Discussion Locked

To Upgrade or Not to Upgrade

0 helpful
24 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.
Okay, I want to upgrade our 98 machines to XP. What are the benefits of buying the full version of XP. Or should I just purchase the upgrade. The cost difference is pretty substantial but my father (MIS Director) says they never purchase the upgrades because they always run into problems with them. So, what should I do? I would rather spend less money since we have spent a lot recently upgrading our systems. But if there are real benefits to purchasing the full upgrade then I will. Thanks.

24 replies

by timwalsh

This usually comes down to a matter of personal preference more than anything elseThe ONLY difference between the Upgrade CD and the Full CD is that the installation routine on the Upgrade CD looks for and authorized upgradable product before allowing the installation to complete.

The only "problems" I have ever encountered is when trying to conduct a clean installation on a computer (if the Installation routine doesn't find a previous product to upgrade, you must provide the install CD for that previous product.

The Full CD can be used to conduct either a clean or an upgrade installation.

Hope this helps.

by thechas

Normally, I would save the money, and go with the retail upgrade version.

However, many e-tailers are selling the Full OEM version of PX for under $140.

Spend $40 to $60 per PC for more RAM (your going to want a minimum of 256MB anyway) to have some qualifying hardware, and you get the full version for a lower cost than the retail upgrade.

Also, in a networked environment, you need to go with XP Pro.

Chas

by jackofalltech

Buy the W2K upgrade, have your W98 CD ready and do a clean install. Don't use XP. I could go on and on about why not to but you can do the research if you really care. The only thing XP is good for is to make it easy for the little kiddies (5-10 years old) to use the PC! In order to make it useable for the professinal, you have to turn off everything that makes it different from W2K!

Ralph

by djent

I agree! XP adds only gaming and some multimedia features targeted at consumers. W2K pro has full security ( in MS terms anyway) is stable and mature. Do clean installs only, upgrades are poor at best, to much trash carried over.

by admin

w2k support and patching will be dropped long b4 XP. We are all headed towards it, albeit reluctantly.

by maxwell edison

Skip XP for the workplace.

Go with Windows 2000 Professional. You can buy W2K Pro upgrade to save some $$ - but do a full and clead install as Ralph (rdschaefer@consultant.com) suggested. The fresh install will create a new NTSF partition, format the drive, and only prompt you for the W98 CD to verify you have a previous product.

In my opinion, that's the best way to go.

by tomsal

I run W2k Pro here at work, at hope I have XP Pro installed. XP Pro makes an excellent OS if you are a gamer, regardless what anyone else tells you.

Its well behind my comprehension, however, that Microsoft actually attaches the word "Pro" to an OS and yet it still lacks security of the older "non-pro" labeled , Windows 2000...not to mention - what's the deal with the kiddy-ize color scheme and icons? LOL..Ok I can see the point in the "home" edition but if you label something "Professional"-- shouldn't it look , well more for adults than for kids?

;)

But anyway, I have TONS of (over two decades) of experience as far as finding/using Oses that run games well .....considering that we are sucked into MS solutions for the huge bulkof new released games, Windows XP is a perfectly logical solution at home.

At work -- w2k all the way (if you must use Microsoft that is).

by mallardtooxx

I Must throw my hat in here and say one more thing, if you go to XP you will have nightmares for a week. Okay maybe not but I will. There is also the minor issue of configuration changes that may or maynot render your computer completely useless until you call microsucks and say "um I just changed the CMOS battery can I get back into my computer now?" Go with w2k you will not regret it. Go with XP and Freddie Kruger will show up on your door step....okay maybe not (again) but he could.
-duck

by admin

and turn off everything at the server once in AD so that you don't have to do it on each machine.
just an idea :)

by jacob

... is that its driver database is much more extensive than W2K. If you do alot of adding and removing hardware periphrials you'd notice a difference.

Jacob Behm

by den dydige

Do you *have to* do this for some reason?

If not, then don't.

I've sinned against the rule "If it works, don't fix it" several times, and I have seriously considered putting up a banner telling me so.

by lordinfidel

there are 2 different definitions here.

1- Upgrading the OS (physically)

2- Buying a Upgrade License.

Upgrading the OS from 98 to XP by inserting the media and letting it "upgrade" the present OS is yes, a bad thing and will have mixed results. I personally also never perform an "upgrade"

So do you have to buy a "Full" license. NO!

You can buy a Upgrade license from 98 to XP, then buy the media (usually $25). Blow away 98 and start from scratch.

You just need to understand the differences when talking about the actual install process and the licensing aproach.

All because you buy a "Upgrade License" Does not mean that you have to actually perform a "OS upgrade". You can do a clean install.

But for licenesing purposes you can not use that 98 licences. The 98 license plus the XP upgrade license = The real XP license.

All of this is assuming that you have a vendor that you can purcahse open volume licensing from.

You only need to purcahse 5 licenses at one time to qualify for OpenLicense. It is where you do not go to the store and buy copies of the OS. You contact your vendor, buy the "virtual" lisences which are then assigned to your "account". And you get your license keys thru M$ eOpen License site.

by admin

actually, you have to buy the license and Software Assurance to get a volume license key for XP. They don't actually sell XP alone with VLK. If you want it they will probably say it is unavailable as a product.

Strange but true.

Incidently, you don't have to get an XP license either, win98 is a qualifying product and then you get SA and then can order XP or 2k media and get your VLK on the e-open site.

I was totally amazed when I actually figured it out too, but my insistance on disk images and no unique identifier won out in the end :)

by lordinfidel

Not sure about it because I don't use XP on my netwk. (we all know how I feel about XP, no need to cover it again)

But I do have "licenses" for it because you can no longer buy 2K licenses.

I was able to buy my upgrade licenses for it and in my license pack I can go to the eOpen site and generate the license keys for XP.

I *ass*ume that I still have to do the whole activation thing.

Your probably correct that there is no "single" VLK for XP like there was in the past.

by jereg

Upgrade the software? Why bother. This is what I told my boss. W2k costs about $200 per desktop. XP pro costs about $400 per desktop. Total software, bout $600 per user, plus installation time reconfiguring, etc. The answer, pitch them all in the trash.

I can buy a new Dell, with W2k, XP Pro, all new hardware, a 3 year warranty, for under $750 each.
I said we buy the software, and get a free computer, or we buy new computers, and get the software free. Either way, you have all new hardware,and all new software. Win-Win.

by lordinfidel

Except, guy's like me blow away the OS when we get a new OEM machine anyways.

I never deploy a factory installed OS on my networks. The install everything under the sun on it. By time I get done removing all of the crap, it would of have been less time to install from scratch.

by tomsal

$400 for Win XP ?

Are you insane?

I can (because I *did*) buy Win XP Pro Full version *OEM* for $130.

And LordInfidel is correct, most of us do trash the factory installed OS as soon as we open the box (that's why god made ImageCast and Ghost isn't it? LOL)...

I hate the crap they install buy default, not to mention how I loathe the default IM's and AOL software installed too...

Just yesterday I placed an order for some Gateways for work and for the hell of it I said "can I get that with no OS on it?"...

They shot back "NOPE! We have a contract with Microsoft that requires each system to have Windows installed..." UGH!!!

I HATE THAT!!!

;)

by lordinfidel

Can now come shipped with NO OS now. They broke away from M$ on that one by offering Red Hat as an option.

Wkstns and Desktops still have to come with an OS.

But blowing away the OS solves that little issue.

Even my servers that I buy, Sometimes it's cheaper to buy them OEM with the OS installed. I just blow it away and install server from scratch.

by thechas

Notice:

1. They want to move from W98 to XP.

2. They already spent money upgrading their existing systems.

I would not want to run a corporate network with W98 PC's as the clients.
Since the decision has been made to switch to XP, the onlyquestion is which version to get:
Upgrade
Full
OEM
Licenses

Chas

by maxwell edison

Have you ever been asked a question like, "should I do this or that?", and your answer was, "well, you should really consider this other thing"?

Also included within the specifics of the post was, "I would rather spend less money since we have spent a lot recently upgrading our systems." (No indication of what the system upgrades were.)

There is the additional consideration of hardware requirements for XP versus Windows 2000. Just because he "wants to" upgrade to XP, doesn't necessarily mean that the desicion to do so is set in stone.

If an office is going to upgrade and there are still some choices that could be made and/or changed, looking at the overall cost - and hassle - of upgrading to XP versus W2K could be significant.

Upgrading from Windows 98 to Windows XP would cost $X.

Upgrading from Windows 98 to Windows 2000 would cost $X - $Y.

(Y = some unknown number, depending on the circumstances, but it will be a factor.)

On a "hassle factor" of 1-10, upgradingto XP would, most likely, be higher than if he upgraded to W2K.

(Of course, this is only one guy's opinion.)

by admin

We have two VLK's for all of our XP licenses because they were purchased in 2 SA units, but we use one key and open media packs (well, the image of one) for all the installs. It gets around the registration and activation, individual id, hard to image etc. complaints legally in an MS proper way.

Of course, we retain the oem licenses with the SA for compliance, but never use the keys or media.

by djent

This may be true BUT M$ doesn't get the bugs patch till SP# and by that time the next release is generating cash flow. The concept of upgrading to atain currency is M$'s goal in life. If the OS and apps perform desired function efficiently there is no need to uprade, period. If on the other hand you really want the new toy then buy it, but new IT toys are always buggy and break easily.

by admin

"Upgrading from Windows 98 to Windows XP would cost $X."

X may be better understood as X^1 X^2 X^3 or x3 and xMe unless XZ, Xs, XO, XSA or XD or Xoem in which case you may want XZ^1, XZ^2, XZ^3, XZ^4, Xs (1,2 or3) XO (please see retailer for fullrange) XSA (for which you will also need t,u,v,w,or x) XD or contact a system builder to understand your qualifying purchases. If you have any questions, we will be happy to give you a list of events near you, forward a list of resellers, give you afree e-mail subscription on our products or have you contact an MSCE for help in your unique situation.

I read on the Lindows site once that Ms has over 50 ways to license an OS. I'm glad they don't license my car. :)

This discussion is closed to new replies.