Discussion Locked

U.S. Economy - fastest growth rate in 20 years

0 helpful
51 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

.
The U.S. economy roared ahead in the third quarter, growing at its fastest pace in nearly 20 years, fueled by greater consumer and business spending. Third-quarter gross domestic product, a measure of all the goods and services produced in the U.S., rose at a sizzling 7.2% annual rate, more than double the 3.3% rate in the second quarter, the Commerce Department said Thursday.

I've seen the results from this growth, as our company is busier than we've been in a couple of years. We've added several people to the staff, and people can get as much overtime as they want.

The stock market, both the DOW and the NASDAQ, is up close to 20% for the year - after being down almost 30%. Intel is up 50%. Both Dell and Oracle are up 20%. Interestingly enough, Microsoft is up only slightly from a year ago. I wonder why? Checkpoint (I have some of these shares) is up 20%. By the way, does anyone remember my Red Hat inquiry a month or so ago? RHAT was trading at $8 at the time; it went over $15 today. If I remember correctly, Lordinfidel recommended to bet the farm on it. (Too bad I didn't have a farm.) The DOW has been trying to break the 10,000 barrier for the first time in a couple of years.

As I said, I see the results of an improved economy, and more importantly, I see the stage being set for more growth in the future.

Have you noticed the improved economy as well? Is there more tech spending on the horizon? I think yes.

51 replies

by road-dog

Now employment should be picking up soon as a lagging indicator.

Now even the NY times has admitted that the recovery was triggered by the Bush tax cuts. Today is a hopeful day on many levels...

by john_wills

Greenspan said that the tax cuts were the wrong thing to do but that it was the right time to do them.

by maxwell edison

Mr. Greenspan, Chairman of the Federal Reserve, told Congress that the country could be on the verge of a period of extended growth."

by thechas

Hi Max,

I have not seen any signs of an improved economy in Michigan.

Quite the opposite, many companies are still down-sizing and closing.

Beyond the automotive sector, the office furniture and appliance manufactures are still in a slump.

The state and most private companies in the area are only replacing dead PCs. Often from there own stock of equipment from layed off workers.

Time will tell.

Chas

by jimhm

Supply side economics - which the Democrats don't believe works - and love their tax's and spend policies...

Yes - it's coming back after the Hire Clinton relm - and kill Reagans economic policies.

For those that haven't felt it yet - the USA is moving from an industrial economy to information/services economy. The old mills and labor are going by the way side - it is cheaper to build and manufacture durable goods overseas where the labor cost is 1/3 of the USA.

I know it sucks - but thats what is happening as I see it from my office....

by maxwell edison

Two years after Reagan's tax cuts, the economy came roaring back and continued into the 90s. And here we are, entering into the second year of Bush's tax cuts.

Employment numbers will be better be mid-year 2004, that's always the lagging indicator, although they're not really that bad. I often wonder why someone sees 5% unemployment as that awful. If a person realizes that a 97% employment rate (3% unemployment) is considered to be FULL employment, 95% isn't bad at all - just part of the economic cycle. Even for the folks who can't find jobs, there's always work available somewhere doing something that could hold them over in the interim. (Yes, I've been there.)

by lizzy

Hi Max,
I haven't seen too much of it at work yet being a state agency and all.

My husband's business is doing better than ever even after all the hurricane (Isabel) damage in this area. He is a wholesale distributor of food product.

I agree with JimHM that a lot of labor will be going overseas. I recently read an article in the Richmond paper that said it's not really the labor costs, but the cost of litigation in this country. The article basically said that the US is so litigation crazy that the US cannot afford to pay the costs of lawsuits and settlements to keep the labor here. Now THAT's sad!!

by road-dog

The end to the litigiousness will come through tort reform using a "loser pays (LP)" system. LP demands that the oser pays all of the costs of both parties' legal expenses.

I would go one step further and expect the losing Attorney to pay a percentage of the winner's legal expenses equal to his agreed percentage of the requested damages.

This is the only way to stop the litigation lottery that has taken over our courts. Frivolous lawsuits are the result of minimal consequences of failure to make one's case. There is almost nothing to lose and fortunes to gain by filing a lawsuit. The defense costs become astronomical when dozens of these frivolous lawsuits are added up.

by thechas

I said and heard it before, "common sense, isn't"!

While there is an issue with litigation hungry clients and attorneys, the primary problem is that the average person in the US is no longer capable of thinking for themselves and using "common sense".

The majority of frivolous lawsuits that I have heard of ALL involve someone who has misused or abused a product INTENTIONALLY.

In addition to some form of jeopardy for failed suits, there needs to be a system that reduces awards when the plaintiff is at least partially responsible for their injury.

A good example of this, is the fools who sue their former employers when they tell the truth about the employees work record to a new employer.

Chas

by john_wills

In California law, and in German law, and probably in most jurisdictions, the loser DOES have to pay the winner's costs, but most winners don't bother trying to collect. In the case of frivolous lawsuits there is provision for punitive costs, i.e. costs greater than the costs the defendant incurred. One problem with these is that plaintiffs sometimes have no wealth with which to make up for the damage they've caused, like the "London Greenpeace" people McDonald's was more or less forced to sue for lying a few years ago: they were forced to stop lying, but McDonalds customers have to pay. The answer may be prison for some such people. "London Greenpeace" - which is not related to the well-known Greenpeace - might in principle have been prosecuted for criminal libel, and Englandandwales still does have the common-law right of private prosecution for public offenses, but the right has been abolished for libel cases, and the public prosecutor didn't bother.

by jimhm

I called into a talk show - that had a bunch of blood suckers - oops I mean lawyers ... Asked them the question of why not do a Loser Pay. Both the Lawyer that took the case and the client - would pay for the loss.

Oh - you should of heard these guys and girls crying a blue streak about how it would take the law away from the Poor and underclass. How those without money would no longer have access to the courts for settlement...

Oh - my cry cry cry ... I truely believe it would work ... but don't tell those blood suckers that... your taking away their meal tickets...

by john_wills

A few years ago an industrialist explained in The Economist why he put his new factory in the S-E USA instead of a third-world country, where the wages would be much lower: phones that work and courts that respect property rights. So the possibility of effective litigation is actually something that keeps jobs in the USA.

by road-dog

The courts do indeed protect property rights, (on occasion). I worry what will happen when litigation costs do increase to the point that companies cannot do business, or when the point will be reached where fear of litigation here exceeds fear of anarchy elsewhere.

Maybe that is the driver of the offshoring trend, that fear of employment litigation here exceeds fear in instability /war in India or Pakistan.

Companies are being hit from all sides, from ADA, product liability, employment rights, government mandate compliance (diversity, environmental protection), and worker's compensation costs.

All of these factors combine to make a "hostile working environment" in many states. These things have to be diminished to keep companies in the state. Too bad that too many folks don't see that when they "cash in" on a "big corporation" they are only hurting us all.

by jackofalltech

I think that a judge should be able to decide against someone, regardless of the merits of their case, if that person is an idiot.

Some examples:
Isn't it reasonable to expect coffee to be hot?
Is it wise to eat ANYTHING at McD's if you're a vegetarian?

Ralph

by jimhm

Being a volunteer medic in the area - we so much stupid shit - where if the person had even 1% common sense they would of known they would get hurt.

We had one of these intelligent fools cut the tips of his fingers off when using his lawnboy as a hedge trimmer ... Yes while it was running he picked it up and start trimming his hedges... Didn't want to browor his neighbors trimmer.

Liberals are removing common sense and personal responsibility from American youth.

We had a group of 15 to 18 year old cheerleaders that got busted drinking at a party, along we two football players. The cheerleaders had signed a contract that they wouldn't drink or use drugs, the football players didn't. The penilaties spelled out in the contract said they would be suspended for 10 days and removed from the cheerleader squad. And thats what happened. The football players were suspended for a signal game (even thou nothing should of happened to them at school it was a legal matter)...

The cheerleaders mom's and cheerleaders - are fighting the suspension and being kicked off the squad. The girls and parents signed the contract - they didn't have to, no one was forcing them to. Now that the girls screwed up - they are crying the blues they have to pay the penilty. Liberal parents - "Now sweety mommy and daddy will fix this you don't have to be responsibile for what you did.."

by jimhm

The Democrats are going nuts - now they are saying "Oh its not a recovery until the unemployement rate goes down." - What are they going to say when that happens in second quarter 2004 ... "Oh its not a recovery until it lasts for a year..." ...

The democrates are just disappointed that Supply side Economics works - Tax and Spend Government doesn't...

by cactus pete

I don't like no tax, all spend any more than I like tax and spend on someone else.

A reduction in spending MUST occur now, regarless of the taxing situation. [Trademark dpetrak, all puns intended.]

by maxwell edison

.
.....an across the board REDUCTION in government spending, say a 10% reduction, was MANDATED for EVERY department of government - no exceptions. Moreover, assume that the spending reductions could NOT result in ANY reduction of services provided by each particular department. The spending reduction could ONLY be applied in areas of waste, fraud, abuse, inefficiencies, redundancies, etc. Further assume, that if a department head, wherever he/she was situated in the pecking order, would be immediately FIRED if his/her reply was that it could not be done.

What would happen?

by dnvrtechgrrl

But, we never felt the recession either. I'm sure if I were still in Denver I'd notice a huge difference. Every weekend or so I'd call and check in with my father and he'd have another horror story of 60,000 or 40,000 being laid off. The title business has been great here. We've had record breaking months for over a year now, and every new staffer added is another user I have to work with. Plenty to do, plenty of expendable cash floating around this little town. Our population is about 200,000 and our unemployment is under 1%. That's not too bad if you ask me.

by jimhm

Where's that I may move ... is it a nice place to live - cheap - freindly - warm - loads of single women - things to do ??? Give with the info

by lizzy

Hi Jim,

dnvrtechgrrl = Denver tech girl

Winters are too cold and long for me...

by maxwell edison

.
Working on the premise that the employment numbers in Denver are similar to the state wide employment numbers, at least within a percentage point or so, the numbers you mentioned seem extremely high. With all due respect to you and your father, I would suggest that they might be somewhat exaggerated.

The population of Colorado is 4,400,000. 25% of those people are under 18 years of age, and 10% are over 65. That would put the potential work force at 2,800,000.

According to the Bureau of Labor Statistics, ~45% of the workforce is made up of women, and since 50% of Colorado's population is women, the potential workforce number would be further reduced (by ~25%) to about 2,000,000.

So if you look at an employment population of 2 million people, and that's probably a very conservative number (and the real number is probably less than that), having 60,000 laid off would amount to an additional 3% of the total workforce - on top of the ones unemployed already. And your message indicated that "an additional" 40,000 to 60,000 were laid off every week or so. That would lead a person to think that the unemployment rate in Colorado went from 5% down to 8% down to 11% down to 14% and so on, each and every week.

That's not the case at all. In actuality, the unemployment rate in Colorado is, and has been, better than the national average, which was around 6%. The unemployment rate in Colorado has never dropped below 5%, and if it did drop below that, it was 5.2, 5.3, or something in that range.

(And note, I said potential work force, as many of those folks don't work for a variety of reasons - early retirement, stay-at-home dads, unemployed by choice, etc. Moreover, a large part of Colorado's population is military, and they're not being laid off at all. And that doesn't even include the self-employed, for which numbers are not kept.)

So I think those "horror stories" are slightly exaggerated. It's not really that bad at all.

by jimhm

Lets say that is true - all your woif's (What If's)...

That would force these agencies to perform at an acceptable production levels as in business. What do you do in your own organization when the budget is cut by 10% and no reduction of services is permitted.

Hum - you become more productive, each employee must perform better - you watch the wasteful expenditures (you don't purchase that new computer when the one you are using is still working) - you start collecting on your collectables -

Gee wouldn't it be nice to see government running like a business - where the employee has to be productive rather than sleeping or goofing off .. in my job if I am not productive - I am gone. It's next to impossible to fire a government employee, so they hire someone else and keep the lazy one, still pay them and give them raises..

YOU MAKE THE DEPARTMENT MORE PRODUCTIVE YOU DON"T DUMP MORE MONEY AT IT - THATS HOW OUR GOVERNMENT HAS GOTTEN TO THIS POINT... Have you been to the unemployement office - those people more slower than water going uphill...

MAKE THE EMPLOYEES MORE PRODUCTIVE - Balanced Budget - No More TAX and SPEND Democrate policies - No More Tax the Middle and give to the LAZY - The backs of the Middle class are carring enough burden - Thanks to the Democratic policies..

If you study Economic's - or better yet - Play SymCity - and rase the tax in your city and see how fast it falls down - reduce the tax and see how fast it grows .... The government does not make money - the government spends money - they have no revenue source other than taxation - they generate no income -

by cactus pete

I'm gonna guess you just fired that one off..

The government certainly does help create wealth. They have a lot of private companies competing for contracts with the military, for one. These companies and their officers have gotten rather rich, as I recall. And they contribute to the economy.

Of course, this could be considered taxing me and giving the money to someone else... But we do justify it sometimes, don't we?

And I think you should not limit your "tax and spend" badness to democrats. Spending without having first taxed, that is worse. It passes the buck to the next generation.

I don't think it would be possible to pay off the debt by simply becomming more productive within the government. I believe that we will have to continue to have taxes, perhaps even higher taxes, for some time.

Is this a "tough choice". I'll let you define it how you like, but we need to pay off our debt and have a fiscal plan that accomplishes this as well as serves us after the debt is gone.

Dems tax and spend.
Pubs just spend.

Why doesn't the US live within its means?

by road-dog

I've seen studies where if the federal government simply froze spending for 10 years, the economy would grow us out of the problem. This actually makes sense, as the government grows at several times the rate of inflation.

I also believe that 5 percent of government employees should be laid off or retired. All personnel slots should be frozen, with budgets left static for 5 years. Fraud, waste, and abuse will only be found and fixed if bureaucrats are left no other alternatives. If a Manager or Department Head says it cannot be done, then they are part of the 5 percent.

by jimhm

The Government (as a Business) does not create weath for itself. Like a business - does your business make money? Does it have income from sales and services.

Government - collect taxes as its source of income - it does not generate wealth for itself - it distributes the taxes collected to other organizations true. But the federal government - state government - local governments do not create income - they tax for their income. If the governments did make income - taxes would begin to reduce as the income increases.

Business - Generates income and creates wealth - Government - Taxes and spends the funds collected they do not have an income... They don't sell services, they don't sell product, they don't create wealth for themselfs...

Does that clear it up ...

by cactus pete

I would love the bloat to be exercised.

But the economy would have to absorb all of the low skill people put out by the firings and cutting back. There would be less of a social net to catch them, too. Immediately, things would get VERY bad - crime, inflation, etc. Those short term problems would make the long term gain that much further off.

I would think just electing decent people would help, but then decent people never run - and if they do, they don't get far. The political machines see to it. That has been my major reason for not trying. I believe it would ultimately be wasted. And I have a wife to whom I feel compelled to protect from the crap involved. [She hates the hours of this job as it is.]

It's all so depressing, really.

But what could be done, just freeze things where they are - no emergency funds, either. Aren't the emergencies already in the budget, anyway?

I'd like to see much of the foreign aid put on hold, too. Drop out rates for school kids in the teens [as a percentage] is rediculous. And they should all go to college - I don't care what kind. A HS diploma doesn't cut it around here anymore.

So many of the parents need to have expectations for their kids, too. That is where it all starts. Let compell the parents to send the kids to school and get good grades. Kids with good grades could be a tax writeoff, for all I care. [Low income people wouldn't see this, perhaps, but I'm sure we could make a reduction in social work and oversight a bonus for kids' grades.]

Grades and school. But one small part in getting this taken care of.

I think a government channel would be good, too. Let's put the administration's word right up there against the for-profit pundits'. Lets see weekly debates by the president and anyone. Let's see daily debates of all the congressional sessions - on free broadcast stations.

Let's get America involved in what it is to be an American. Get some morals back around here, stop the corruption in elected officials and corporate officers, and get the economy - from which all other things flow - where it belongs.

by road-dog

100,000 federal employees hitting the streets would cause a ripple, but not a collapse. Remember that businesses lay off 5000+ at a time.

100,000 spread nation wide means an average of 2000 per state. That's not so big, really? The private sector has been getting reamed for decades. It's time the government began to do more with less.

As for requiring college, I don't agree. Some folks have it, some folks don't. It's harsh, but somebody's got to make the french fries. It won't be my kids unless it's after school and their grades are good. Even if it were a rigid law of the land, some parents will still suck. Even with free college, many of these kids will suck also. Mandatory college will not change this either, other than forcing kids who want to better themselves to be subjected to 4 more years sitting with a bunch of genetically engineered minimum wage earners.

Law cannot override human nature. Human nature is that some of us excel, many apply ourselves, some do the minimum and get the minimum. The skinny left end of the bell curve isn't going away. Throwing money at it will not fix that.

by cactus pete

By your definition, no one creates wealth.

Government applies strategies and directs monetary policy. [I wish it did a better job at fiscal policy.]

Of course, if you're willing to cede that Bush has nothing to do with creating wealth, please go ahead.

by maxwell edison

.
I think that George Bush (either one of them) would make that admission himself. The president doesn't create wealth for the citizen. Nor does Congress. Nor does government. All government can do is to "clear the way" for the individual to create wealth (or choose not to) for himself.

And yes, I think that's exactly what the President would say. He might also say that government, in general, all too often gets in the way of people attempting to create wealth for themselves. Both of which I agree with, by the way.

Gee, I wonder what Bill Clinton would say in this regard? Maybe yes, he CAN create wealth - by REDISTRIBUTING it? :~)

by cactus pete

Again, I generally don't disagree with you on this topical line..

But I wanted to clarify my statement about college:

"And they should all go to college - I don't care what kind. A HS diploma doesn't cut it around here anymore."

The 'kind' of college was left open. This could be training in anything, even just customer service, pride in citizenship, or "how to volunteer". But high school doesn't teach you to flip burgers, not does it teach you much of anything you will likely use in a job. It's really just a liberal arts program [not that there's anything wrong with that].

The 'college' after high school doesn't have to last even a year. If you want training in one little thing, like how to serve customers, then there should be 'schools' around to teach that.

Yes, this should be done by the private sector, I think, but there is nothing wrong with the state taking a lead here. Perhaps private schools can get tax credits for giving away classes in being nice people.

by cactus pete

OK, I'll get into this one...

If the government can hinder the creation of wealth by others, it can foster the creation of wealth by others, thus having a hand [invisible as it may be] in the creation of wealth.

The government can also identify areas in which wealth can be created. Defense contracts are an easy illustration.

"We need 100 new aircraft" and Boeing makes them, gets paid, etc. The goverment was the consumer in this case, but that simply completes the market. They had an effect in the creation of this wealth.

If there were a budgetary freeze and they couldn't buy these new planes, no wealth would be created, because there was no demand for the product. Boeing wouldn't just build them anyway and sell them to other interested parties.

And I'm not sure that the Air Force [of which I am a brat] could trim out the billions necessary to buy them simply by firing 5% of their people and being more efficient. I suppose you could aruge the efficiency of the lease itself... But this is a different debate.

Government directs the creation of wealth on way or another. We cannot deny this.

by cactus pete

The Bush comment was made in jest, I would think you saw that.

At any rate, if Bush (43) doesn't see how the creation of wealth is manipulated [fine, we'll say guided] by the deeds or omissions of the government, than he needs to talk with his father about economics. (41 received his degree in Econ in 3 years. I believe it was 41 who coined the phrase "Voodoo Economics" when referring to Reagan's Supply Side theories which are being employed by 43 now.)

My take is that the Debt [note the big D] is the main issue for our economy. We must address this almost 7 trillion dollar monster. Sometimes this will mean not lowering taxes, but spending the receipts in a manner best suited to creating wealth.

Of course, when the government pays back the interest on the Debt, someone makes money. Maybe this is the Supply Side manner of creating wealth.

by onbliss

...that the IT market is up. Billing hours have increased. Layoffs are here and there. Today I heard a company laid off bunch of people. But the general perception is a sigh of relief and a cautiously being optimistic. Hearing lots of .Net opportunities. The Holidays spendings should keep the general economy moving and gather further momentum.

Hope all of us have seen the bottom (atleast for some time). Here is good luck to everybody.
Happy Holidays!!! Keep smiling :-)))

by maxwell edison

.
In its simplest form, it could be said that wealth is created by providing goods and services for others - assuming, of course, that others are willing to pay for those goods and services. Wealth goes to the person providing the goods and services, not to the person paying for them. Therefore, creating wealth equals creating goods and services.

Does the government directly create wealth (for itself) by providing goods and services? No, it doesn't. Does the government indirectly help others create wealth for themselves by being a customer of those goods and services? Sure they do. But it's the efforts of "the others" that creates wealth, not the customer.

If the ACME bomb and bullet company created wealth for itself by providing goods and services, i.e. bombs and bullet, to the government, then so be it. (But the "government" is really you and me, since WE pay for those goods and services.) What if the government no longer continued to be a customer? Then either ACME bomb and bullet company would have to find another customer for its products, or go out of business - cease to create wealth for itself, or find different goods and services to sell to those who want them - widgets, for example.

Providing goods and services "creates wealth". Being a customer just facilitates that effort.

Of course, you could give examples of where people create wealth for themselves while NOT providing goods and services, but bank robbery and such is rather frowned upon. Wait - maybe the government DOES create wealth!

by jimhm

OK - The US Airforce needs 100 new F22 jet fighters at a cost of $150 million each us. Now where is the government getting that money. Did they sell some kind of goods or service? Did they produce that $1.5 billion by billing for services?

Where is the income being produced by any government? There is none - government can aid in the creation of individual wealth or hamper it. Through taxation and higher interest rates, or lower taxation and lower interest rates as one means.

The democrate way of thinking is that the government is making money through taxation. That that taxation money is income to the government - wrong! You can not tax yourself to riches..

I Know GWB would say that he does not create wealth - he enables the system to aid in the creation of individual wealth. (Reduced tax's for one)... I am not sure if Billery and Gore'be would say the same thing...

Government produces no wealth no goods no services (for sale) - they suck the life blood out of a civilization if not kept in check .... the beast can grow to unmanagable size in a matter of years...

by cactus pete

Treasury Bonds.
Leasing federal lands for grazing or logging.
Licensing airwaves.
Hauling cargo into space.

These are examples of ways the government generates income from its wealth. [As these terms are defined in the economic perspective.]

The term wealth is any thing that can generate income. Every criminal kept from stealing or destroying someone's assets - the government has prevented the destruction of wealth. Since we are the government, we have benefitted, and income is generated.

If you want to get really technical, let's argue the definition of income versus that of wealth. Let's see if "wealth" can be created at all! [It can]

by maxwell edison

...then why is Microsoft sitting on a forty billion dollar pile of cash while I'm sitting on a forty billion dollar pile of bills?

by maxwell edison

.
Creating income does not equal creating wealth.

And I further agree that the government can create "income" for itself by:

Issuing Treasury Bonds.
Leasing federal lands for grazing or logging.
Licensing airwaves.
Hauling cargo into space.

and

By imposing taxes.

by maxwell edison

.
...as a way of generating income, it "could" have the opposite effect and actually reduce income.

Thus we have all these interesting political discussions.

Tax something zero percent and you get zero income. Tax something 100% and you get zero income.

The optimal percentage is somewhere in-between, and it's constantly moving - kinda' like a pendulum. It's just like the President's Day sale at the local furniture store. They reduce prices to increase their volume of units sold, and even though their per unit profit is reduced, their total income is increased.

So lower taxes might mean more income to the government, right?

by jimhm

First selling bonds is not Income - it is selling Debt - into the future ... you owe interest on those bonds??? Ah - freaking democrats...

What was that about selling - timber... Not after the Greeny Weenies stop it. Crying the blue streak about about killing off the old growth forests...

And flying stuff into space... Try again when was the last time NASA took a satelite (non-military or government) into orbit? France and Germany launches are cheaper than americas...

So from the few Trillion the US and all governments in America take in from TAXES - they also take in what maybe another 200 million at the federal level only ... there is no income from state or local levels... and they are all running in the RED! ...

Lets simply raise Taxes - lets not control spending - lets not balance the budget - Na - the government creates the wealth we so much enjoy...

by cactus pete

Jim, what DOES the government do, in your opinion?

Aiding the creating of 'wealth' sounds like a service to me!

Producing a secure environment sounds good.

Does the government get the bulk of its income through taxes? You bet.

Does the government NEED that much in taxes?

There's the argument. What are the obligations og the US Federal government?

It must - pay off its debt.
- secure the liberties of the people.
- insert any promise the gov made to its people here.

There must be SOME taxes. To this I'm sure you will agree. How much in taxes do you feel are mecessary to do its job? What rate do you feel would be appropriate?

How else, other than from its wealth, does the government produce income? Yes, taxes. We have agreed, as a society [through elections of officials to carry out our desires] to raise income for ourselves to protect ourselves. We each give some of what we have in some manner to the society as a whole.

We, the people, are the government's assets - we are our own assets. We contribute to the whole for certain basic functions of the government.

If receipts are lower than expenditures, how else do you want the government to remain solvent? It can't just print money and spend it - the books have to balance somewhere.

Cutting taxes without cutting expenditures AT LEAST AS MUCH is irresponsible. Especially over the long term. Deficit after deficit is bad for the economy. Do you disagree?

by cactus pete

Why do you argue points at which we agree?

Yes - sometimes lowering taxes can raise income for the government. But that only happens if you're currently taxing too high. Show me a number - we can debate it.

I have ALWAYS said that we need to control spending - and stop calling me a democrat. I certainly hope you don't label me anything [but honest in my efforts]. I don't fit neatly, but can be crammed into stereotypes.

I think that the government should:

first - reduce spending.
second - reevaluate taxes.

Of course, there is another interesting twist - reducing spending reduces taxes, too. We do tax the defense contractors on their income, right?

Selling bonds - selling debt is selling something. When one sells something, one generates income.

A lot of people BUY these bonds. Then they sell them back to the government [or among each other] and they have [hopefully] made money. This is income generated from the government.

It all comes back to the people, of course. The people sold themselves bonds and made and lost money at the same time. How's that for confusing?

by maxwell edison

.
Cause I don't think I've ever called you a Democrat. (I like you; I'd never insult you in such a way.)

by cactus pete

The sigh was a response to finishing the last post to find about 5 [i'm not counting] more against my points... But the flesh of the response was an attempt to address both of you [was it just two of you?].

by maxwell edison

Actually, I think we agree, at least in principle, on most of the points made.

We're just calling them different things - you know, I'll call a rose a rose, and you might call it an onion. (Or vice-versa, of course.)

by cactus pete

Max - I am just trying to stick up a little rationality I feel is missing.

If the pendulum really does swing both ways, then you admit there are just as many times that taxes need to be raised as there are time they need to be lowered.

My personal wish is to the the pendulum swing very little so that when taxes are raised or when taxes are lowered, it is not such a freakish event as to cause large political debates.

Fish need water within certain pH ranges. If I test the water and find that my Oscar, who likes a pH of 6.8 [he's not on as much acid as most other Oscars], is atually living in water that shwos to be 7.8 [the scale stops there, maybe it's higher!] then I need to change something.

But do I lower the pH from 7.8+ immediately down to 6.8? The reading is too high, but no, I don't. Other fishly attributes would already be trying to compensate for the high pH levels and I could kill it. That would break my heart, so I lower it gradually.

If I somehow found the pH to be too low, I would actually need to raise this, wouldn't I? But I wouldn't do that too fast, either.

Now, most Oscars like a pH of 6.5, but I, through experience, have noticed that mine seems to thrive best at 6.8. Maybe this is because the hardness of the water is different than others who typically show good pH reading lower than I do. But they are different. And it is a complex mix of varying factors.

The sure thing is that when I notice something wrong, the worst step would be to over correct right away.

Some people might still be mad at me for raising my fish in 6.8 since they know that 6.5 is 'better' for it. But actually, 6.8 is still low for an acceptable range, and I know the tank works well there, as a whole. [Besides, these people should mind their own business.]

by jimhm

I am not saying there should be no taxes - there must be some taxes. But when it takes the average wage earner to work until - may or june to pay all their taxes - that is far far to much.

That's not income alone that is the taxes on the taxes .. sales tax on income already taxed - that income to the store is tax - and then taxed when it is paid to the employee... Usage taxes - sin taxes - taxes on taxes on taxes on taxes ...

The average worker can not support these any longer - the government needs to get off the middle wage earners back and out of their pockets... we can handle another tax.

Reduce the taxes - it works - look its working now and worked back in the Reagan days...

by lizzy

I had to bring this back up at home so I could read more of this. It has been wonderful to see so many intelligent people out there making very astute points about this whole situation. My opinion is that the economy will always have its ups and downs in cyclic-types of periods in time. The US was already headed for the downturn that we experienced. It was just brought out much more quickly by all of the turmoil surrounding 9-11, terrorism, other nation's economies, corrupt accounting practices and the like. Stock prices were much too inflated or bloated to stay where they were. We (my husband and I) personally lost more money on paper in 2001 and 2002 than we made in incomes. Key words are "on paper." I would like to say that here in Virginia, Governor Warner has indeed cut spending. There have been some mistakes (DMV for those of you familiar with what happened there), but the cuts are ongoing and sometimes harsh. They are also necessary. While I don't consider myself either Republican or Democrat, I tend towards the conservative.I agree that we should not be spending or wasting taxpayer money recklessly. VA has been working very hard toward this.

by lizzy

A man I know that was a driver was hit head on in a collision in his personal vehicle and suffered massive head injuries, possible brain damage, and some vision loss. (this is not a client of the place where i work but someone i know personally) He can still drive, but dr.s say he should avoid driving. He got a job at a major grocery chain. He walks to work from his home. Pay is $13/hr. for 40 hrs/wk, for $520/wk. Store pays nothing above 40 hours--no overtime. Here's the offer from the store that can't get anyone to take manager positions there:

Assistant manager position for $750/wk. working up to 60 hours / week on salary (again no OT) and also travel ~45 minutes to other store location as well. This translates into a pay cut to $12.50 /hr., longer hours, added traveling/driving time, higher -personal- gas costs from no gas costs. I guess they figure this man had severe brain damage...

Time will tell if he accepts it under pressure from his wife who used to work as a pricer in the Dollar Store...

I can't make this stuff up!

Longer hours for less pay is becoming the norm in the US. We also get much less vacation time than most other developed countries.

This discussion is closed to new replies.