This is sad but so true as to possibly give you nightmares
This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post
Hardware
This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post
by jardinier
Because of a particular website I publish, I am kept up to date to a certain extent on the influence of Christianity in places where there has only existed "primitive" (indigenous would be a better term) religions.
Christian missions, by providing practical assistance especially, seem to be making more progress than Islam in these places.
I would be interested to hear any opinions, supported by data/statistics, that might prove me wrong.
Some of you know I have a strong personal emotional investment in the plight of orphans in third world countries. Christianity gives hope to the "hopeless."
My research has indicated that Christian-based organizations (sometimes referred to as NGOs) are doing much more work than Muslim-based organizations.
Please feel encouraged to refute my belief if you can.
As to the actual topic of this discussion, dawg might be interested to know that some 15 years ago a neighbor of mine in Sydney predicted that France would be the first European country to become Muslim. I dismissed the idea at the time. Now it appears that he was right.
by jdclyde
by tonythetiger
Pro Islam to some, but apparently created to try to instill fear in the ignorant and stupid.
I don't give a rat's ass about your religion, your politics, your color, your country of origin, or your sexual preference. Humanity needs to rid itself of this pesky habit of judging the person by the category they are in rather than what each individual DOES.
by jdclyde
If you belong to a group that does "bad things", then you are a part of the down side of that group.
ANYONE that joins the KKK should be looked down upon, for just one quick example.
by oz_media
Tony you said it all, right there. Funny I thought you sat on th eother side of that fence, forgive me for reaching such a conclusion, it's not like we haven't discussed much with each other.
The lack of cultural immersion is what leads to such unwarranted bigotry. Poeple think they are being sharp and on the ball, when in fact they are merely displayign their ignorance.
by jamesrl
The KKK have a core set of beliefs that include some pretty nasty racist attitudes.
But Muslims should not be judged solely based on the actions of radical Muslims, anymore than we should judge Catholic priests by the actions of the few that have abused children.
Every religion has had adherents who have abused others. Because religions are made up of humans, and humans are fallible.
James
by tonythetiger
They "joined" a group that has, in my opinion, an evil purpose. Most KKK members claim to be Christian. Do we hold ALL Christians responsible for what one of the KKK members DOES?
Likewise for Muslim terrorists. Because one of them "joined" a radical group that claims to be Muslim that has, in my opinion, an evil purpose. Do we hold ALL Muslims responsible for what the one does?
Please note that "saying" and "doing" are two different things as well. You can "wish" all of (insert disliked group here) were dead if you want, and voice that opinion all you want, and though it might be in poor taste, thoughts, expressed or not, are not legally actionable.
"The law" should be logical at all times. There is no room for even the slightest hint of emotion. Chaos would ensue if we were to write laws based on "feelings" or who might be offended. One, because people's feelings often differ on the same subject, and two, because there's no legitimate way to ascertain whether the "feelings" are genuine or contrived. We'd end up with speech that was either legal or illegal, depending on who heard it.
by oz_media
by oz_media
A bad group such as the KKK, yes you have a point. A bad group such as anarchist, arayan, skinheads, sure.
But Islam is a religion that encompasses so many beliefs that it can't be judged teh same way. A mainly peaceful religion of giving yuorself wholly to God is not a bad thing. However there are those who interpret their God's will to mean other things, such as death to all non believers, which is an issue for concern I think.
So your analogy is accurate in more defined areas, it does nto however mean that anyone believing in God is evil.
KKK believe in God, the same Christian god that racially accepting people pray to.
Arayan's have faith in God, the same Christian God than most racially accepting people pray to.
In fact, both of thse groups are no different than bigots who consider anyone from the middle east is an enemy to be disposed of.
So teh group here, that posts such fears of those who are different from them, are no different than tklan members, White arayan nation, black panthers, Islamists etc.
they hate without cause, they hate because of difference. In fact, the Klan doesn't even care about yoru religious preference, they are just hell bent on skin colour alone, at least radical islamists and muslim terrorists are doing so out of a misconstrued religous belief and not just skin colour.
Now that I think of it, they are a lot more acceptable than our own racist groups.
So being
by oz_media
Is that he and many others like him, actually believe such garbage and live it/parrot it day in day out. I just feel for their kids should they be brainwashed into such a backward mentality and not lead to make their own decisions based on facts and not 'creative cultural examination'.
It's almost like the old US war propaganda, that still exists in some people's minds as fact even today.
Or my sisters first mother in law, who swore to her grave that the holocaust never happened and that there was no such thing as death camps. It was all western propaganda in her mind.
Sounds absurd but its really no different than some of the ignorant bogotry displayed in this thread.
They really do think they see what others living through such experiences themselves do not.
by oz_media
So now you've changed your tune from all Europeans are socialist/communists to you have "proof" that Europeans are more likely to lean farther left than right. My god, somebody call the captain, we have dissention amongst the ranks, how DARE they lean left! LOL, what a tool!
So anyone leaning more toward the left in America or Canada,(which includes MOST Canadians under American standards) is a commie out to let us all be overrun by Allah crying Muslims.
You sir, are a nuttter! I've always said so and you just keep proving your insanity al the time, in fact going well out of your way to ensure we all know you are a looney this time.
Somebody get the net.
by gate keeper
let me try to explain something to you; it is probably in vein but here it is anyway.
This whole debate is an Apples vs. Oranges debate.
The entire argument is based on a few flawed assumptions:
1- If you are born to Muslim parents; you are by default Muslim. (hint im talking about converts here which there are a great many on both sides)
2- If a country has a majority population of Muslims that country is automatically considered an Islamic state(e.g Turkey)
4- That the fertility rates quoted are actually accurate.
you are comparing a religion to Race, where barrier to entry to one of them is trivial and the other impossible.
over a period of time guess which group will have the more members ?
to put it more plainly in terms even you can understand:
[b] The barrier to entry in Islam: [/b]
All that is required is to embrace Islam and a simple declaration called "Al-shahaada" which translated into English means "I bear witness, that there is no other god but Allah, and Mohamed is his messenger" and presto you are now a member of the [b]mass-breeding heathens [/b]
[b]The barrier to entry to be American/European/??? culture:[/b]
Admission is by birth alone
which is implied by the argument that X% of Muslims will be born in Europe/America .. meaning being born in America/Europe does not grant you access to this club; if you are born to Muslim parents.
Then is it any surprise that the more exclusive of the two groups will have less members .. I know you are quite slow but I hope I have been able to help you connect the dots a little bit.
by oz_media
Lefty commie baystard, what do you know?
You need to lean much further to the right in order to match such thoughtless racism.
by gate keeper
I felt bad about, taking the kiddy gloves off in my earlier comment; so I thought why not try to show him how dumb he actually sounds ;)
That is my charity for the day
by jamesrl
...that in many communities that I have spent time at in Canada, the Muslims and Sikhs tend to be very conservative socially, financially and politically. They are far from socialists, in the main, though in any group you will find some on both fringes.
I recall the clash in France over religious headgear. It was the "white" long time French who fought for the ban on students wearing any religious items in school -crosses, kirpans, turbans or Hijabs.
So this idea that all non westerners are socialists and that their immigration to Europe will hasten communism is a red herring.
James
by oz_media
show him how dumb he actually sounds? LOL, riiiiiight.
I did that for months and he STILL thught he was clever, even when standing there with his pants down and nothign more to add, he STILL thought he was clever.
Must be all that time on his private jet service, goes to your head I suppose.
by tonythetiger
I'm all for immigration. The other is I don't think people should be limited in opportunity merely because of where they were born.
The extreme conservatism you may perceive from me applies only to government functions and policies. The rest of me functions largely in the opposite direction :)
by jkameleon
It's from this concert
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1,2,3_Soleils
Khaled recently had a concert here, and that's what turned my attention to Arabic pop.
BTW, Rachid Taha's is the author of the "Barra Barra" piece
http://www.dailymotion.com/video/x2yb7f_rachid-taha-barra-barra_music
which became famous after it appeared in the movie "Black Hawk Down". It's being used as a background music for nearly every anti islamic documentary since then.
by oz_media
so?
Perhaps the correct solution is to go there and remove everyone's ears , so they too can't be drawn into the lair of horrors and ugly, creepy things.
by jardinier
The figures given in the video are very questionable but the unarguable reality is that Islam is infiltrating Western countries by immigration and it is a one-way street.
You will not find Westerners queuing up to migrate to Pakistan, Bangladesh, Indonesia or any other country that has a sizeable Muslim population.
I personally am in favor of national identity and so I would be against anything that would dilute that, whatever the country.
by jamesrl
If I look at the history of my country and the United States, you can hardly consider it to be "static". Each culture that came to our land changed the overall "culture".
Afterall if there were no "dilution" as you suggest, I'd be speaking a Huron/Algonquin dialect, and you'd be speaking aborigine.
So what right do we have to somehow stand in front of the tide and demand it stop when we once were that tide?
I certainly don't suggest we go back to the old days of "state" religions. And I think countries who have rules on immigration should not base any part of those rules on religion. I can see rules on language, working skills, money in the bank etc., but never on religion.
You can't force a national identity to stay the same in the tide of globalism, anymore than you could hundreds of years ago when Western Europe was immigrating to the Amnericas and Australia. I know we have people in Canada who are trying, particularly in small town and rural Quebec but its in my opinion wrong headed.
I do take pride in my heritage, both my families long history in Canada and our origins in Scotland, but it would be disingenuous of me or anyone to suggest that others mute their national pride just because they chose, like my ancesters did, to seek a new life in a different country.
James
by jardinier
Yes it would depend on what particular point in time the culture was measured. Australia has always been referred to as "The Lucky Country" perhaps because we have never had to fight on our own soil for our independence or freedom.
Much as I appreciate the increasing cosmopolitanism of Australia -- it saves me travelling overseas to meet people from other countries/cultures -- I would not like to see the character of Australia change to the point where it was no longer recognizably unique.
"rules on language, working skills, money in the bank etc." These are definitely the criteria set for migrants to Australia -- money seemingly the most important.
As I like Eastern philosophy, I enjoy very much chatting to Hindus and Sikhs who work as check-out persons at supermarkets, and also Nepalese. The staff at gas stations, at least in the area of Sydney where I move, are almost entirely Indian. I have a lot of Chinese friends.
Whereas people from Asian countries assimilate readily into Australian society, the same cannot be said for Middle Eastern peoples.
But I would have to make a study. There are enclaves of different nationalities in particular areas of Sydney.
I will sleep on this and add to it later perhaps.
by jdclyde
Especially when there is talk of recognizing sharia law in civilized nations?
Something apologists seem to want to allow in the misguided efforts to appease Muslims.
by tonythetiger
by jamesrl
I see that you identify all these people you meet in Australia, not as fellow citizens, but by their country of origin. Surely the majority of them are now Australians. My experience in Canada, is that the second and third generations from the initial immigrants tend to lose some of their cultural distinction and take on "Canadian" traits and I'd be suprised if it isn't the same for Australia.
James
by jdclyde
if the children of immigrants stick to the subcultured regions where people seek to be who they were before they came to Canada/America.
It is criminal for a second generation (now citizen) to not speak the language of the land.
by jamesrl
Many third generations can't speak their grandparent's mother tongue.
Our citizens must be able to communicate in one of the official languages, English or French, in order to pass the tests.
But of course English is a second language in India, Pakistan, Hong Kong dating back to the days of British rule.
James
by jardinier
Perhaps you overlooked this remark in my post. Because I have a high respect for Eastern religious philosophies, I have always felt a strong affinity with Indians and Chinese especially. I regard essential Hinduism as light years ahead of the "religions of the book," and also relate strongly to Taoism.
My principle interaction with Indians occurs at the supermarket where they work as check-out persons -- often while studying at university. I have established a strong mutual friendship with some of these people. They raise a big smile when I enter the shop. They speak perfect English, usually with no perceptible accent.
I know a few words of Mandarin and I can say "hello" in Hindi, Korean and Japanese. These people obviously respect the fact that I have taken the trouble to learn just one work of their language.
I live in a part of Sydney known as the North Shore, which is upper middle class. The only enclave we have here is of South African Jews who are much disliked because of their arrogance.
I will always consider my Asian friends to first be Indian, Chinese or whatever, even when they get Australian citizenship.
A 22-year-old Sikh girl (I will insert her name later) was delighted when I asked her to explain their marriage system. The girls marry between the ages of 22-25. When they feel ready to marry, they tell their parents who then choose a suitable groom for them. The system seems to work well.
Alas she told me her parents would not consider me a suitable husband for me. :(
I may add to this later. This is my third attempt to make this post after two other carefully worded answers disappeared into cyberspace before I could upload them.
[Edited twice because parentheses appeared as question marks.]
by jdclyde
by jamesrl
In Ontario, it was recommended by a sub committee but when it came to the Ontario government, they shot it down. At the same time they realized that the Jewish community had been allowed a similar privelege with no contest divorces, so that privelge was also withdrawn.
We still have aboriginal sentancing circles but only for minor crimes.
James
by jdclyde
German and Greek, and I can't speak any of either.
I have been reading more about my Greek heritage, and wish I knew more.
by jamesrl
My suspicion that this isn't much different than Christian versus Christian or Hindu versus Hindu, etc etc.
Many people think this is religious in nature, but its often more about power.
In England centuries ago, and Ireland, years ago, there were murders based on religion, but power played much into it.
In Northern Ireland, the Catholics felt they were discriminated against in the job market. But did the Catholic Church or the Protestant churchs themselves encourage violence?
In England of King Henry VIII's day (and for many generations) it was a struggle over which religion would hold sway over the King (or Queen).
Is it worse for a Shia to die from a Sunni murderer than for a Muslim in Bosnia to die from a Christian? They both end up dead.
James
by oz_media
Islam does NOT "demand" you get circumcised. Your assertion is false.
Circumcision is the Sunnah of Prophet Ibrahim and Prophet Muhammad . The Prophet said, "There are five things that are of the nature (i.e. of the natural hygiene): removing the pubic hair, circumcision, trimming the mustache, removing the underarm hair, and cutting of the nails.
It does not have to be done before conversion, it does not HAVE to be done after but it is encouraged and highly recommended.
by forum surfer
My current girlfriend asks the same things of me! I have to go check her closet for bomb making supplies...
:paranoid:
by tonythetiger
by jardinier
Some of you may not know that historically this barbarous practice was not confined to Islam. It was practiced also by Jews and Christians.
It is practiced by Muslims in Australia and I am pleased to be able to report that it has been made illegal -- not that this will stop it occurring I presume.
Sydney : Female circumcision is called female genital mutilation (FGM) in Australia and it's a crime.
Those performing it face a possible seven-year prison term and those who don't report it risk a stiff fine.
In Sydney's outer suburb of Auburn, there's a specialist FGM clinic that has been in operation for over 10 years and sees around 40 women a year.
The typical patient is in her 20s, is about to wed, and was operated on by a village midwife in an African or Middle Eastern country when she was young.
The clinic adopts the World Health Organisation definition of FGM as a surgical procedure "involving partial or total removal of the female external genitalia or other injury to the female genital organs for cultural or other non-therapeutic reasons".
There is anecdotal evidence that the law is being broken and FGM is being performed in Australia. Ten doctors have reported being approached by parents looking to have it done.
There is also a suspicion that parents skirt local law by taking their daughters to their homeland to have the operation performed there which is also an offence.
Earlier this year, a judge in the Family Court set a precedent by confiscating the passport of an African-born citizen and that of his nine-year-old daughter "just in case the purpose that I have mentioned is in fact what he has in mind".
The father, who described himself as a "respectable Muslim scholar in the Muslim community", insisted he was opposed to FGM and that he had no intention of taking his daughter to Africa for that purpose. His wife, who was also questioned, said that she too was against the practice.
It was the second time that the Family Court had addressed the issue. In the first case, which involved another family, the court ordered the parents to be "restrained from visiting upon the child the act of circumcision, or any other surgical procedure with like effect, and allowing any other person to do so".
http://www.twocircles.net/2009apr30/australia_takes_tough_line_female_circumcision.html
by jdclyde
I do not care what was done 100 or 1000 years ago, I care about what is happening today.
We also had an issue about a year ago with "honor killings" here in the States.
by jardinier
Then please use Google to educate yourself as to what is happening today.
The U.S. Department of Health and Human Services states that the custom of FGC "cuts across religions and is practiced by Muslims, Christians, Jews and followers of indigenous religions."
by tonythetiger
[i]There is also a suspicion that parents skirt local law by taking their daughters to their homeland to have the operation performed there which is also an offence.
Earlier this year, a judge in the Family Court set a precedent by confiscating the passport of an African-born citizen and that of his nine-year-old daughter "just in case the purpose that I have mentioned is in fact what he has in mind".[/i]
would probably be unconstitutional here. Can't punish someone for something you think they might do. I'm not sure how going somewhere, legally, and doing something THERE that is legal THERE can logically be called illegal HERE. How do you get jurisdiction of something happening in another country?
(I'm not supporting the practice, mind you, I'm just trying to grasp the legal reasoning).
by jdclyde
crossing a state line for sex with a minor, offense.
taking a minor across state lines to have sex in a state where it would be legal, offense.
then there are the sex tourists. going to a country where anything/any age goes to have underaged sex is also illegal.
when they get back, they would be charged with the crime. of course, the child has already been mutilated by her barbaric parents for life.
so much for protection.
by nicknielsen
It makes criminal not the intent to have sex with a minor, but crossing state lines with that intent.
I believe there are several [u]federal[/u] laws which make it illegal to cross a state line with the intent to commit a crime. From what I've heard, they are primarily used as "piling on" charges by federal prosecutors. "A federal grand jury indicted him for bank robbery and other crimes."
by tonythetiger
I can see it in the "taking a minor across state lines" one, it is the "taking a minor" that is prosecuted, not the sex.
I don't understand the other ones though... I'm not in my home state's jurisdiction, so I don't know how I can be prosecuted. Prostitution is an example... It's legal in many countries, so if I go to one of them and partake of the wares, when I come back, I can be prosecuted? As I said... I'm not supporting the practices... but I don't see the logic.
by jamesrl
Canada has a similar law about sex tourism. But how do you try someone for an act committed in another country, unless the country where the crime takes place wants to extradite someone.
So even if it is somehow legal to prosecute, can you summon witnesses etc. in another country?
Unless there is solid evidence (video) available to the prosecutors, how can you have a successful trial?
James
by jdclyde
"for the sake of the children".
Just like lawsuits, you learn real quickly that justice is not equal, nor "fair and just".
by jdclyde
lets just say, I have NEVER heard of a single Christian or Jew in the US, Canada, or the UK perform these barbaric acts.
Got an example?
Looking at your link:
[b]Judaism[/b]
The Oxford Dictionary of the Jewish Religion states that female circumcision was never allowed in Judaism.
[b]Christianity[/b]
FGC has never been part of Christianity as a faith system.
by jardinier
to do a search yourself, I gave a link to the one page that specifically uses the present tense: "cuts across religions and [b]IS [/b] practiced by Muslims, Christians, Jews and followers of indigenous religions."
If you would care to do a search about circumcision in general, you will most likely learn a number of things of which you are currently unaware -- notably that [b]MALE [/b]circumcision predates Judaism, Christianity and Islam.
In fact the whole study of circumcision of both males and females is indeed most interesting.
So you have never personally heard of a case. That is why we have Google -- to learn about things about which we previously were uninformed.
by jardinier
If you do a search you will find that female circumcision is not mentioned in either the Koran or the Hadith.
So the fact that it is not referred to in Judaism or Christianity proves nothing at all. It was practiced by indigenous peoples BEFORE all of the religions of the book and so they continued to practice it, just as people in South American countries continue to observe aspects of their native religions, combined with Roman Catholicism.
From the wiki article and other references, I learned many things that I have previously NEVER HEARD OF through my normal study of comparative religions.
You will see that there are many reasons why girls are mutilated -- one being that it discourages masturbation because the genitals are no longer itchy or irritating.
by jdclyde
by jardinier
"Savages in the jungle or the middle east are hardly sterling examples of what to look up to."
What a totally stupid remark which is in no way related to the forum topic or the offshoot on female circumcision.
Who is asking you to look up to anything or anyone? I guess you just can't handle the notion that circumcision on females occurs [b]TODAY within ALL THREE religions of the book.[/b]
What on earth makes you post what you do? You assure us what a fine fellow you are with your patronising references to Hindus. Gosh! you can say "hello" in Hindi, Korean and Japanese. Wow! And you're only in your sixties!
Out of nowhere we get the post on FGM. We get "Some of you may not know that historically this barbarous practice was not confined to Islam. It was practised also by Jews and Christians."
It's CULTURAL, you idiot. It doesn't belong in this thread. The "offshoot on female circumcision." over which you lambast JD for his apparent disinterest is entirely down to you. Maybe he, like me, doesn't get excited about your copy-and-paste from Wiki.
But when has relevance ever bothered you?
:)
Hello, Julian. I thought we'd seen the last of you.
About a year ago one of you help me find the registry entry that caused my dvd burner not to work It has happened again.
Can any one please help.
I use windows vista
Optirac DVD RW AD 7200A aTA burner
Many Thanks
This is a thread about European Muslim birthrates and the eventual take-over of Europe by Militant Islam. Whilst some of the respondents are pretty clued up on Registry matters, many more will read a question with a relevant title. One of them might be your original saviour...
:)
by jdclyde
by jardinier
The thread is about the intrusion of Islamic people and their [b]CULTURE[/b] into Western countries.
Thanks for the warm welcome back. :x
I hope it gives you a warm, fuzzy feeling to be so superior to me in intellect and wisdom.
I do a lot of research on the internet for a variety of reasons. In most cases the wikipedia article is far more comprehensive than any other website or link, and includes illustrations (useful for my websites). Additionally there is a warning at the top of the page if the item might be biased.
If you have a better source of information you might like to share your secret with me.
I don't know why you feel the need to be continually rude to me, but I will regard it as your problem not mine -- you know, water off a duck's back and all that -- sticks and stones may break my bones etc. etc.
I have been posting here since November, 2002, and before the PTB changed the format, the number of threads started and total number of posts made by myself were given.
You used to be a nice person. Something has caused you to change and I don't think it could be me.
I did at one time make an undertaking not to start another thread in off-topic. However this was such a long time ago that I think the moratorium has expired.
Maybe I will start a thread: "Why do so many atheists feel intellectually superior to religious people?"
Well, Julian, I think of it as a public service. "You used to be a nice person. Something has caused you to change and I don't think it could be me." Alas, Julian, I think it could. you weren't necessarily what I would describe as nice but you were tolerable but your choice of topics in the last couple of years has been particularly gross.
In this particular case, however, it was just brought on by a combination of your posts. This particular thread was, indeed, about Islam and it was started by Dawg with a link to a pretty nasty, simplistic piece of racist crap. It was just winding down and along comes Julian, parachuting in from god knows where with another piece of racist crap - "Female circumcision. Some of you may not know that historically this barbarous practice was not confined to Islam. It was practiced also by Jews and Christians."
Why post that?
As your own Wiki link states, "The traditional cultural practice of FGC predates both Islam and Christianity. (...) The U.S. Department of Health and Human Services states that the custom of FGC '"cuts across religions and is practiced by Muslims, Christians, Jews and followers of indigenous religions.'" The Wiki page goes on but I'll recommend you to read it all for yourself as you've obviously not done that.
I have.
I'm just bloody ANNOYED with you. In order to post a reply, I had to read your link to find out if there was any veracity in your post. I now know more about the subject that I did before but I also know more than I need to know and more than I WANT to know. It was enough that I knew that it happened and that it was illegal here and illegal to take someone out of the UK for the practice if you wanted to bring them back or come back yourself.
Neil :)
By all means, start up "Why do so many atheists feel intellectually superior to religious people?". As I can't guarantee civility, I doubt that I'll post - so the field is yours.
And I think that he wants the same person to dig him out again. Oh, and not get pissed off that the OP forgot to write the fix down anywhere.
I've got to be honest. I do admire the poster's really, really poor placement of his question. It must go down as one of the most inappropriate thread hijacks since Julian's Female Circumcision comment... And his toasting of you for not being interested!
by jardinier
Maybe your parents didn't teach you good manners. Who knows? Who cares? I certainly don't.
And especially so from someone who self admits to using these forums purely for entertainment. :)
BTW it takes two people to debate or argue. I hope you enjoy any ensuing conversation you may have with yourself. :^0
to submit to the judgement of our peers. I'm happy to do that.
p.s. I notice that in your post you don't address my comment above that your original post on genital mutilation was racist, ignorant and inappropriate for the thread. It's probably beyond the bounds of inappropriate for the site.
Hey, just get stuck in with a bit of [i]ad hominem[/i], I guess I'll survive it.
This discussion is closed to new replies.
Sort by Trending