Discussion Locked

Video Compression File Sizing

0 helpful
2 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

What are recommended file size ranges for downloadable Real, QuickTime and Windows Media movies via Broadband and 56K?

For some material, I'm preparing six files: Real Media, Quicktime and Windows Media optimized for both Broadband and 56K connections, progressive download. I have been compressing for a few weeks now, trying out no less then 4 (!) utilities (Premiere, Quicktime Pro, Camtasia Producer, Cleaner 5.) I am getting mixed results, including non-relative file sizes. For example, for the exact same source material, Real settings for BroadBand often generate a file with a similar size to those generated by Quicktime and Windows Media for 56K. Confusing!

Given that the material is generally:
- 2-5 minutes long
- Voice w/ background music
- Sometimes has light animation
- Often has rather simple video footage, i.e. cuts and dissolves but not a lot of SFX or compositing

What is recommended target file size range for downloading such a movie via Broadband and 56K?Would these be the same across all 3 formats - Real, Quicktime and Window Media? If not, why are they different, and why when given the same specs are Real files 1/3 the size?

Once upon a time I was told for that 28.8, a Web page shouldn't be more than 50 KB in total size, graphics and all (preferably 15 KB). Isn't there a similar BASIC GUIDE for sizes of A/V files for downloading via Broadband and 56K? I've found lots of authoring info online and in the manuals, but nothing that serves as such a guide. Any info. is greatly appreciated!

2 replies

by smorty71

Here is a link to an Adobe PDF titled "A Streaming Media Primer." Pay particular attention to the "How Much Compression is Enough. Understanding Bandwidth Math" on page 30.

Here is the link:
http://www.adobe.com/smprimer

Hope this helps.
sm

by lyric

I don't know what is downlable movie, if u want to downloadable not stream for online show, that are different concept. For download u should not consider file size.

Encoding Formats:
>WindowsMedia v8 encoder
>RealPlayer 8 encoder
>
>Speeds:
>220k for each format
>56k for each format
>
>Sizes:
>320 x 240 pixels for 220k format
>160 x 120 pixels for 56k format

This discussion is closed to new replies.