Question Locked

The unsolvable chess question

0 helpful
70 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Two TR members are playing chess, they play 5 games and they both win the same number of games.

How is this possible?

70 replies

by deepsand

1) This belongs in the Off-Topic section of Discussions; the Question forum is for [b]Technical[/b] issues only.

2) The players in question play each other for either 0, 2 or 4 games, with each winning half of that number, and play the remaining 5, 3 or 1 game(s) against a different opponent(s), with each winning the same number of those games.

by older mycroft

They don't have to play each other at all!

They just happen to be playing at the same time, but not against each other.

Couldn't be against each other anyway coz there'd be too many interruptions from the forums!

by michael jay

You are correct sir, they were not playing each other at all.

Sandy got the incorrect answer that is not acceptable as correct but there is one other answer that is incorrect but acceptable as correct.

If this is confusing then you must listen carefully to Firesign Theatre's "Eat or be Eaten" then you will be completely confused.

by absolutely

as illustration of how much has been overlooked in the site's new desgin. I'll stop bicthing about your question, now.

by deepsand

The [b]intent[/b] of the post determines which Forum is the proper one; the [b]subject[/b] determines the appropriate Tag to be used.

Within [u]both[/u] Forums, the "Off-Topic" Tag is merely the "miscellaneous" category. In fact, prior to the recent makeover of this site, "Miscellaneous" was the term used by TR.

The Questions forum, which was formerly named the "Technical Question & Answer" forum, is, like its predecessor, intended to be used solely for the solution of problems which are IT related; all other questions belong in the Discussions forum.

by absolutely

He is trying to kill his own king.

Alternatively, they are not playing all 5 games against one another, in various combinations.

by absolutely

Not only was deepsand's answer correct, it was more complete than the one you credited with a "Thumb". Up yours.

by michael jay

I posted this question as simple research to see just what options are available to the question poster. I should have added humor to the tags, as this is taken from the Firesign Theater production called "Eat or Be Eaten". I was not looking for serious thought processes in the art of Chess, I was looking for the answer in the production. It was funny and pithy, "they weren't playing each other" was the correct answer.

Sorry, I should have made that more clear and I thought that I had by my post in:
https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=102&threadID=223460&messageID=2248079
I should have clarified that in the top of the question so as to remove any confusion.

Soooo Do you have the other answer?

by michael jay

I have noticed that there is an undo for helpful.

I ask myself should I just undo Mycroft's thumb?

As I gave it out because he had the "correct answer" even though he probably does not know Firesign Theater at all, I cannot take it away.

A convening of the judges is required so I shall take it up with my wife and daughter and I do believe there is a satisfactory conclusion to this coming.

BTW this is Firesign Theater:
http://www.firesigntheatre.com/albums/dctd1.mp3

by michael jay

The jury is in and I have been deemed wrong, but does anyone know the second answer? It is so simple.

by michael jay

and thanks for the post as I noticed a misspeling in my previous post so what the heck heres another thumb. But what about the original question, how did they do it?

Mike

edited for another one.

by tig2

Beyond the response that they are not playing each other, I can't think of a way this could happen.

Sheesh!

by michael jay

in 2d the only other possible answers have already been given. There is another way.

by absolutely

The third possibility is a stalemate. I don't believe that defines a third 'dimension', but it is a third possibility, which allows the numerical problem to be solved.

:p

by tig2

The final game is a draw?

Grrr!

by absolutely

UP YOURS!

For [i]SOME REASON[/i] you didn't seem to like that answer very much. Go & figure...

:^0

by triathlete1981

you responded to my post about the "unsolvable" chess question being solved pretty quickly which by definition means it's not "unsolvable"

the second or third responder answered the question. looks like it was pretty solvable. but, since you're not too intelligent to realize what i just wrote above, i'll simply repeat what the first guy said. they're not playing each other.

here's a riddle...i smell something. what is it? smells like two sticks rubbing against one another trying to create a fire. where's the fire coming from?

answer...your brain trying to be smart.

here's another riddle...who thinks they're smart by repeating a riddle that someone else came up with?

answer...you!!

yipee. these riddles are fun.

by absolutely

An odd number of the matches is played to stalemate; they split the remaining even number of matches.

[Or, as deepsand explained in depth, they played 5 games [i]each[/i] with varying numbers of those games against one another.]

by absolutely

Not that I'm dissatisfied with the # of thumbs already stuck up at me, but I would like to know why the "correct answer" is so particular.

by deepsand

[b]including[/b] their playing [b]0[/b] games against each other:

1) Where is the error; and,
2) How can there be a "better" answer?

by absolutely

I think there are three possibilities in every game of chess: win [what you do], lose [what your opponents do] & draw/stalemate ["WTF," says deepsand, "is THAT??"]

If it were up to me, I'd excuse you for forgetting the one that you never see!

:^0

by deepsand

The apparent oversight was actually an error that occured during my editing of the post.

Originally, I had listed all of the specific possibilities. I then edited that answer, before posting it, to condense such into it's final form; that, after midnight, amidst high temperature & humidity, and with great irritation to my eyes.

The initial entry, editing & posting went quite slowly, as most of my machine's resources, along with my available bandwidth, were being consumed by several large simultaneous file transfers.

Once the original post was visible, I noticed several errors, edited & re-posted, wholly overlooking the fact that the phrase "with each winning the same number" got pasted into the latter portion re. "outside" games, but not the first portion re. games involving both players.

In fact, I'm even more tired & of poor vision now than I was then, and had to re-read my initial post several times before spotting the error, as I kept "seeing" what I knew I intended to say!

And, if I've found & corrected all of the typos in this post, it will have been by sheer luck.

by deepsand

The apparent oversight was actually an error that occured during my editing of the post.

Originally, I had listed all of the specific possibilities. I then edited that answer, before posting it, to condense such into it's final form; that, after midnight, amidst high temperature & humidity, and with great irritation to my eyes.

The initial entry, editing & posting went quite slowly, as most of my machine's resources, along with my available bandwidth, were being consumed by several large simultaneous file transfers.

Once the original post was visible, I noticed several errors, edited & re-posted, wholly overlooking the fact that the phrase "with each winning the same number" got pasted into the latter portion re. "outside" games, but not the first portion re. games involving both players.

In fact, I'm even more tired & of poor vision now than I was then, and had to re-read my initial post several times before spotting the error, as I kept "seeing" what I knew I intended to say!

And, if I've found & corrected all of the typos in this post, it will have been by sheer luck.

And now, of course, the Custom 404s are back.

by deepsand

The real question now becomes why you are gaming the Question forum's rating system?

by michael jay

that is the other answer, 2 wins each one draw.

Finally someone comes by with their complete brain working.

You are the best
thanks Tig

by michael jay

this question has been closed, all further posts will be ignored.

Thanks for your input all

by deepsand

The old Tech Q & A allowed for formal Closing; this forum doesn't.

You [b]can' Close a Question[/b].

by tig2

Be nice.

At least someone tried to have a learning experience. That is a good thing considering all the seagull posters we get.

Come on, Sandy. You are just being contrary because of the heated nature of some of the discussions lately. Have you seen to one about "Fear of Technology"? THAT one will be a doozie! I'm already ticked!

by captbilly1eye

The 'two TR members' are actually one person with two screen names.
Playing against him/herself, he/she would always win. 5 for 5.

Billy Idol - 'dancin' with myself...'

by deepsand

I've not had a decent night's sleep in 4 days. That worked 40 years ago, but no longer. Now, sleep deprivation sucks.

by tig2

After 11:00 and I have to get up at 6:00 to go walk training miles. Then get ready for the new job starting Monday.

Today was only 10 miles, tomorrow is only 8.

I should feel good about this, and I will... later.

Hang in there, my salty friend. Air conditioning will help, so will a martini.

What is keeping you up? If the heat and humidity, try putting your top sheet in the freezer. That used to work for me.

by deepsand

Plus, during times of high H & H, I'm prone to RLS. So, can't breath or sleep well.

Yet another bad night; after 4 hrs. of tossing & turning, finally gave up trying to sleep, brewed another pot of coffee & started checking my overflowing e-mail accounts.

by older mycroft

Just a casual Sunday afternoon jaunt followed by a cursory, glancing perusal of the TR environment, and it turns out that after you guys have had a good old moan at each other, the poor bugger that started this thread has been beaten into submission and handed out THUMBS to :

1. A bloke who got the wrong answer.
&
2. A bloke who just said "Up Yours" to him.

And as for your "overflowing e-mail accounts" hatemail can be very difficult to stem, especially when the only way you get a THUMB is to verbally berade your source until he eventually capitulates!

Yours Disgustedly,
OM

by michael jay

for kicking me in the pants, the whole thumb thing has now been corrected to reflect the actual reality of the thing on the thing.

Just because they thought that this was a chess question should not dissuade me from following the letter of the law, it was taking quotes from a spoken word album and the quote had to fit.

1. They were not playing each other.
2. There was a "draw". not a stalemate

I know it is kinda picky, yes a draw=stalemate but while 2=two if you are writing a program and put in 2 where you need to put two the program will bomb.

by deepsand

A "spoken word album" is irrelevant to question as actually posed.

by absolutely

But it might alternatively be Old Mycroft convincing Michael Jay to not take some jokes in the jovial spirit they were intended. What does it look like to you?

After all, I meant "up yours" [i]in the nicest possible way[/i], and I [u]was[/u] trying to provide the correct answer his stupid question.

by michael jay

In the nicest possible way.

You slay me, it had nothing to do with my stupid question it was all about the question process.

Thanks for being there.

by deepsand

Yes, my final edit failed to clearly allow for draws; [b]but[/b] even as stated, it [b]does produce the requisite outcome.[b]

by michael jay

I could not stand by my original thumbs, they had to go.

It was not that the last game was a draw, any one of the games could have been a draw.

The key is the word "draw", nothing else is correct.

Remember this was not a chess question but a question taken from a spoken word album.

by absolutely

Stalemate is a specific type of draw, in which "the player on turn has no legal move".

Bah!

by deepsand

you say vageena, I say ... let's call the whole thing off.

by deepsand

BTW, it is not the case that I thought that you were deliberately altering the rating system, but that such was simply overlooked; i.e., a consequence of the Law of Unintended Consequences.

I finally got some real sleep, the 1st in 5 days. If I seemed a bit on edge lately, blame it on sleep deprivation.

by michael jay

The question is not about chess, the question is about the exchange between two players in the spoken word album, that is why it is unsolvable unless you know the album.

Chess is irrelevant to the question.

But I do hope you are feeling better, and are the rumors true that you are leaving TR, or perhaps going on leave from these parts?

by deepsand

not as you hold it closed in your mind.

And, you've still 3 "thumbs" to remove.

by charliespencer

Posted before I read any other responses. No, really, I mean it.

As an alternative, they each win one and they draw three, or they each win two and draw one. it is chess, after all; a draw is not uncommon.

by charliespencer

since I've never heard of it. Is it anything like Prairie Home Companion?

by deepsand

Meaning what?

"The pattern is full" sounds like something that santeewelding might say.

by michael jay

like Prairie Home Companion, think "Monty Python" only without video.

This discussion is closed to new replies.