Discussion Locked

The other side of Computer monitoring in business

0 helpful
10 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Well I'm one of the first to admit that there is no privacy in the work place particularly when it comes to the use of computers for Internet communications or web surfing but yesterday I saw the other side of the coin.

A small company who is specifically monitoring one of their workers instant messaging for their own titillation. While I do accept the need to have some knowledge over what a companies computers are being used for if only to protect that company from any Legal problems this there has to be a line drawn somewhere as well.

To me this is just as much abuse of the system as the person who is offending. If it was up to me I would remove everyone concerned but as the practice is being instigated by the boss and is allowed to continue unchecked there is nothing that I can see happening to stop this practice.

To me and I'm sure I'm not alone here the monitoring of a young females IM only for the titillation of several people concerned is sickening.

Any comments on how to avoid this in future?

Col

10 replies

by oz_media

I think you've got a great point here Colin, there MUST be a way for employees to complain about misuse of these 'employee' privaledges the same way that we can report companies to Employment Standards. In fact, the use MAY have a case. Unfortunately, I see them taking the perspective that if the company gets it's jollies from reading company IM's then all the power to them. The only response the user could say is "well his ISN'T company IM's and they are personal" at which time the whole thing loses all credibility as theri only response is going to be, don't use IM's at your company for personal use or for discussing personal matters.

Again, as in all these things, the company wil prevail as it is theri system. Now I agree that your point is valid and that they shouldn't be reading this for theri jollies BUT (there's always a 'but' isn't there?)if this makes you feel uncomfortable that your boss knows when you last put out for your boyfriend, then simply don't discuss it on their channels.

This is the entire reason I ONLY use a personal email system for personal email, my friends know what they can send through my cutomers GroupWise email systems and what needs to be to my personal and online accounts.

Personally, I wouldn't use it at all, especially if the employer was reviewing it (fortunately in my case I review my employers email). I would just tell her to not say anything over IM that she would be embarassed by or wouldn't weant her employer to read, they are taking advantage of the system that is in place to protect an employer and using it inappropriately to read employee correspondence, but legally they are entitled to.

IM is as insecure as life can get, yuo may as well try carrier pigeon and hope it gets to the intended recipient. If her boss isn't reading it, chances are someone else is as they are usually quite easily blocked, intercepted and redirected without the user knowing.

Do you know where YOUR IM was sent today?

by hal 9000

YES!

I really do know where my IM is ending up nowhere as I don't use it for anything as it by its very nature is so insecure.

I really don't even trust e-mail for any really important messages only the ones that need to be somewhere fast and since my recent experience with "Registered Mail" I'm no longer too sure of that either so short of placing a printed form into someones hand there is not any real secure way of transferring information. Even then once you have placed it into their hand you have no control where it eventually ends up so to remain secure you should never pass on any information right?

HELL NO we do however accept the fact that there is a limited measure of security in anything that we do and supposedly make allowances for these security breaches which may or may not work as we intended, but in this particular case the Owner is abusing the system and encouraging the person to continue by the very fact of not warning them that what they are doing is inappropriate.

Actually I know that every bit of tel co communication is monitored by the Government of each country that it passes through at the very least but this isn't a problem to me as some unknown person reading/listening to my personal communication will very soon get bored to death and want something else to do but it is a totally different thing when the person is not only known to you but is sitting 10 feet away entering this rubbish.

Col

by oz_media

Working for the CRTC (Canadian Radiotelevision and Telecommunications Commission)I saw this first hand as I also did a LOT of work in the communications monitoring dept. They don't actually hire people to sit and monitor all calls, they simply have a voice recognition system that is prompted by keywords and flags conversations to be monitored for authenticity. If the call is flagged, it may either be monitored manually (live) or will auto record both eof the parties numbers and partial conversation that was flagged. Right now they have removed MANY keywords and upped the algorhythms to detect ANY instances that may be terro linked. Mention of specific chemicals, companies, names etc. They are looking for specifics not people talking about buying a gram of coke, discussing marriage, sex etc. These calls generally go unflagged and unheard of.

That's the story here at least. :-)

by jamesrl

in order to do any close monitoring, you have to have permission of the CIO and/or HR. Anyone using monitoring tools without express permission is fired - end of story.

A previous employer used to tools to monitor internet usage(IM was not allowed - blocked). Their big fight was to get HR to take over the process of notifying managers when abuse happened. There were also problems with employees who once managed mail servers continuing to access them after they moved on to other positions - this should have been fixed with password changes but people were too trusting or lazy or both. Again, if the individual had been caught the consequences would be severe.

If you have and use these kinds of tools on a regular basis, its important to let the employees know up front. I actually did presentations on the tools - showed actual reports and all. I'm sure I prevented alot of heartache by being proactive.

James

by hal 9000

That's exactly what I did in this case quite some time ago when I got stuck with this job who someone else had started and then walked away from leaving the company in question with only a Internet connection and no software on any of their computers except for an accounting package on the Bosses unit. As there are only 5 people currently involved in this place it was fairly easy to let them all know exactly what was possible but like most things it went unheeded as they had more important things to do and IT isn't on their list of priories.

Currently they have a DSL modem connected to a hub and then every computer is thus connected to the net, well when I saw this I hit the roof as there was no form of any security installed let alone {no I don't want to go there again} but lets just say that I explained exactly just how vulnerable they where to attack and the reply to that was "Why would that happen?" I got together with their ISP and explained just how open they where and their ISP who they know personally suggested a Linux Gateway which I agreed ed with on a machine that they where removing from service, well that still hasn't happened but at least I got wall plugs on a;; the network cables hanging out of the walls and the thing at least properly marked even if it wasn't setup the way I would have done it. But the real killer here is the company who supplied all the units walked in the door just as I was finishing off the work of properly installing the network and wanted to know what the Hell I was doing there and exactly why they had called me in to supply all the required software as they could have of supplied it (the person in question only had walked out 14 + weeks previously after saying I'll be back and never bothered to contact them to see if they required anything else.} It was a total mess when I went there to allegedly fit a DVD drive to a unit that didn't have one installed but came with Cd's as the recovery disks and to fit a second monitor to the unit as they couldn't figure out how to fit the thing after it was sold to them in the "Proper" configuration for their needs.

Well that 15 minute job ended up requiring 4 weeks work and several thousand $ worth of software an I did the job at nearly "cost price" as they had already been ripped off by the original company who sold them the hardware, Well at least most of the computers had XP Pro on them with only one having XP Home installed but unfortunately that is how some companies work they just take the money and laugh all the way to the bank. I could have setup a far more secure network and supplied all the hardware and software for less than they paid for the original hardware and then the added costs of running cable.

While I may be a "Soft Touch" in things like this it really only makes my work harder when the money grubbing places just take the money and walk away and expect the company in this case to be able to function. When I first walked in to the place the only way they had to transfer data between terminals was to e-mail it to each other even though these workstations may only have been 10 feet apart {I latter learned that their ISP rented a server in the US to handle all their work so it got even worse with the data being sent from one terminal to the ISP in America and then back now that a hell of a lot of distance to cover just to move a file 10 feet.}

Col

by jamesrl

There is a government agency in Canada which does this - in the old days there used to be recording of all international calls, now they use software and can cast a wider net.

They datashare with the US and others.

The person I met who used to work there was one of the most paranoid people I ever met - or was he???

James

by mlayton

You don't really say who the people are doing the monitoring: if it is NOT the owner, then it is abuse of their position - and either way by selecting a single employee it is sexual harassment. If they were monitoring all employees and came across this one and used it, there might be some gray area, but targeting an employee for this reason of personal enjoyment and fulfillment is wrong wrong wrong

by hal 9000

It is in fact the boss and her son who are the offenders here.

While I'm still not really sure of what the son is currently doing there as he is only a recent addition to the business what I am sure of is that at the very least this is an abuse of power that should be stopped.

But the situation originally came about I think because the girl in question loaded so much junk onto her workstation that she compromised its function. I had to go out there and remove a lot of the junk that was unnecessary to that companies business and get that workstation up and running again as it would lose the use of the "Enter" key after 15 minutes of use, which was time consuming to track down.

However I latter found out that they added something to the computer to pickup all the IM sent from that work station and I think that their ISP who they are friends with supplied whatever they installed onto the unit. But the girl in question has reinstalled Yahoo IM after I told her not to use it anymore as that company doesn't use it and every listing on it is personal.

Now every time I go out there I do drop some gentle hints to the girl in question to stop what she is doing but as I'm obviously a "Dinosaur" who knows absolutely nothing I'm ignored by her.

Thank God for these young know it all people who just can't be told anything.

But while she is out of line by miles what is happening is still wrong in my books as if I was the employer there I would first give her a couple of warnings and if she continued fire her.

Mostly the incidents start with something like "What is she calling me today?" said by the owner while the girl is either out on lunch or left for the day and it at that point that the son takes it into his head to read out everything that the girl in question has posted that day.

When I first became aware of what was going on I just walked out of ear shot and added the comment that I would be very careful in your actions unless you want to get sued there are better ways to handle this.

As no questions where asked I then provided a copy of what is considered as acceptable Internet usage policy to the owner as well as the current Industrial Relations Legislation and left it at that.

But I'm very uncomfortable about the whole situation that is going on there at present. While there is unacceptable usage of the workstation in question they are doing nothing to prevent this from continuing and actually seem to be enjoying what is being said. While there are some adverse comments about the Boss there is a lot more stuff of a sexual nature that is being sent by Yahoo IM and nothing is being done to stop this abuse of the system.

Col

by deadly ernest

From what you have said here it sounds like the owner has not spoken to her saying that she should not use the IM software whilst being thoroughly aware that the staffer is. Thus the boss is saying that this use of software, time and resources is an acceptable use of her property.

The fact that the boss is having the conversations closely monitored and discussed with other staff without the person being monitored informed that this is, or may be, happening leaves the boss open to charges of invasion of privacy and harrassment.

Depending upon how strongly you feel about this issue, and how much you value the boss as a client, you can tell the girl as much about what is happening as you want as there is no legal or moral restriction upon you. The Boss has not told you NOT to tell her and the boss has openly discussed what is happening with other people in front of you as if it was common knowledge so there is no confidentiality on your behalf.

by deadly ernest

Generally when a business sets up a policy to cover the use of their resources they should, and usually do, set out how this use is authorised or monitored. Any monitoring outside of that is usually a misuse of equipment as well and continued monitoring like you mention would be seen by most courts as harrassment and invasion of privacy.

Long term monitoring without official comment would also be seen as tacit approval of the use of the system by the worker being monitored.

This discussion is closed to new replies.