Discussion Locked

Telling your old boss about a new job

0 helpful
31 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.
Do you agree that you shouldn't divulge information about your new position to your present boss? How have you handled this when switching jobs? Have you ever had a bad experience from telling about a new job too soon?

31 replies

by james r linn

if you are switching companies.

I've always found though that honesty is the best policy - I still have good relations with bosses who I've left, and one even hired me again, after he moved to another firm.

Now internal swicthes are different.When I worked for a large multinational, the rule was that if you wanted to apply for a position in another group, you needed to discuss it with your current boss. In the vast majority of cases though, this was helpful. In the one case where a senior executive just told my boss he was taking me, it caused a rift that never healed - I would have told her, had I had the chance.

James

by oskiller

Like he said, I would wait until I had started the new job to tell them where I was working. You do have to put in notice etc, but you do not have to tell them where you are working. I never experienced a problem, but I have seen it happen before.

by njaneardude-30601088

I got three calls in one day from three different agencies for the same job! They all asked if I had a clearance and I said no, but one said that would be no problem. She offered me the monster pay, the called back in a week, told me I was skilled for a higher job and offered me insane drooling pinch me pay. She asked if I would take the job, said yes, she said I would have to start following week. Told the boss, he was upset, but no problem. Next day, she calls back, two more weeks, tell boss, no problem. Calls back, or did I call her, one more month, tell boss, no problem. Then I inquire about the clearance situation and she said there maybe a problem.
Five months later, still shmucking it behind the same desk, waiting for a clearance to come through with current boss, then I hit the road running, and he is aware of that. In fact, he is trying to be nicer, sweeten the pot and everything...

by svrarvind

Hi,

Do not tell your employer where you are going.If you want to share it do it after a week or so.

by svrarvind

Hi,

Do not tell your employer where you are going.If you want to share it do it after a week or so.

by svrarvind

Hi,

Do not tell your employer where you are going.If you want to share it do it after a week or so after you have joined the new job.Make sure you have a written statement from your new employer about your job.

by svrarvind

Hi,

Do not tell your employer where you are going.If you want to share it do it after a week or so after you have joined the new job.Make sure you have a written statement from your new employer about your job.

by david adams

This is a question I've considered in the past. What if your current boss doesn't want you to go, and does something to sour your relations with the new organisation? Often you have to give references from your current employer, so the chance of keeping your boss in the dark until the deal is finalised are zero!

by jmhe1

Your new employer, if decent, will not contact your current employer until after you have started your new job. Legally, your current employer cannot do anything more than confirm that you were employed there and when.
You may wish to disclose that you are or are not going to a competitor depending on whether you want to finish your last 2 weeks or get walked to the door. If you get walked to the door, your current employer should still pay you for your last 2 weeks.
I have heard of a person whose job move was torpedoed by the executives of the current employer calling the executive of the new employer.

by jduke22

I would try very hard not to give out that information. I have seen supervisor's try to let you go sooner or maybe even fire you. I have also
seen supervisor who will drive you crazy asking questions.

by wrlang

I've seen literally dozens of cases where old bosses and co-workers have bad mouthed people to their new employer. I don't even tell my buddies where I'm going until well after I've started a new job. There are many people out there that aren't mature enough to understand what can happen to the people they bad mouth.

by cberding

I've worked in industries where the competition regularly snatched people from other companies. They pretty much forced people to tell them where they were going, or risk being let go that day (since they assumed that's where you'd be going).

It really depends on your situation...

by jang1108

Years ago I had an experience where my boss was promoted and they hired a replacement for him. This guy was an incompetent jerk. Without going into details, he fired me without cause, then another guy, then the company wound up firing the entire department. Besides myself, six good people lost their jobs because of this jerk. Meanwhile, I had been getting great interviews, but no jobs. I suspected this guy was sabotaging me, but I couldn't prove it. Well, in the end this jerk got fired along with everyone else. A week after he was fired, I got two job offers.

This might be coincidence, but I doubt it. It also doesn't relate directly to this article, but it just goes to show that you just never know about some people, so I definately feel discretion is the the wisest choice.

by iisguru

I had this instance where my employer was a huge establishment with several I.T. departments and I was in one of them. I switched over to another wing as a consultant. My old employer did not know for at least a month after I joined the new position. She did try to jeopardize my prospects there. However, I had already established myself and so all her efforts went in vain. I will never divulge on my own for at least a month or two.

by rpecaut

I had been looking for a job both directly and through a placement service. The placement service asked for a list of places where I had already applied and if any of the companies I visited seemed interested. I answered that there was one that showed interest and answered several followup questions. Several days later I received a call from the company, but not to offer me the job. Instead, they were wanting to confirm that I was a reference for a person that I did not know. It seems the placement service sent another applicant to interview for the job I had located and gave my name as refering this person to the company.

by azaria elburg

There are only a few reasons why coworkers or employers would want to know where you're going.
a. Genuine interest in a friend's life.
b. Thinking maybe they can also go there. It must be worth your while, otherwise you wouldn't be going. So maybethey can also better their situation by following you? Or maybe even instead of you...
c. Maybe they DO hate your guts and will try to ruin it for you before you actually make the move.
This can be because of something in the past or even just thefact that you are leaving "now". It is never a good time to have a team member leave.
d. Sheer gossip interest. It would make a nice subject over lunch in the cafeteria. "Say, did you hear Joe is going to work for Xyz?" Would put them right in the center of things.

In any case. No good can come of telling. Either they can wait a few weeks until you have settled down in your new position, or if they are very eager to know right away, it is pretty sure they fall into one of the less pleasant categories above.

Since there are reasons for keeping it for later and no reason I can see for telling in advance - the answer is very simple. Don't tell until you're moved!

I dare anyone to suggest a good reason for others to need to know where a person is going. So that the person moving would actually benefit from telling.

by rawbit

The best way is to give a little information and see what the response is. Say something like, "I am working for a large manufacturing firm on the east side". Most boss's after that would be too embarassed to ask what the name of the company is, andit should be openly obvious that you don't wish to give the actual name. If the boss still asks the specific name, it looks unprofessional, and should make you more on your guard about revealing any more information. If he doesn't show any curiosityat all, you can decide based on the reaction whether it is safe to offer more information later.

by road-dog

where you're going. If you can get a new position without a contact with your present boss, then great. Once you've put in your 2 week's notice, then your supervisor has no right to any information relating to you other that settling your affairs with the company.

Keep them guessing, you might get a real sweet counter offer.

If you are leaving due to conflict with a present Manager, tell him that you would discuss your reasons for leaving with HR or IT Executive only.

by kentb

I'll go Nicks advice one better. He said not to say anyhting for a week or two after starting a new job. I say wait at least 30 days (the usual probationary period) if ever! It's none of their business where you go or what you do after you leave your old job. Why give an employer ammunition to use against you (if they are that kind of employer)? And don't think your current employer would never do that to you--you just never know until something happens!

by james r linn

But I've had some good bosses, and I wouldn't do anything else but be honest with them. I haven't had a bad boss in a while.

As a result, if they have moved on to other positions, they think of me when they have an opening. I doubt they would have done so if a) I'd been evasive with them, or b) they couldn't find me.

Its important to network. Its certainly helped my career progress.

James

by the chad

Where you end up working is none of their business.

Maintain contact for networking purposes, sure -- that's what email is for. Everyone has a Yahoo/Hotmail/whatever account or can get one.

However, business is business, personal is personal, and "e'er the tween shall meet."

by pnmiller

I agree don't tell the old boss where you are going. You'll know if you are violating conflict of interest clauses and can let your old boss know that much.

Let the new boss know that you're not telling the old boss. In this day and age if youaren't relocating to another country - chances are that the old & new boss are members of the same professional organization - and the new boss may assume you've let it be known let it be a part of casual convesation with your old boss.

I told mynew boss "I am a very valuable member of the firm in my previous employment. While I would like to think that we are all professionals, there may be some dissapointment at my leaving thier firm and I can't predict how they will respond. I will letting them know that I am leaving but I will not be letting them know where I'm going to. I know that you will appreciate my position"

The new boss not only appreciated my honesty - but told me some horror stories of their own!

by charles.bosse

How do you answer your potential new employer when he asks you your permission to call on your references? How do you tell him not to contact your current employer. Not sure how you get around that. If your boss wants to torpedo you, that would be his perfect opportunity to do so when the new employer calls for references on you. I certainly would not tell co-workers, but it seems like it doesn't matter whether you tell your current employer or not--because it's out of your control because of the verification of references situation. Any comments?

by jang1108

... as a reference, and explain to your potential new employer that you do not wish to jeopardize your current position. They should understand.

by jdietz

I have witness this twice. Once a programmer told
everyone about his new job. The owner of the company called the new boss and delayed his start
date and the programmer did not find out about it until the very last day. If he wanted to start off on the right foot, then he had no choice but to stay the extra week.
The second was when I interviewed for a new job and my supervisor found out...They were cutting back and guess who ended up at the top of the list.
Oh! one more if that is not a enough!
My partner got a new job and on the last day, I got called into a office and asked if anyone was
trying to steal me away. I told him no, but due to
my very very long drive each dat (87 miles one way), I would have to consider any offer.
Well, being honest was the wrong thing, It took
a whole year to re earn the lead position on the team.
Bottom line. Take care of your life, your career,
no matter how nice they treat you..once your gone
your get blamed for any errors anyway. That is SOP!

by smmurphy

My first question to you would be: Have you received an offer or are you 'just looking' at a possible change.
If you are at the point in the interview process where the new employer might contact your supervisor for a reference, I think that it would be a good idea to give the boss the heads up. It will go a long way toward maintianing the relationship and a future network contact. However, this could be a problem if you do not have a good relationship with your current employer.
In the past(depending on the situation) I have notified select individuals within the current environment that I was looking at other offers. In one situation I disclosed my job search to a supervisor and as a result she ended up coming to work as my peer in the new organization. Then a few years down the road I was her supervisor when she left and I followed her to a third employer because of the open communication that we maintained.
In a separate incident I left a company and I ended up presenting a proposal to a former supervisor for an RFP that I had helped develop before I left. It may have been other issues but it may the lack of possitive communication about my job change that caused my new employer not to get the contract.

by kel

I agree wholeheartedly with Nick. I had one moron supervisor that was jealous and pissed as hell when I left after he had already laid of a bunch of others at SDRC. I had to be extremely careful not to reference this company at all for a long timein my resume as everyone knows that the gumshoes talk to everyone around that company during investigations.

by duke0313

Let me share this. I had an employee give me his two weeks notice. He told me where he was going and what his new job would be. I was happy for him, it was a good move. A good manager should have his employees best interest in mind, many do not. When I discussed his departure with my boss, my boss asked me if I wanted to squash this opportunity for him, so we could keep him with us. We had an existing relationship with the new employer, and very easily could have gotten the offer rescended. Be aware, no matter how big the IT industry is, it can still have a small communty feeling.

by jereg

We never leave jobs because we're happy. Obviously there are problems or else we'd still be there. That said, I've been laid off from jobs I liked and they liked me, it's just that the money was gone. I had no problem letting them know where I was so that if things picked up I could get my old job back if I wanted. (That happened, but at the time I didn't want to go back).
I left my last job because the VP of IT wanted to fire/get rid of everyone on the staff. The network manager and I got along and he knew I was going to leave and why. When I got my new job, he even dropped by to see my new office. And we still talk.

On the other hand, if things are bad, your boss is a jerk, no don't tell them, They didn't do anything for you, so there is no reason to tell them anything.
It really depends on your relationship with your employer.

by brian.kiser

I've told every boss I've ever had about my new job. I've always been a trusting person. I also feel that I do a good job for my employers, so naturally you'd think that they would have no reason to bear ill will against me, right?

Haha.

Honestly, I've had a couple of great bosses through the years, but I've had a couple of real turds as well. One alleged turds' WIFE actually asked me, "Where are you going?" with a smile on her face. Innocently, I responded, and also wished her well, and told her I'd be glad to train anyone she desires, etc, etc. I was trying very hard to be nice and have no bad feelings between us. With a smile still, she said, "It must be nice to be paid to find a job." Confused, I asked, "What do you mean?" She said, "Well, you must have used your vacation days to interview." (She knew I worked long hours (on salary) and had no time to interview during a regular work week. She then proceeded to blast me for being such a "low employee." Then she saidshe was going to call my new boss and tell him what a "bad employee" I am. (Never mind that my work saved them from losing 33% of their income, or about a million dollars, that year.)

And she did. Apparently, she was friends with the CIO of my new company. It's the only job I've ever lost in my life. It was a hard lesson.

So yes, I've shared this information with other bosses since then, but just be aware that YOU ARE TAKING A CHANCE when you do.

-Brian

This discussion is closed to new replies.