloomberg connects to which from the diagram is R1 [which should have an interface for the 10.50.X.X subnet]. R1 then forwards to the next hop router, which seems to be either R2 or R3 from the diagram. Either path must go through a firewall. If the firewall won't allow the traffic, then well he's screwed if he can't reconfigure them.

by gkscala

Thank you very much to all of you for the excellent information and assistance. I suggested that we put the bloomberg workstation on the 12x.12x network and he agreed with that. Dont ask...

by mpeters

how do you handle redundency, what if the curcuit goes down, how do you fail over a backup router

This discussion is closed to new replies.