First I seriously doubt it's the motherboard.
Since you've experienced the same problem with 2 network cards I'd uninstall everything in network properties. Plus open add/remove programs and uninstall dialup networking from the windows setup/communincations/list.
Now reinstall but keep it simple, just install client, adapter, protocol and sharing. Should look like this;
Client for Microsoft Networks
Network Adapter
TCP/IP
File & Print Sharing for Microsoft Networks
Please re-check the settings for the network.
WORKGROUP: obvious, check spelling etc.
CLIENT: windows, remove others
Adapter: Is it set to auto-detect the speed and bound to the correct protocol. Is there conflicts in device manager with other deivices?
Dialup adapter(s): as mentioned remove til connected
PROTOCOL: what is the protocol? remove others like IPX/SPX and netbeui.
If TCP/IP, is it matching the rest of the network? DHCP, DNS (hostname, domain, primary & secondary server IP), Is IP addressing within the same range(example 192.168.0.1), is there a matching subnet mask (255.255.255.0)
If using a gateway is it correct?
Are you using firewall software? Has outgoing & incoming been allowed for the network adapter.
As mentioned can you ping the internal/loop address 127.0.0.1 or any of the others on the network.
Disconnect one of the working PCs and input those exact same settings on the PC with problem.