Question Locked

Spanned Volume on Raid

0 helpful
3 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Hello,
I'm setting up a NAS device (Windows Storage Server 2003 R2 x64) to use as a file server.

The machine has 5 750gb drives setup in a Raid5 configuration. Because of the 2tb limit when using MBR formatted drives I had to create two virtual drives: one of 1tb in size and the other was 1.8tb in size. Obviously these show up as separate drives within Windows.

What I really want is for all this space to appear as one drive. I know one is option would be to convert both drives to GPT drives but for internal reasons I cant do that. So, what I was thinking was that I could convert both from Basic to Dynamic disks and then create a Spanned partition across both. This would seem to solve my problem.
My concern, however, is that this setup (with the spanned partition) would somehow come back to bite me if/when one of the physical disks failed.
One part of me feels that since the underlying setup of the disks is Raid5 that if one disk fails it will keep running like it's supposed to and I can replace the failed disk.
The other part of me wonders if a disk fails if somehow this will corrupt the spanned partition so that all the data on it has to be restored.

Anyone doing anything like this? Any problems? Am I going about this the wrong way?

Any help/suggestions would be appreciated.

Thanks.
RobinH

3 replies

by churdoo

The underlying hardware RAID simply appears to the O/S like a physical disk, so were you to proceed with the spanning, I would expect that if there were a disk drive failure, no corruption would occur, and you could replace the failed drive, as in any other RAIDset.

However, any mfr RAID documentation I've ever read has said do NOT convert a disk that's sitting on a hardware RAIDset to dynamic disk. I have however, seen peeps convert such disks to dynamic, usually by accident, or by trying to do something they shouldn't have been doing, though have not had a problem running the disk as dynamic disk.

I personally would avoid dynamic disk and spanning like the plague, even if for the simple fact that that's just way too much data to do something that could potentially be unsupported should something go wrong.

Can DFS help you instead?

by rhailey

Churdoo,

Thanks for the response. I had seen some of that information regarding dynamic disks on hardware raid as well.
But, I also found a TechNet article that seems to suggest that the setup I was considering is ok. If you're interested, the article is here (link may wrap):

http://technet2.microsoft.com/windowsserver/en/library/d1d1cb92-8221-4156-b6b3-13953ec506341033.mspx?mfr=true

Also, I found an article on the Dell site (my server is a PowerEdge) that outlined a configuration very similar to what we're considering.

So, I'm just a little confused about it. I hadnt considered DFS (actually I've never had need to use it) but I will definitely take a look and see if it might be helpful.

Thanks again for your insight.

Robin

This discussion is closed to new replies.