Question Locked

SHOULD an administrator 'spy' on employees by logging in as the user

0 helpful
54 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

I have tried to search around here (and Google) for the answer but failed. And I really need this answer if possible, please.

I know that as an Administrator of a small network myself, I can log into another user's account and find out exactly what they have been doing on the company computer. What I don't quite know is this - how ETHICAL/LEGAL is it?

Personally I would not do it as there was no reason to, no hint of wrong doing etc. But I was told another Administrator was asked to do this to the other Administrator, and of course didn't like having to do it.

Should they have done it, or should the manager have asked them to do it? I am in Australia so I am not sure if the law would be different here.

The manager is not an IT person, and may not know the ethical issues involved. And as I am still studying, I am unsure either. So I thought I would come to this great place and ask what you think.

I would appreciate an answer very much. Thank you!

54 replies

by wizard-09

No it's not illegal to access someones computer on your network I.E work network if your the administator, i would say that you should not do this unless you are investigating something or someone.

You should also have a legal notice when they sign into the network that they have no rights ect ect google network logon notice.

by aussie gal

Thanks for this answer. The interesting part is that it is the Administrator that the other Administrator supposedly 'spied' on, that is supposed to actually write the policy. There is no legal notice about what is and is not allowed. And I think the worst this Administrator was doing was chatting only in their brief lunch break, but again there is actually not even a policy saying that chatting/emailing is not allowed either... yet.

We are a very small NGO and are in the middle of writing up the IT Policy. I just find the thought of logging into another Administrator's account without any reason to suspect any wrongdoing (porn etc)... distasteful. And it opens up a can of worms, since the 'target' is an Administrator, if the users don't know this could happen....

That is why I am interested in hearing all opinions on this matter. Because I know this happened, but I do not know if I should approach the Manager and discuss my concerns - at least not without finding out where I stand first. I am a VOLUNTEER so... I have a bit more freedom than workers, but still...

The manager had asked for and received ALL the user's passwords, but swore they would not be used. IF they have been used to spy on another Administrator....

Is there a need for Administrators to have user's passwords, when they could easily just reset them???

Thanks heaps for this.

by wizard-09

No matter what passwords should not be given to anyone, not even your manager or co workers lets put it like this.

If someone knows your password they use your account and mess up or hack some part of the system and are using your network ID your going to get the blame for it.

If a admin needs to login as another user he must 1st tell the user the password is being reset and that he will be accessing the pc (If the person is not being investigated.

If one admin is spying on the other then something is going on i would take to your manager about this, if i was the other admin i would not be happy.

by oh smeg

By handing over the User Passwords the Manager themselves can now be accused to placing things on the system and can be libel for any wrong doing.

There is never a need to Secretly Log into a Terminal without the End Users Knowledge for the Average System Admin. Even when the End User requests this to occur they will just hand over the Password and if the system is working correctly the System Admin will Log in with that. Personally I find that I don't remember what End Users Passwords are the moment that I have entered them and that can be for something as simple as a Data Entry Persons Terminal to the Companies Bank Account Access on the Owners system. Most of the time I just don't want to even know what the Passwords are to begin with but am forced to ask for these during the course of my Job. I always suggest tot he End User to Change their Password after I leave or finish the job for basic Security. This is for those not on a Domain who generally speaking own the Business in my case but for normal End Users I reset the Passwords and let them enter what they like.

However from my limited experience if you really want a end users Password most times all that is required is to lift the Keyboard and look at the Sticky Note either stuck to the Desk or underside of the Keyboard. I tell them not to do this but they continue to as well as use the same password that I suggest that they change after I finish.

The Conscientious of Opinion is that if they can not trust me they shouldn't be doing whatever it is that they are doing and I don't like it one little bit but as they say you can only lead a horse to water you can not make it drink.

When I need to consistently Log in and reboot whatever I write the password down on a piece of paper nd shred it when I'm finished the job if it is a short duration job that will only take a few minutes like maybe 45 minutes if it is any longer I just disable the password as I find it a nuisance to my work constantly needing to enter a Password on every restart.

But in a case like this the Manager and anyone else how is given the Password/s can be accused of placing things on the system if this hits the Courts. It will be impossible to prove who is responsible for placing anything on the system at all under those situations and the Company will loose any case brought against. It will also show a culture of inappropriate behavior to the Courts who will award Damages accordingly.

Col

by aussie gal

I am glad to get you online, as this really helps me.

Problem is that it is the MANAGER that 'asked' the Administrator to spy on the other Administrator. And it is the Manager that 'asked' for the passwords.

Thank you for this information, it means a lot. As the IT policy will be discussed at the Management Committee Meeting, I intend to point this out. And I will also quietly suggest to the staff that they all change their passwords and don't tell anyone.

I am very grateful for this, thanks.

by dr dij

'spying' on them. It is simply pointless, and worse destroys the integrity of your system.

For spying on them you would not need their account password at all, only to access relevant logs and monitoring software. And this is called monitoring, not spying, since any employee or admin should expect that data on a company system could be monitored.

Logging in as someone else violates the ethic of holding admins accountable for their actions. If someone else can login as htem then that means they MIGHT NOT HAVE COMMITTED any particular act that shows up in the log. So someone might use logins to frame them for a malicious act.

Since another admin can do anything the orig user can do there is not the slightest reason to login as the other admin except to commit crimes to implicate the other person, fake transactions, etc.

you could setup logging on sept machine to insure integrity of logs.

As other posters have said, in general it is better to reset passwords if lost rather than keep them. That way if the person asking for password is not correct person then next time correct person trys to login will regain control and that would be noted.

This isn't as far out as it seems. Do you know personnally everyone who might ask for password? In our case I worked for a company that supported clients at other companies logging in to system. I sure as heck have hard time authenticating that they are who they say they are. Therefor resetting password is much better than storing it, with inherent risk of master list being stolen, read.. At the other companies, when a password was 'lost' it generally instead meant some new user was now incharge of the data access / maint.

Resetting pwd means that previous person no longer had access that they should not have anymore.

by wizard-09

Glad i could help you out a little, good luck with it.

by oh smeg

There is no way yo expect Privacy of an Individual Users Account or actions.

Personally I wouldn't have a Problem with looking at the general things but I wouldn't draw the line at looking at what are obviously Personal E-Mails received at work.

As I'm in Brisbane the Law here is the same for both of us and this is where things get fuzzy. Some Places like QANTAS attach a Footer to every E-Mail that they send which says that they are intended for the recipients eyes only even if they are sent to a Work E-Mail Address this sort of applies. It really depends on what if anything is found in E-Mails like this. On occasions I have had to access a End Users Computer to get some information for either the End User themselves who are out of the office or for their employer when the End User was at a International Conference.

If you look specifically for what was requested there isn't a problem but if the person looking opens every e-mail or whatever and goes looking for anything just as a Fishing Expedition that is wrong. It is sometimes necessary to look for genuine Business needs and as such you don't need to go digging around for the fun of it. After all I don't have the time to waste just looking anyway for the fun of it.

However if there is a Genuine Legal Need to do this for some claimed Illegal Activity you will breach the Chain of Evidence and anything found will not be considered as belonging to the person under investigation. For instance if someone was assumed to be downloading Kiddy Porn on a Business Computer and you go looking in Court it will be argued quite rightly that the person who went looking and found such & such planted it there to frame another and the person who goes looking will be considered far more likely to be Guilty than the actual user who may have been responsible for it being on the computer to begin with.

If there is any possibility of Legal Action you should drop everything and call in the proper Authorities to investigate the system and it's contents. When they give Evidence they are considered as [b]Expert Witnesses[/b] unlike a Local Admin who has complete control over what ends up on the individual or complete system. So as you will be a Suspect it is better not to go looking to begin with.

Depending on the organization there should be strict Guidelines in place for reporting any potential activity that can harm the Business or is blatantly Illegal to begin with. As we are not Experts in what Constitutes Pornography or Kiddy Porn we should not be involved in looking for this type of thing or unnecessarily accessing systems just because we can. If there is a Genuine Business Need to look at a individual system you have a right to look but not a right to blindly examine everything that is stored on the system.

However if you are instructed to look for something not directly Business Related you should cover your A$$ and get the Instruction in Writing so that when called to give evidence or be Interviewed by the Authorities you can quite rightly point tot he Written Instruction and I wasn't looking for anything I was instructed to have a Look see and this is what I found. While it will not cover you fully it will at least help to Mitigate the concerns of what you have done in doing your job and show no Intent.

Col

by aussie gal

Thanks! I was born where you are hehe.

The problem is that the Manager did ask the other Administrator to have a look around, FISHING. There was nothing to find, but there is emnity between the Manager and the 'target' Administrator. The other Administrator did log on and left the Manager with the computer, as they were too ethically challenged to do more.

The Manager has no idea about Ethics as far as computers are concerned. And this is what bothers me. I feel like she might ask this person to do it to me (nothing to find) or others, and it is just an invasion of privacy.

As I said, we are a very small NGO, right in the middle of building the policy. And I just find it offensive that the Manager logged in on a fishing expedition, hoping to get the target in trouble. There is no question about porn etc, just that 'oh you chat too much' when they only chat in their lunch break, and 'you answer personal email' when there is no policy against it etc.

I just feel like everyone needs to change passwords and we Administrators refuse to give it to the Manager. The Manager is not IT literate, and has proved they will log into your account to spy on you if you have done something to upset them. That's just an abuse of power, IF this happened. I am going to do checking tomorrow to see for myself if the Manager did in fact do this.

I hate this kind of spying in such a small organization that up until recently was a family....

Thanks heaps for your input :-)

by oh smeg

The down side however is that those who do it are leaving themselves and the Company Wide Open for a massive Court Challenge and loss when someone complains.

I have seen cases where the owner also a female will alter the Windows I'M to send copies of all communication to them as well as whoever is on the other end of the line. They have done the same with E-Mail so they get to read everything that is done relating to IM & E-Mail applications. I find it disturbing when those involved in this do it for nothing more than their Own personal Titillation or self gratification but maybe that is just me.

Justice Connelly however has spoken to me on this issue and confirmed to me that it's wrong and is a very dangerous thing to be involved in. Perhaps you should talk to Terry O'Gorman. I would suggest contacting him through the Civil Liberties Association or what ever it's called now rather than ringing his offices where he is a Barrister and ask for direction here. Either Terry or Ian would be better to speak to rather than me as they know the Law in far greater detail. After all that is what they do for a living and both are highly competent and quite approachable from my experience.

Personally i prefer talking to Terry but that's a very personal thing as once upon a time when I had a Life and went out everywhere I went I would bump into Ian and his wife or his entire family. I had to warn him that if he didn't stop stalking me I would have to seek relief from the court's. :D

But both are very friendly and quite approachable if you get them outside of their Legal Practices.

Only possible down side is if you know the Law it may get you into trouble when you refuse to do something that is Blatantly wrong. These people who do things like this don't worry what is right or wrong or even know most of the time but they do take it personally when they do not get their own way or end up costing the organization that they work for lots of money.

In QLD Health I have seen some higher up Bureaucrats ruin a perfectly good investigation because they believe they know better and will do as they think right. This has always resulted in the wrong thing happening and the guilty party doing as they please to the determent of all others. This type of person fails to comprehend that they are not the End of everything but just a cog in the entire machine and go crazy with what little power they do have allocated to them.

It's one of the problems of working at a small organization where some more senior people are scared of their staff and constantly try to find reasons to have then stepped upon to advance their own positions. When it happens it's no fun and if these can be pulled into line places like this can be a real enjoyment to work at.

Maybe you could suggest hiring a very Prominent Barrister to advise on the Legal Aspects of the Computer Usage Policy so that the company doesn't leave itself open to Litigation if some one is unhappy with the goings on of all people at this place. You or at least the company needs to ensure that what they come up with is actually Legal and enforceable.

However if someone was to want to look at what I did on one of these computers they are welcome to as far as I'm concerned as I never do anything that could land myself with problems. Though I would be very uncomfortable if they where to access a Sensitive section of the business after I had worked there when they have no right to access that area. Things like accessing the Companies Bank Accounts/Records or Staff Review Forms and things like that would make me very unhappy and less likely yo return there if a breach like that was allowed to happen. Doesn't matter if it's the owner but when they are only an employee there and they start to get into the Owners files and things like that I do have to step in to improve Security.

Also if they left this person to dig around they would have left tracks and if the Admin in question is any sort of an Admin they would know already. Generally speaking doing things like this are not Legally Wrong unless you sneak around and employ Subterfuge to try to hide your actions. That is where the real problems start and the possibility for Litigation against the company begins.

Cheers

Col

by tony hopkinson

However, log on as them. How are you doing that?

If it means you know their password, then all your investigations are meaningless. All hey have to say is you did it logged on as them and you're near f'ed.

by aussie gal

I *thought* the person who logged the manager in as the other administrator, was themselves an administrator. However, on logging into the server today, I discovered the person that was forced to log the manager in, has the passwords, but is NOT an Administrator. So for the manager to get another user to do this... not happy.

Myself, I would never do it. Especially since the 'victim' is actually an Administrator.

I am trying to figure out how through Windows Server 2003, I can find out when a user logged on, if logging was not already set up??? I need proof this happened, though the person who did it, all but admitted it to me.

This is just dirty business, that is why I need other people's advice. And I appreciate it all very much.

by tony hopkinson

Depends on where they did it from. When 'they' logged on as another user, it would have created them a profile.....

by aussie gal

There was never anything to find anyway. It is more the manager having a problem with the administrator, and wanted to find evidence against them. All that could be found was chatting in lunch time which is allowed, and so is emailing.

Today I told everyone to change passwords and do NOT tell anyone, not even the Manager.

Should the Manager be an Administrator? They know NOTHING about computers, and if they are this paranoid, they could log into the server. And if they want to shut down the computer.. they would 'shut down' but that would shut down the whole server!!

This is just so complicated, but I appreciate everyone's opinion, thanks.

by larryd4

No matter where you work, no matter the attitude of IT in the organization. You have to respect the trust the user has, that his logon, as long as the user is compliant with policy, has some semblence of privacy.

Most companies have policies protecting both sides of the coin. Our policy is explicit and vague all at the same time, but it is a work in progress. See below.

====================================================
III. No Personal Use/No Expectation of Privacy

Users are advised that computers, computer networks, E-mail and other electronic communications systems and all communications created, received, stored on or transmitted through these systems are Organization property. Accordingly, users shall not use these resources for personal use and have no reasonable expectation of privacy regarding this equipment, networks, systems, or these communications and are advised that the systems and their communications are subject to monitoring and interception by management. While the systems may contain passwords, locks, encryption or other security features provided to users, users are advised that these security features exist to protect the Organizations?s business interests and not to protect a user?s personal use of a business resource.

IV. Routine Monitoring and Systems Maintenance

Authorized information technology personnel may access or monitor computer systems, networks, internet access/use, electronic mail, and other communications created, received, stored on or transmitted through these systems only in the course of system maintenance and repair, and only for purposes of assuring system performance and security or detecting breaches of that security. Any violation of this security policy discovered during such routine maintenance and monitoring shall be reported to the Administrative Director and the user?s immediate supervisor.

V. Non-Routine Monitoring

Approval to access or monitor the computer systems, networks, internet access/use, electronic mail, and other communications of a user may be granted by the Administrative Director for any legitimate purpose, including but not limited to, the following circumstances:
? In the course of asserting a claim or legal defense of the Organization or a Organization employee in a civil action or administrative proceeding;
? Investigations of allegations of employee misconduct or violations of the law;
? Investigations of abuse of Organization resources;
? Investigations of breaches of security; and
? When a user is unavailable and the Organization must conduct business. Verification of a user?s unavailability is required. In this instance, management should attempt to contact the individual and inform the individual prior to asking the Administrative Director for permission to access the individual?s computer files.

VI. Information Sessions/Training

All authorized Organization users shall be informed or trained on this policy and its importance.

by aussie gal

Thanks for your post. I find that policy very interesting. That is what we are trying to do now, formulate the policy. But if the Manager themselves abuses this policy by having the Administrator spied on... hence the problem.

I am going to discuss this as a meeting tomorrow so I need everyone's opinions and appreciate it. You guys are cool :-)

by jck

A) If the manager is not the IT Manager, that manager should not be ordering around IT staff to do things. If they are an executive above management level, then they should go through their subordinate or the executive overseeing IT function.

B) I think it's unethical to just "spy" on a user, unless you feel there are possible legal, moral, ethics, or policy violations. Just reading their email because you can is not right to me.

C) If another manager is ordering around IT staff without authority to do so by position in the corporate structure, then I'd go to the IT manager. If they are unaware, inform them. If they are aware, doing it to make sure shows you care about your boss and them not getting end-arounded...if done and said right.

by aussie gal

The problem is there is only one Manager who knows little about IT. The person who was spied on is effectively the IT Manager lol, and I am the IT Volunteer. (Staff is very small.)

I think it is all about control and power.... I totally agree it is unethical, and the person who had to log the manager into the administrator's personal account, is having their own serious issues about it.

I am just lucky I am in a position to do something about this, once I fully understand what the right thing is. I am learning a lot, thanks to everyone here.

by jdclyde

First, is there are reason you suspect the employees?

Second, is the suspected activity SPECIFICALLY listed as a "no no" in the computer use policy?

Third, what does your boss think of this activity?

Very thin ice to walk on, make sure you CYA at all times. If YOU log in as others, YOU could be breaking the policies AND/or invalidating any potential evidence as they can claim you did the activity when YOU were in their account as them.

by aussie gal

I might have been misunderstood, but I am the other administrator, that would never do this to anyone. It is my fellow Administrator, who is the IT Manager that is the victim of this. And just a staff member, that the Manager forced to do this, so I was told anyway.

There is no policy yet, we are writing it. There is nothing saying the staff can not chat during lunch, and email during lunch. That is all the administrator was doing. So yeah, there was absolutely nothing to find.

The sad fact is, it has more to do with the ill will between the Manager (Director of whole small organization) and their subordinate IT Manager, than anything else.

It is the boss that had another user do it. And it was another user who logged in as the other Admin, not me. Though I am concerned my account could be compromised as well. what is to stop the Manager doing it to anyone?

If the Manager asked me to do it, I would say NO. But since I am a volunteer, I don't have a job at stake. I do understand the user who did it though as they had no choice.

I just need to find the proof, because the IT Manager only works certain days. So how can I find out (as I am still a student about to study Bachelor of IT) when someone else logged in as them the day they were not there?? I can't do anything without proof...

Thanks for your thoughts :-)

by jdclyde

If this is a Windows desktop, something as simple as looking at the Event Viewer will show if they system was active at that time, assuming the ADMIN in question has his system off when he is gone for multiple days.

Off the record and off to the side, you can inform the Admin of what you suspect, even if you have no proof to back it up. That will at least allow them to keep from being blindsided, and allow you to sleep at night.

Other than that, try to stay out of it, if at all possible.

Good luck with that.

by boxfiddler Hot topic

should do whatever s/he needs to do to maintain a secure network. As long as what s/he is doing is legal, and within company policy.

by aussie gal

I believe that the Manager had the user log in as the Administrator's personal account, in hopes of getting 'bad' stuff on them. There was nothing to find. And it is one thing to have it done against just a user. But to do it against the IT Manager?????

by boxfiddler Hot topic

who better to take down an entire company, costing how many people their jobs?

by nationjd

If an IT administrator needs to check anything out on the account, he can usually access it by logging in as administrator and be able to check what files are on the system.

Also, if the IT administrator needs to login as the user/client he could in all actuality reset the password from the domain controller on their account. This other administrator/ manager is wrong for having the other employee's passwords, and should of course be audited and asked why he has them.

by aussie gal

It is the Manager who asked for the passwords and was given them... despite my and the other Administrator telling them that it is dangerous and being 'promised' they would not use the passwords.

I have, as I said, today told the users to change their passwords and tell no one. I will get in trouble for that, but I do have power to protect myself and the staff....

The thing is, right now I only have the word of the other Administrator that this happened, however, the 'user' who did it, seemed to allude to the fact that they did something they didn't want to do.. which makes me think, yes this did happen.

I just need to know exactly where I stand so I can try to make things right.

Thanks for your post.

by .martin.

as the computers belong to the company, the IT admins can do that if they want, but i know I, and a lot of people on TR would not do this under an circumstances (except when the police come knocking on the door)

by aussie gal

This is just a very complicated thing... I would not do it at all either, but I am a volunteer so I can't be forced to do it.

*was in Melbourne last month for an IT conference hehe*

Is there any where on the Net where I can get definite efforts about the Ethics of this? I do not want to show the Manager this... as I don't want to get in trouble for what I said. The IT Manager/Administrator said things that the Manager didn't like, and this is what happened...

Thanks for your answer, appreciate it.

by .martin.

that I can think of, ethnics is a hard thing to pin down to one set of rules.

ethnics depend on country, time, ect.

by tig2

While I think that the jury is somewhat out on the ethics of this situation, there is nothing illegal happening. The business workstation is the legal property of the business and everything on it belongs to the business.

If you have a Use Policy, it should spell out to end users that they do not own the computer and should not have anything on the computer not work related. It should also define what, if anything, is tolerated. For instance, your company may allow employees to surf on their lunch hour.

If you don't have a formal Use Policy, suggest to your manager that you create one. Without it, I would question why he is having Administrators logging in to User profiles. Short of looking for porn on the hard drive, nothing he finds would be useful to him from an HR perspective. He wouldn't be able to take disciplinary action, for instance. If he did, the employee could conceivably go after the company for unfair dismissal.

In order for inappropriate use to be a reason for dismissal, the employee would have had to be provided with a written policy and, in many offices, signed a statement acknowledging that they were provided with a written copy, and that they read and understood it.

In the same position, I would respectfully request that the manager ask someone else as doing so is, in my opinion, a moral issue. But if I was the only one available, I would do it. The workstation is not owned by the user.

by aussie gal

It is complicated because there is no policy right now. Also, as I hope the Manager will never come here, I will be blunt. The organization is run by a Management Committee of which I am a part. The Manager is employed by us just as everyone else is. And the computers belong to US, the Management Committee....

I have to report to the Management Committee if I have proof that the Manager did this, because I do believe it was done to try and get rid of the IT Manager.

The Manager is new, and the other employees were allowed to chat and use email... and there is no written policy against it.

The problem is, we deal with people with mental health issues, and there is a lot of confidential information. If the Manager will do this to spy on the IT Manager/Administrator, would they also look at other confidential member information they should not see... see THAT is an even bigger issue that has to be considered.

So yea, it might not be illegal, but I believe it is immoral and unethical.

by oh smeg

Looking at client Data without reason is Illegal. Using that Data for any reason not connected with their direct job is Blatantly Illegal and there are stringent Penalties in place to dissuade those who would breach their Trust.

Centerlink has been terminating employees who access client Records for 5 years now and for the last 3 there has been n active Investigation and Criminal Actions taken against those caught in Exceeding their Authority or doing what they shouldn't be doing.

Under the QLD Health Act there are also severs penalties for accessing Patient Data without a Valid need to do so for the benefit of that Patient/Client. This action alone could place this Organization in severe trouble if it was to occur so it is Vitally Important to get Legal Advice on what is and is not acceptable.

Col

by oh smeg

As this is in Toowoomba sort of east of Brisbane on the Darling Downs or at least just the top/other side of the range where they are located NSW Law isn't any use here.

While they have a reasonable free hand with QLD Law what is being asked here may be in Violation of Commonwealth Law.

Anyway after reading what is actually happening here if nothing else anything found is useless in any form as the person doing the looking seems to have a vested interest in finding issues and they would be accused of inserting them there if push came to shove because of the way that they are doing things here.

At the very least if things go sour it's going to cost the company and the person involved quite a lot of money as there is no way that they could Defend if any form of Litigation was started. Sounds very much like very poor management control is being placed in Place here and the person demanding this level of access is running riot out of control.

Col

by rob miners

as they haven't been invented up here yet. :p

Those laws were passed in 2005 so it will probably be another 17 years before we see anything like that. ]:)

I know that when I was administering a network I knew everything that was going on with the users. I never logged on as the user though. Administative accounts should be kept to a bare minimum, we actually shared an account and it is a practice that I have kept up. It is all based on trust and if you can't trust the other bloke you will end up in strife. I think that the manager should have had the balls to confront the other bloke. Nothing like getting it out in the open.

by aussie gal

I will 'out' myself lol and say I am Secretary of the Association that employs the Manager. I only became aware this was happening this week, and I was outraged. I have notified the other office bearers, and will be bringing this up to the Management Committee tomorrow.

This answer is very helpful thank you, because you have no vested interest in saying the manager is out of control. I agree. I am just so lucky that I am in a position to stop this now. I believe in getting as much information as possible though, that is why I asked here, and I am so grateful to everyone.

Thank you. Wish me luck tomorrow lol.. I will post tomorrow night on what happens. Your opinions have really helped me a lot.

by oh smeg

Though it will probably be closer to 50 years before those QLD Pollies get their act together and actually pass some useful laws.

You should know the old saying when you visit QLD from anywhere else turn your watch forward an hour and your calender back 50 years. :D

Th Borg is way to interested in Playing Political Games and so is the other side so any useful legislation will be a very long time coming after all they are more interested in fighting over water fluoridation, recycled water and dams then really addressing the really important issues like Data Security. :)

But the described situation sounds very much to me like what happens with Bureaucrats who are involved in Empire Building. They just drive me nuts so I try to avoid them whenever possible.

Col

by rob miners

I've seen it go to a few peoples head over the years when they have been given a position of Authority. And I really am glad that I don't deal with Bureaucrats anymore. ;)

by aussie gal

They can empire build all they like. They are just as much employed by me (as a member/secretary of the committee hehe) as the other staff members.

I just can't confront the Manager without independant proof. I don't want to say the IT Manager/Administrator TOLD me, because they are too much of a TARGET already.

We have Windows Server 2003, but I don't know if we had logging enabled, so I can prove what date/time the user's account was hacked into...

Any ideas? Please be gentle, as I said, I am a student hehe

by aussie gal

I am getting driven nuts by this but at least for once I am not powerless lol.

The problem is that the Manager knows nothing at all about IT, so they may not know what they did was wrong. They will find out though.

by aussie gal

I do agree with your answer though hehe. I should have said the Manager is a woman just like me, sorry. The IT Manager/Administrator that is the victim, is also a woman. (Yes we do have men on staff too hehe).

I agree that things should be out in the open, totally.

by aussie gal

I got paranoid as I realized that I used my email address as my user name. And given what is happening to the other Administrator who is the IT Manager, I hope you guys and any gals can understand :-)

by oh smeg

The Bots roaming the Net picking it up and flooding your In Box with Spam.

The majority of us here just couldn't be bothered looking anyway and as no names where mentioned there is little Likelihood of this being picked up on a General Web Search.

Basically it's quite safe. :D

Col

by aussie gal

I was just too lazy to create a user name so my user name was my email address. But as I said, I was being paranoid lol.

I am an Aussie gal anyway so... I love your user name.. OH Smeg rox.

by oh smeg

It may be worth a talk to either Terry or Ian for their advice. Both are very knowledgeable on issues like this. :)

Col

by aussie gal

I have a phone phobia though hehe but if I can find proof this was done, I will suggest this to our President... thanks.

by aussie gal

Thanks so much for this. I agree, that is why I have told the users to change passwords and not to tell anyone, even the Manager. I have to ask the Committee for permission to remove the Manager as an Administrator, because they know NOTHING about IT and if they did think "I have to shut down" and hit shut down while logged in to the server management.. they would shut down the server.. big mistake.

So yeah, thanks heaps for this.

by oh smeg

If Client Records where accessed and a complaint by a Client was made you would have the Feds paying you a visit for this Breach as it is Federal Law not State Law.
Having been through this previously I can assure you it is not something that you want to experience.

We imported some Measuring Devices for some Cosworth Racing Engines and had the Feds pay us a Visit. They came in with Full Body Armor and weapons drawn because we Imported some Precision Measuring Equipment that didn't have a Metric Scale on it. Personally I do not want to see what they do when there is something several Times worse happen.

They are not people to upset and I do try to avoid them at all costs. Generally speaking they are not Nice People to have to deal with as they seem to think the worst of you and you have to prove yourself & company Not Guilty to a much higher standard than a Court would require. When you where like us and actually in breach of a new law that we had no knowledge of it's much worse.

Apparently by importing Measuring Equipment that lacks a Metric Scale on it the Feds see this s akin to an [b]Act of Treason[/b] and behave accordingly. Mot something you really want to undergo I can assure you. :)

Col

by oh smeg

Though my Alter Ego HAL 9000 is also another Nice Name to go with the Nice Person that I am. Just watch out for airlocks unexpectedly opening as you walk past. :^0

Col ]:)

by Member 19291532

Indicates that this is an issue that is potentially very risky and that varies a lot by jurisdiction.

I would talk to your company's legal team, HR or a lawyer and define a policy specific for your organization and location. Even then, it might not keep you out of trouble, but it certainly couldn't hurt to be able to prove that you exercised your due-dilligence before taking action.

Generally speaking, I try to dissuade department managers from requesting us to look very deep into user's accounts unless there are clearly grevious violations going on. Being an HR/Corporate police officer is not part of my training and not something that I want to have associated with IT duties, roles and responsibilities.

Now on the other hand, I think there are some admins out there that *relish* in this kind of role.

by rob miners

Unfortunately unless you know the date and time that this event happend and if the User wasn't actually using the account on that particular day you won't gain very much. If it was a successful logon using the Users credentials it will show as event ID 672. Having said that and the User was in Brisbane on that day then it is obvious that someone used those credentials. Here are a couple of ideas for future reference.

Audit Account Logon Events

http://technet.microsoft.com/en-us/library/bb742435.aspx

How to track users logon/logoff

http://support.microsoft.com/kb/556015

By the way welcome to TR. The best support/information site on the net. ;)

This discussion is closed to new replies.