Discussion Locked

The behavior of Microsoft is right?

0 helpful
123 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

First of all, I need to say one point about this post. I don't want to set up any flame. I just want to know something, no matter from professional technolgy view, or from ethic view. Here we go.

The day before yesterday, I saw a TV program, on a English channel, which talks about the 'blank screen' plan adopted by Microsoft recently. I had not completely understanded what they say, but one thing I heard is about the privacy, of which I am interested in.

Of course, we are not right to use the pirate version, but the software is too expensive for a lot of people in China. And in addition, can Microsoft use this way to control personal computer or to know your privacy? Is this kind of behavior too much? What do you guys think?

Because the limitation of my poor expression, here are some links could help you to understand. :)

http://www.latimes.com/news/nationworld/world/la-fg-china29-2008oct29,0,3703471.story

http://www.extremetech.com/article2/0,2845,2333057,00.asp

http://www.worldlawdirect.com/forum/internet-law/17761-microsoft-black-screen-plan-china-foiled-u-s-copyright-law.html

123 replies

by boxfiddler Hot topic

that even outside the boundaries of your question, a lot of folks here think that Microsoft is a bully. Among other things.

Too, do not be surprised if a flame fest does, indeed, arise. Tends to happen when discussing Microsoft and ethics.

As far as I am concerned, Microsoft stepped over the line with Digital Rights Management, and Vista hardware requirements coupled with their standard practice of forcing upgrades by halting sales of previous versions of Windows. Once that line is crossed, anything else they do is over the line.
That would be my notion of an acceptable business practice line. Oh, an ethical line.

Hope I haven't rambled to the point of losing you...
:)

by Former member

I like you, you are friendly.

Here is a question, how much is a software of Microsoft in US?

You know in China, a genuine software grnerally costs 1000RMB or more than 1000RMB, that is a juge nomuber for most Chinese.

And does the black screen relate to privacy?

by boxfiddler Hot topic

I couldn't afford MS software if I couldn't purchase it at a significant discount through my campus bookstore.

I gave nearly $300 USD for WinXP Pro several years ago. It was painful, let me tell you.
Windows Vista Business, which it appears I now need to purchase is running nearly $300 USD, too. Again, painful. My pockets ain't deep.

I don't know about the black screen, sorry I can't answer that.

Thank you for the compliment. You're friendly too!

by neon samurai

If you mean where the screen shades in black and all you get is a message windows over it; that would be a security feature. The idea is that Windows detected a program trying to do something suspicious so it's frozen everything before confirming with the user. It could have been done better but at least they didn't do nothing.

For pricing, I've seen a few people get the current local price from Amazon.com then convert that to there own currency for comparison.

by santeewelding

I understand plain and simple.

I won't afford their latest services, either. I paid ~$300 cash for retail XP some years ago knowing up front I didn't own it. It's like my water or power. Sometimes I turn the faucet or flush my indoor plumbing and it's nothing or a disaster. Or a switch and I'm in the dark. Shilt happens.

But the minute MS goes beyond serving me -- turning my plumbing and switches on and off -- I find out where they live and send Guido.

by Former member

you know your words always consume my lots of energy to understand, although the contents are not too much.

$300??? Oh my god!

by .martin.

it normally ranges between $150 (home basic) to $450 (ultimate)

but you can find it cheaper

by .martin.

Now I don't want to start another giant flame like I did with tctucom (now that was a fun few days, wasn't it?), so try to keep you hats on. And I will try to be as unbiased as I possibly can. :D

I honestly think they get what they pay for, with comments like:

"Why is Microsoft automatically connected with my computer? The computer is mine!" - the software that you are running is not though, sure you payed a few dollars for it but it is not a real copy.

"Microsoft has no right to control my hardware without my agreement." - well you have no right to use Microsoft's software without proper licensing.

"If the price of genuine software was lower than the fake one, who would buy the fake one?" - WHAT? how are you going to do that? you want everything free? (cheapo!)

"If, when I'm programing, the computer screen goes black, that will probably cause some important information to be lost," he said. "Who will pay me for my loss then?" - who is going to pay for the loss made by Microsoft? most likely the HONEST people that buy genuine software.

Sure I do not really agree with what Microsoft are doing TO AN EXTENT. Microsoft have an obligation to protect their software from piracy, because in the long run who loses? If Microsoft put their prices up to make up lost revenue, piracy goes up. so the only way to abolish piracy is to make Windows free, but then where will everything go from there?

by Former member

but if genuine Microsoft's softwares only cost 100RMB, instead of 1000RMB. I think all of us will buy them. :) and that will not cause such things.

by .martin.

but there are still a LOT of cheap people. and if they can get something for (in your case) 10RMB rather than 100RMB (if it unrealistic, sorry, I can't find conversions) what do you think they would choose?

Also you have to look at it to the point that Microsoft have to break even, and as most companies hope, make a profit. selling their product for a tenth of the price would result in a lot less profit, resulting in less being able to be produced.

by santeewelding

First, "god", and now, "cause".

Your words consume little of my energy to understand, although the contents are much.

by tony hopkinson

They lose, just another argument for an alternative OS.

They lose not us, at least in the long run.

MS are banking on the inertia they've gained from their market dominance.

As we all know banking is a bit of a mess at the moment. :p

Sticking people with more cost for less functionality is going to go down like a lead baloon at the moment.

Let's get something clear though, leasing the OS and giving MS the right to nose about in your private data doesn't reduce cost, doesn't increase quality or function. All it does is help to maintain the dominance they believe gives them the right to maintain their pricing structure.

by Former member

because you state what I want to state, especially the last sentence.

Sometimes I am very curious how to define and measure the value of IPR. Cost+what?

Yes, MS has right to make own sales strategy, I totaly agree. But here I want to mention: if your price policy is not reasonable, i mean it doesn't conform to the local people's interests or can't maintain a balance which local people are able to endure, someday you will lose this market. Actually, it exists now.
Few people buy your genuine products, because our 'pirate talent' can produce hundreds of thousands of pirate productions. I am not complacent, I just say a truth. This is because MS stupid high price.

by oz_media

Would have a had a field day, especially if I was in one of 'THOSE' moods.

MINE, MINE, MINE, possisive little bitch!

by Former member

this time your post is not long. You know generally speaking, when I find this letters 'Oz_Media' showed in the forum, I will prepare for a bottle of water to read your posts bit by bit. Your opinion is very impressive, especially about politics. Your posts always mix politics, history, and anger, very impressive. I learn a lot from your opinion.

As for the deal, thank you, i think i don't need and i can handle it. :) Merry Christmas in advance! although there is still one month.

by neon samurai

?
I honestly think they get what they pay for, with comments like:

"Why is Microsoft automatically connected with my computer? The computer is mine!" - the software that you are running is not though, sure you payed a few dollars for it but it is not a real copy.
?

I can?t argue with that; you have to have the license. If you agree to the license terms then you pays your money and takes your chances. The MS license clearly states ?we own the software, you get permission to run it but nothing more?

?
"Microsoft has no right to control my hardware without my agreement." - well you have no right to use Microsoft's software without proper licensing.
?

Hehe.. still true. MS offering the software under a disagreeable license does not justify using the software without a license. The user can either choose something else or bend over and smile wide.

?
"If the price of genuine software was lower than the fake one, who would buy the fake one?" - WHAT? how are you going to do that? you want everything free? (cheapo!)
?

I think MS could offer a more reasonable license fee given the amount of margin they must make off each one. Five years of development pays for itself in what.. the first year? More pricing what the product is worth rather than ?what the market will bare? could help the end user but at the expense of the share holders. From the user perspective though, that?s the cost; choose to purchase a license or don?t and use something else. I?m personally in the later group of people happy with something else and existing licenses.

?
"If, when I'm programing, the computer screen goes black, that will probably cause some important information to be lost," he said. "Who will pay me for my loss then?" - who is going to pay for the loss made by Microsoft? most likely the HONEST people that buy genuine software.
?

I?d suspect that if someone is programming, they can manage to understand the black screen of attention and how to work around it. I hear they did fix the allow/deny sensitivity in SP1 or SP2 though. (is sp2 out?)

?
Sure I do not really agree with what Microsoft are doing TO AN EXTENT. Microsoft have an obligation to protect their software from piracy, because in the long run who loses? If Microsoft put their prices up to make up lost revenue, piracy goes up. so the only way to abolish piracy is to make Windows free, but then where will everything go from there?
?

With Microsoft?s chosen business model, they could seek a reasonable price rather than maximizing what the market segment is willing to pay. They also focus on business more than consumers so upsetting the consumer base is less of a risk when the business customers are still willing to pay 400$ per license (business class, none of that ?home? crap). There will always be those who want everything for free but the majority just want quality that justifies it?s cost. Adobe Photoshop for Linux didn?t fail because everyone wants it for free but because the difference between Photoshop and GIMP did not justify the 700$ markup on Photoshop versus GIMP.

by Former member

i know maximizing profit is ultimately aim for a company, but you must think about the realistic situation. Even in Beijing, most people's salary is from 2000RMB to 3000RMB, do you think they will buy something which costs half of their salary?

by .martin.

but a price drop will probably never happen. little suggestion: why not try Linux? It's free!

by Former member

for both of them.
i don't know the cost of producing a software, but the current price is tooooooooooooooooooooooo expensive!

I am basically a technology idiot, I heard of Linux, but it seems that I and my friends surrounding me don't use it. We are more accustomed to use XP. I think that could be an answer why the Microsoft can price at a high level.

Hope someday there is someone can beat Microsoft!

by neon samurai

I thought I saw a release notice for a newer version anyhow. If the state sponsored distribution is not preferred then there are many other's to choose from.

If it's a gaming machine though then the user will likely want to stick with Windows. There is the option of Cedega/Wine and Linux based OS native games which are all good but not the latest titles. Besides, considering Cedega/Wine would probably negate most of the questions in the original post.

A current Linux distro or BSD would be worth a look though.

by boxfiddler Hot topic

as far as I can tell, big business doesn't give a sh*t about 'the realistic situation', much less a thought.

edit the usual

by .martin.

staff (just to name a few):
programmers (7 million lines of code)
designers (windows look)
supervisors

cost of producing the software (i.e., burning discs)
cost of designing box (very expensive)
cost of making packaging
cost of shipping

by Former member

One thing can explain all of your confusions:

my reading capability is better than writing, especially when I read thousands of times of your posts. haha

by boxfiddler Hot topic

Try substituting noob for idiot. I don't find you to be an idiot.

In the meantime, if you have an older, spare PC amongst you and your friends, why not experiment with Linux? Unbuntu comes to mind. I found it amazingly easy to deal with.

I'm no geek, while I manage Windows and various software packages well, Windows has been my PC world. But I'm finding Linux well worth the time to 'play' in. Before too long, I expect to be free of Windows, with the exception that I use it at and for work.
(I freaking teach it, it's looking like. :D )

by Former member

i will try, but i think Lunix is not a very common system in China. and thank you. noob, i like this word. :)

by Former member

are you testing my English level? i think i got the meaning of both of words on the surface, but this time i don't know the derived meaning.

by Former member

even i am really noob for this thing, but i will try. :)

by the scummy one

Since you mention that you hope someone will overtake Windows, Linux seems to be a good answer. Personally, I like PCLinuxOS, and it has a Live cd version (no installing to the hard drive until you want to).

As for being common in China, I cannot say. However was the government not trying to get people to use it and develop in it until last year?

by boxfiddler Hot topic

mess around with your necessary computers. Play in a not necessary machine.

by Former member

i don't know, i just heard of Linux from some friends of Department of Computer Science in university. They said Linux is good and somthing about source code, as well as Linux has a nice future.

But now even my friends who are called a computer master-hand, they still use XP.

by .martin.

is that some elite rank when it comes to computer knowledge? or just translation?

by Former member

but some of them are pretty good at computer, no matter software or hardware, i think. One of my friend said linux is not suitable for green hands, anyway, and also said the same words as BOXY's.

by boxfiddler Hot topic

I really like the term 'master-hand', and below, 'green-hand'.
Yup, bighair nailed it with both. I have to remember to use those. :D

by the scummy one

MS working with the Chinese government to offer Windows at a lower price.
Linux, for years has been hard to adopt for most users. In the last few years it has become very much user friendly.

If you havent tried a Linux distro in a while, or never, I suggest giving one a try. You cannot beat the price, open-ness, etc..
To give an example, back in '99 I gave up on Linux -- never to go back. in '06 I gave it a try again, and now I use it often.

It is likely that the distro that was pushed at one time (I forgot which one) was more cumbersome for users than the Windows environment. This would dissuade many from using it.
However, if pirated versions are becoming problematic, give a live distro a chance. Try to learn Linux. The easiest (my opinion) would be to obtain a copy with KDE (K desktop environment), as it more closely matches the Windows environment. However many Linux users really like Gnome, and it has been around longer and is more stable (from what I have heard anyway).

by tony hopkinson

While you won't look into alternatives (it may be that there isn't a viable one). There are no alternatives for you and it's a sellers market, and you get to pay through the nose.

by charliespencer

You said, "the software is too expensive for a lot of people in China."

A BMW or a Mercedes car is too expensive for me; am I right to steal one from a car dealer? That is what you are doing, stealing.

You should use free software like Linux and OpenOffice instead.

by Former member

if I have no money to buy a BMW or Mercedes car, i can choose SUZUKI, which is more cheaper and save fuel, but the basic function equal to those two. But software is different. Everyone knows Linux is not good as Windows, even I am a noob.

Yeah, you can say we are stealing. Sometimes I wonder since we can produce A-bomb, why we can't produce a software by ourselves? anyway

by boxfiddler Hot topic

um. No.

Even though I am not yet comfortable with Linux, I will say that Linux is better than Windows. Ubuntu gives me no trouble, none, no trouble whatsoever. No maintenance issues, few to no virus issues, works like a charm on my older hardware. Doesn't need defragging weekly, doesn't collect spyware and adware (to my knowledge).

I take exception to 'everyone'. Because I know that Linux is 'better'. On my time, at any rate.

by Former member

>"Everyone knows Linux is not good as Windows, even I am a noob."

You must be. Everyone here pretty much knows that for somethings Linux is the best choice of OS and for others Windows is.

If you choose the open source v. closed source argument, sometimes closed source is the only choice or the better choice and sometimes open source is the better choice. As an example: if you are doing math then you are most likely using either Maple or Mathematica. Though there are other Math programs, these are the most popular and they both come in Linux and Windows formats. However, if you are doing mathematical research where the function that is used may be in question, then because of the proprietary nature of both, neither are a good choice. In this case, you either want to write your own program, or else use an open source alternative "Sage" because sage allows you to view the way the function is used.

>"Sometimes I wonder since we can produce A-bomb, why we can't produce a software by ourselves?"

Isn't it China that is making the Dragon CPU. Seems to me that you have to write the microcode for it, therefore China is producing its own software, also M$ has a Chinese branch writing code. Ditto for the "Red Linux" - product of China for the Chinese.

Arm yourself with knowledge before you engage in combat with a knowledgeable person; it is no fun to fight the unarmed.

by the scummy one

"if I have no money to buy a BMW or Mercedes car, i can choose SUZUKI, which is more cheaper and save fuel, but the basic function equal to those two. But software is different. Everyone knows Linux is not good as Windows, even I am a noob."

Are you saying a Suzuki basic function car is equal to the BMW or Mercedes?
Your argument does not hold water at all.

Lets start with, you want Windows OS, however you dont have money for it. There are several free or low cost operating systems, some are more advanced than others. Some have just the basic functions, some are full fledged massive hulks of an OS with most things built in (including applications).

Then you argue that these free or low cost OS's are not as good as the Win OS, therefore it is OK to steal it.
WRONG!!!
Sure there are some things that Windows does better, however if you are not abiding by the licensing terms, why complain when it stops working? If you pirate the SW, it should have an ability to be disabled. Just like the BMW likely has a GPS tracking system and alarm, and an engine cut-off switch, Windows stops working at 100%.
These are very comparable, just not what you wanted to hear.

If you want to move from Windows, we can help you out. If you just want to b!tch that MS is protecting their investment, STFU (meant in the nicest possible way of course) :D

by charliespencer

"Everyone knows Linux is not good as Windows,"

No, everyone does not know that. Linux is as good or better. Have you tried it?

"if I have no money to buy a BMW or Mercedes car, i can choose SUZUKI ... but the basic function equal to those two"

The basic function of Linux and Windows is the same. They are computer operating systems. You say Linux is not as good as Windows (wrong) and that makes it okay to steal Windows. A Suzuki is not as good a car as a BMW; is it okay for me to steal a BMW?

by Former member

I do not think that M$ is acting correctly for the consumer of their products, but the company is acting correctly in the pursuit of the greatest profit for the company.

M$ lost a monopoly lawsuit in this country. Part of the evidence used against M$ was the pricing structure that they used. M$, until that loss used the min/max formulas taught in Calculus to determine the point of the greatest profit. M$ used min/max to sell the greatest amount of copies for the least price to maximize profit. The great government of this country seeking to force M$ to get in bed with them used this as evidence of a controlling monopoly, even though most large corporations use this branch of math to maximize profits. The loss of this action forced M$ to change its pricing structure to what it is today for good or bad.

This same lawsuit is what forced M$ into writing rootkit code into the software that was deployed in your country which allowed the US government to steal and investigate your countries military and economic data. When your country found out, the slip hit the fan. This is also why M$ now allows your government to examine the source code for Windows.

Throughout the world, all software companies have used "click throughs for EULAs" that violate contract law in this and most other countries. Recently one jurisdiction in the US found click throughs to be predatory and in violation of the law. Unfortunately that is an isolated decision that is relevant to a single state. On the other hand, recent research has shown what we have known for a long time - no one bothers to read EULAs. This will certainly bear on the legitimacy of click throughs when the issue gets to court.

What do click throughs have to do with an OS. M$ and other ware vendors assert that the EULA is what licenses the program to you, even though that belief violates lease law in which right to control is vested in the leasee. Software vendors, however, use this one sided assertion to strip you of the right to own, examine, or control their software; they also use the EULA to force you to agree that the company can modify the software without your permission.

This is not legal advice and constitutes my position only and is based on my understanding of the various laws.

I think that all software developers and vendors are wrong in 1) asserting ownership over a program that by act they have sold rather than leased you, 2) are acting illegally when they modify that program without your permission, and 3) need to be called to the bar for their acts.

I also think that this is one of the many reasons vendors are moving to a subscription service; when a hungry blood sucker gets this to court, it will be a real mess.

Developers have the right to protect their work, but how is another question.

This position extends to the media companies who disable my full DVD drive functionality when I insert a movie or music CD. I extend this one however to the media companies violating the DMCA when they do this; but they have not been called on it yet.

by notsochiguy

...but in this case, I can't fault them for their actions.

Actually, I have to give them some credit for restraint. I probably would have decided to lock down the system fully.

Of course, when people were stealing candy from my desk years back, I replaced some of them with Ex-Lax chewables; as I have little regard for thieves.

There are enough alternatives out there (Linux, OpenOffice, etc, etc) that piracy really shouldn't be condoned; regardless of whether or not the corporate 'victim' is an offender themselves in some way. Wronging a wrongdoer doesn't necessarily make something right.

by dumphrey

Windows in that there are skill levels needed to perform tasks. Nearly anyone with a spare computer can install Ubuntu by accepting the default options, and then browse the internet and read email, write documets etc. Where linux becomes more difficult is flash (getting better) installs and multimedia set up to stream content and play dvds (legality issues here as well). but, in most cases, many people have already solved these problems and posted answers on the web. Don't expect to be fully competent with Linux right away, but many tasks are not as difficult as others make them out to be. There is no harm in putting linux on a spare old computer and seeing what it can do. Or by booting your computer off a knoppix or other "live-cd". You may like it, you may hate it, you may be indifferent. But the key point, is that it is a choice you can make.

As for Microsoft's behavior. While I do not like it, I believe they are in the right. If I do not like the terms of their license, I have the option to not use their products.

by oz_media

I [i]think[/i] is about $150.00 USD.

XP Professional still retails for around $250.00 Canadian dollars here now, which is actually a normal going rate for a new OS from MS, but comparatively, it is expensive for you.

I'll make you a deal, if you need a copy, and you PROMISE it is for your own use, I'll mail you one.

Merry Christmas.

Just PM me and give me your details, I'll have it in the mail in a week.

Again, an open offer, but only if you really need a copy.

If you have a copy and were just wondering how they can get way with it, well, that's American capitalism at its finest.

"God bless America....and nobody else."

by pringles86

When Windows detects an illegal key being used it changes the background to black.

I'm not sure what Windows does when it detects an illegal copy of Windows, but I know we are talking about legal issues and cost not UAC.

by neon samurai

Isn't that where Vista says "thanks for trying our product, now crippling the system until you pay for it". I could see that trapping data but it wouldn't really be lost for anyone with a liveCD. If one is going to use Windows, they do need a legal license for it though.

by .martin.

Thank you for using Windows, unfortunately you evaluation period has expired, please wait while we cripple you hard drive beyond repair, if you want to save your files, you have 24 hours to enter a LEGAL license number.

24:00:00
23:59:59
23:59:58
23:59:57
23:59:56
23:59:55
23:59:54
23:59:53
23:59:52
23:59:51
23:59:50
23:59:49
23:59:48
23:59:47
23:59:46
23:59:45
23:59:44
23:59:43
23:59:42
23:59:41
23:59:40

by neon samurai

VMware Server v1 and v2 are both free to download provided you register. I'd suggest downloading one or the other and using that to create as many test VM as you like. I'm currently using it on a WinXP work machine to host a Debian workstation with all my actual tools outside of Outlook.

One could do the same for learning Ubuntu or some other distribution easily. If your comfortable with Windows then the install is pretty easy to do.

by jamesrl

I'm certainly no fan of MS's corporate behaviour.

But they are within their rights to implment the Windows genuinine advantage, as long as it works properly. In North America, it doesn't give you a black screen, but it does deny you updates patches and add ons if you don't go through the WGA verification.

In a free market, Microsoft can charge what it wants, and if the market is truly free, others can compete on price. There have been a few lawsuits about Microsoft's competitive practises.

Stealing software - buying pirate versions, is theft. No one expects to get the hardware for free, why is software any different.?

James

by jdclyde

We use the lotus smartsuite, but working to move to OO.

A user "likes" office. He asked me to "just put a copy on for him".

I told him that I wouldn't ask him to go up to the corner store and steal a candy bar for me if he didn't ask me to steal a $300 package.

He was not amused, nor pleased.

I will not install pirated software for someone, at work or otherwise.

I don't mind MS checking if it is a legit copy. The thing I don't like is MS changing the file layout, intentionally making ITS SELF incompatible with the rest of the world. And then simpletons look down upon other packages because they can't open the new MS format. Who deviated? The deviants.

by jamesrl

Internally, we are all very clear, everyone takes a course in software licensing so they understand corporate policy and enforcement.

With our custoemrs, they often buy one copy of MS Office and ask us to put it on a server and share it for everyone. We refuse. They complain, we point them to MS's site. We explain that if we are found to pirate MS software, we will lose the right to sell MS software whcih would cripple our business. We often joke that we could barter one of their products for MS office - I'd take that trade.

James

by Former member

'No one expects to get the hardware for free, why is software any different.'

Hope you answer this question:
How to define and measure the value of IPR?
Cost+what?

by jamesrl

In a free market, you charge what the market will bear. If there is high profits, then you invite competition, which lowers profits.

But the owner of the IP has the right to set the asking price, and the laws of supply and demand will define the selling price.

It is impossible to value intellectual property on a cost plus ratio. Should all composers, artists and writers get paid the same if they put in the same amount of hours?

In the case of Microsoft, its a bit of chicken and egg (which came first, the chicken or the egg?). If fewer people pirated, MS could charge everyone less and still make the same profit. The pirates are not only impacting MS, the are also impacting the rest of us, who pay more.

James

by Former member

I know I have no arm, especially about computer. And I have no interests to fight with knowledgeable person. Actually I am happy to know your ideas, no matter from commendatory or derogatory sense.

George Bernard Shaw said, when two people carried each apple exchange their apple, to the end, they evently have one apple; but they exchange two ideas, they will have two idea. (sorry for my poor translation, you can look up by yourself!)

I really want to know how American people see this thing. that is what i want to say.

I know we produce a lot things about computer, but we still are your equipment workshops, not the R&D or the 'nervus centralis'. I just say this thing from I real Chinese common people.

by Former member

>"I know I have no arm, especially about computer."

I think what you are saying is: "I do not understand computers well."

I have no problem with this and did not mean to be derogatory or insulting, I was simply making a point with irony.

>"...I have no interests to fight with knowledgeable person."

I was attempting to place this in light of something you may understand. I used a heavy paraphrase of the idea's of Sun Tzu which I garnered from "The Art of War."

>"I know we produce a lot things about computer, but we still are your equipment workshops, not the R&D or the 'nervus centralis'."

Most of us are the same, just workers for the powers that be. I do not know just how strongly you are censored in your country, so give me some patience. Your country was the first in the world to develop a super sonic cruise missile, your country put a man into space in less than five years when it took us over ten. You have the largest military force in the world. From my own personal perspective, your country is taking jobs that belong in mine - but this is not your choice, it is the choice of the corporate powers that we both are slaved to. Nothing personal against you. Your people are industrious; I watched your country come to the state I live in, cut apart an entire steel refinery and take it to your country. Your country develops most of the electronics that we use over here; unless you are more segregated and secretive than I know, you are learning our technology by building it. This is learning by doing, in our country it is often called an apprenticeship.

On a personal level, as a young teenager two of my best friends were Chinese. They would buy all the drugs I could use, let me get as high as I wanted, then get their friends and beat the hell out of me for getting so high that I could not defend myself. I learned much of what I know of (your words) Wu Shu from them. I dated Micheal Luey's sister at his and his families behest. It was unheard of for a white kid to date a Chinese girl in the Chinese community. Micheal and his family were born in Hong Kong. Micheal was killed in his 20's in a Tong war in Los Angeles.

>"I really want to know how American people see this thing."

The opinions vary among the people. The fact is that the black screens can be defeated in about 35 seconds by deleting three files. M$ attempted the black pirate screen over here. People that were computer illiterate complained, the more knowledgeable simply deleted the files. The files you will have to find on your own on the internet because no one on this board will tell you what they are.

Speaking only for myself, the developer deserves to be paid for his/her work. But the payment should not include the extortive pricing that often accompanies software. I find no issue with others that purloin software when the pricing is extortive or the practices are immoral. Remember morality is a personal preference and vairies with the people.

by the scummy one

it wasnt meant as a bad thing unless the conditions were true. If so, it fits nicely (especially with the disclaimer)

Sorry, I have been too nice for too long. I guess it was just building up :0
or not ?:|

by jdclyde

it isn't good to keep all the negative vibes locked up, man. It will have a dulling effect on your aura, man, and that is like, you know, a drag, man..... ;\

:p

by jdclyde

If you can't afford that BMW, you would be a scumbag if you stole it.

Software is no different, nor the effect it would have on the end resulting scumbagism.

no offense to the scummyone intended

by jackofalltech

No company EVER loses money from piracy! Most of the people who pirate software wouldn't buy it anyway at any price therefore there is no loss. Ironically, if the companies charged less, they would make MORE money because more regular people would actually buy it.

I am not condoning piracy, but please don't be sheep and believe everything these poor, misundertood and mistreated companies tell you. ;-)

by the scummy one

If no company loses money due to piracy because they wouldnt buy it anyway, how would they make more money by lowering prices?

by .martin.

someone might jump out, AND GET YA!!

I was more speaking about bighair1240's comment, but hey!

by the scummy one

I have been in a 'dulling effect' recently :0

Good thing I ran across this, or I may have become -- well, Dull :0

I do find it funny though, when people try to legitimize their theft by stating that it is only software, so it doesnt count, or its not the same thing.

by jdclyde

oh, you meant "funny" as in an odd way, not "ha ha" funny.

I get insulted when people ask me to install pirated software for them. I just tell them I am not a thief, thankyouverymuch.

As I said further down, I just explain that I won't ask them to go up to the gas station and steal me a candy bar if they don't ask me to steal them a $300 package. Disagreeing on the price does not make stealing the package right.

There are viable alternatives for people that do not have the money for a MS OS. But then again, unless they built a whitebox, it came WITH windows. How did they afford to make the whitebox?

People that claim an OS should be "free", is "free" to write their own.

[b]( Thanks Linus! :D )

by jdclyde

Next your going to tell me to pick up my dirty clothes.... And no, they are NOT in "the middle of the room". They are off to the side a little bit.... ;\

by Former member

I forget that you live in a capitalism society which owns alleged free market. This market can't exist 100%, in my opinion.

The behavior of Microsoft likes a Monopoly Capitalism in our society. Yeah, supply and demand, the basic theory. When the market is seller's market, does buyer's market only have the right to obey the rule which is established by those greedy dealers? Why can't those dealers reduce a tiny price to maintain a balance.

Nobody initiatively wants to buy private product unless the rule is too cruel.

Anyway, thank you.

by .martin.

I know for myself (and a lot of others on this website), the easiness of going and downloading an illegal copy of windows would be simpe, but the majority of us have a moral telling us that it is wrong.

by Former member

I make a wrong example.

I haven't tried Linux, I will.

by .martin.

even if it is just a live version (which is REALLY slow), other than the gaming side of windows (which can be overcome), Linux, in a way, is a better alternative to windows (stolen and no-stolen)