Discussion Locked

Thin client vs fat client, Opinions?

0 helpful
6 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

As part of my duties I currently manage a network of about 20 stations with a single NT server on a single domain (very basic). I'm now faced with expanding to about 50 stations and have been suggested with a thin client set-up. My knowledge is somewhat limited, but I understand that I will need a more powerful server, special licensing and can use less powerfull stations (terminals).

My questions are:

1. Would this be advanatageous, and why?
2. How is the licensing for each terminal handled?
3. Whould I still need OS installed on each station?
4. Would I be able to install one copy of office XP on server and allow each terminal user to use it without purchasing 50 licenses for office?
5. Would I need multiple servers, what specs would be recommended?

As I stand now I don't feel that the thin client is for my company mainly b/c some of the software we use does not support nor recommend the thin client. (Mortgage loan handling/tracking software) I also don't seea cost savings since a more powerful server is required with additional licensing.

If so can anyone provide me with ammunition so I can back my aurgument against the thin client setup.

Thanks

6 replies

by jimbb

On first sight, it depends where your priorities are.
In general you can say that a terminal server supports 20-25 "light" users, or 15-20 "heavier" user per CPU. Up to 2 CPUs per server, and you can count on 2 servers for you (20 now, +50 coming), plus a third server for fault-tolerance/failover. Why a third? If 2 servers can hold 2x40=80 clients, and one crashes or so (it does happen they say <-;), the remaining one cannot handle the 80 clients alone. What servers? 2x heavy CPU+512 MB RAM per CPU and 128 MB to start with, or 1152 MB. Relatively small disks, they just hold the OS and applications, no data. So far for your new hardware.
I'm not sure about MS Licensing, maybe someone else can fill in or correct, but you need a license for your new servers, and a TCAL license per simultaneous user. And depending on the OS on the workstations, maybe a CAL as well.
You should consider Citrix, since its failover/loadbalancing capabilities are better, and its client is far more efficient (requires 10 Kb/s bandwith per client, compared to 25 for MS TS). Count on about 300$ per simultaneous user, I believe (can someone confirm?).

This sounds bl**dy expensive, but it means you can cut on the costs of your clients. A relatively light (read: old) machine will do, or a thin client costs typically about 75% of a real PC. With that you add that all of the application management etc. is done centrally. The simplest setup for a PC is an OS and the client software. With policies or whatever you can block off all the other possibilities of the PC, no risk they install yet another cute screensaver.

So if maintaining workstations (upgrades, new ones, support, re-installations, application management) is an issue, count all of those things and compare, and you'll notice terminal services are not th?t expensive. But it's you who has to evaluate your current costs, and where they come from.

Jim

by admin

I'm really hot on Citrix too right now. We are converting HR\Payroll department to it.

I liked your answer and just had a minor thing to add.

I think this person should look at their skills and what outside resources or training would be needed. If his company supplies Citrix training and then he coupled it with experience he would be potentially very valuable right now. Citrix is definately growing.

Otherwise, the only thing I would add is that the restricted workstation model doesn'tfit the culture of all of our areas of business and is confined to one department here currently.

I can also attest to the robust nature of this service in a real world setting. It is really solid so far and takes really minimal resources on theclient end. It has helped free people immensily to work from wherever they can get to the web in a relatively quite secure enviroment.

~

by goobs

You really need to rethink your career. If you think that you can run an entire network for 50+ users on a single server and not have to purchase additional license for the workstations, you obviously don't know the field.

Also, my question is, how many of your current workstations and servers have proper licensing? None would be my guess. You need to look to hire a competent and knowledgeable Network Administrator so that your company can continue to legally and efficiently run its IT infrastructure.

by Former member

Mr. Goobs...

If your intentions are to insult someone, go home and take it out on your wife or kids! I did not visit this forum to listen to a wise ass but rather to gain insight from others.

To answer your question, I have about 20 users with 25 CALs. So yes I am licensed properly at the moment andwill continue to do so.

Get a life....

by admin

did you mean to post to a different thread? The Citrix client is FREE. Check it out. Citrix is NOT an OS either.

by goobs

I am not meaning to insult. I am glad that you are currently properly licensed. I applaud you for that as many companies are not.

I am just frustrated that there are those that can't figure out basic solutions to IT issues while those like myself are left with difficulty finding jobs even with experience backing us.

Please don't respond with if I am any good I would have job, because companies would rather hire someone with certifications and no experience and have their network screwedup than hire someone with the experience to get the job done correctly.

This discussion is closed to new replies.