Question Locked

Vendor Evaluation

0 helpful
3 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

I offered an RFP to 4 vendors to supply, configure and implement an infrastructure upgrade for my office. I have 6 infrastructure implementation areas, and all 4 vendors proposed different solutions to each of the 6 areas. With overwhelming options, how can I evaluate the proposals fairly, and shortlist the best vendor? Have any of you guys been through this experience before? If yes, appreciate it if you could share it out. I am really at my wits end. Some details of the options that I am facing with:

1. Firewall with VPN - Retiedge 905, Fortigate 300A, pfSense & Cisco ASA 5510

2. Corporate Antivirus - Panda Business Secure 2008, TrendMicro OfficeScan 8 & Sophos

3. NAC - TrendMicro Network Viruswall Enforcer 1200, Untangle (it's not even an NAC solution, if i'm not mistaken), Panda Business Secure 2008 & Sophos

4. Infra Monitoring & Management - MS SCE 2007, Nagios & OpManager

5. VoIP Upgrade (currently using CallManager 3.3 and needs voicemail) - Cisco Unity 4.x, Cisco Unity 2.0 & Asterisk

6. Backup solutions - Symantec Netbackup, Backup 3G, Amanda & FalconStar.

Thanks.

3 replies

by david.wallis

i would ask them each to demonstrate a similar setup they have deployed in another business and outline the improvements the system has made to that business.

You want to choose the vendor who has a proven track record and isnt installing this setup for the first time.

Also consider which one is offering you the best support deal, and choose one that isnt pushing for one certain brand and has given you different options.

if i was you i would choose -

1. Firewall with VPN or CISCO
2. Trend Micro (panda and sophos no good imo)
3. Trend
4. Cisco
5. no experience of them, but look into Veritas and EMC Retrospect

what are your requirements maybe i can given you more options :)

by shah.shaharuddin

Thanks for the tip David! :)

My requirements are high level.. I need:

1. A firewall with high throughput, VPN and can create zones.

2. To consolidate endpoint protection and manage them centrally. This covers AV & NAC. Currently, we have norton, avg & mcafee used in the office, and they are all standalone.

3. A system to monitor and manage my infrastructure. I'm biased to MS SCE 2007 because of their richness in reporting options.

4. A reliable backup and recovery infrastructure where it can be easily managed.

5. a redundant internet connection at the gateway level.

Why all this now? We had a substantial increase in marketing staff, and they spend most of their time out of the office and attending company events. They need to access SharePoint sites and other network resources in the office and I need to provide a secure, but easy method for them to do so. I need to monitor their devices so that they will not infect the office network. And the company needs a backup and recovery infrastructure as it is poorly managed at the time being.

This discussion is closed to new replies.