Discussion Locked

Virus Protection Suggestions?

0 helpful
16 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

I am looking to get a standardized sitewide virus protection software in place at my company. I have looked at both Norton and McAffee, however they seem very invasive.
The qualities that are important to me are:
Regular Updates.
The Ability to push updates to clients.
And finally cost.

Any sugestions?

16 replies

by tobin59

I'm currently investigating TrendMicro and Solomon. Maybe one of these will be what you're looking for.

by shawng

My company currently uses Norton Corporate Edition. I'm unsure as to why you find it "invasive", but the software works very well. It has a centralized update server so that it can automatically push out virus definitions as soon as each workstationlogs on. It has a centralized quarantine server also. We have approimately 60 machines utilizing it. So far so good. Good Luck on your search.

by louieace1

Does it scan each individual workstation from the MBR to all drives, after each worksation logs on?
And does it isolate the worksation or just the virus?
Thanks for the info

by dazcon5

We went with the eTrust AntiVirus suite from Computer Associates. I have one central server which set policy, schedules local scans and updates the signatures. I have it set to update the signatures daily automatically to all clients.
From a single interface or remote interface installed on your PC. The local scanner get the MBR all drives and even the alternate data stream s in NTFS. The is a virus wall setting which will replace infected system files on the fly.
Admin server can send alerts via pager, printout,Lotus Notes, Exchange, SMTP or SNMP.
When a machine gets infected I get and email alert with the machine's NetBIOS name and IP address, with the logged on user name. I love the look on a users face when I show up at their desk a few mintues after eTrust catches and cleans the virus. This also integrates to all the other eTrust software and Unicenter. It just works great!

by shawng

Yes, it does scan workstations as they log on(MBR to all drives) if you want to set it up that way. I don't do the log on scans only because it slows the network down. I just allow it to check each file as it's saved or copied. I have it check for updates daily. I really like the program. It has works very well for my company, and for clients i used it for when i worked as a consultant.

by radiic

Trend micro is exactly what you are looking for. I use a 3 tier approach with them.

1> Trend Scanmail for my exchange servers.
2> Trend Serverprotect for the servers.
3> Trend Officescan for the desktops.

With the office scan i setup a small 2k box with iis and I am able use the built in Http based portion of Trend. This box goes and grabs the newest patern file from Trend at 7 in the morning. It automatically updates my desktops and servers. Client side is locked meaning that the user cannot turn off the virus scan with out a password. One other great thing about Trend is that they consider backdoor & crack utilities a threat to the corporate network and dont allow them to open up.

I love being able to logonto the AV console via a web browser and look at the stats or make changes. Plus I have it email me when a user tries to open up a virus. Even if they use there browser and go to a rogue website, it stops that too.

Trust me...Use Trend Micro...It will be the bestdecesion you make for your org. and you will look like a champ to the boss.

Rad

by tomsal

I was in the "anti-virus software market" about a year ago, asking pretty much the same thing the author of this thread is asking now.

After my own research (and feedback from TechRepublic forums) I chose Trend Micro's Viruswall product with the E-Mail Manager module.

Two words: Brilliantly Easy.

The primary issue at my company is e-mail transactions and the viruses they can bring, e-mail is HEAVILY used at my company as we deal with corporate HQs for nearly any/every major retail chain you can think of. Those corporate HQs love email (and sending file attachments).

Viruswall scans at the gateway both HTTP and SMTP traffic. (Note: For HTTP scanning you will need a proxy server set up first)

The software, once you configure it with the correct IPs and select any custom rules (ie. What files you want restricted, content rules, etc.) the software from that point is completely automated.

A true "set and forget" functionality. It only even crashed twice and BOTH times were MY FAULT (it was when we first got it, there was a file I needed to edit so it worked with my mail server and I had the wrong settings at first). It auto updates on any interval/date/time you specify and you control the frequency as well.

PlusI get reports on email content, who's violating what rule, the amount of traffic, etc.

I just really like the product and I'm thoroughly pleased with it.

by madwoodsman

McAfee ASaP has an agent that runs as a service...problem is that this service doesn't always load...and the icon in the tool bar doesn't indicate that the service failed to load. This could leave your users without necessary DAT updates. Frequently, the updates McAfee pushes out hose ASaP so bad you have to re-install the client...so much for saving time/money.

The Viruscan product allows you to use BackWeb to push updates from your own server, but this is rather cumbersome to get setup.
I am planning to try something different ASaP!

- Gordon

by rabbit_runner

We are using Network Associates McAfee Net Shield, Web Shield, and Group Shield. Each of these are managed with the ePolicy Orchestrator. We made a change from Computer Associates InoculateIT, during this past year. The reason was that the CA product did not adequately protect our email server. We found a large number of viruses when the change was made.
The ease of administration with McAfee is a snap. The ePolicy Orchestrator allows us to place workstations and servers into various groups. We can then set different policies for each group. However, each computer is set to download new virus signatures each day.
I do not know what your budget limit is, but the McAfee was more expensive than the InoculateIT product. However, we found the cost to be worth it, since we have not had any infections since we made the change. Group Shield catches any virus before it enters the LAN. The NetShield protects the workstations (all staff have internet access), and Web Shield protects our web sites that we host.

by mc_user

I have a pile of literate on my desk right now from Sophos Anti-virus. They had a large booth at the recent Chicago Comdex.
They only sell to companies that have networks and their only product is their anti-virus software. They promise quick updates, an excellent support staff and a lower cost per node than the competition. I haven't loaded their trial software yet.

Sophos is number four worldwide. Number three is TrendMicro. I am told they are quite populare in the Asia/Pacific readion of the world. I have no experience with their software.

by mc_user

Don't forget to look a the Products & Services section of this web site. There are product review and Gartner reports for almost all of the anti-virus products we are talking about.

Let us know what you decide on! Thanks.

by wilson.ed

I used Computer Associates Inoculan and then InoculateIT to keep over 1000 users at two sites virus free for the past 5 years. Signature updates were updated every two days or so and we implemented automatic updates on the clients when they logged in to the network. We never had any outtages and were never down for days like some of the other bigger companies.
We tried McAfee but it consistently allowed too many viruses to pass undetected.
If anyone needs a Network Admin in Dallas who knows viruses and how to stop them in their tracks
I am available just email me.
Cheers

by jbanks1005

I have heard of a network antivirus called panda security. I haven't tried it but it may be something to look into.

by radiic

As Bob the tomato pointed out, Trend Micros has offices in Asia and the far east. What does this mean. ALOT... Anyone remember the I LOVE YOU virus (lovebug) >? Im sure you do if you were using Mcafee like I was. I was working for a county agency when that one hit, lucky for us it came into our PR department and for some reason crashed the 3 pc's that it came to. I was suspicious at first because it crashed when she opened an email attachment. Anyways. After scouring the net (which was hard to do that morning cause i know every admin was doing what i was doing,) I found my cure at Trend Micro by 10 am. I know for a fact that Mcafee didnt have anything til real late that day. I was able to use the tool from trend to fix the pc's, I turned back on our smtp (cause i had a policy in place that at first sign of trouble to turn it off.) and we were back in business. Needless to say we purchased our licenses for Trend Imediately. It was easy to install ( it even un-installs other virus products for you).

Why the long story>? Simple. I believe that because Trend had offices in the Far east that they had a full 8-12 hrs. jump on the virus before Mcafee and others did. Ive been a believer since. I have new net admin job now, and first thing I installed upon arival was Trend Micro. Found several virus's on servers and stations that InoculateIT missed. Even when I tried to open up my lophtcrack to check out some of the passwords in the sam that the prev. admin didnt record anywhere, Trend quarintined the program. Thats another great thing about them, they consider back door programs and hack toolz to be inapropriate for your network.

Well I guess I have said enuf. Good luck in the "War of Good & Evil" I hope us whitehats win.

Rad

This discussion is closed to new replies.