Discussion Locked

Switch hub Vs. Switch backbone

0 helpful
3 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

I am trying to get the pros and cons on the following situation:
My IT department has decided to get rid of a Cisco switch to replace it with a 3com 24 port switch and connect about 20 hubs into the 3com switch. We have our users going directly into the switch now and yes the Cisco switch needs some maintainance and upgrading but has worked well. They want to save money and so they decided to take the Cisco out and replace it with an inferior new switch and install hubs on that switch and thenconnect the nodes to the hubs rather than straight into the switch. We have about 220 nodes and we ran out of room on the Cisco switch.

What impact will this have? What are the pros and cons?

3 replies

by stevef68

Every node that is connected to the same hub will share a collision domain with every other node attached to that hub, possibly reducing available bandwidth on that segment. Luckily the switch keeps all the hubs from sharing the same collision domain(CD) as each port on the switch will actually be a different CD. I am curious what kind of switch the Cisco is to have 220 nodes plugged directly into it?
This is could also make troubleshooting connectivity issues a little harder-if one segmentgoes down, you will have to determine if is the hub, the switch, and/or the connection between the hub and the switch.

by soylantgreen

First off, if your network is 10mbs, forget it. Let em do what they want.
However, if the network is 100mbs, that's another story. If you have all of the nodes running into standard HUBS, then have your HUBS going into a SWITCH you'll more than likely experience a bottleneck issue. If the client sends a request to the server (DHCP, Netware, etc..) and the server doesn't respond within a given amount of time, you got yourself a timeout issue caused by bottlenecking your network into HUBS ratherthan SWITCHES.. I've seen this happen before when the CAT5 wiring on site isn't up to standards. (a given run is longer than 285 ft, etc...)
More to the point: Spend the extra money NOW and prevent these types of problems...

This discussion is closed to new replies.